First impresssion

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
IZDemon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 128
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2011 9:22 pm

First impresssion

Post by IZDemon »

My very brief time playing last night was enjoyable and I really like what you have done here. I didn't get an opportunity to explore much because I was on limited time. Can you tell me how big the world is?

A few things I noticed:

I like the class specific shops but I was unable to find a shop that would buy things or perhaps I was just trying to sell the wrong things.

It is helpful to see the damage I am doing when attacking but it is also a distraction to see that number pop up everytime I attack something. Is this something that will be turned off in the future? It kind of ruins the immersion for me and the mystery of other peoples damage.

I love the level system that does not require a trainer. You just learn by doing. That might be my favorite feature so far. However, I did notice when I leveled; my attack and defense did not change immediately. It did eventually bump up but not until several minutes later and while I was out of combat. It is set up that way or is it buggy?

Great job so far and I look forward to getting the opportunity of spending more time learning and exploring what you have created here in Shattered Isles!
Swark
Academy Student
Posts: 9
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:43 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by Swark »

Are you just in the area with the training targets? If so if you leave that area there is a pawn shop in the town.
IZDemon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 128
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2011 9:22 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by IZDemon »

Ahh yes...I did not realize there was a town. Thanks
Sharl
Academy Student
Posts: 6
Joined: Wed Jan 04, 2012 6:14 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by Sharl »

Hiya! I'm going to throw my first impressions here too if you don't mind.

First, a quick look at the pros. The descriptions are well done without being too lengthy and what lore posted up so far is fairly well done and I'm quite liking the wide selection of races as well. I'm also liking the levelling system and it shows that you've put a lot of work into the mechanics of the mud.

Aaand now the things that aren't so great. Some of these I've already brought up with one of the creators and they put them down, but I'd still like to reiterate them.

First of all, colours. Not a huge thing for most, but I really, really like my ansi colours to help me differentiate between objects, players, mobs, etc. It's built right into coffeemud so I don't see why it's not already here or why you yanked it out if you did.

Second, lore. I know you guys want us to to play this alpha ICly as you want us to build IC connections and the such, but it's really hard to flesh out details if all we have for lore is a city or two, some background that leaves out the Shattering which is a really big event from what I gather and two paragraphs for each race. I know this isn't something that can be rushed but a little more information would be wonderful.

Third, OOC communications. I really went into this with a creator the other night as I feel that OOC relations are as important as IC relations for a healthy community, but as the mud is in an early alpha and things aren't all working yet, it would nice to have a way that we all can communicate about potential problems, things not working yet, etc. I know you guys don't want to have the mystery of a brand new mud spoiled by OOC talks about it but there should be some leeway for mechanics and bugs so we all can warn each other that 'Hey, that's kinda broken right now don't do that' or 'That's not in until beta' or 'Oh god don't enter this room it's bugged to hell'. I know the creator I was talking to suggested using tells but uh, that's not really a good means of mass communication. Something that would placate me a bit is if when a bug was found it would be thrown up here on the forms asap as well as rebroadcast by a creator server-wide so the people already on have a chance to find out about it before they run into it.

Fourth, doors. It kinda confuses me that you can't see them on your exits.

Anyway, those are my views so far and while those cons make up a fair wall of text up there I'm quite enjoying myself on the mud.
Tollkirsche
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 100
Joined: Wed Jan 04, 2012 4:51 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by Tollkirsche »

figured i might as well put my first impressions up as well. first and foremost i would like to thank everyone who has put so much time and effort into maken this game what it is and opening it up for alpha.

one of my biggest likes for it so far is the huge crafting system, though some of it is still being put in and being worked on i really do like the fact that i can go into the forest and chop down some tree's and make me a club or two. or forage off the land for things of importance, i really enjoy the ability to make a PC self suffient, so if i want to play someone who doesn't oftten go into a city i don't need to

another thing i enjoy is the world that seems to be alive and working, so far i have seen a few msgs from things happening around the area. to things streaking through the sky to gust of winds blowing about, to when the weather is hot it gives little msgs that makes it feel like the world is interacting with you

and so far i have no major disgruntlements as i understand this is an ALPHA things will grow and change.

only minor thing i have to say of note, and have no idea how hard/easy it would be to code in would be eating creatures you've killed. I.E if i give a field mouse a beat down, given your race i wouldn't think it would be to much for an almost 9ft tall Gavial to eat it and smash it to mush in his mouth. granted this is more of a appeal thing then something that is world breaking
Sharl
Academy Student
Posts: 6
Joined: Wed Jan 04, 2012 6:14 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by Sharl »

IZDemon wrote:However, I did notice when I leveled; my attack and defense did not change immediately. It did eventually bump up but not until several minutes later and while I was out of combat. It is set up that way or is it buggy?
I used to play on another coffeemud sever (abit less heavily modified) and that question came up often. Assuming that it's the same, your stats don't change until your character 'refreshes'. You could force this refresh by sitting down and then standing up, but I don't know if they changed that here or not.
Tollkirsche wrote:one of my biggest likes for it so far is the huge crafting system, though some of it is still being put in and being worked on i really do like the fact that i can go into the forest and chop down some tree's and make me a club or two. or forage off the land for things of importance, i really enjoy the ability to make a PC self suffient, so if i want to play someone who doesn't oftten go into a city i don't need to
I also enjoy this kinda thing, and I'm happy to see that it's not only expanded beyond the original coffemud stock items but has some of the limitations removed as well (Limited number of common skills). I wonder how well things will work without crafting expertises though.
Nocturn
Posts: 2
Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 10:26 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by Nocturn »

Thanks so much to all of you for sharing your impressions and input. Your input as players is not only helpful in giving us the information and tools we need to further complete the S.I. experience mechanically, but also allows us to implement your vision as part of the overall world. We feel it is absolutely necessary to build with our players, not just for our players.

As always, we are a roleplay intensive world, and feel that we can communicate mechanics and OOC gaming issues with the most effective outlets without the experiencial compromise we find in general mass OOC chat channels. Please feel free to use the ASSIST, and BUG commands freely to communicate game issues with staff. Also, the "tell" function is our OOC contact tool and can be used if immediate OOC contact must be initiated.

Again, thank you SO much for taking this journey with us, and we look forward to watching this world grow with you.

Nocturn
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: First impresssion

Post by Austere »

I wanted to point out that the damage numbers that have been displaying during combat are for testing purposes and are not intended to be included beyond alpha.
IZDemon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 128
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2011 9:22 pm

Re: First impresssion

Post by IZDemon »

Austere wrote:I wanted to point out that the damage numbers that have been displaying during combat are for testing purposes and are not intended to be included beyond alpha.
Ahh, thank you. I am happy to hear that.
Post Reply