A lot of you have gotten into at least one area of crafting, so I felt like it would be a good time for some suggestions. I know some of the crafting lists seem lacking. We have all the room in the world to add as many things as you can think of, we just usually don't have the time to focus on improving these areas right now. We will be revisiting Trade Skills before long to clean up the values of the finished product. Some things are out of whack as far as price and weight are concerned. There's not enough consistency between the similar skills either.
Since this is likely a month or two out before we do revisit them, this would be a great time to start building a list of suggestions for new items. Right now none of the skills allow crafting of weapons or armor. Shields are the closest thing and they need some work within the different skills. We're looking for RP items. Items that have a functional use are a plus, but not necessary. Items that are pieces of a larger set, like the chess pieces, are always fun. Keep in mind that these skills start out simple but get more complex as you advance in level. We'd like to get to a point where each new level unlocks not just 1 item but multiple options. A real reason to push forward in these skills.
Right now we're looking for suggestions for the following:
Cooking Recipes
Bone Carving
Stone Carving
Wood Carving
Blacksmithing
Glass Forming
Pottery
Thanks to everyone who has already sent in suggestions. I know at times it can feel like we don't always use your suggestions and that can be frustrating. It just takes time to work them into the world. Some previous item, shop, and spell suggestions have been implemented, not all of which have been released yet. When it comes time to work on Trade skills, you'll see your suggestions for this latest request in action.
A custom RP item will be awarded to those that send in at least 10 usable items.
Crafting Item Suggestions
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
My primary focus has been mining and its related tradeskills... still unlocking jewelcrafting, so I'm not going to offer any suggestions on it as yet. I have noticed that the type of material is included in the item made, so I indicate a space for that with either <stone> or <metal>.
My suggestion when going to work in more recipes and cleaning up the trade skills is to approach it with a tiered structure in mind. You have tiers one through five, for instance, and simple items that correlate to those tiers based on descriptive adjectives. For example, a low level table would be a crude <stone> table, while a mid-level may be a smoothed <stone> table, and a high level would be a finely-crafted <stone> table. Note that pre-existing items, such as blacksmithed plates or stone toys can easily be adapted to a tiered system.
In addition to 'simple' items that can be prefixed with tier-related adjectives, there should also be special level related items, with greater description. For example, a <metal> plate may be a simple item, but there could also be a "rough <metal> plate engraved with two knights dueling," which is a special item found in lower levels (hence the rough). I've included several offerings, but I encourage anyone to add more or continue my line of thought with greater descriptions.
Onto the show~
Stone Carving
Prefixed descriptors by tier: (t1) crude, (t2) rough, (t3) smoothed, (t4) finely-carved, (t5) pristine
Simple Items
<stone> post
<stone> chair
<stone> stool
<stone> table
<stone> round table
<stone> brazier
Miniature <stone> obelisk
<stone> paperweight
<stone> nightstand
<stone> candelabra
<stone> lamppost
<stone> bookcase
<stone> sarcophagus
<stone> bench
<stone> birdbath
<stone> fountain
<stone> statuette of <god>
<stone> statuette of <king/other important figure>
<stone> statuette of <dragon/wyvern>
Complex Items
Crude, unidentifiable <stone> statuette
Spiritual <stone> monolith
Rough <stone> tablet (bonus if we can write on it in some way, but I don’t know if that’s within player power right now)
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of billowing fire
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of winding rivers
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with squiggly lines of wind
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of rising mountains
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of shield covering sword
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of a blackened hand
Smooth <stone> obelisk detailing the achievements of <king/important figure> (bonus points if it is readable with those achievements; I don’t know them and so cannot offer suggestions.)
Smooth <stone> obelisk bearing the symbol of <god>
Well-chiseled <stone> chair with carved lion’s paw legs
Well-chiseled <stone> feasting table with carved lion’s paw legs
Well-sculpted <stone> candelabra with carved lion’s paw base
Well-carved <stone> drinking stein with lion’s face and tail handle
High-backed <stone> chair crowned with clawed hands
Crude <stone> Goblin gambling table
Smooth Dwarven mead-hall <stone> table
Elegant Pearlean <stone> dining table
Stretched <stone> feasting table
Well-chiseled <stone> statue of a knight on horseback with sword outstretched
Ornate <stone> altar of <god>
Elegant <stone> altar of Tetherias with fine bas-relief of mountains, trees, and caverns
Elegant <stone> altar of Kaleith with fine bas-relief of crashing waves and <stone> cistern
Elegant <stone> altar of Pyrous with carved vibrant flames and ceremonial brazier
Elegant <stone> altar of Aerthane with cloud-shaped carved openings and windy reliefs
Elegant <stone> altar of Astraeva with bas relief of a shield covering a sword concealing rays of light
Elegant <stone> altar of Itzal with carved, blackened hand overstretched above a ceremonial brazier
Itzalite <stone> altar of blood sacrifice
Pristine <stone> stool with runic engraving
Pristine <stone> sundial with elegant numerical engraving
Pristine <stone> sculpture of life-sized snarling dragon with intricately-carved scale pattern
Pristine <stone> sculpture of life-sized tail-striking wyvern with intricately carved scale pattern
Massive <stone> bas-relief depicting the Great Shattering with intricate, excruciating detail
(Note: Left a lot of room for statues/sculpture ideas if anyone else wants to throw some in. The formulaic tiered items provide options and give accomplishment, but the individual, more well-described items are the special ones we work for.)
My suggestion when going to work in more recipes and cleaning up the trade skills is to approach it with a tiered structure in mind. You have tiers one through five, for instance, and simple items that correlate to those tiers based on descriptive adjectives. For example, a low level table would be a crude <stone> table, while a mid-level may be a smoothed <stone> table, and a high level would be a finely-crafted <stone> table. Note that pre-existing items, such as blacksmithed plates or stone toys can easily be adapted to a tiered system.
In addition to 'simple' items that can be prefixed with tier-related adjectives, there should also be special level related items, with greater description. For example, a <metal> plate may be a simple item, but there could also be a "rough <metal> plate engraved with two knights dueling," which is a special item found in lower levels (hence the rough). I've included several offerings, but I encourage anyone to add more or continue my line of thought with greater descriptions.
Onto the show~
Stone Carving
Prefixed descriptors by tier: (t1) crude, (t2) rough, (t3) smoothed, (t4) finely-carved, (t5) pristine
Simple Items
<stone> post
<stone> chair
<stone> stool
<stone> table
<stone> round table
<stone> brazier
Miniature <stone> obelisk
<stone> paperweight
<stone> nightstand
<stone> candelabra
<stone> lamppost
<stone> bookcase
<stone> sarcophagus
<stone> bench
<stone> birdbath
<stone> fountain
<stone> statuette of <god>
<stone> statuette of <king/other important figure>
<stone> statuette of <dragon/wyvern>
Complex Items
Crude, unidentifiable <stone> statuette
Spiritual <stone> monolith
Rough <stone> tablet (bonus if we can write on it in some way, but I don’t know if that’s within player power right now)
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of billowing fire
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of winding rivers
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with squiggly lines of wind
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of rising mountains
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of shield covering sword
Small Rough <stone> shrine marked with the symbol of a blackened hand
Smooth <stone> obelisk detailing the achievements of <king/important figure> (bonus points if it is readable with those achievements; I don’t know them and so cannot offer suggestions.)
Smooth <stone> obelisk bearing the symbol of <god>
Well-chiseled <stone> chair with carved lion’s paw legs
Well-chiseled <stone> feasting table with carved lion’s paw legs
Well-sculpted <stone> candelabra with carved lion’s paw base
Well-carved <stone> drinking stein with lion’s face and tail handle
High-backed <stone> chair crowned with clawed hands
Crude <stone> Goblin gambling table
Smooth Dwarven mead-hall <stone> table
Elegant Pearlean <stone> dining table
Stretched <stone> feasting table
Well-chiseled <stone> statue of a knight on horseback with sword outstretched
Ornate <stone> altar of <god>
Elegant <stone> altar of Tetherias with fine bas-relief of mountains, trees, and caverns
Elegant <stone> altar of Kaleith with fine bas-relief of crashing waves and <stone> cistern
Elegant <stone> altar of Pyrous with carved vibrant flames and ceremonial brazier
Elegant <stone> altar of Aerthane with cloud-shaped carved openings and windy reliefs
Elegant <stone> altar of Astraeva with bas relief of a shield covering a sword concealing rays of light
Elegant <stone> altar of Itzal with carved, blackened hand overstretched above a ceremonial brazier
Itzalite <stone> altar of blood sacrifice
Pristine <stone> stool with runic engraving
Pristine <stone> sundial with elegant numerical engraving
Pristine <stone> sculpture of life-sized snarling dragon with intricately-carved scale pattern
Pristine <stone> sculpture of life-sized tail-striking wyvern with intricately carved scale pattern
Massive <stone> bas-relief depicting the Great Shattering with intricate, excruciating detail
(Note: Left a lot of room for statues/sculpture ideas if anyone else wants to throw some in. The formulaic tiered items provide options and give accomplishment, but the individual, more well-described items are the special ones we work for.)
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Blacksmithy
Prefixed descriptors by tier: (t1) brittle, (t2) poorly-forged, (t3) smoothed, (t4) well-forged, (t5) pristine
Simple Items
<metal> nail
<metal> cuff links
<metal> chalice
<metal> goblet
<metal> horseshoe
<metal> pole
<metal> spike (not necessarily a weapon?)
<metal> doorknob
<metal> jug
<metal> flask
<metal> urn
Cast <metal> fence
<metal> wire
<metal> mask
Complex Items
Roughly cast <metal> bull statuette
Rough <metal> plate engraved with two dueling knights
Rough <metal> washing tub
Rough <metal> washing board
Hammered <metal> wall fixture depicting the sun
Hammered <metal> hooded lantern
Hammered <metal> prison shackles
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with symbol of billowing fire
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of winding rivers
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with squiggly lines of wind
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of rising mountains
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of shield covering sword
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of a blackened hand
Smooth <metal> brazier with heating coals
Smooth <metal> candelabra with gold-leaf engraving
Smooth <metal> cistern with gold-leaf engraving
Well-forged shining <metal> chandelier
Well-forged shining <metal> plate engraved with roaring lions
Well-forged shining <metal> chalice with open maned-lion maw
Pristine cast <metal> molding of a [dragon/wyvern] with wings outstretched
Ornate pristine <metal> plate engraved with dragons in flight
Tools: These should be exempt from the tier system, unless the quality of the tool changes the way it is used somehow (need a bronze mining pick to get iron? Dunno, don’t think it works this way right now)
Honed <metal> mining pickaxe (my mining pick can be used as a weapon – I have to assume this could be too, but I’m sure you have some way of making it so they it deals little to no damage regardless of metal quality…)
Thin <metal> wood saw (as above, but with axes)
Delicate <metal> skinning knife (as above, but with daggers)
Ornament Armor: I wasn’t sure if you could use/wanted armor suggestions, but as far as I know, only the torso matters, so these are largely RP set items. I went with similar descriptors as are on the purchased armor, so that we can forge sets that match the purchased pieces. If this will later be part of a separate skill (I noticed steel armor on the website being a separate skill potentially), then you can save the concept for later.
Dented <metal> vambraces
Dented <metal> barbute
Dented <metal> greaves
Dented <metal> sabatons
Hammered <metal> vambraces
Hammered <metal> barbute
Hammered <metal> greaves
Hammered <metal> sabatons
Polished <metal> vambraces
Polished <metal> barbute
Polished <metal> greaves
Polished <metal> sabatons
Fur-lined <metal> vambraces
Fur-lined <metal> barbute
Fur-lined <metal> greaves
Fur-lined <metal> sabatons
Full-plate <metal> vambraces
Full-plate <metal> barbute
Full-plate <metal> greaves
Full-plate <metal> sabatons
Prefixed descriptors by tier: (t1) brittle, (t2) poorly-forged, (t3) smoothed, (t4) well-forged, (t5) pristine
Simple Items
<metal> nail
<metal> cuff links
<metal> chalice
<metal> goblet
<metal> horseshoe
<metal> pole
<metal> spike (not necessarily a weapon?)
<metal> doorknob
<metal> jug
<metal> flask
<metal> urn
Cast <metal> fence
<metal> wire
<metal> mask
Complex Items
Roughly cast <metal> bull statuette
Rough <metal> plate engraved with two dueling knights
Rough <metal> washing tub
Rough <metal> washing board
Hammered <metal> wall fixture depicting the sun
Hammered <metal> hooded lantern
Hammered <metal> prison shackles
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with symbol of billowing fire
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of winding rivers
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with squiggly lines of wind
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of rising mountains
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of shield covering sword
Hammered <metal> plate engraved with the symbol of a blackened hand
Smooth <metal> brazier with heating coals
Smooth <metal> candelabra with gold-leaf engraving
Smooth <metal> cistern with gold-leaf engraving
Well-forged shining <metal> chandelier
Well-forged shining <metal> plate engraved with roaring lions
Well-forged shining <metal> chalice with open maned-lion maw
Pristine cast <metal> molding of a [dragon/wyvern] with wings outstretched
Ornate pristine <metal> plate engraved with dragons in flight
Tools: These should be exempt from the tier system, unless the quality of the tool changes the way it is used somehow (need a bronze mining pick to get iron? Dunno, don’t think it works this way right now)
Honed <metal> mining pickaxe (my mining pick can be used as a weapon – I have to assume this could be too, but I’m sure you have some way of making it so they it deals little to no damage regardless of metal quality…)
Thin <metal> wood saw (as above, but with axes)
Delicate <metal> skinning knife (as above, but with daggers)
Ornament Armor: I wasn’t sure if you could use/wanted armor suggestions, but as far as I know, only the torso matters, so these are largely RP set items. I went with similar descriptors as are on the purchased armor, so that we can forge sets that match the purchased pieces. If this will later be part of a separate skill (I noticed steel armor on the website being a separate skill potentially), then you can save the concept for later.
Dented <metal> vambraces
Dented <metal> barbute
Dented <metal> greaves
Dented <metal> sabatons
Hammered <metal> vambraces
Hammered <metal> barbute
Hammered <metal> greaves
Hammered <metal> sabatons
Polished <metal> vambraces
Polished <metal> barbute
Polished <metal> greaves
Polished <metal> sabatons
Fur-lined <metal> vambraces
Fur-lined <metal> barbute
Fur-lined <metal> greaves
Fur-lined <metal> sabatons
Full-plate <metal> vambraces
Full-plate <metal> barbute
Full-plate <metal> greaves
Full-plate <metal> sabatons
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Pottery:
Teapot
Sugar bowl
Creamer
Flour canister
Sugar canister
Coffee canister
Tea canister
Gravy boat
Casserole Dish
Salt Shaker
Pepper Shaker
Decorative Vase
Whiskey Jug
Teapot
Sugar bowl
Creamer
Flour canister
Sugar canister
Coffee canister
Tea canister
Gravy boat
Casserole Dish
Salt Shaker
Pepper Shaker
Decorative Vase
Whiskey Jug
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
dagger
sword
big sword
bigger sword
biggest sword
pointy stick
spear
longer spear
longest spear
rock
rock club
club
heavy club
disco club
sword
big sword
bigger sword
biggest sword
pointy stick
spear
longer spear
longest spear
rock
rock club
club
heavy club
disco club
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Sugar cookie, shaped like a big sword, with sprinkles
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Thank ya for all the serious suggestions, mates. Hope to see more.
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Wood Carving:
Trencher
Pipe rack
Humidor
Salad bowl
Lidded box
Trunk
Trencher
Pipe rack
Humidor
Salad bowl
Lidded box
Trunk
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Slight amendment to the tiered system I suggested... After doing the math and realizing it would take 116+ days of around the clock grinding to reach level 50 in any craft, which is unreasonable and impossible due to material costs, I suggest removing T2 entirely (moving everything down a tier) and having everything beyond 40 be masterwork/complex items.
Lots of great suggestions!
Lots of great suggestions!
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Re: Crafting Item Suggestions
Glass Blowing:
martini glass
wine glass
champagne flute
Desert bowl
Glass carafe
Fancy potpourri bowl
ink well
glass quill
tall glass candle holders
decorative oil lamp
large serving bowl
martini glass
wine glass
champagne flute
Desert bowl
Glass carafe
Fancy potpourri bowl
ink well
glass quill
tall glass candle holders
decorative oil lamp
large serving bowl