First off, let me say that I like the idea that the game has only one level of currency. However, I believe the game would benefit greatly from a secondary, yet finite, form of currency. I will explain. Doubloons are plentiful - infinite. You get them from just about everything. They are easy to come by. Eventually, you will run into a situation where everyone in the game has an endless supply of these coins. This happens in just about every game out there. Then you have to get creative and find ways for players to spend all of that money. There is nothing wrong with this but I believe there is a better way to create a true economy within the game.
If you create a secondary currency and limit the total amount of these coins/gems to a finite number, you would create a separation of economic classes along with other opportunities for roleplay. For example, buying land or buying a home in the city of Pearl would require a form of currency other than doubloons. When the city needs to make improvements, they would need the funds to do so. Since doubloons are infinite, there is currently no monetary reason why they wouldn't be able to. If the improvements required a different currency that was not infinite, there would be much more caution in spending them.
Doubloons would be universally accepted and they can buy just about everything in the shops. However, certain peddle items, crafting materials, etc. would require something other than the universal, infinite doubloon.
I could go on and on about this but I will stop right here.
There are many unspoken complexities to this idea and I know that it is unlikely to ever happen but it would be nice.
Currency
Re: Currency
Becoming a merchant seems to be a extremely expensive venture. There are other thing opening bushiness and the like. All large drains on the pocketbook.
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Currency
I don't think an alternate currency is the best way to handle the problem. Game economies are very difficult to balance, especially in a small player population because, unlike the real world, you can get something for nothing - every doubloon earned exists until it is recycled back in the game.
Right now, peddles are the main way in which large numbers of coin are being recycled into the world. This is fine, and allows the devs to fluctuate costs based on the needs of the economy - god-level approach to economy works fairly well in MUDs due to their small populations and lack of chaos-related emergent systems.
That said, I think there is a danger of inflation if prices do not get altered a bit. Repairs should probably be more expensive by scale (your old cotton jerkin repairs cheaply, while your blacksteel and above drains the pocketbook!), and potions may become more important at higher levels when money becomes more easy to acquire from monsters. And when looking at crafting prices, I might suggest having the level of material be just as important as the finished product, which would help prevent crafting being too lucrative and give greater incentive to go for the gold - literally. That last one might be a little more difficult code-wise, if I'm not mistaken, as it looks like material is simply added to the finished item price, and if so, upping the cost of material means gathering itself can become too lucrative.
A lot of things to consider when it comes to economies, and there's rarely a clear answer. I wish you good luck.
Right now, peddles are the main way in which large numbers of coin are being recycled into the world. This is fine, and allows the devs to fluctuate costs based on the needs of the economy - god-level approach to economy works fairly well in MUDs due to their small populations and lack of chaos-related emergent systems.
That said, I think there is a danger of inflation if prices do not get altered a bit. Repairs should probably be more expensive by scale (your old cotton jerkin repairs cheaply, while your blacksteel and above drains the pocketbook!), and potions may become more important at higher levels when money becomes more easy to acquire from monsters. And when looking at crafting prices, I might suggest having the level of material be just as important as the finished product, which would help prevent crafting being too lucrative and give greater incentive to go for the gold - literally. That last one might be a little more difficult code-wise, if I'm not mistaken, as it looks like material is simply added to the finished item price, and if so, upping the cost of material means gathering itself can become too lucrative.
A lot of things to consider when it comes to economies, and there's rarely a clear answer. I wish you good luck.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**