Bad shield, BAD!

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Anselm »

Heya mates,

I'm going to start this off with something I'd like to be rather clear on:

If someone is giving feedback, reporting bugs, or making sweeping-claims about the viability of a skill, then they will be honest. Do not misrepresent the situation to gain from it. All it does is waste the time of fellow players and staff. Speculation, wondering, and asking questions is fine and we both welcome and encourage it. Intentional misinformation, however, is not, and it will not continue.

Thank you.

Moving on!
Wren wrote:Warriors seem to be a lot sturdier than Assassins in general, too, so there's that.
They're not, mate. I dunno how many people roll up both assassins and warriors, but for those of ya who haven't checked they both have the same AR/DR progression. Warriors get shield block, parry, and dual parry as they defences.

Don't worry, can't hold a shield and an off-hand weapon at the same to get parry, dual parry, and shield block for three defence checks. They both take up the HELD slot. Shield block is different from parry, dodge is different from shield block, parry is different from dodge, and so on.

There's no sturdiness difference, though. Only different defence-types. A lot of warriors are bigger races, though, so there's that. Stats are based on race at rollup, not class.

Blink wrote:The problem is that a skill available to all being able to replicate a classes main powers. It's not so much how it is at level 30, as it is going to be at 60 and 90 and 100. Combined with the current defense setup. If this was a skill that let all classes train up and throw lighting bolts, this wouldn't even be a debate. It'd be soon changed.

And realism. I can tell you it sucks to be swinging a two handed weapon reallly hard at someone and have them sit there laughing at you as they bandage. Damage output for the big damage dealers should never be falling behind the healing skills of non clerics. Just look at how small the damage gains are for everyone. It takes a lot of teeth gritting to climb even a damage point it seems.
You're absolutely right, mate. After doin' some testin', I think we'll be lookin' at wound mending. There's never any reason a wide skill like wound mending should be outperforming a specialised healing class skill at comparable levels.

As for damage, also right on, mate. I'm sure if ya ever been in a hunt you've all likely noticed the damage range is, to put it lightly, a mite loose. This has been an issue for a long time, and we've been trying to tighten it up. We're still searchin', because a tighter damage range is gonna help all classes across the board. Gir's really put his nose to the ground tryin' to find the tiniest of clues on how to make this better, one step at a time.
Morley Darkfire wrote:That's my point.... I've had parry for awhile too. And unless I PT it up while mending. it's not that fast to raise. Where Block seems to work consistently better.
All defence skills have the same success rate in PVE. PVP might be another matter entirely and something we're looking into. There's little PVP in the game outside of the AFC (thanks for running it, guys!), so there's only a bit of live-action testing for it.

For example: The shield/parry double block doesn't happen in PVE, it only happens in PVP. In PVP sometimes you'll see the a display message for a successful parry, dodge or block, but then you'll also see someone's swing go through it and hit (or miss) the opponent. We're not sure if that's the game reading the success/fail wrong and firing off a display message, or if it's something deeper. It's being looked at, because clearly that's rather confusing in PVP (or in the case of barbarians/warriors (because I'm not sure if it happens with parry/dual parry?), it'll eat up a defence check against two melee opponents).

Thankfully, none of this happens in PVE.

Defences actually raise rather fast for passive skills. Something for everyone to keep in mind is, if someone is going to use parry it means they've got a weapon readied, obviously. If they've got a weapon readied, their DR is increased substantially. If their DR makes it so they're not being hit consistently in their hunting grounds, they're not going to get frequent defence uses. It's also problematic if someone's a parry user and fighting monsters with ranged or natural attacks.
Morley Darkfire wrote:Trust me, if you or I had fought them, they would not have been able to mend the damage away.
With the numbers on mend, I wouldn't be so sure of that.
Morley Darkfire wrote:There is also no delay on a failed spell. So in PvP or PvE you're just stacking commands anyway. So what if you have a fumble. a second later you're back in the game.
Mage spells and prayers have delays for failures. Whether offence, defence, or utility. Regardless of level or tier. If there's one that's been overlooked, please report it.
Aumnren wrote:By this, I assume you mean to argue that it is a might unfair that healing prayers can be used standing up. Yes, this is an advantage to being a priest, and should be an advantage.
Agreed, mate. Consider melee and mages having to sit to heal (or, again, alternatively you can buy potions) the balance to priests having terrible PVE damage against anything that isn't undead.

-----

The starting stats for all races are being looked over. However, I'd point out an eight point DR difference in a game that will have over 500DR at max is indeed very little.

Furthermore, I'd ask people to stop derailing this thread even more with aimless and contumelious comments. If a person has a disagreement with someone, then state it is so in a respectful manner and as to why.

Every one is free to be as rude, angry, disrespectful and sarcastic as they like in-game. On the boards every one is going to treat one another like adults.

Cheers, and happy Valentine's Day! Enjoy ya puddings and ya friends or significant others,
Anselm
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Creon »

The starting stats for all races are being looked over. However, I'd point out an eight point DR difference in a game that will have over 500DR at max is indeed very little
so don't bother with level 99 and 100? ;-P
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Creon »

Morely is a assassin right? After last night I can't see how anyone could say they are not equally durable 13 minutes I am almost positive me and him are nearly the same levels CC and defense wise. Except parry of course I'm nearly 30.
User avatar
Morley Darkfire
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 97
Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Morley Darkfire »

If you're not yet 50 then we're not nearly equal. It's all that extra health and damage bonus. There really is no downside to playing a gavial, no racial or rp limitations.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Creon »

Morley Darkfire wrote:If you're not yet 50 then we're not nearly equal. It's all that extra health and damage bonus. There really is no downside to playing a gavial, no racial or rp limitations.
We are close, if you do the % on how much we exchanged blows it would be clear can't argue with the math. We were both hitting each other for decent blows you're numbers were 11-18 same exact weapons and you had better armor. 13 minutes isn't a tell us all but it's a good look. I think it's a good look on how durable assassins really are.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Swamp Ape »

Teef wrote:Can't used up all my slots and the option to delete a character isn't there anymore.
Use the retire command in-game to delete characters.
Doxx ~
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Wren »

They're not, mate. I dunno how many people roll up both assassins and warriors, but for those of ya who haven't checked they both have the same AR/DR progression.
There's no sturdiness difference, though. Only different defence-types. A lot of warriors are bigger races, though, so there's that. Stats are based on race at rollup, not class.
Yes, I believe this is where I got the idea from. So far the only Warriors I know of have been Gavial, Argali, Vuk, or Gargoyle. While their starting stats are a factor, it's more their higher health and stamina I think that gives them a significant advantage over humans and other smaller races when it comes to doing things solo. In all my CC, ranged and unarmed levels, I still don't have the same amount of stamina my Vukasin started with.

Not sure if that's being looked at/tweaked as well, but I thought I'd throw it out there!
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Illegal Activity
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Dec 11, 2013 11:17 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Illegal Activity »

Gargoyles have one of the lowest HP pools! 160 which is 5 more than a Slyph.


Also someone said warriors start with 2 defense skills? I only see shield at roll up
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Blink »

Yes, I believe this is where I got the idea from. So far the only Warriors I know of have been Gavial, Argali, Vuk, or Gargoyle. While their starting stats are a factor, it's more their higher health and stamina I think that gives them a significant advantage over humans and other smaller races when it comes to doing things solo. In all my CC, ranged and unarmed levels, I still don't have the same amount of stamina my Vukasin started with.

Not sure if that's being looked at/tweaked as well, but I thought I'd throw it out there!
I think part of the problem is we know so little about magic races and magic damage. Yet it's very easy to see the physical advantages of Gavials and Vukasins.

I think the game is supposed to have a basic setup of the two extremes being the huge race warriors and the geeky mage elves. the Humans are about right in the middle of that.

Because we know so little about magic damage, and elven racial damage bonuses (And because magic damage may not be being done right) we aren't certain that the elves are the magic equivalent of the warrior Gavials and Vuks. Once we begin to see that, once it is in place, then you can kind of see how a Human is in the middle, able to be a decent mage or warrior, but not necessarily the best at either one. Humans seem pretty beefy in this system though, just not Gavial strong.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Post by Snaek »

Creon wrote:Any staff watch last nights games from the hidden sidelines? Thoughts?
Yes. We all did. We are in agreement about the original topic. All this other stuff doesn't really have anything to do with defensive skills. There was nothing about the fights that looked bad to me other than the high success rates of shield and parry in PvP.
Post Reply