Priest feedback.

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
Garim
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 24
Joined: Wed Aug 28, 2013 10:08 pm

Priest feedback.

Post by Garim »

Priests are an enjoyable class. I think the spell progression is good and makes sense. It is a fun, almost group only class that does it job well and feels and plays differently than other classes.

My suggestions and feedback for this class are primarily for when the priest wants to go it alone. I think these changes would not overbalance the class and still allow for it's original design.

AR/DR progression. I really wish that AR/DR progression would be bumped to 3/3 per level. This would still leave the priest way behind other classes that are more offensive combat oriented, but at 2/2 progression it's almost worthless to progress or attempt to hunt with weapons. 3/3 would not be overbalancing, and if a priest were to commit major time to advancing Close Combat they would have some benefit from it and be able to have some fun when groups are not readily available. Maybe even 3/2 progression if we are worried about too much base defense at high levels.

Which also ties into this suggestion. Turn Undead. I get it, Priests are built and designed for groups. But when you are playing a MUD, groups are not always going to be available unless your player base gets up into the 100-300 range. Turn Undead should do major damage to undead at higher levels (maybe I am too low and this skill does at higher levels?). Also at lower levels, I really wish it would not make monsters flee. I'd rather it fail, resist, stun, or do minimal to maximum combat damage as a best result like weapons and spells do. But only to Undead. Undead should be the one type of create that Priests can effectively hunt and destroy alone when they are unable to find groups.

Perhaps another option to this would be to allow their Heal Prayers to actually do damage to Undead instead of benefit them?

Priests are fun, and I'd love to play one. But even with a wife that plays the game, I just feel like a healbot when playing one and not really and truly engaged or feeling like I am making a major impact on the PvE side of things (beyond drastically reducing downtime which is a great benefit I understand). It just feels like I am an hp/stamina recharge battery with some buffs.

This is my low level feedback, I understand things may change but also understand I am a new player and we want to draw in new players. First impressions are big, and critical in keeping new players around long enough to get to the really fun neat skills.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Blink »

2/2 progression? Yeah, that is crazily low. Mages get 3/3.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Aumnren »

Hey Garim! There's actually a lot of good stuff here on priests.
AR/DR progression. I really wish that AR/DR progression would be bumped to 3/3 per level. This would still leave the priest way behind other classes that are more offensive combat oriented, but at 2/2 progression it's almost worthless to progress or attempt to hunt with weapons.
I actually don't mind the 2/2 progression. As priests are built now, they suffer in the CC arena, but that should be expected. It may seem underwhelming as it is, but (hopefully) with the prayer update priests will see some debuffs to help them hunt alone in more areas, as well as increase their utility beyond "battery recharger."

If there were to be changes to the AR/DR, I'd like to see it go to 2/3. CC is not entirely worthless for a priest, however. Leveling CC gives the priest more stamina, as well as an increase in DR. Granted, the DR gain won't be much against PvP, and only marginally useful against PvE, but with the RNG, it might mean the difference between life and death. In general, CC makes you more hardy and harder to hit - attributes that help with being a tank.

Speaking of tanking, priests get defend at Shield block 10, and is actually one of my favorite priest skills so far. Priests have great survivability because of their heal, and you can use defend to bring this survivability to the forefront in group hunts. In stead of just standing behind others and healing, you can take the agro and both reduce the damage a team member takes, and healing away their wounds faster because of it.
Which also ties into this suggestion. Turn Undead. I get it, Priests are built and designed for groups. But when you are playing a MUD, groups are not always going to be available unless your player base gets up into the 100-300 range. Turn Undead should do major damage to undead at higher levels (maybe I am too low and this skill does at higher levels?).
Turn undead does do damage to undead, and can kill them, either instantly (very very very small chance) or through repeated effects, making them run, stunning them, etc. I've often wondered if the effects of turn could be separated into two classes: Turn and Rebuke, where turn makes undead flee and destroys them, and Rebuke stuns and commands. However, the skill, even as is, works pretty well for solo, and for emergencies when hunting in groups for undead areas. For instance, you're group is assaulted by four vampires, and you can really only take two. You can turn the 4th until it flees, follows, you, or is stunned and removed from combat (a warning though, after struck when commanded, YOUR target will switch to the group member attacking. In other words, if you turn a vampire, and Loriel hits it with a sword, YOUR target become Loriel - at least, this has happened to me and resulted in a very surprised teammate when I started calling down the wrath of Aerthane on them instead of the undead creature after it had died. If you strike the creature, it will break the command. As well, if someone attacks a stunned undead, it will break the stun).

Your main damage attack against undead will be Holy Strike, however. Against anything else, it does practically nothing, but against undead it hits like hammer.
Priests are fun, and I'd love to play one. But even with a wife that plays the game, I just feel like a healbot when playing one and not really and truly engaged or feeling like I am making a major impact on the PvE side of things
Even as mostly a healbot, I've enjoyed playing a priest. I'm hoping that with the update, priests will see a bit of love in prayers, as we don't have much of a toolbox right now. With some more buffs or debuffs, we should be able to make a bigger impact on PvE hunting.

Thanks for posting this! :)
Garim
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 24
Joined: Wed Aug 28, 2013 10:08 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Garim »

Thank you for pointing out Holy Strike, I was using it to fight humanoids (since we only get 2/2 for CC). I did not realize that it did more damage against undead. That with Turn Dead is a great deal more feasible then.

:)
Bloodforge2
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 4:04 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Bloodforge2 »

I have been playing a priest for the past 2 or 3 weeks, and I am having a blast of a time. I have been slowly soloing content, and the other day I got involved in a pretty fun group hunt that allowed me to stay active with heals/rejuvs and mix it up with the mobs a bit. Overall I am pretty happy with the class so far.

I do have a few hopes/suggestions for the class though. My biggest hope, forgive me if this is in game already, is for an assess group command. I want to be able to see the health and stamina levels of my party-not the numbers. Currently, I have been using the look command to look at a group member and it only gives health.

Something like this:

>Assess group

>You assess your group and see that:
groupmembername1 is somewhat fatigued and somewhat injured.
groupmenbername2 is extremely fatigued and considerably battered.
groupmenbername3 is ...etc.
[Delay: 1.0 sec.]

Another suggestion I have is for spells. Firstly, I would love it if when we cast spells we used something to ID our God's element. For example, Pyrous could use holy ashes, Keleith could use holy water, and Tetherias could use holy dirt- I don't know. Finally, I would love to have a sanctuary spell that stops mobs from spawning in a room. Im not sure if this would be OP, but the idea is that if I walk into a room with two mobs and cast the above spell no more mobs could come in until the spell ends or I leave the room and I could do as I wished with the two that are already present.

Something like:

Priest X carefully begins to sprinkle holy ashes on the ground consecrating the area and creating a sanctuary for all that are worthy.

Either way, I am pleased with what I have seen from the class so far-though I agree 2/2 progression is a bit harsh- and look forward to our prayer updates.
Last edited by Bloodforge2 on Fri Feb 21, 2014 6:55 pm, edited 4 times in total.
User avatar
Morley Darkfire
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 97
Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Morley Darkfire »

Assess has two "S" LOL
I think you can diagnose and that show's the groups health
Bloodforge2
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 4:04 pm

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by Bloodforge2 »

lol! fixed!

Thanks for the tip about diagnose too!
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Priest feedback.

Post by SquallScribe »

You can also use the "group" command.
Post Reply