Backstab

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
Requiem
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 53
Joined: Thu Sep 19, 2013 2:18 am

Backstab

Post by Requiem »

I know this is intended to be a complimentary skill but after the coffee with the creators discussion I have some concerns. It was discussed that there is a good possibility that thieves would be losing shadow strike sometime in the future, leaving them with backstab as their primary means to doing stealth or initial attack damage. If one follows the COC outlines in regards to backstab and gets only 1 use (after level 10 of course) per target, the rate of leveling is slower than disguise or anything else I can think of. Even with the weakest creature, you get one backstab use, then somewhere in lines of 3-15 close combat uses before it dies. That's assuming you get to hide prior to going into combat, which is somewhere around 50% for most creatures. I'm not even going to try and do the math but I bet that you will hit level 100 CC following the COC before you reach level 20 in backstab. I guess this is fine if the additional damage bonus to backstab is significant at that level, but from what I have seen so far, the additional damage (yes I know there is an AR bonus as well, but I can't figure out how much that is) is not really that much. It just seems either their should be an easier way to level it or the damage boost increased. Perhaps it has been tested and it's where you want it but from my experience its not worth the effort and needs to be revisited.
I think there needs to be more thief opportunities other than the "con-artist" as was described a thief should be at the same meeting. There needs to be a way a thief can do some offensive damage if the situation calls for it. They already have a 4AR per level progression which makes it hard to stand up to any true offensive class. Taking away shadow strike is fine if backstab has some punch to it. Well that's my two or three cents worth.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Backstab

Post by SquallScribe »

Since Backstab seems like it is intended to be a one-off ability, and I guess Shadowstrike is being removed from thieves? (sorry was not there for that, so I don't know the particulars), would it be too much to separate Assassins/Thieves by having either Backstab or Shadowstrike? For instance, if Shadowstrike leaves the thief class, does Backstab then leave the assassin class? Is the intent to give them each one unique complementary attack skill?

If so, and even if not, Backstab and Shadowstrike damage needs to be increased. Backstab, as a true one-off I would suggest doing 25 - 30% of a victim's current HP (even at low levels, as it is assumed your accuracy is so low the bonus damage won't honestly matter that much) and to top out at 50% of a victim's current HP. These numbers might sound a little high, but as a one-off, it honestly needs to be effective. If it proved to be far too effective, I'm sure it could be balanced. Another suggestion would be to make Backstab damage armor piercing for either all of its damage, or a portion of its damage so that you could never do LESS than a certain amount of damage (I would suggest never doing less than 20 damage on a successful Backstab hit since it can only be used once per fight and does not rehide the aggressor like Shadowstrike does). This would mean that low level Backstab successes would need to be tweaked to be in line as well, since it also draws from CC levels for its success.

As Shadowstrike is a chain attack, and rehides the aggressor on success without the victim being able to reciprocate damage, it should not be as powerful in immediate damage. It should, however, be crippling if successful in a chain and should likely do an equivalent amount of damage as a one-hit Backstab over a successful multi-hit Shadowstrike chain at same levels.

This doesn't help the leveling issues, but as a skill that leads off CC, even moderately low levels of BS/SS should be effective if doing 25 - 30% of a victim's current HP on a successful one-hit (BS) or a successful chain of multi-hits (SS).
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by Aumnren »

Having BS do a percentage of damage rather than factoring damage in normally is actually an interesting idea.

Say to begin it does 15% of someone's health, and max's at 50%, that's an increase of 35% over 100 levels, so .35% a level, which means every 3 levels the damage increases by a percent.

Now, combine that with some armor piercing so even blacksteel and the like can't reduce half of it. Say 30% to begin, up to 80% at max. That's an increase of 50& over 100 levels, so .5% per level, which means ever 2 levels you'd see a 1% armor piercing effect.

How this works in my mind is that the damage is based of off the target's max health. To keep numbers easy, let's say 100. At the beginning, BS would do at least 15 to this poor soul, and at max 50, minus damage reduc. However, say the poor soul is already weakened, at 70 hp. If this kid were to be struck with BS, the attack would still do 15 - 50 (minus damage reduc) because the character's MAX health is 100. This allows for character to actually kill a weakened character using the skill, but makes sure the damage is always scaled to the target. It doesn't, however, allow someone to one-shot a character or creature, even a freshly rolled one, but it gives the Assassin/Thief a definite advantage if they get off the first blow.

Also, I personally thought SS would be taken from Assassins before thieves. Perhaps thieves could have a "Flank" ability, that allows them some added AR/damage/armor penn or something if they are attacking but not being attacked. As soon as they are targeted the ability can't be used.

Sorry I missed the meeting. Will a log be posted soon?

Edited to add: An option for the leveling would be to allow Backstab to be used from a hidden position, or under the circumstances described in my "Flank" idea above. Of course, if this were to happen the damage would have to be adjusted to compensate, as it would no longer be a one off, but a buffed, opportunistic attack. Perhaps one that does more damage if done from a hidden position, and reduced when used as a flank ability.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by Teef »

Leveling backstab even before CoC killed it only netted only 200 uses per hour. Following the prescribed regimen it's 20-40 uses per hour. Levels 1-20 is 22150 uses. So 1,107.5 - 553.75 hours to 20. On avg most hunting grounds provide 600-700 uses per hour for CC if you have a decent spawn rate not counting time torest or go pawn. So that give you from 664,500- 387,100 uses in CC for the same amount of time invested. So you'd only be from level 70-90 in CC... ;P I would have already passed 80 in CC if I had avoided working either backstab or shadowstrike.

At level 20 there is hardly any difference between a backstab and normal damage maybe 1-4 pts more. Which is better than when I was doing less damage than a plain stab at level 20. Yay. I gave him a scratch and not a graze. This is combined with damage only increasing every 10 levels. Which means, level 1-9 does squat right now and those people won't see any progress until sinking in over 200 hours for an extra point or two if they're lucky.

Of the two shadowstrike is more useful at the moment even if it doesn't work as intended. I say let thieves keep backstab and shadowstrike. there's nothing they can do with them anyway as it stands.

Separate shadowstrike like you did with Disguise and give assassins the ability to shadowstrike with a one-hander since we're stuck with one defense type that leaves up open to attacks.

I love how people want to take attacks away from the "attack orientated" class
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by Teef »

An option for the leveling would be to allow Backstab to be used from a hidden position
Image
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by SilverShade »

Why on earth should shadowstrike, the more offensive of the two attacks, be taken away from assassins? At the meeting, it was explained that backstab was seen as a sort of 'throw everything you have at your enemy's back' type of ability, which is what a thief would want to do. If anything, I'd love to see backstab get some serious work and go to thieves while assassins keep backstab.

I do agree that both need some serious work. Neither are really worth the effort it takes to train, and as of now, there's no reason for a complimentary skill that's actually quite lackluster to require more leveling dedication than a primary skill. I've noticed that the success range of shadowstrike is absolutely ridiculous, and can range from one to more than ten depending on luck. I wouldn't mind seeing that tightened up. Having the success range be something like a minimum of 2 or 3 and a maximum of 6 or 7 would not only make the skill worth leveling, but make it a much less painful process.

For backstab, bringing up the damage alone might help. I think I do more damage with my unarmed skill than I do with backstab. I have a list of ideas waiting to be used at a meeting concerning the sneak classes, and several of those could probably help with this skill as well.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by SilverShade »

Backstab can only be used from a hidden position, just like shadowstrike. Difference between the two is that shadowstrike MIGHT rehide you.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by Aumnren »

Aumnren wrote:Edited to add: An option for the leveling would be to allow Backstab to be used from a hidden position, or under the circumstances described in my "Flank" idea above.
This was or as in used from a hidden position or used during combat in the same manner as the "Flank" ability I suggested above. I understand how the skills work. My suggestion was that BS could be used under both circumstances, but have an increased effectiveness if striking from a hidden one.
Morley wrote:I love how people want to take attacks away from the "attack orientated" class
Now, I wasn't at the meeting, but from Requiem's post, it was thieves that might get the attack taken away from them, not assassins. I don't think SS should be taken from assassins, but thought it would be taken from them before it would be taken from thieves. It just seems like a more utility-stealth ability than an assault one so I felt it fit better under the thieves MO. I think it might be interesting to see the thief equipped with more stealth attacks like it, focusing less on burst, and more on the added effect. Like a mug ability that was (is?) suppose to be coming out, the flank or other skill that they could use in combat when no one is paying attention to them - different skills to differentiate their combat style from the more combat-focused assassins.
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Backstab

Post by SilverShade »

Only reason assassins are so combat oriented at the moment is because we don't actually have other useful skills to work on. I think shadowstrike is a nice blend of offensiveness and the stealth an assassin should be using.

Unfortunately, it just isn't worth the hassle to work.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
Post Reply