Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Blink »

Some specific feedback regarding Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs being used against Outlaw PCs.

I think overall the crows work fairly well for two things. One they freak the outlaw out, and Blink is very easy to freak out, of course. And two it provides intelligence to the knights. It's also far superior to some form of instant scry (Although that may be coming in later with Diviners) Couple things though. One I was able to see them while I was underground one day. I don't know if it's some global display, but if at all possible it'd be good if people indoors couldn't see it, in particular the outlaw. I assume and hope they also can't see you when you are indoors.

The other thing in regards to crows, I think there should be some kind of range limit on them. Not necessarily due them not being able to physically fly out there, but more in regards to the chilling effect this can and is having on player interaction. I was greatly cheered when the Rum Runner captain told Blink that the Rum Village would soon be cleared. However, recently one of the crows perched on the Rum Runner ship. Now, this is great for freaking Blink out, but the problem is it kind of signifies to him as well that not even the Rum Village as safe. And this is important because as things stand Blink is terrified of getting his friends outlawed by associating with them and thus it is nearly like he doesn't know any of them at all anymore. He's only in contact with one of them and even those conversations tend to be terse, as the threat is always there. This is kind of the fallout of the Geel case where outlaw associates were roped in, which was an awsome scenario, but has this sort of result on interactions. It's not just on Blink's side either. He's kind of a toxic guy now, as you can see from Wren's post, and he's also trying to protect others by not being seen with them.

So basically I'd have a very few slivers of safe zone from crow use, which is what the knights use for long range intelligence it seems. It wouldn't necessarily mean the knights were totally blind, but perhaps use other means such as PC spies or having random npc bounty hunter attacks, etc. I'd suggest the Rum Village, the Rum Runner, and the Southern Outpost as safe areas for now, then add more as the world expands outward.

It might be a worry that PC outlaws will use this to hide completely from the law. You could address this though either using IC means, such as ever larger npc bounty hunter crews going after the PC who stays too long, or by pulling the player aside for a chat. I think it's not in the outlaw's interest to do that anyway, because it's a bit like crapping where you eat. You want as an outlaw to use the place for banking and interaction needs, not cause the place to get raided or destroyed by hanging there all the time. (Although one day I would like to really change it into a town and fortify it, which I originally planned to do with the Burning Bandit area, which I was going to name Cowtown)

In regards to Gate spells. I think they are fine when used on outlaw mages, thieves, and assassins, as they have means to deal with them. I think it'd be a vicious thing though to do to warrior types. It's not so much they may get killed pretty easily, although that may happen. It's more that it'll let the knights easily learn all their favorite hide/hangout spots. It must be remembered the current map is very small.

In regards to NPCs. I really loved some of the NPC reactions when my law stat was recently changed, in particular when I was called "Infamous Blink." LOL. I've yet to see one of them take a swing at me though. Not sure if they are meant to. I think I should get bloodied now and then running through Pearl as I was. Gates closing on you might be cool too, but that perhaps needs to be limited if there are no other exits. Not everyone has portals after all. Perhaps make the interactions get more violent and numerous the longer you stay in Pearl after you are detected. Much like the raising star levels on the GTA games after you've done some major crimes.

And even outside the city perhaps have some random attacks. Bounty hunters. Greedy adventurers. You could also use the guard squads for more than just searches. Just have a guard squad march in and attack.

Oh yeah the horns are great for freaking you out as well, but dont' have a huge effect unless there's an active Knight Marshal. There just aren't a lot of PCs around that are like, yeah I want to defend Pearl from this scum!

I hope this helps. I'll probaly have some more feedback, but it hasn't been that long yet.
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Anselm »

Blink wrote:One I was able to see them while I was underground one day. I don't know if it's some global display, but if at all possible it'd be good if people indoors couldn't see it, in particular the outlaw. I assume and hope they also can't see you when you are indoors.
It's an area display. Sometimes you'll see it even if you're indoors because it's in the area you're in. As to whether they can see you indoors or not, that depends if you're by windows.
Blink wrote:The other thing in regards to crows, I think there should be some kind of range limit on them. Not necessarily due them not being able to physically fly out there, but more in regards to the chilling effect this can and is having on player interaction. I was greatly cheered when the Rum Runner captain told Blink that the Rum Village would soon be cleared. However, recently one of the crows perched on the Rum Runner ship. Now, this is great for freaking Blink out, but the problem is it kind of signifies to him as well that not even the Rum Village as safe.
There's really no safe place for an outlaw. It's been established that the guards have no limitation to where they can go and pull someone out who has committed a crime. Outside the walls is free range in terms of breaking laws established in the city, but not for being captured. There'll be places you'll be able to hide, but not indefinitely.
Blink wrote:In regards to NPCs. I really loved some of the NPC reactions when my law stat was recently changed, in particular when I was called "Infamous Blink." LOL. I've yet to see one of them take a swing at me though. Not sure if they are meant to. I think I should get bloodied now and then running through Pearl as I was. Gates closing on you might be cool too, but that perhaps needs to be limited if there are no other exits. Not everyone has portals after all. Perhaps make the interactions get more violent and numerous the longer you stay in Pearl after you are detected. Much like the raising star levels on the GTA games after you've done some major crimes.
The guards do attack, but they wont be able to get a swing off if a person runs by too fast. Unfortunately, people tend to spam run right by them.

The bounty hunter npcs are an interesting idea. We've spoken before about how there is, in fact, a bounty hunter system in the stock code, it's just not ready for use yet. It'll be fun when that goes in, one day, I'd like to think. Once you're an outlaw, the guards are always going to attack you when you're in the city. So it's not really something that can be escalated in this regard.

There's always going to be major consequences to being an outlaw, because being an outlaw signifies a character has done something exceptionally bad/dangerous/harmful/illegal.

Thank you for your feedback. Cheers.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Blink »

There's really no safe place for an outlaw. It's been established that the guards have no limitation to where they can go and pull someone out who has committed a crime. Outside the walls is free range in terms of breaking laws established in the city, but not for being captured. There'll be places you'll be able to hide, but not indefinitely.
I figured that. The issue I see is not so much that you can be captured anywhere. It's that anyone you talk to could be spotted talking to you and be pulled in for questioning. And the crows make them more likely to be seen with Blink.

You won't get any argument from me that it's not realistic. And I'm actually usually a big fan of realism in gaming and other art. Need for human interaction is indeed one of the thing that gets fugitives caught in the real world.

I do think there needs to be some leeway on this issue though so that outlaws have some small space to roleplay with others without causing them to get outlawed. Perhaps a windowless tavern in the Rum Village or something. Being outlawed has a huge impact and is not something you'd want inflict on your friends. The alternative is to avoid them, which is what I've mostly done. It just seems to cut down on interaction in the game overall, which isn't a good thing. (Even if it is good for my powertraining)
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Wren »

Completely agree with Blink there.

While Wren of course had ample reason and little choice but to alienate Blink, it really is a shame that she can't set foot anywhere near him without potentially getting into trouble, let alone exchange a few words, of which she would likely have plenty for him.

The law system is great and the sense of dread and danger it inspires even moreso, but there does have to be some leeway so that those outlawed still have a window of opportunity to 'safely' interact with other characters, without damning them in the process. The map is small enough that this is difficult as it is even while trying to be sneaky or creative about it.

All that to say, I miss RPing with him ;(
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Anselm »

I do not know where you're getting the idea that people cannot interact in private. These two characters plus a third interacted plenty in a private location whilst two characters were wanted. When the hounds went off all three moved appropriately, but the only reason the third character was ever questioned was because of public information. These are active decisions on part of the characters. No one is being stopped from meeting privately, but it cannot be helped if people make strange decisions to interact publicly or talk about it in front of NPC marshals. You must be aware of the game environment and understand there are consequences.

When another character was outlawed they spent time in the company of the others in private, and those characters were neither questioned or outlawed for being with them despite the crows or hounds, because they were never seen. They were questioned for other matters, yes, but not for being in the company because again, they were never seen.

If your characters want to meet, please, feel free. If they meet in public or somewhere semi-public or are seen by other PCs, that is a decision they've made and with it comes the consequences. I'd advise being more careful.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Blink »

Thanks Anselm. That clears it up. I didn't fully understand the game environment. It was the crow seeing someone talk to me and them getting outlawed that worried me. I understand I need to be careful. Something that must be understood is there just aren't a lot of interior rooms away from Pearl. You often have to choose between being far from Pearl and being outdoors, or being indoors but near Pearl.

Yeah, I wasn't fully aware of the Geel situation and didn't know he met someone. During the outlawing he pretty much didn't talk to me and sent a message that he was protecting me.
NotXavier
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 11
Joined: Wed Feb 12, 2014 12:17 pm

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by NotXavier »

Blink wrote:Yeah, I wasn't fully aware of the Geel situation and didn't know he met someone. During the outlawing he pretty much didn't talk to me and sent a message that he was protecting me.
This kinda thing should really be kept IC, man. I understand your need to explain out situations and give the example as to how you came to a certain conclusion/idea, though. Perhaps just use "Person1" and "Person2"? I know we aren't supposed to metagame and use OOC knowledge for IC gain, but some people will, regardless.

-Ryan
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Teef »

Board monitor Ryan to the rescue!
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: Outlaw Feedback: Crows, Gate Spells, and NPCs

Post by Austere »

Yes, not everyone knows what transpired with whom when. It is best to not name names, lest it create any biases.
Post Reply