I understand where you're coming from, and your point overall, but I feel there are other areas where this could be far more beneficial. I would in fact love to see a need for eating and the cooking skill eventually, and that is a very good example of where there is room to encourage more realism. There is a considerable difference in impact, though, when comparing a coded need for sustenance to coding a message for 'You think you sneak quietly to the east', and I'm not in fact sure if it's even possible to neither fail nor succeed but be 'unknown' in this game. (I know diddly squat about coding) In regards to the suspense aspect, let me throw this example out there: Though I clumsily sneak into a room, my character might not realize it and still try to immediately hide upon entering. Maybe she succeeds, and though everyone in the room saw her, they can pretend they didn't and begin talking about something entirely different/incorrect, which is one of the potential reactions you mentioned. All of this can be handled through RPing, the only issue (and it is a relevant one, mind you) is the potential of people abusing OOC knowledge to alter their RP, but ultimately I like knowing if it worked and being able to choose how to respond to a failed sneak attempt - either by a humorous show of failing spectacularly, or by my character thinking she got in quietly when she didn't and possibly being fed false information.
You see it as a coded solution vs asking for higher standards in roleplay, but the fact of the matter is that regardless of how thoroughly the designers code something, there will always be those that disregard it. I don't think it's at all unfair to ask that players treat matters IG/IC as someone would realistically, rather than try to herd them to that end with more complex coding. Case and point: deaths. There's something that desperately needs more attention both in coding and in the IC world.
There has to be a healthy balance of both, and I'd absolutely agree there are some aspects of the game that need to be tweaked in order to add more depth and realism to them, but Sneak would probably be last on my list.
Sneaking
Re: Sneaking
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: Sneaking
I'm with you on most of that. I'm not looking to win an argument on putting a third emote into the sneak process. I'm also well aware of the perpetual responsibility we all have to cheerfully step up when code seems inadequate or imperfect. I just became very concerned about a critique that underestimates or dismisses the power and usefulness (I would contend dominance) of code to promote good roleplay. I felt the counter-argument needed to be presented. Not lastly because I hoped to recognize the critical importance of coders to making a great game.Wren wrote:
There has to be a healthy balance of both, and I'd absolutely agree there are some aspects of the game that need to be tweaked in order to add more depth and realism to them, but Sneak would probably be last on my list.
Code defines our roleplay style to a much larger extent than maybe some people realize. To be convinced of that, go to another MUD with a different coding philosophy and experience how quickly your roleplay style shifts.
Bihi
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Sneaking
A good roleplayer doesn't need code to achieve immersion and what can pass for realism in a fantasy setting. You don't need extensive, even convoluted coding to promote good roleplay. Good roleplayers promote good roleplay.
I've played a lot of different games, and the roleplay I've experienced hasn't had a need for coding to be good. In fact, I've seen excellent roleplay DESPITE the game's code, in cases involving games that cater more to the raider or PvPer with mechanics that actually inhibit interaction(roleplay). As neat as it is to have filler and flair like needing to eat or bathe, it isn't required to make good, inclusive, immersive roleplay. PLAYERS make that.
The only change I'd ask for regarding sneak is returning the stamina cost to two. I shouldn't be able to spend less energy climbing than sneaking.
I've played a lot of different games, and the roleplay I've experienced hasn't had a need for coding to be good. In fact, I've seen excellent roleplay DESPITE the game's code, in cases involving games that cater more to the raider or PvPer with mechanics that actually inhibit interaction(roleplay). As neat as it is to have filler and flair like needing to eat or bathe, it isn't required to make good, inclusive, immersive roleplay. PLAYERS make that.
The only change I'd ask for regarding sneak is returning the stamina cost to two. I shouldn't be able to spend less energy climbing than sneaking.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Sneaking
Eating should not be required. It's against my character's roleplay, heheh.
Re: Sneaking
Good news, player-cooked food in Shattered Isles does give a boost in stamina and/or health!
Re: Sneaking
I feel sneaking should take 2 stam when not hidden and 4 stam while hidden since that would be a harder sneak to pull off.
And mages need to cast unarmed, unarmored, and without a shield.
And mages need to cast unarmed, unarmored, and without a shield.
Re: Sneaking
I like the idea of 2 when revealed and 4 when hidden!
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: Sneaking
Oh my god! I was just about to make that suggestion in a long thread about sneaking. What a coincidence.Teef wrote:And mages need to cast unarmed, unarmored, and without a shield.
Re: Sneaking
oh my god. sorry to beat you to it. you got next