Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Information regarding the latest updates to Shattered Isles. A complete list can be viewed in game from the account menu and also by using the UPDATES command.
Post Reply
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by Snaek »

For the past 6 months or longer, we've been working hard to try and find the source of some major bugs created by bundled resources. There's three main bugs here, one of which has been our biggest exploit that we've exhausted a lot of time monitoring to prevent it being abused. Currently, when you bundle resources together, add more to a bundle, get a single item from a bundle, or craft from a bundle, the recalculation process is not correctly totaling the value. The results range from making a bundle worth nothing, to seeing values rise far beyond their intended price. It's been nearly impossibly to catch, outside of the insanely high values that many of you have reported witnessing.

We recently reached out to the main programmer of our code base for help, along with some other outside sources we often go to for complicated issues such as this. We were able to narrow down the issue, but it has proven to be too far reaching and too complex to address at this time. Rather than continue to invest time into closing a loophole, time better spent on more important aspects of the game, we've decided to go a different route that addresses the problem for the short term, and can serve as a long term fix until we reach a time when the issue can be revisited.

Starting today, you will no longer be able to sell bundled resources to shops. The resource shops in the Academy and Pearl will still stock supplies for you to purchase, but they will no longer buy anything from you. Unbundled resources will also not be sellable for the time being. This will be a setback for some that have advanced by gathering resources for selling, but from the monitoring we've done, the majority of you gather with the intent of crafting. Not to sell to shops. We've seen a PC market spring up as well for crafting and we feel this will aid that endeavor more as they'll become the place to sell large quantities of resources. That is the silver lining to this change.

This is a temporary change, but one we feel can stand for the long run if the issue can't be resolved. We've considered many options and this approach eliminates the risk of a bug being abused, either on purpose or by accident. One faulty priced bundle can easily eclipse the bank account of any player in game. Fortunately you all have been great about reporting this, but we also don't have an idea of how often the pricing has been effected on a smaller scale that went unnoticed. When more pressing issues have been taken care of, we fully intend to revisit this problem with a fresh perspective and a better understanding.

Thanks for your patience and understanding with issues such as these. We would rather have things working at 100% then add more capabilities that don't work as they should.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by ditchhook »

I'm a big fan of making lemon-aide out of lemons.

This may be a good opportunity to push towards a 'free' economy entirely based on player decisions.

The main issue to overcome is to bridge the connection between buyers and sellers who might be willing to buy, sell, or trade a resource, but are not in the same part of the world, or logging on at the same time.

I know that CoffeeMUD 'out of the box' has an auction option: folks put an object into the auction, and other folks can go to the auction house and see what's been offered and bid. After a limited time (48 hours?) the highest bidder gets to pick up the item, and the seller gets the money deposited in their account. Might that be adapted to this purpose?
Bihi
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by Shadowbane »

For those who haven't figured it out, you haven't lost your craft skills. They show up under a different command called TRADE.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by Snaek »

Update:

We're still powering through the resource shops, but we're finding you can still sell your resources individually. This process will take further adjusting to have gathered resources match the ones sold in shops. Part of a larger overhaul to the game's economy to balance pricing based on the material used in each item. We're not economists, but staying true to the raw material value gives us better consistency from top to bottom. Unfortunately, it's a long process to get gathering, treasure, skinning, shops, and custom items on the same page.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by ditchhook »

Snaek wrote:Update:
Part of a larger overhaul to the game's economy to balance pricing based on the material used in each item. We're not economists, but staying true to the raw material value gives us better consistency from top to bottom. Unfortunately, it's a long process to get gathering, treasure, skinning, shops, and custom items on the same page.
I think that you may be underestimating the difficulty of that task.

Players can and will figure out all the 'right' prices for you. As players come and go, and player tastes change, and other parts of the game are developed, players can and will be clever and adapt much faster (in their particular interest and specialty) than the admins can figure out all the little repercussions of a change. If it's too easy to forage something, people will do it until the price offered by other players goes down. If it's too difficult, the price offered will go up until the foragers find it worthwhile. If there are no players codedly capable of making something others want, the demand will skyrocket, players will work towards being capable.

Once all that comes into a precarious balance, it becomes much easier for staff to make realistic RP events. Close an area that supplies an important resource and suddenly prices change and players need to adapt.

Harness our greed and ambition! Don't see it as losing power over the game. See it as dumping onto the players' collective plate a whole bunch of tedious, never-ending tasks so you can concentrate on the big picture.
Bihi
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Bundle Issues, Resource Shop Changes

Post by ditchhook »

One example: The reason there is a vibrant market for bone at the moment is exactly because there isn't an infinite supply of bone at the 'proper' price at a coded shop. That has spurred player interaction, wheeling-dealing, even speculation about what at that bone is being used for?!
Bihi
Post Reply