The Consistency of Staff and General Guidelines

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

The Consistency of Staff and General Guidelines

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

One of the more frequent buzzwords in the Shattered Isles vocabulary is “consistency” and that’s a matter I’d like to address tonight. Something we’d likely all agree upon is there’s no shame in striving for consistency and it’s a goal to be sought in almost all fields, which is admirable (unless your field is ‘serial killer’). However, when the desire and theory of consistency ends up in a practise of inconsistency, well, we run into some problems and discouragement amongst those to whom such a promise is sold.

As this is the player feedback forum and there is a history here of hard criticism of staff, I would hope a move to open dialogue and discussion is welcomed instead of shutdown. Additionally, considering staff doesn’t have a problem critiquing behaviour of players in-game which need to be addressed - the discussion on death -, likewise I would hope they’re welcoming of this kind of public discourse.

In the past nine months the playerbase has been given word on quick or soon to come bug fixes, skill updates of a major kind, templar implementation, more spell and prayers added, open areas, expanded crafting and treasure lists, fixed crafting prices, more varied hunting grounds, dual wield, poisons and traps off the top of my head. Of these there have been three spell/prayers added between the two of them (with the now promise of spell evolution to be ‘coming’), two areas open back at the beginning of January (I don’t think the opening of the main city in the game is applicable) - or six months ago - as well as some tweaking to bite and changing of sneak. If I'm mistaken and some of these have been put in, I apologise - they're not on the update list which I can find. It’s not unheard of for pledges to be broken or go unmet. There are times when what one wishes to accomplishes is simply beyond their skillset. Yet each of these have been promised in every single meeting (perhaps the Vukasin RP meeting aside) which has been held by staff in the aforementioned time frame.

When a promised outcome doesn’t happen once or twice, it’s understandable. When it becomes a theme to give assurances of “upcoming month” or “next update” which never come to fruition, it starts to churn itself into discouragement, disappointment and disenchantment. It’s absolutely true unforeseen events or shortcomings can come up, all easily understandable. Yet when it starts coming across as lip service or a means to make those in charge be seen in better light, it doesn’t boost morale. Quite the opposite, it quickly and quite assuredly erodes morale and confidence because it is realised they are empty words. If staff is unable to complete a project on time, don’t have the means to finish an update when they had anticipated or it is beyond them, it’d be better served to simply stop giving specific deadlines and guarantees. People, at least reasonable ones who are mature, are both forgiving and understanding to delays and shortcomings - as long as they’re not being fed pretty words with little substance.

On the matter of crafting, whilst absolutely the pricing would take a longer time than putting in additional items this doesn’t answer the question as to why the item lists are for the most part still barren. Outside of I believe the scrimshaw list which was scarcely updated a month ago, none of the other lists have been touched beyond a few considerations here and there. I’m sure most of us players understand it can be a smidge irritating to come up with new items; yet, at the end of January staff asked players to submit items and they were given several good ones by Seren, Coraleth and Wren which have either not made their way into the game or have been so little used it’s escaped the mind (the same point is applied to the treasure list which staff long ago asked for items and in the last six months were given some which fit the theme of the game by Visyn and Loriel, yet I don’t think there’s been any added outside of a few rags).

Additionally, a suggestion by a former player to help bulk up the list by implementing an increasing adjective lists for each new level was brushed aside. For those who don’t understand the idea, because whilst I can be wordy sometimes I’m also a little obscure, it’d essentially be a broader, more innovative use of single items over and over again like is somewhat currently in use. An example is the game has some items such as a cup or a simple cup or an intricate cup, but they’re spread multiple levels apart. The suggestion here was to do a level one cup (for example) as just ‘a cup’, followed by at level two ‘a simple cup’, level three ‘a smooth cup’, with increasingly more elaborate, in-depth and multiple adjectives as we progress up our crafting lists. Most of the crafting lists currently stop between level sixteen and twenty for new items gained, which can be disheartening for those who delve into the crafting world or find it a nice escape from the doldrums of combat. There could be an argument by staff against the addition of new adjectives per level, transitioning to multiples past a certain point, by saying it would interfere with peddle events. If such thoughts are held I would say, whilst yes I understand such a point, but I would hope peddle items from staff might strive for a format beyond a/an <one simple adjective> <jewel/metal/wood> <basic name> which is how the crafting format under such circumstances would work. Ideally we’d have a system in which players could add their own adjectives to the works they’ve created in the crafting system - beyond gaining such a simplistic ability by becoming an apprentice or merchant and having staff make the items for you -, but I don’t know if that’s now within staff’s abilities to do so.

Moving on from crafting and back solely to the mantra of consistency (though crafting, which is used as an a stand-in for all unmet promises on skills, classes, abilities and expansion, also certainly falls under this topic), I wanted to touch upon the inconsistent, back-and-forth nature of necessary information learned in-game, on the boards and on the website as presented by staff. Now obviously scenario information, random information which is vital to an actor’s background but not moving in-game events forward, chit-chat and conversational pieces of this nature they don’t apply, and one should be as vague, obscure as they do or do not want. This isn’t what I want to address. Whether staff agrees and then forgets, or they change their mind, there must be consistency in how vital process and position related information is handed to the players. Be it from misinformation to multiple parties on the emissary process, to there being no lead authority figure amongst the knights in Pearl to suddenly being a Lord Marshal (can we rename him Jon Snow?), encouraging players to submit ways to enhance the game through the conclave (buildings, items, shops, etc), then trying to steer players back to putting forth those submissions OOCly, and finally to pertinent information regarding religion and lore which still isn’t greatly detailed on the website, despite the falling in with the previously mentioned promises, but is handed out when randomly asked at OOC events - not all which are logged or read, and thus isn’t fair to the rest of the playerbase who don’t have an equal opportunity to come across this knowledge which would undoubtedly help them enhance their characters. It’d be appreciated by several current players and myself, and I don’t speak for any others outside of those I know, though they might feel the same, if staff could at the very least, if they don’t have a desire or time to present this information publicly, if they’d sit down with each other and set a guideline to follow on these topics internally. This way all players are given the same exact information on the processes detailed above. As I’ve said before and I’ll repeat here again, certainly decisions and thought processes change, but staff can’t try to hold players to guidelines of which they’re never made aware, nor is it fair for players to suffer because staff change their minds, forget or don’t consult with one another on these should-be-set-mostly-in-stone matters.

Then there’s OOC matters such as the class change process as well as blended IC/OOC ones such as post removal and reactions in-game. I will not bring up what it entails the class change because I respect staff’s desire to keep it private, however it’s something that’s gone back and forth each time. Maybe it’s set in stone now, which I’m sure players wishing to go through this change would greatly appreciate. However, it’s an example where it wasn’t in the past and that can be a detriment to some players thinking about taking that ‘plunge’, if you will. It isn’t fair to them, it jerks their chain in a matter of speaking, and quite understandably they might be a bit irritated by it. Once more, completely fair to not want to post the process and maybe not a lot agree but I think some would, but hopefully it’s reached a point where it’s completely settled amongst staff so players don’t get conflicting information. Likewise, the same applies for how to react in-game and on the boards to casual OOC matters. It’d long been held a process to encourage players to outright enforcing them to respond in-character as much as possible, even to casual OOC slip ups. We’ve seen people respond to the dreaded afkchoo used in an IC setting for example, and I think that’s a credit to players to be IC even when OOC situations creep in. Staff has always preached immersion as being paramount and at the forefront of their wish in-game, yet it seems we’re at a crossroads as to how this is applied or not. Maybe it’s now in fact a rule set by staff to not respond ICly in all circumstances, but it’s not posted anywhere at all. It’s long been said by staff that IC posts are in fact not deleted, and there’s only three occasions under which this was previously done:

1. When a IC post about a major OOC transfer message for a staff character was posted, implying the character was the god of death. This post was deleted, but it was then said by staff that this wasn’t how they wanted to operate, and in the future such things would be handled ICly.

2. Multiple posts regarding the same topic posted by the same player, but they weren’t deleted until two months later.

3. Some posts were edited due to some inappropriate - on an adult level - content.

It’s confusing when a helpful IC nudge over an OOC mistake is pulled immediately when it falls under the same vein staff previously encouraged - in particular the sentiment that OOC behaviour would be policed a majority of the time by the players ICly. Especially when one of the arguments is, inexplicably, that a reminder was given for OOC reasons. One would think the original mistake was made due to OOC reasons, that being it was simply easier to copy and paste the in-game EVENT calendar into an old post, OOC events and all, without changing it one bit. Now, again (it feels like I’ve said that a lot, little repetitive, apologies!), while I certainly understand policy is subject to change, considering this has been encouraged and enforced for in-game circumstances and also encouraged on the boards between players, wouldn't it be best to have a written statement and guideline for how staff wishes for players to handle these moments going forward? With a guideline there’s a clear way for players to understand how to properly handle these moments, rather than it coming off like a staff member is feeling embarrassed about a mistake they’ve made and are lashing out at players who corrected them. There’s nothing wrong with a little self-deprecation, humility and accountability all wrapped together.

I’m sure most of us might hold the thought that in-game meetings and events tend to drag on, which isn’t helped by the unavoidable fact that many of them are scheduled later into the evening. The gradual removal of the bickering from the conclave is likely a great help, but there’s other ways in both this event and others which can improve. It’d be a help to the playerbase if staff always came prepared to these events, stuck to the dates they’ve set (though absolutely there’s times this is unavoidable, but repeatedly brings questions and frustration) and start events on time and not thirty minutes to an hour after. Meetings don’t drag on because of players, I’m afraid, they drag on for the most part because of staff.

Finally, I want to bring up the idea of skills put into the live server and testing done on the live server. There’s been numerous cases where a skill, ability, MOB and/or hunting ground aren’t working properly due to lack of testing on the appropriately named test server. As a result some pretty big game-changing, game-hurting, game-influencing bugs have been brought over into the live environment. Obviously and naturally there’s a difference opinion between all players on whether this should be done, but like a player at a previous meeting said, it can be discouraging to new players to see these kinds of bugs which can be game-breaking when they’ve first entered the world. Likewise, when skills and hunting grounds are tested by a small number of players on the live-server, this can end in some added benefits (skill gain, monetary gain) to them which aren’t afforded to the rest of the playerbase. I’d encourage staff to make use of the test server by setting up certain trial hours where they can oversee players who want to help and test upcoming changes on the test server. This way it’s in a controlled environment with little effect on the live world, players can be rewarded in other ways such as roleplay items, and it doesn’t end up breaking the game or going unreported by a player or two who might come across an exploit in it which benefits them. It isn’t fair to most of the players to do little testing on vital abilities, areas and skills before it's thrown them into a live game. Understandably staff might not have the time to test it to the amount they want, but it often doesn’t seem like they’re tested very much at all. Under this process, a willing playerbase would be able to poke around at these changes on the test server and this better serves everyone, instead of punishing the playerbase on the live server - even if unintended.

I understand the desire and wishes for staff to live by a standard and meet goals - both public and internal. Yet standard and goals are not met on buzzwords and catchphrases alone. If they remain only theory instead of executed practise, then we’ll continue to experience a Shattered Isles which speaks over and over regarding “consistency”, but in truth is mired in the reality of low expectations, pretty words filled with unmet or unrealistic promises and dispiriting inconsistency most of all.

Thank you to those who took the time to read, and I hope everyone has a nice week.
Post Reply