Crafting philosophy

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Crafting philosophy

Post by ditchhook »

Right now Bihi is working on having his own cottage. In a nutshell the process is this: he collects resources from the wild, spam crafts them into meaningless trinkets, and sells them wholesale in the pawn shop or supply shop, banks the money, and repeats until he has enough to buy an IC house. Others might just rely on mob drops to collect the money to buy their home.

It is a very individualist effort that promotes lone spam crafting or hunting instead of player interaction.

I propose a different approach; one where all the components that make up a home need to be assembled by a player, and these components would reach across many crafts. Clay roof tiles, or straw 'thatch' bundles, glass window panes, iron nails and hinges, wood doors or shutters, glass or bone doorknobs, clay or stone bricks, wood beams and floor boards, etc. All these items (and possibly more) would be in one or another craft list that PCs can create. And staff would intentionally spread the items all across the various crafts.

And while all the components could (and must) be made by characters, mostly likely not all by one single character. A home might need one thousand clay tiles, one thousand nails, 20 glass window panes, 5000 bricks, etc. The 'spam crafting' of such bulk items would make more IC sense-- at least to me. If it's not to take forever, a player would need to rely on friends and allies of different skill sets to get the job done. Only after all these items are assembled would builders create the coded room, and delete the items from the world. The lone wolf would still eventually be able to make their own home, but it would take them much longer.

This idea can be expanded:

A simple example would be: feathers plus wood shafts plus bone/metal/stone arrow heads make arrows. Only a scout can make the arrows, but she would need to have some other skills to make the components-- so much so that only a more advanced player could do it all on their own: most players would end up relying on other players' skills for some component for a long while. And for me, making a thousand bone arrow-heads makes more sense to me than a thousand bone earrings, especially when other players are asking for that component to complete their own projects-- even if only occasionally. I would feel that my crafting was having more of an impact on other players and the game world. And 'assembly' crafts: like quivers or shields or swords would have very high failure rates, demanding dozens of components for one successful product, thus sucking up lots of the beginning crafters product and encouraging more senior crafters to recruit 'apprentices' to make the easier items for them.

The point is to promote player interdependencies, alliances, and mentoring-- encouraging senior players to recruit junior players to help accomplish their goals.
Bihi
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Shadowbane »

And what about those who DON'T want to rely on others? For example, my character trusts very few people in the game. Why should she turn to people she likely doesn't like or trust for help in building her home? I will go and interact when I chose to, I don't want to be forced into it. Sometimes, I just want to play alone. It doesn't mean I'll blow people off if they come across me, it just means my character isn't in the mood to chat.

I don't believe forcing people to interact is the best approach. Players will interact when they wish to. Forcing it on them will only frustrate them and possibly push them away from the game. Right now, SI can't afford to do something like that. Instead of making it mandatory for players/characters to interact with each other (which, really, is a little unfair to those who prefer a slightly more solitary form of game play), those looking to interact on this level should put themselves out there instead. Got a material or service to sell? That's what the ATC forum is for. There's a good chance that someone in the game is willing to pay for convenience.

If a player wants to contribute massive amounts of material to a building effort, I believe it should help cut the financial cost of the construction. To my knowledge, something like that is in place already. Instead of a lot of money spent, it's a lot of time spent, and I feel that makes it even. But I don't believe forced interaction among players and characters will help with growth. Those looking to mentor, be mentored, or build alliances and connections will find opportunities for it, as they have in the past. Don't get me wrong, it's a solid idea, but with how SI is currently, I don't think anyone would truly benefit from it besides a very small circle. :\
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Wren »

Shadowbane pretty well covered any points I'd have to make, but in addition to her comment about SI having a small playerbase, we also have to keep in mind that the lore and story of Shattered Isles heavily emphasizes religious conflict. Unfortunately with how few players we currently have, we're already forced to rely on other characters far too much for hunting groups, and social RP in general. Characters we, ideally and realistically, should be tense around if not outright against. Trying to force more reliance on each other is not, in my opinion, a good idea, especially not while the amount of active characters to a temple is so horribly unbalanced.

Instead, I would like to see public projects be open to crafters. Things like the bath house, the museum, etc. That way characters have the choice to chip in and see it built, and could perhaps receive payment for the resources they provide.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by ditchhook »

Shadowbane: not once did I use the words "force" or "mandatory." Not once did I imply it is wrong for you to go solo. Critique my ideas, please. But don't recast them into something I neither implied nor would agree with and then critique that.

Wren: I like your idea of a public project. But I believe you are off base a bit with your larger premise. If all of us can do anything we desire in the game on our own, there is no motivation FOR conflict. Scheming, betrayal, rivalry; these all start out with a character needing something they cannot get on his or her own. If you want dramas and conflicts (as I do) it behooves you to create characters and groups relying on one another to accomplish great goals. The other thing you need to consider is how 'left out' new (weak) players can feel, We should not be sending the message to them that they will be allowed the full benefit of the game only if they 'pay their dues' with months and months of tedious, repetitive troll killing, and in the meantime be ignored at best, or picked upon at worst. Every new player that logs on should-- within a week-- feel they are important to, and welcomed by, a faction of the player base; and have a contribution to make NOW, not in some distant future, after they spends months and months of boring mob slaughter so they can be 'strong.' That's never going to fly.

And maybe we are at some level speaking past each other: our little competition for bones to craft is in my view exactly what I'm writing about here: Bihi and Wren creating conflict (at least by me) getting new players involved in a simple project (collecting bones for Bihi) that builds alliances between Bihi and them. They come to Bihi for advice on where to get bones fastest, etc. They have the option of betraying me and selling to you if you can motivate that successfully. I cannot achieve my goal (quickly advancing my schrimshaw knowledge) without their help-- nor can you. That's what I mean by creating conflict via interdependence.

I've played lots of MUDs and have seen lots of tricks I can use to quickly integrate a new player into the game culture rather quickly, but many of the newbies I meet here are not so adept at that. They are quite befuddled by 'how to play' a mud and quickly bore (as we all do) of the repetitive monster bashing or crafting. If it weren't for triggers and my DVD, I would have abandoned this game long ago.
Bihi
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Shadowbane »

Shadowbane: not once did I use the words "force" or "mandatory." Not once did I imply it is wrong for you to go solo. Critique my ideas, please. But don't recast them into something I neither implied nor would agree with and then critique that.
I may not have been very clear, but let me show you what I read that made me feel people could be forced into interactions they don't want.
I propose a different approach; one where all the components that make up a home need to be assembled by a player, and these components would reach across many crafts.
And staff would intentionally spread the items all across the various crafts.
And while all the components could (and must) be made by characters, mostly likely not all by one single character.
The lone wolf would still eventually be able to make their own home, but it would take them much longer.
Bold and italics added by me for a little emphasis. I feel that this method would take away from the solo player. Why should any player who enjoys their solo play feel forced to rely on other people to get something they want, that everyone else has access to? Or, if they're that opposed, why should they feel forced to level the game's various crafting skills to get what they want without help?
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Wren »

I guess what I'm not understand is why we should need each other to have our own homes built. That is, as far as I can see, the main goal behind your idea of interdependence. For the sake of example, my PC should not have to go looking for the help of people who she's fully aware are only pretending to be her friends in order to get the necessary materials to build a home for herself. She and her partner both worked hard and saved up their coins in order to buy one. This is their accomplishment alone, and that's how it should be for everyone.

I've played this game long enough now to know people will happily create conflict even when there is little to no premise for it. This is by no means me complaining, I am merely stating fact. Bihi stepping in on Wren's bone market is one of the better ones I've seen so far. That is an example of proper conflict which makes sense, but I don't feel this is something that should be applied to player housing. I stand by my statement that striving for more interdependence should not be considered until we have a larger playerbase and, as a result, more options with who our characters can approach to get things.
The other thing you need to consider is how 'left out' new (weak) players can feel, We should not be sending the message to them that they will be allowed the full benefit of the game only if they 'pay their dues' with months and months of tedious, repetitive troll killing, and in the meantime be ignored at best, or picked upon at worst.
I needed to quote this because I'm quite honestly a bit lost. Who is picking on new players? Who is ignoring them? How is requiring other crafters to build your home going to make them feel as if they are being given the full benefit of the game, especially since they would have a far lower skill than our present avid crafters? As far as I've seen, and personally experienced, most characters are helpful and invite newer ones to hunt, go to faith meetings, tell them about drink night, etc. Whether that player/character actually GOES, is another matter entirely, and ultimately their responsibility.

Likewise, it is their responsibility to establish their character in the world and befriend others, in order to see themselves further involved in what ever dealings those characters may have. You implied that a player should feel important regardless of their skill levels, and I completely agree - they can attain this by roleplaying. I come back to this point a lot, because I feel it can some times be forgotten or disregarded. This is a roleplaying game. If you want to be involved in something, if you want to befriend people and feel like part of a group, you do it through RPing your character.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by ditchhook »

On housing: as it stands now I NEED to collect so much money to have a home. In that sense it's a requirement. You can play solo and grind out money and eventually buy a home. I am quite confident that if we had say a low level craft to produce roof tiles (instead of figurines or whatever) the shops will be full of roof tiles and someone who wishes to play solo can take their money to the shop and buy the necessary materials to build their home. What I'm proposing is not pushing the current process aside. It is admittedly adding a step. But it also adds a whole new aspect of play: where players who wish to have a home can approach newer and less experienced players for help: "the shop pays you 2 for a roof tile, but I'll pay you 3, and I'll avoid paying the retail price of 6."

I believe I've created more than a thousand bone earrings in this game, while no one else in the game has any use for more than maybe two. Right now the game ENCOURAGES me to play solo: to spam craft junk I know the pawnshop will buy. If I could build ANYTHING that could be of much use to other players, I would have a prop: a tool I can use to create roleplay, especially roleplay with players of different skill levels. Right now I would guess 99% of purchases are between player and pawn shop, and the vast majority items ending up there are just deleted from play.

Right now the only PCs that can make something other players generally desire are master crafters and their peddles. A more complex virtual economy-- one we all can make something potentially useful from the first week or so we play-- would enhance the game by giving newbies a sense of worth, by creating more opportunities for roleplay, and by a deeper sense of emersion.

Creating thousands of bone earrings doesn't enhance my sense of emersion.

I see a MUD that requires roleplay as kind of a virtual stage where we all work together to put on a vast, unending play. The objects in the game world are our props: objects the purpose of which is to advance the story, support our imaginations, or-- like the Maltese Falcon-- become the stuff dreams are made of. We as a community could make much better use of our 'props' than we are now.
Bihi
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Shadowbane »

So why not just propose that in the first place? Instead of making a suggestion that sounds like "let's force players to interact" when you get to the short of it, you could have made crafting suggestions for the various fields and followed it up with "these could be applied to the housing market to lower costs. Not only that, Player A can make tiles, sell it to the pawnshop, and Players B, C, and D can buy them for their house." It's all about the wording.

I can agree with something like that. The crafting skills still need some sprucing up, with items that could be made useful to players and the game itself. I also like the idea of crafting "quests" that require you to make so many of a certain item to get an item reward necessary to complete a really nice crafting oriented tool or item.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Swamp Ape »

I like the idea and frankly I'm not really sure why your shooting it down so hard.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Crafting philosophy

Post by Shadowbane »

Because the wording made it sound like mandatory or forced interaction between characters. I like the idea of crafting having more purpose, don't get me wrong. I just don't believe people who prefer more solo play, or those who play characters that are very well aware that their friends aren't really friends, should suffer if they chose to not work with people to get something they want. They should have the option to use money from hunting to fund projects if they don't like crafting, and they should have the option to do it on their own.

Options and wording, that's all.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Post Reply