New Armour Values and Changes

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Swamp Ape »

I apologize if I took part in derailing this thread. As a Priest I took offense when I read this.
SquallScribe wrote:A level 10 priest in healing can out-heal vampire damage even when someone is wearing 'new' value armor - or even no armor at all.
This is a generalized statement that needed more information it to enhance what SquallScribe was claiming to be fact. Without doing so it was indeed an irresponsible statement. The additional information that was later presented makes this plausible. A moderately skilled player can be kept alive by level 10 heal in the Vampires.

There is a difference between claiming a level 10 healer can out-heal vampire damage and claiming a level 10 healer can keep a moderately skilled PC alive in vampires.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Bocon L »

I'm sorry, but the statement that "Armor does not detract from the talents of a priest" is totally false. Anything that reduces or mitigates damage, be it Armor, Mending, or Defenses, detracts from the need for healing. Then the level 10 comment was made and that added to the pot and was not taken well by not only me, but by others as well. I was the one who brought up priests briefly in my first comment, because I was concerned about the effect of higher armor values. But instead of seeing a players concern and opinion, you guys took it personally.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Swamp's person,

Please read the quoted sample again.
SquallScribe wrote:A level 10 priest in healing can out-heal vampire damage even when someone is wearing 'new' value armor - or even no armor at all.
There's two unique people here. First to the priest and then to 'someone', the someone being in reference her and me in our own hunting party - a fact referenced multiple times in this thread. We used our own testing we did whilst on a temple hunt, unbeknownst to the poor priest as I decided to start testing without armour, and this is the context which is referred to and pretty clearly, honestly. It isn't an irresponsible comment when the context is openly there and has been referenced a number of times.

The priest was a low level member of our hunting group. The "someone" was her and me as we have laid out we were the ones testing, and "someone" suggests another person other than the priest. I'm fairly positive since we've competed in both OOC games and the AFC that anyone who has ever watched that knows we're capable of hunting vampires - let alone seen us there -, and neither of us are level ten melee/caster sitting there having it out-healed. I don't know how we can keep pointing this out, how the context and comment could be any clearer or more connected. Instead a thread about the very real changes to armour, with a brief mention of how a priest was unknowingly part of the test whilst hunting, has somehow been made by priests as if people were calling for them to be nerfed. Easily read comments have been labeled irresponsible, bold and untrue (despite factual testing), and has taken away from how this change primarily affects not even the two of us, but rather solo hunters, people who weren't informed and new players.
Bocon L wrote:I'm sorry, but the statement that "Armor does not detract from the talents of a priest" is totally false. Anything that reduces or mitigates damage, be it Armor, Mending, or Defenses, detracts from the need for healing. Then the level 10 comment was made and that added to the pot and was not taken well by not only me, but by others as well. I was the one who brought up priests briefly in my first comment, because I was concerned about the effect of higher armor values. But instead of seeing a players concern and opinion, you guys took it personally.
Armour doesn't detract from the talents of a priest. Armour coexists with the healing capabilities of a priest, especially in a system with a tighter damage range (to be implemented). If people don't want to hunt with priests it's because of a playstyle preference (almost assuredly solo), and has nothing to do with the value of a priest to a group. I don't think there's a group in the game that wouldn't take a priest under the OLD armour values (50% and 5 which most people had access to), and absolutely under these new values which I hope staff is testing.

Priests make life indescribably easier and more efficient for all players who want to hunt with others, they decrease downtime, irritation, a need for potions of either kind, and make hunting a much more relaxed and enjoyable experience.

The level ten comment could not be clearer in the context or what it was concerned, since the entire conversation thus far had been centered around two people hunting in vampires who were accompanied by a priest on a temple hunt. The only direct response to your initial post by itself and the roles of priests was by Wren's player, presumably because the character prefers to solo hunt for the most part. The others were centered around the original purpose of this thread: armour value changes, with a slight reference to a priest being there on a temple hunt to give further context to armour values.

Mending once upon a time did in fact detract from prayers, ONLY because it was actually out performing them. For example, level 50 wound was doing 30-80 return where level 50 healing touch was returning 20-28. This obviously wasn't intended, and it was fixed promptly with some annoyance expressed by those who used mend frequently. But that has been fixed, and it doesn't detract from priests now because with a 5 second delay in combat, an increase in failure rate in combat and much lower returns, someone cannot sit there and mend themselves against anything above lower tier/non-swarming academy MOBs.

There was no one else to "take it personally" from your original post, because no one else responded to it alone. The post by Faran's player only made brief mention about the roles of priest and armour not detracting and how from her experience that wasn't true, the rest was in response to everyone else. However, when you start saying people make comments which are "unbelievably ignorant" and "had no real thought behind it" (in particular when they have made it clear this is something that actually happened to them and they tested it), when you yourself have taken the original comment out of context, yes, I will take it personally and respond to correct you. But I'm the only one to do so, so there isn't an "you guys." I'm the only one to respond to you since you made that comment.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Wren »

Bocon,

Your concern seemed more like you saying "Armor is shitty now? Good, that means people will need me more" and unfortunately that isn't going to be well received by people who enjoy solo or small-group hunting and, depending on their class, may already have added limitations in place :/ Priests are a commodity as it is and once an area with stronger mobs opens up, even with blacksteel and arcsilver armor (As it was/should be. Not this new version), you will be all the more beneficial to a hunting party.
I'm sorry, but the statement that "Armor does not detract from the talents of a priest" is totally false. Anything that reduces or mitigates damage, be it Armor, Mending, or Defenses, detracts from the need for healing.
No, it detracts from the need of having to go and find a healer to follow you around everywhere if you ever want to train your combat skills, and hunt for money in any moderately efficient capacity.
I was the one who brought up priests briefly in my first comment, because I was concerned about the effect of higher armor values. But instead of seeing a players concern and opinion, you guys took it personally.
Beyond my response to you that included "I" when addressing the potential argument of Priests being a necessity, no one took what you said personally. Certainly not to the point of warranting some rather snarky and unnecessary comments from you.
So you're telling me that a person with good DR and defensive skills is easily kept alive? If I could post the ORLY owl here, I would do that.
Like this.
The comment made about priests being better off than mages with the armor change was unbelievably ignorant and had no real thought put behind it.
You misunderstood her post, there was no need to be rude.
It would take you far less time to kill something and heal, than it would for me to do the exact same thing.
You're a support class, there is no fathomable reason why you would or should be able to kill something as easily or better than any other class, with perhaps the exception of undead, so I'm not entirely sure why this point was in here.
I'm sorry you guys are hurt and don't agree with the changes, but belittling people for having a difference of opinion is really childish.
Stating facts to counter someone's argument is not belittling them. This entire thread is based around facts attained through intended testing.
There's a lot of self entitlement going on in here too, which I am having a hard time understanding.
Self-entitlement? Like wanting your class to be needed instead of letting people have some choice in how they want to play if they don't have a healer buddy? No one is trying to be self-entitled. This concern is for all players who may be currently handicapped in hunting due to shoddy armor, yourself included.
The biggest downfall I see from this, however, is that people are going to instantly explode in PvP if it's anything other than a 1 on 1.
This I agree with. I'm sincerely hoping it'll be re-fixed to how it was before the next tournament.
Well I thought the original post was well written, brought up valid concerns, and was informative. I for one had no idea that there were changes currently occurring to armor protection values. I'm not sure how the post was interpreted as a direct or indirect call to nerf priests. The main point I walked away with was that the new armor protection values for store bought armor was too similar to peddle armor that costs exponentially more. I'm glad the OP brought it up, now its up to staff to determine if thats the way they want it or not.
Thank you for this, Req. This is what I got out of it as well and I do hope it is looked into some, there's no reason high end armor should have such a marginal difference in protection from store-bought stuff and lesser qualities such as crudesteel, orichalcum and thoraxium. Assuming this is the armor we'll be using for a good while longer, I hope all the more as once new hunting areas open up with stronger creatures, we'll really need it.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Now to respond to other things and hopefully get this back on track to armour, and clear up any confusion.

I've already address wound mending so I wont rehash it.
Bocon L wrote:I cannot solo anything past a lesser vampire with my skill levels as a priest. Even then, if I'm only using holy strike, I still have to retreat to heal most of the time. I cannot heal AND do damage AND vigor myself AND try to turn and expect to live. Our heal heals for 20 points of damage on average and lesser vampires hit me anywhere from 0 to 30+ through armor. If I'm lucky, I can solo one without the need to retreat. If I'm unlucky, I have to run within a few hits. Did I mention it takes 15 or more holy strikes to even kill one? Let's also bring up that priest spell failure rates are far higher than a mage at the equivalent level. I'm not really going to get into the failure rates, pure randomness of success and the amount of uncontrollable things that occur, when you do get a turn off.
No one said a priest could solo anything as in hunt it, the entire original comments were about how a member of the hunting party was out-healing the damage done to another member whilst they were unarmoured. Also, whilst you may not be able to do so I've seen priests of extraordinarily low levels hunt lesser vampires with relatively little to worry over, though it was lengthy. There might've been some changes recently, even disregarding this armour business, that makes it so that isn't the case. But no one was even talking about this in the first place. However, the reason you're now taking 30+ damage is because of the armour changes which was the original point of this thread, and it effects people like yourself and not you alone.

It takes most people of all levels - melee, priests and mages - 15 attacks on a vampire to kill it. Anywhere between 12-18, really. I don't know if there's any real difference between failure rates, the RNG can be pretty brutal. I've seen mages fail an invigoration seven times in a row. From an eyeball test it looked about the same between the two from all the hunts I've had with both a mage and a priest, but I never calculated any of them like I've done for the data regarding armour in this thread (and previous posts about mechanics).
Bocon L wrote:Every other class in the game is able to hunt other mobs, while we are stuck with the crypt or vampires. After many, many, many runs in both areas solo, I made more on average per 2 hours of hunting in the crypt, than I did in vampires. As a mage or melee, you can easily hunt other MOBS that pay similarly and don't hit nearly as hard. So I don't understand why you would pick the hardest MOB in the game for anyone to solo, to test on and base your assumptions around.
I don't know your levels, but the above isn't a unique to you. That's the case for any class in any game. You can hunt above your levels and be successful at it, but you probably wont be efficient at it at the same time. So you can hunt in your specific range and make more money, or you can underhunt and make extremely more money, but again that's for every class. You see it with melee and mages, too. Well, mages a little bit less because they have a higher low end for damage, but a lower high end (again, something both Blink and Faran's players have brought up). Plus, resists are real wonky right now so a mage (and priests - though I think for priests resist is actually working on MOBs) 'hits' more often than their melee counterparts. Which is fine, they get hit so much themselves. I don't really have a problem with any of the casters overhunting and being a little more efficient at it. There's just missing aspects of the game right now that'll be hopefully corrected in the future.

But to your last point of the above quote, I don't think you maybe understand. This test wasn't about priests. It was about armour changes. The reason I included the final bit about vampires was not to suggest this only affects people who hunt vampires (it doesn't, it affects the entire game, all players and all hunting grounds), but rather because those were the numbers I had in front of me since that's where a temple hunt was. I put the greater vampire statement to point out the limited difference in an unarmoured hit (35) against an new arcsilver armour hit (32). You guys started making this about priests when it wasn't about priests, it was just about numbers - percentages, static values and absorb rates on armour. I cannot stress that enough.

As for lack of hunting, I don't think you'd find any body in game or in this thread who would disagree with you. We'd all love to see more diverse hunting grounds for hunters of all types, priests included. But your class is not meant to do a lot of damage anyway, you're a support class with healing. It'd be like me whining about wound mending changes from so long ago, that I couldn't heal comparably to a priest with a skill that had a shorter delay. That isn't what warriors are about and that'd be questionable of me.
Bocon L wrote:I'm sorry you guys are hurt and don't agree with the changes, but belittling people for having a difference of opinion is really childish. There's a lot of self entitlement going on in here too, which I am having a hard time understanding.
This is actually kinda funny, because in truth whilst the changes are entirely out of whack and most materials are protecting for around 20% regardless of tier - something again I wont rehash because I'll give staff a chance to hopefully test and adjust -, we can still hunt. Not as efficiently as before, but we're not so bad off. It'll cost more in downtime and potions, as I assume it will for everyone. This post was to alert the entire community to significant and silent changes across the board for armour which reduced the effectiveness by nearly 30% for some, and made peddle and high-end tier material on the same level as shop bought steel and its equivalents. This change affects most of all new players, old characters that don't level a lot and mid-level to higher-level characters that hunt by themselves. As for the belittling comment, well, nothing productive is going to come out of that.
Bocon L wrote:But I'd like to have faith that things like that would be fixed through a simple PM, notifying them that it might have been a mistake.
That's your feeling, and you're quite welcome to it. Unfortunately, I have the most first hand experience of how little notes are responded to, how often they get ignored or get lost. Whether due to time constraints or any other number of factors. I made this post so everyone could be aware and the situation could be addressed by the entire community, questioned by the community in any way they felt, and so it wouldn't be lost or shrugged off.

As for Swamp Ape, I think rereading his posts I already addressed that in a previous response. The confusion he had over comments which were clearly connected in the context and relevant to that context led to his posts. The entire thread was supposed to be about armour, and priests were brought up by Bocon and then briefly touched upon in a response by Faran's player which was in reference to the hunt in which some of the numbers for damage (35 vs 32) were pulled.

Because again, this wasn't about priests, nowhere was it suggested, stated or even hinted at that a level ten priest could sit there unarmoured by themselves and out-heal a vampire of any kind, it was a clear reference to the two other people who were actually testing armours, and is in no way an attempt to discuss the validity of priest healing. No one wants to see it nerfed. People want to see priests see an increase in prayers and utilities, along with mages.

This is strictly about armour values and its impact on the communnity as a whole. Thank you to those who understood that was the entire purpose of the thread.
Last edited by Nikolas Suyessod on Thu Sep 04, 2014 4:38 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Bocon L »

I guess we'll just have to agree to completely disagree with one another then. That is all.
Alex
Academy Student
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Jul 16, 2014 12:37 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Alex »

In theory it isn’t a big change - somewhat noticed, but easily adapted to -, unfortunately in practise it seemed not to have been tested and there’s some major problems that come with it.

This is the first ussumption that surprised me.

I highly encourage staff to please, please be consistent in testing changes - no matter how small or significant, and this one is incredibly significant - before throwing them out to the players. If it’s going to be thrown out to the players, please have the decency to inform them in matters such as armour protection values being changed, in particular if it isn’t readily tested beforehand. If it’s where the core absorption or damage settings, matters of a mechanical nature, are being changed in a huge fashion please set a date to change every person’s old piece at the same time, so half the game isn’t protecting such a hefty number compared to newly purchased or singularly ‘fixed’ pieces. It isn’t cool nor fair to any player to have untested mechanical changes thrown into the live world with little or, as more often is the case, nary a word given to them so they might know what to expect and give proper feedback. Lack of testing and chosen silence hobbles the playerbase in its entirety in PVE/PVP.

This is the second ussumption that I found arrogant and a sense of entitlement. You really think you should be asked before changes are made to the game?

Throwing something out and hoping it isn’t buggy or that you’ve guessed it’s going to work correctly isn’t fair to anyone, and it’s going to keep causing problems down the road. Obviously, issues arise with even intensive testing but it isn’t being done here. Please give the players that chance so it stops making the live world unbalanced for people who may or may not get caught up in the thrown net of untested changes.

I'd like to assume that staff put in more effort than just a guess. I agree that there is an armour issue to deal with. I don't agree that it has any impact on the game and isn't worth this thread, a PM to staff would have worked just as well.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

If you're going to hide behind a different forum name, at least be honest in your replies. No one said staff should ask players before changes are made. It was asked that there be some consistency in testing, some thoroughness in testing and that there be transparency in major mechanical changes. That isn't a strange, new or unique request. It was done for things like spells, wound mending, and oh, look.

October Armour Changes

Also for the previous armour change. But I guess now it's self-entitled. I'm going to be moving the relevant points of this discussion to a new thread in hopes there is no derailing, and you can all continue your priest discussion here.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Wren »

Whoa, okay. I think this is getting a little out of hand.
You really think you should be asked before changes are made to the game?
Informed, not asked. This game is of course not an MMO but for the sake of example, WoW lists every change accompanied by a patch for the entire playerbase to see every time. Even SI puts up things that were added, tweaked etc in the UPDATE list in-game, but I can't find this change anywhere. It was also mentioned this might be beneficial so that players could knowingly test the changes and, as also mentioned, give feedback so staff gets an idea on whether or not more changes are needed. How would this at all be a bad or unreasonable thing to ask? It benefits all involved.
I don't agree that it has any impact on the game and isn't worth this thread, a PM to staff would have worked just as well.
I don't mean to sound rude but this subforum is called 'Player Feedback' for a reason, and there are plenty of threads in here that could have easily been sent as a PM instead but weren't. I really don't understand where this animosity towards a post that actually contains numbers and thorough information instead of speculated inconsistencies is coming from. Nobody is being harmed or inconvenienced by this thread. If you don't care for the contents and how the changes have affected your character, fine, skip over it then.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Austere »

Thank you all for your feedback, we'll take it into consideration as we continue to adjust how armor works. We have been running tests on the calculations for the past week after we discovered a major issue that had gone unnoticed since long ago. Please bear with us as we find the correct long-term solution.
Locked