I can compete and win, if they're more poor than I am and can't afford the gear I do and if they're a very new mage. However, outside that? I actually can't. I can't hunt in the best available areas now, because I have zero defense against them. I can solo statues and squatters only because I outlevel them by an absolutely ridiculous amount, and I'll be honest, I don't want that to be the reason. That's like hunting ice trolls all over again. I can't beat a mage because of their tighter damage range and slows, and they can defend against my attacks while I can't defend against any of theirs at this moment. Because of my limited means of defense, my ability to earn money is also limited since I put my character's IC nature above her need to make money and have 'friends.' Unlike some, I don't have hours and hours in a day to hunt. Wish I did, but I don't.
I understand what fixes are needed to even things out, but until those fixes get put in, folks are still paying the price for not making FOTM characters. My hats off to those who stick with it, it's tough to swallow.
And yes, I still want to see OOC games return and hosted. Those are fun.
OOC Games and AFC
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: OOC Games and AFC

Hierophant of Itzal
-
Nikolas Suyessod
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am
Re: OOC Games and AFC
IC games have never truly been popular in SI, though through no fault of Visyn now or Blink, Loriel and Hrall originally. It didn't matter how many adverts they had, how large the pot, how many prizes they were able to offer, how much or little support from staff they'd receive. There'd always be a specific crowd who joined and several people who wouldn't participate for whatever reason. I don't think it's fair to try to categorise it as a purely mechanical issue, or for a large encompassing statement as if balance issues are a wet blanket to RP and thus this is the primary factor in discouragement for characters having a go. For example, for the first ever AFC it was unarmed combat only. I had to cajole/bribe two people to enter so there'd be four total, and there were still people watching from the crowd that wouldn't join. There's no real imbalance issues with unarmed combat only (outside of a larger race, but larger races are meant to be stronger than slighter ones in melee combat), but still..Shadowbane wrote:But if there's no chance for me to be genuinely competitive and stand a chance in a match of any sort, I'm going to find something more enjoyable to spend my time on. No one has ever played a game with the intent to feel like they're losing or coming up short. Games are meant to be fun, and if it's not fun, people tend to go find their fun somewhere else. Until classes are completed and combat between different damage types is balanced better, OOC games will probably be more popular than the IC ones, unfortunately.
Even when there weren't mages signed up for the AFC the number was still low, and even though the same person won every time the same people joined in. It seemed readily accepted that the most skilled combatant won, and those who did want to fight took it as an opportunity to strive toward a goal. Only after a mage, followed by another one later, was it talked about how imbalanced it was without the same consideration or goal.
Whilst I'm thankful for Visyn's goal of wanting to host games (plus hope staff will hand out RP rewards like before to give some tiny extra encouragement for people to go), will absolutely attend if my schedule permits and appreciate he's trying to use it as a venue to achieve better balance/breadth of options IC games, it's hard to do so completely through OOC games. The AFC is a completely controlled setting, usually of 1v1. Even in team games there's just going to be certain combinations/fights where one person/group composition will always win, no matter what, unless they're terrible at playing their class, if someone is lagging, or there is a significant level and gear disparity. Not all classes are going to kill one another, and that's fine. Some melee aren't going to beat casters, some casters aren't going to beat some melee, some melee wont beat each other, and some casters wont beat each other. I'm a human warrior, and I don't expect to beat a Vukasin, Gavial or any larger race melee of similar, higher or even somewhat lower levels. They have a damage modifier which is high for a reason, and the only way I can beat them 1v1 is if they make a huge strategical error. I might be able to beat them in OOC games, but OOC games are different. They're generally group games where people target specific people to start, so it's hard to use it to balance 1v1, controlled fights in an IC setting.
This isn't meant to discourage Visyn in any way as I definitely am looking forward to him hosting games. His desire to start healthy community events is admirable and I'm grateful for him doing so. But I hope people don't go into OOC games under the impression that it's somehow more "fair" or "balance-inclined" than a 1v1 IC fight. Feedback from both events is useful, but they both must be taken under context. Just because someone can beat you over and over in a 1v1 fight doesn't mean they're "godly" or unbalanced, it might just mean that's how it's going to be. We all know the stuff about damage problems being bad for both casters and melee, so I wont drudge it up again. There must always be losers and winners in any 'contest', and in an ideal scenario there are foils for each one so every person is both a winner and loser. There's nothing wrong with losing in an interactive world where there's others around you. I'd like to think under ideal circumstances every one OOC would like for every one IC to win at some point, even at the cost to their characters, so every one else can have OOC fun.
I can understand wanting to play OOC Games to have some PVP fun you might not achieve IC, it's something I've done before by rolling up 'games characters', but I don't think having foils or losing/not being able to beat a specific class or class/race combination is necessarily a 'wet blanket' on RP. Mechanics enhance RP to some degree, but they don't make it in the end.
And thank you, Visyn, for wanting to host them. I'll be happy to see their return.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: OOC Games and AFC
I must not be very good at articulating my thoughts, here.
It's not that I have a problem losing in a competition because my class has natural 'foils.' I mean, I played a warrior in WoW, and at the time I quit, they sucked for PvP. Everything was a foil for a warrior except for a bad player. Mages laughed at me as I flailed at them in a pitiful attempt to defend myself when I was alone. They were near the bottom of the list for most comps because of how the class was set up. The heavy hitters were only that because they blew all their earnings on weapons for damage, and not armor for survivability and class bonuses. However, I was good with the class, and my skill made up for many of the class weaknesses. That's what the best warrior players did, we sucked it up and got better and trucked on. Did I lose? Oh yeah, a lot. But there were times I won, too, so the potential to win balanced the fact that I got my butt handed to me many days of the week.
I don't have that here. At all. Again, everything is a foil when they reach a certain point, When you play a class that doesn't have a snowball's chance because you didn't pick the strength boosts of a gavial or vukasin, the only real draw for IC games is RP. Given the nature of my character, the draw just isn't there. If she goes, it's certainly not for the fights.
Maybe it's different for other players, and that's perfectly fine. But there's some out there that really aren't interested in being rolled over or just spectating. It's not fun for them. OOC games will allow them to enjoy the competition with a chance of actually winning, if only because they were lucky and got on the winning team for the night. Sometimes, a slim chance is enough for a draw. Being able to truly put up a fight is enough incentive. If the character RP doesn't accommodate the setting for the IC games, and there's no chance to place (much less win), then there's no draw. It's just how it is for some, and I'd like to see something like OOC games hosted to bring those players into the community as well.
It's not that I have a problem losing in a competition because my class has natural 'foils.' I mean, I played a warrior in WoW, and at the time I quit, they sucked for PvP. Everything was a foil for a warrior except for a bad player. Mages laughed at me as I flailed at them in a pitiful attempt to defend myself when I was alone. They were near the bottom of the list for most comps because of how the class was set up. The heavy hitters were only that because they blew all their earnings on weapons for damage, and not armor for survivability and class bonuses. However, I was good with the class, and my skill made up for many of the class weaknesses. That's what the best warrior players did, we sucked it up and got better and trucked on. Did I lose? Oh yeah, a lot. But there were times I won, too, so the potential to win balanced the fact that I got my butt handed to me many days of the week.
I don't have that here. At all. Again, everything is a foil when they reach a certain point, When you play a class that doesn't have a snowball's chance because you didn't pick the strength boosts of a gavial or vukasin, the only real draw for IC games is RP. Given the nature of my character, the draw just isn't there. If she goes, it's certainly not for the fights.
Maybe it's different for other players, and that's perfectly fine. But there's some out there that really aren't interested in being rolled over or just spectating. It's not fun for them. OOC games will allow them to enjoy the competition with a chance of actually winning, if only because they were lucky and got on the winning team for the night. Sometimes, a slim chance is enough for a draw. Being able to truly put up a fight is enough incentive. If the character RP doesn't accommodate the setting for the IC games, and there's no chance to place (much less win), then there's no draw. It's just how it is for some, and I'd like to see something like OOC games hosted to bring those players into the community as well.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: OOC Games and AFC
Hopefully those are loud noises of APPROVAL.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: OOC Games and AFC
Not really, I see no point in PvP of any kind with the mechanics the way they are, which leaves my main high and dry since it's a PvP/Conflict centric class and I can get pwned by any mage that puts in more than 2 weeks of work into leveling
Re: OOC Games and AFC
The point is it's fun. It brings the community together for more than just peddles, and in this case without the aggravation of IC grudges.
I play the same class as you and I had a LOT of fun at the last two games. Don't have to 'win' to have fun.
I play the same class as you and I had a LOT of fun at the last two games. Don't have to 'win' to have fun.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: OOC Games and AFC
Is it all individual games? I never was around for the OOC battles, so I'm not sure. I personally think Teams would be nifty for both the AFC and ooc fighting. People could root for their teams, bet on them, get little pennants, things like that. (In the Middle Ages, people would root for their favourite jousters, or in different cultures, wrestlers, and wear their colours or insignia, things like that.)
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Re: OOC Games and AFC
Oh man, sudden thoughts about jousting in the game. That'd be badass.
Anyway, to answer Kiriath - They actually comprised almost entirely of team-based games, minus a few 1v1's for fun like Blink vs Wren. There were different styles/rules, but each one had about 3-5 people per team from what I remember. The only exception was when we had a Free for All match which was just utter chaos, but still highly enjoyable and, at times, hilarious when random people would gang up on someone else.
It's a good time, so I hope you'll be there if Visyn is able to organize it!
Anyway, to answer Kiriath - They actually comprised almost entirely of team-based games, minus a few 1v1's for fun like Blink vs Wren. There were different styles/rules, but each one had about 3-5 people per team from what I remember. The only exception was when we had a Free for All match which was just utter chaos, but still highly enjoyable and, at times, hilarious when random people would gang up on someone else.
It's a good time, so I hope you'll be there if Visyn is able to organize it!
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
