High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Wonton »

So I've seen the character Trystan with a "Prelate" title for the High Priest of Aerthane, Bocon with the 'Empyrion' (or something? I forget how you spell it) title for High Priest of Pyrous, but I was wondering what the other religions titles for their High Priests are.

Also, there rises a question as to who can become High Priest, and from reading some of the race and religion pages, I've arrived at the general conclusion that only priests or mages can fill such a roll, as they are the ones most connected with the elements: mages more so to the raw elements, and Priests to the Gods, who control their given element. But I think the religions can differ in preference. So my thoughts are:

For Kaleith I'd likely say either Priests or Mages. Kaleisians seem traditional in the sense that those studying the elements would rise to take clergy positions, but not so traditional to form castes, as the Verdani would.

For Aerthane: Due to Aerthane's general philosophy to 'stick it to the man' and generally say 'whatevs. Imma do me', I'd be willing to say that anyone of any class might become High Priest. I don't think they'd have rules that'd delineate one person over another, though certainly a Priest might gravitate towards the position naturally.

For Tetherias: I'd think that Tetherias is the most restrictive of the religions, allowing only the Priest or Templar classes to ascend to the roll of High Priest. They seem very socially structured and rigid, with the Verdani likely balking at any race taking the position that is not one of their own.

For Pyrous: I see Pyrous as accepting mainly Priests and Mages, but that it would not be unusual to see a non-clergy class ascend to the role due to a coup to take power, should they gather the appropriate following.

Now, I haven't seen any "Archmage" titles, but I think its a valid title and main position to fill. The background stories say that magic has waned with the disappearance of dragons, but now that they're returning, I expect to see mages rise into their own again, bring some instability to some of the ordained positions of Power. And especially since only mages will be able to form an elemental bond with dragons, this title might be more prevalent (and also add the fun effect of creating tension in temples between who holds the power: High priest or Archmage?).

However, that leaves this: what roles can non caster classes assume? Merchants, certainly, as all classes should be able to. Emissaries, I assume. But perhaps the community can think of more that a class might aspire to fill.

---

Bears!

Actually, race and religion dynamics!

Thinking about the different way each faith might handle certain classes ascending to positions of power has got me to thinking about race and religion dynamics in general.

For instance, as Kaleith, I know I'm suppose to be at odds with Pyrous, though it pains me to be a jerk to Visyn (or Bocon) when he's only ever been nice to my character :? , so i try to be as polite, but as stand-offish as possible. I've also noticed that Aerthane and Tetherias get along well IG, and don't seem to have very many religious quarrels - so generally the RP guidelines I've read are a bit up in the air. The SI web page does seem a bit dated, so I wanted to know how others have been handling religious conflicts and race conflicts so far.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

There is a title for the Kalesian leader, yes. I've some more thoughts on the rest of the post but don't have the focus to discuss it at the moment. I'll try to get it down tomorrow.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Xiija »

The SI web page does seem a bit dated, so I wanted to know how others have been handling religious conflicts and race conflicts so far.
I've been kinda lost with the whole RP thing here....
I asked about racial conflicts etc, but it was mentioned that most
conflict comes from religion. I read the web pages and learned that
my temple (Aerthane) is most often in conflict with Tetherians ....

so, I try and instigate by calling all tetherians "Treehuggers" , but ....
several people seem to think this is out of line....
... also, a member of our temple is married / partnered with a Tetherian.

truly, so far, the ONLY decent RP conflict i have heard about is Someone
leaving dead dog corpses in Temple Aerthane... ( kudos to whoever is doing that!)

from the web page .....
Aerthane is often viewed as the most chaotic of all the religions, elemental or not.
Our temple has great people in it, but we seem pretty mellow, not chaotic.
I'm just wondering ..... can the game be fun to play if everyone plays nice nice and gets along well together?

As for High Priests ...or Temple leaders ....
It's a temple, not a militia?.... I see Only priests as leaders .... although you could stretch that to mages,
as the "gods" were once high mages themselves...?
Any other classes would be support for temple leadership...war leaders, Emissaries, etc...?

::hoping more will chime in on all this, I'm not sure if Xiija's RP is makin it ::
Treehuggers!
:P
Image
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Shadowbane »

I think there needs to be more conflict within the game itself. Not the petty stuff you might see now, but real tension that goes deep. I only see that sparingly, and it's always annoyed me just slightly to see some of the current relations existing in game. I don't pretend to be in a position to judge someone's RP, so don't get me wrong there, but I do believe there are some things not being adhered to.

I play a member of the game's most disliked/hated religion. I expect conflict. In fact, my character is often offensive or standoffish in some manner to help encourage that. If I wanted to play a game where everything was rainbows and butterflies, I'm sure there's an MLP game out there that could deliver. However, I enjoy meaningful conflict that has consequences. Not the sort where someone's a tool just because they can be, especially in a world where your god might not bring you back from the dead. Irritate enough characters, and they'll come after you eventually. Keep it up, though, and the constant retaliation will get old and tiring and probably make the game less fun.

It's a tough thing to balance. Once that balance is found, though, it's enjoyable (to most).
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Swamp Ape »

The High Priest is a priest and the High Mage is a mage. Either one or both can and are the figureheads of the temples. If you're interested in the position there are a number of ways this can be accomplished and all are through roleplay. However you come about the position is determined by your characters actions. A few examples would be: you can take it by demonstrating good leadership abilities, take it by force, bribery, trickery, coercion, assassination etc. I think you get the idea.

If you have a non-mage or non-priest character that can pull it off then you too could be in a position of temple leadership. It's all about your character and if you can get others to buy into it. The titles are player ideas that are submitted to staff to be attached to whomever is the temple leader. I do not know all the different titles but if you have a suggestion toss it out there to your fellow temple mates and see where it goes.

I do not agree with some of the relationships in the game and I do not think we have enough conflict between the religions. I think part of this is because our player base is not large enough to support the intended system. However, no one should be stopping your character from being an ass to followers that are at odds with your religion. It feels like too many of us just want to be friends. If we are supposed to be a game based on religious conflict I think this needs to be nipped in the bud and dealt with sooner rather than later.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Blink »

Now, to really blow your mind, Wonton. Our Emissary of Aerthane, Ayderias, told Blink that the High Priest on the Isle of Aerthane is both a priest and a mage.
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Kiriath »

Blink wrote:Ayderias, told Blink that the High Priest on the Isle of Aerthane is both a priest and a mage.


And now you know what Kiriath wants to be when she grows up, because being both a mage and a priestess sounds very spiffy.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Wonton »

Shadowbane wrote:I think there needs to be more conflict within the game itself. Not the petty stuff you might see now, but real tension that goes deep.
SwampApe wrote:I do not agree with some of the relationships in the game and I do not think we have enough conflict between the religions.
Xiija wrote:
I've been kinda lost with the whole RP thing here....
I asked about racial conflicts etc, but it was mentioned that most
conflict comes from religion. I read the web pages and learned that
my temple (Aerthane) is most often in conflict with Tetherians ....

so, I try and instigate by calling all tetherians "Treehuggers" , but ....
several people seem to think this is out of line....
... also, a member of our temple is married / partnered with a Tetherian.

truly, so far, the ONLY decent RP conflict i have heard about is Someone
leaving dead dog corpses in Temple Aerthane... ( kudos to whoever is doing that!)

from the web page .....
Aerthane is often viewed as the most chaotic of all the religions, elemental or not.
Our temple has great people in it, but we seem pretty mellow, not chaotic.
I'm just wondering ..... can the game be fun to play if everyone plays nice nice and gets along well together?
Since there are so many that disagree with the current religious RP going on, I guess then, to foster the kind of 'good conflict', it'd be helpful to know three things:
1) how have players seen their race's RP in the context of their religion (I would expect different races practice their faith in unique ways)
2) how do these race/religion ideas differ from what is already laid out by staff, and
3) how do players currently enact religious tension out in the game?

Also,
SwampApe wrote:I think part of this is because our player base is not large enough to support the intended system.
I think this is true, though, together, Temple Aerthane and Tetherias seem to make up quite a large percent of the active players, and their religious tension seems not to be there. So, I agree that there are a lot of religions for the small player base to fully act out, but even with such a small base we should try to effectively enact the religious tension for the groups we have.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Swamp Ape »

Wonton wrote: I think this is true, though, together, Temple Aerthane and Tetherias seem to make up quite a large percent of the active players, and their religious tension seems not to be there. So, I agree that there are a lot of religions for the small player base to fully act out, but even with such a small base we should try to effectively enact the religious tension for the groups we have.
I do not disagree with this. If I had my way even if the player base was just two players I think they should RP the religious tensions. Once we start making excuses and exceptions those bad habits turn into problems later on when the proper groundwork was not fully embraced and implemented.

The staff has given us very little background and history to go on, relying on the player base to fill in the gaps. I'm not sure I agree with this approach. I'd like to see a lot more official information and history made available to the players to use as a base to build off from. We have unusual interracial parings and inter-religious relationships that do not seem to fit the current known history and lore. When you start allowing this type of thing for a few then later on when the player base is larger you'll have to allow it for all.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Shadowbane »

Swamp Ape wrote:The staff has given us very little background and history to go on, relying on the player base to fill in the gaps. I'm not sure I agree with this approach. I'd like to see a lot more official information and history made available to the players to use as a base to build off from. We have unusual interracial parings and inter-religious relationships that do not seem to fit the current known history and lore. When you start allowing this type of thing for a few then later on when the player base is larger you'll have to allow it for all.
This. I cannot agree more with this. The game is based off religious conflict, not racial conflict (though elves can only belong to one specific religion, based on species, so perhaps for them it's both). However, there are indeed some religious relations that just don't fit. Unless it can be made clear that those relations are not for the sake of friendship and have solid ulterior motives (attempting to take members from another faith, attempting to gather information on an opposing religion, trying to cause rifts in alliances, etc. etc.), it will be accepted behavior in the future and staff will have a hard time fixing it.

Granted, I believe there's JUST enough information on the game website for people to get a good general idea of things. No one likes Itzalites, Temple Aerthane and Temple Tetherias are opposites and rarely see eye-to-eye, and so on and so forth. It's up to players to actually follow the guidelines presented and build off from there.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Post Reply