Kiriath wrote:Am I the only person who feels conflict should be personality driven, not coded into the system so to speak? I really hate how limiting it is to be told that because I am y, I must hate Fred over there, because he is x. If I wanted that sort of intolerance, I'd go out into the real world. All the elements have to work together for the world to exist, so I fail to see why there should be some pre-conceived hatred going on in spite of it. Based on the sort of rationale I feel is being used, I should hate the only people who have been nice to me outside the Temple, and beg indulgence of those who have openly insulted me. (which is not about to happen)
How about if all of you who want to go ahead and create strife along religious lines, and those of us who do not, or if I am alone, then I alone will go along and only be in conflict with those who give me cause? Making people war is as stupid as any other forced rp, and just as lacking in fun. Because the battle lines I would draw are not those the rest of you would, I suspect.
There is a world history and conflicts which have existed throughout time because this is necessary to set down a foundation for the game. It offers something from which players can pull from and build their characters. Conflict is necessary to also create alliances in addition to enemies. It drives the game and keeps it moving rather than allow for it to become stale and stagnant. This isn't to say there can't also be personality driven conflicts, yet the primary focus of this game from a lore standpoint is religious based conflict as well as The Shattering which only increased the former. There will almost always be different theologies - not all of them - which clash because they have such different core ideologies.
There are guidelines in place for religions to create conflict yet often they aren't adhered to. I think many people so far in this thread enjoy experiencing the dynamic of conflict in an IC setting. Just because the characters are in conflict because of these guidelines which should be followed doesn't mean the players behind them have to feel animosity toward other players. That's the beautiful part about text games. I like to think of these games not unlike a book in their own way. An ongoing, interactive media written and compiled by multiple parties. A way in which to explore new thoughts, new experiences, better understand the world around us, other people and ourselves.
We all have our own roles, we're all presumably here to increase the joy of not only ourselves but others around us so everyone can get the most out of the characters they're playing. Again, there is joy in conflict. As with any form of media there are going to be protagonists and antagonists. Much like with any other form of media, depending on how you interpret it or which side you're on you're going to view different people as the opposite of what another person might. I'm sorry, but this isn't a chatroom or a sandbox. There's guidelines in place for a reason and they should be followed. They create basic foundation and structure. If that isn't a person's thing, I totally understand that and I don't hold them any ill will for it. However, again, there are guidelines in place that we all presumably read before or shortly after rolling up. We chose the characters we did - their races and religions - of our own free will. It's our responsibility to abide to them and it's staff responsibility to ensure the players are following them.
This isn't to say that one must always be in conflict with all members from a certain opposing religion, race or faction. Not at all. There's amazing and rewarding roleplay to be found in months long journeys to overcome conflict and resolve issues that the game has set out as groundwork. Yet this doesn't mean a character would perhaps view all other people from that religion or race with such forgiving or kind thoughts. They likely would still hold at the least reservation toward a group which theirs have been in cultural conflict with for centuries if not longer. However, this is months of roleplay and work. It can be disheartening and frustrating to see written up guidelines ignored almost instantaneously upon meeting, and at times feels like it might be for mechanical benefits. Months of work is rewarding to experience first hand or view as a detached party. Not so much a week or two.
I'm in absolute agreement that more information needs to be laid out and provided by staff to further establish conflicts and the reasons why. Yet, the little amount we have right now is enough to work on and that is our responsibility as players. Playing these different roles, filled with conflict, also helps people from playing themselves in different bodies from game to game. Maybe in one game someone's a generous person and the next they're a total jerk. The lore provided by staff gives players a boost to ensure this happens. We can't use the excuse that there isn't enough given out when the stuff we have isn't followed. That isn't fair to staff and it isn't fair to other players.