High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Shadowbane wrote:However, I enjoy meaningful conflict that has consequences. Not the sort where someone's a tool just because they can be, especially in a world where your god might not bring you back from the dead.
I wanted to touch on this first and then some other stuff later. I think this is one of the bigger problems in the game. People just don't take death seriously for the most part. At all. It's frustrating to watch unfold. I know it was partially addressed at a previous meeting, yet I don't know if much has changed. Yes, we the players know our characters will come back no matter what because this isn't a perma-death enforced game. Our characters on the other hand wouldn't know this bit of information, and I feel it isn't unrealistic to expect them to be at least wary of death or respond appropriately to the traumatic experience of dying. For them to think the next (or first) death might be the last (or only) they endure and they aren't afforded a resurrection by their god.

I don't think anyone is asking or expecting for everybody to go through months long traumatic experiences or roleplay, but some kind of response or acknowledgement over how painful it would be, one would assume, isn't much to ask, I don't think. Certainly not treating it like a joke. It can be jarring to see people literally laugh it off, to ignore that it happened, to wave it off, or in worst case scenarios act like the biggest part of death is that it's an inconvenience to PT or earnings from a hunt. Not that our characters just died or people watched them die.

If people don't see death as even moderate consequence, if people act like they will always return so it isn't a big deal, then conflict is both hard to achieve let alone sustain.
Geel
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 92
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 2:25 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Geel »

I think that what Nikolas says is exactly right, as far as it goes.

But isnt the death part really only half of it? Since we really aren't suppose to know that we will be resurrected, shouldnt we also RP being celebratory over that when it happens?

To me, this has always been a before and after thing. Before you die, you should act as if doing so is a big deal. But after having done so, being resurrected just blows it away. Your god saw fit to bring you back. You should be ecstatic about that and filled with love/appreciation for your god and a desire to be with those you thought you had just lost forever.
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Kiriath »

Am I the only person who feels conflict should be personality driven, not coded into the system so to speak? I really hate how limiting it is to be told that because I am y, I must hate Fred over there, because he is x. If I wanted that sort of intolerance, I'd go out into the real world. All the elements have to work together for the world to exist, so I fail to see why there should be some pre-conceived hatred going on in spite of it. Based on the sort of rationale I feel is being used, I should hate the only people who have been nice to me outside the Temple, and beg indulgence of those who have openly insulted me. (which is not about to happen)

How about if all of you who want to go ahead and create strife along religious lines, and those of us who do not, or if I am alone, then I alone will go along and only be in conflict with those who give me cause? Making people war is as stupid as any other forced rp, and just as lacking in fun. Because the battle lines I would draw are not those the rest of you would, I suspect.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Synche
Academy Student
Posts: 3
Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:12 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Synche »

Hello, I'm new.

I think it's crazy to not what to create strife in every way possible as a game designer. Yes, that includes racial strife. I don't think this is ever a situation where you "have" to do anything. You can play an elf that likes dwarves, even if most elves hate dwarves, and go against the grain.

I think putting those options which give the player license to cause trouble is part of what makes a great roleplaying game. Unlike you, I feel people are going to be nice as a default. It is hard coded into a lot of people to be tolerant and accepting and promote equality. Having a race that had enslaved another is a great way to promote a good type of tension and leave options on the table for people who want to use them. Not just religious options, but all options, class v class, race v race, and religion v religion.

If religion is the only conflict driver this world will be extremely narrow, and I would argue, boring. What about the situation where two racial enemies overcome tension because they follow the same religion, or any combination of those interactions?
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Austere »

While you'll find some religions at odds with others, this doesn't mean that each individual in that religion is at war with each individual in that other religion. There is room for your personal interactions to determine the extent of your conflicts. Each race in each religion may also have its own perspective and/or motivations. I'm looking forward to conflict within the same religion. Each religion has two sides within itself, this was part of our motivation on having two representatives from each religion on the Pearlean Conclave. Pyresians, for example, have a destructive side and a rebirthing side--some want to destroy, others want to create. Just because you're both Pyresian, it doesn't mean you are friends or work together very well.

I may not have addressed the original post much, but Snaek will be following up later.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Kiriath wrote:Am I the only person who feels conflict should be personality driven, not coded into the system so to speak? I really hate how limiting it is to be told that because I am y, I must hate Fred over there, because he is x. If I wanted that sort of intolerance, I'd go out into the real world. All the elements have to work together for the world to exist, so I fail to see why there should be some pre-conceived hatred going on in spite of it. Based on the sort of rationale I feel is being used, I should hate the only people who have been nice to me outside the Temple, and beg indulgence of those who have openly insulted me. (which is not about to happen)

How about if all of you who want to go ahead and create strife along religious lines, and those of us who do not, or if I am alone, then I alone will go along and only be in conflict with those who give me cause? Making people war is as stupid as any other forced rp, and just as lacking in fun. Because the battle lines I would draw are not those the rest of you would, I suspect.
There is a world history and conflicts which have existed throughout time because this is necessary to set down a foundation for the game. It offers something from which players can pull from and build their characters. Conflict is necessary to also create alliances in addition to enemies. It drives the game and keeps it moving rather than allow for it to become stale and stagnant. This isn't to say there can't also be personality driven conflicts, yet the primary focus of this game from a lore standpoint is religious based conflict as well as The Shattering which only increased the former. There will almost always be different theologies - not all of them - which clash because they have such different core ideologies.

There are guidelines in place for religions to create conflict yet often they aren't adhered to. I think many people so far in this thread enjoy experiencing the dynamic of conflict in an IC setting. Just because the characters are in conflict because of these guidelines which should be followed doesn't mean the players behind them have to feel animosity toward other players. That's the beautiful part about text games. I like to think of these games not unlike a book in their own way. An ongoing, interactive media written and compiled by multiple parties. A way in which to explore new thoughts, new experiences, better understand the world around us, other people and ourselves.

We all have our own roles, we're all presumably here to increase the joy of not only ourselves but others around us so everyone can get the most out of the characters they're playing. Again, there is joy in conflict. As with any form of media there are going to be protagonists and antagonists. Much like with any other form of media, depending on how you interpret it or which side you're on you're going to view different people as the opposite of what another person might. I'm sorry, but this isn't a chatroom or a sandbox. There's guidelines in place for a reason and they should be followed. They create basic foundation and structure. If that isn't a person's thing, I totally understand that and I don't hold them any ill will for it. However, again, there are guidelines in place that we all presumably read before or shortly after rolling up. We chose the characters we did - their races and religions - of our own free will. It's our responsibility to abide to them and it's staff responsibility to ensure the players are following them.

This isn't to say that one must always be in conflict with all members from a certain opposing religion, race or faction. Not at all. There's amazing and rewarding roleplay to be found in months long journeys to overcome conflict and resolve issues that the game has set out as groundwork. Yet this doesn't mean a character would perhaps view all other people from that religion or race with such forgiving or kind thoughts. They likely would still hold at the least reservation toward a group which theirs have been in cultural conflict with for centuries if not longer. However, this is months of roleplay and work. It can be disheartening and frustrating to see written up guidelines ignored almost instantaneously upon meeting, and at times feels like it might be for mechanical benefits. Months of work is rewarding to experience first hand or view as a detached party. Not so much a week or two.

I'm in absolute agreement that more information needs to be laid out and provided by staff to further establish conflicts and the reasons why. Yet, the little amount we have right now is enough to work on and that is our responsibility as players. Playing these different roles, filled with conflict, also helps people from playing themselves in different bodies from game to game. Maybe in one game someone's a generous person and the next they're a total jerk. The lore provided by staff gives players a boost to ensure this happens. We can't use the excuse that there isn't enough given out when the stuff we have isn't followed. That isn't fair to staff and it isn't fair to other players.
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Kiriath »

With all due respect, to both your comments, and the groundwork laid by the creators, I view it as just that, groundwork. Just because something was true from a historical viewpoint, does not mean it must always exist, or that it is always the best idea.

Having not even heard of this game, (though not new to MUDs or RP) I deliberately created a character with a very sheltered, limited background. So I could come to the game without any biases. Someone mentions elves and dwarves. Just because Tolkien used that idea to create some dramatic tension, does not mean it is set in stone that all must adhere to it. (would you believe the built in auto-spelling dictionary did not have the word dwarves? Boggles the mind.)

I've never done chat room rp, so I couldn't say how this is similar or different. YMMV. But in a very real way it IS a sandbox, one the creators have generously decided to let us play in, because it's more fun when you have friends helping you imagine things. If staff wants people to toe the line and all be good little boys and girls, (which I doubt) then yes, strict adherence is required. But assuming all humans want the same things, or view things the same way, is silly and pointless. If your character has become a caricature of "a human" or "member of religion X" then what is the point?

Since the game is still being developed, and changes are still being made, why should those be limited to game mechanics? Is it more disrespectful to have religious politics and traditions developed outside of the written documents than it is to point out a change you'd like made to game mechanics? Unlike a book, (unless you're talking about something like Thieves' World or the Wild Cards books) the world does change when it's reacted to by others. I can tromp through Rivendell a thousand times, but it won't change a word of what Tolkien wrote.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Swamp Ape »

The way I see it is we have various religions vying for influence, power, or whatever. You may not like members of your own religion but you do have a common goal or enemy. The crusades, Holy Wars, Christians -v- Muslims are real life example. Just like real world religions you have varying options within that religion. You didn't have to like the guy you're standing shoulder to shoulder with but you damn sure hated the guy across the battle field from you.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Kiriath wrote:With all due respect, to both your comments, and the groundwork laid by the creators, I view it as just that, groundwork. Just because something was true from a historical viewpoint, does not mean it must always exist, or that it is always the best idea.

Having not even heard of this game, (though not new to MUDs or RP) I deliberately created a character with a very sheltered, limited background. So I could come to the game without any biases. Someone mentions elves and dwarves. Just because Tolkien used that idea to create some dramatic tension, does not mean it is set in stone that all must adhere to it. (would you believe the built in auto-spelling dictionary did not have the word dwarves? Boggles the mind.)

I've never done chat room rp, so I couldn't say how this is similar or different. YMMV. But in a very real way it IS a sandbox, one the creators have generously decided to let us play in, because it's more fun when you have friends helping you imagine things. If staff wants people to toe the line and all be good little boys and girls, (which I doubt) then yes, strict adherence is required. But assuming all humans want the same things, or view things the same way, is silly and pointless. If your character has become a caricature of "a human" or "member of religion X" then what is the point?

Since the game is still being developed, and changes are still being made, why should those be limited to game mechanics? Is it more disrespectful to have religious politics and traditions developed outside of the written documents than it is to point out a change you'd like made to game mechanics? Unlike a book, (unless you're talking about something like Thieves' World or the Wild Cards books) the world does change when it's reacted to by others. I can tromp through Rivendell a thousand times, but it won't change a word of what Tolkien wrote.
When I say sandbox I mean an open ended world with no rules imposed except the mechanical ones. This isn't a sandbox, there are roleplay guidelines.

No one asking people become caricatures, this is a discussion on sticking to - in some way - the guidelines and structure we've been given. A discussion to not toss them away in a short amount of time without thought, reason or lengthy work behind them. Yes, the world does change and it's reacted to by others. I don't think anyone would disagree. Yet this isn't about change at all. This is about guidelines being ignored from the start of rollup. Neither is anyone saying all people want the same things, yet whether or not we like it we are influenced by the environment in which we grow up. It is the reason racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, ableism, etc still exist. Society shapes and influences us. We must afford the same to our characters when we roll them up as per the guidelines we have been given as players. We need to hold ourselves accountable and responsible to that point.

People change over the course of time, personalities evolve and grow, tensions between individuals fade or increase. This isn't in question or discouraged. Yet individual development doesn't necessarily mean heartwarming feelings towards an entire group, it doesn't necessarily mean the erasure of centuries of cultural conflict which would've been instilled into a character's mind. It doesn't mean we all get to ignore the guidelines to our religions or races at the whim of our own desires. Roleplaying games have structure and it is necessary.
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Post by Kiriath »

Apparently this has gone from a discussion on whether conflict should be more intense to "you are doing it wrong", so rather than engage in a pointless quibble, I shall just simply say that, barring ic directives from Aerthane or ooc directives from staff, I will let Kir evolve, and hopefully help the world evolve. I prefer to avoid unpleasantries whenever possible.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Post Reply