First Impressions

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
Synche
Academy Student
Posts: 3
Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:12 am

First Impressions

Post by Synche »

Hello, I just came across SI, and I want to let you let you know what I think about the game very early on, because I feel like there are significant flaws that I would love to see improved, but also because I am extremely excited to have found a game that make me feel the old sense of wonder I used to have. I'm a former DGate player, and I joined because of the familiarity, but I also understand a need to differentiate yourself.

1) Lack of interesting racial profiles. You website gives very little to latch on to for the new player to be excited about. There's a distinct lack of racial tension and differentiation. The only true positive is the elven variants, and I feel there's also a lack of character and personality. Many of the descriptions latch on to a animal as a physical description, but little is said about mannerisms. Bolineau that are inquisitve, Vukasin that are extremely proud and can not abide insults, etc. I also hope that as the history is fleshed out some strong interactions between the races are included.

2) Improved randomization. I think when creating a game, like this one, that feels like a world it's important to mask as many numbers as possible. I love the idea of truly random events and suboptimal events, stats, combinations, etc. It gives the world a more natural feel and is the opposite of the direction most games are going these days, which is a great way to provide originality. Examples are randomized stats on startup, random stat increases, and random abilities on character generation.

Your religion system I think is fantastic, and while I haven't gotten into the mechanics much yet, if you are able to create the diversity of clerics and templars based on religion that DGate had, I think it will be an amazing game for old school roleplayers like myself.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: First Impressions

Post by Shadowbane »

Stats are set at certain levels across the board according to race, atm. In the near future, those stats will be affected by the class a player has chosen for their character.

There are random stat raises in game, though the chance is extremely low. You have a chance to get a stat raise when you increase a skill's level, though the stat doesn't have to have anything to do with the skill. (For example, I got an intelligence raise off a close combat level on one character.) I do like the idea of random abilities earned, and think that would be a neat thing to add later on down the road. It would add some variety to a character, sort of like pseudo-multiclassing. You aren't really blending two classes, you're just picking up one extra skill or two.

The website is undergoing some updates, but the game actually focuses more on religious conflict instead of the typical racial conflict. That doesn't mean your character can't have prejudices against a race, though. Mine's a closet racist, and tends to keep it under a lid most days. As much as I wish we had more information to work off of, I do like that players have the opportunity to help build the game world they're playing in.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: First Impressions

Post by Xiija »

Welcome to the game :)
I found there to be very little to guide a new player when I
first started, so ...
1. stay in academy till lvl 10 in your main skill, if you take the ferry to Pearl
you lose the ability to use the golems to PT on, and your resurrection point will be
on the mainland.
2. Crafting is in, but i sucked at it, and there is no manual, so you have to ask
a player to help you in game. ( you get certain craft skills from NPC's. )
3. The staff & players are awesome, just ask anything you need on the forums,
and you will get a swift response :)

Merry Meet, ( from a former DGate & Aedin player)
Xiija, 'na Kurapiira, 'na Glinka
Image
Post Reply