Bank Box = Locked box?

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Visyn
Conclave Representative
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2013 4:25 pm
Location: Illinois

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Visyn »

As a side note, you can actually already filter your inventory in game for quick search purposes by doing i/in/inv/inventory <letter>/<word> and it'll return only results as specified.
Yes, this can be very helpful. Bank boxes should be able to be filtered as well. When you "list bundle" at the bank, it states that there isn't a shopkeeper there.
A numbering system would help, yes. But pure filtering alone wont help because whilst you may be able to filter it out, it probably wont stop people from stopping and thinking of the order of similar keyword related items (under Visyn's setup). In the case of Shadowbane if they deposited IRON still if the iron-buckled was still first it'd take it over the bundle of iron every time.
I completely agree. The inventory system really needs an overhaul. The way it works now is the item that last entered your inventory is placed at the bottom when it should be sorted by category and then alphabetically. The alias I posted doesn't arrange your inventory in a physical sense, just the way it is viewed. Something like this below would be great:
Ammo
1. a small quiver of applewood arrows x10
2. a small quiver of balsa arrows x15

Containers
3. a canvas scavenger's pack
4. a multicolored woven hemp bag

Resources
5. some bone x9

Weapons
6. a long ebony-handled serrated steel dagger
7. a bone dagger x13
Instead of:
give dagger nik (which would end up giving him my custom dagger)
or
give bone nik (which would give him 'some bone')

You would do this:
give #7 nik (which would give him one of the bone daggers)
or
give all #7 nik
or
give 4 #7 nik

EDIT: This is entirely possible to do with a client-side alias and maybe I'll work on it. Maybe.

Of course the other method would still work but this gives you another option when you have many items in your inventory. I know this doesn't really help 100% given the example with the iron-buckled as looking through your inventory for a number each time when all you want to do is make a quick deposit but I don't think the code allows for parts of an item to be removed as a keyword since the items are tagged by their entire description.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Visyn wrote:
As a side note, you can actually already filter your inventory in game for quick search purposes by doing i/in/inv/inventory <letter>/<word> and it'll return only results as specified.
Yes, this can be very helpful. Bank boxes should be able to be filtered as well. When you "list bundle" at the bank, it states that there isn't a shopkeeper there.
A numbering system would help, yes. But pure filtering alone wont help because whilst you may be able to filter it out, it probably wont stop people from stopping and thinking of the order of similar keyword related items (under Visyn's setup). In the case of Shadowbane if they deposited IRON still if the iron-buckled was still first it'd take it over the bundle of iron every time.
I completely agree. The inventory system really needs an overhaul. The way it works now is the item that last entered your inventory is placed at the bottom when it should be sorted by category and then alphabetically. The alias I posted doesn't arrange your inventory in a physical sense, just the way it is viewed. Something like this below would be great:
Ammo
1. a small quiver of applewood arrows x10
2. a small quiver of balsa arrows x15

Containers
3. a canvas scavenger's pack
4. a multicolored woven hemp bag

Resources
5. some bone x9

Weapons
6. a long ebony-handled serrated steel dagger
7. a bone dagger x13
Instead of:
give dagger nik (which would end up giving him my custom dagger)
or
give bone nik (which would give him 'some bone')

You would do this:
give #7 nik (which would give him one of the bone daggers)
or
give all #7 nik
or
give 4 #7 nik

EDIT: This is entirely possible to do with a client-side alias and maybe I'll work on it. Maybe.

Of course the other method would still work but this gives you another option when you have many items in your inventory. I know this doesn't really help 100% given the example with the iron-buckled as looking through your inventory for a number each time when all you want to do is make a quick deposit but I don't think the code allows for parts of an item to be removed as a keyword since the items are tagged by their entire description.
I think we'd all kill to be able to filter bank boxes, absolutely, especially scouts/ranged weapon users and anyone into heavy crafting/people who collect a lot of trinkets/clothing/jewelry/rp items of any kind. Or just pure gatherers.

Your example would absolutely be ideal and would work wonders compared to what we've got now. Unfortunately, with the keywords system the only thing that will make it 100% safe/not aggravating is so the bank can accept items within containers without spitting them back out at the character. If this was able to be put in along with either making all RP items/clothing etc zero pounds or putting a flat carry of five hundred for everyone like Faran's player suggested, that'd take us from a frustrating/annoying inventory system at times to a really great one.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Wonton »

While I would like to see normal, unenchanted clothing redcuced to zero weight as well, and see weight of other items scale to the character's size, the only problem I foresee is that we can pick up treasure clothing from MOBs. I think, then, if it's possible, that clothing have weight when in your inventory, but no weight when worn. That way, you can't collect an infinite number of weightless shirts from MOB drops, but it still lets small or large races look the way they want to without interfering with mechanics.

I'd also like to back the idea of at least being able to deposit containers without having their contents empty back into your inventory. The ability to store infinite stuff in the banks is super, but I'd also like or organize the way I store those items. An idea, though: I think there is a lack of money sinks in the game currently, so buying bank space might be a way to go:

Each character starts out with a single box, witch can hold, say 100 pounds of stuff. The next box costs 1000 to buy and increases your box space by another 100. The price of each additional box could raise in price, say by 1k each time, so your third box would be 2k to buy, your fourth 3k, etc.

At any rate, however, I would like to see the bank system revamped to allow us to organize our items there by the use of containers, and to be able to do so without needing to purchase a house.

Another thing about carry weight as it relates to race: when I was still test driving some characters, I found a rather large divide in the weight between the large, beast races, and the smaller races.

Sylphs I believe have a ~75lb carry weight.
Gavials had around 1k I believe.

While I can believe Gavial can carry that much as opposed to the tiny Sylph, mechanically, it leaves the sylph at a pretty large disadvantage. Even with what seems like a pretty quick regen time (I spent less time waiting for my stamina to regenerate as a sylph than I did a Gavial, even while swinging a weapon), it doesn't seem like the sylph has any real advantage to being small to compensate for the severely low carry weight. There's fly, bit flying didn't seem to affect my DR at all, or seem to impart any other benefit.

As Nikolas suggested, there doesn't seem to be any real mechanical downside to playing a beast race. And it seems that the obnoxious carry weight for larger races supports this.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Shadowbane »

I can have several thousand pounds of crafting material alone in my vault at any given time, divided into bundles of 100 and 200 pounds depending on what I use it for. I'd much rather pay money to buy other "boxes" instead of having to pay out the nose to increase my box limit by 100 or whatever. By the time I bought enough space to store what I need to store, and what I think I might need to store, I may as well have bought a house with eight rooms and several containers in each of them. Now, I'd be willing to pay a few thousand for more "boxes" at the bank and then just tell the teller which box I want access to. Box 1 could be random clothing/container/RP item rap, Box 2 could be weapons and armor and potions, Box 3 meats and foraged goods, Box 4 crafting materials, etc. etc.

As for the beast-type races, there really is no downside to playing them. Great strength, great dex (for something so huge, compared to a humanoid that's significantly smaller and lighter), a big health pool, several hundred to a thousand or more pounds of carry? When my toon finally kicks the bucket, I won't bother bringing her back. Gimme a race change to a vukasin, unless gavial and gargoyles suddenly learn how to be assassins.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Wonton »

Shadowbane wrote:I can have several thousand pounds of crafting material alone in my vault at any given time, divided into bundles of 100 and 200 pounds depending on what I use it for. I'd much rather pay money to buy other "boxes" instead of having to pay out the nose to increase my box limit by 100 or whatever. By the time I bought enough space to store what I need to store, and what I think I might need to store, I may as well have bought a house with eight rooms and several containers in each of them. Now, I'd be willing to pay a few thousand for more "boxes" at the bank and then just tell the teller which box I want access to. Box 1 could be random clothing/container/RP item rap, Box 2 could be weapons and armor and potions, Box 3 meats and foraged goods, Box 4 crafting materials, etc. etc.
That's a good idea too. Especially if you could name your boxes.

'Armor' Box
'Resources' Box
'Apparel' Box

if you don't just want 'Box 1, Box 2, Box 3' etc.

It'd be interesting if there was a vault where you'd go to manage items and such, and then you could just withdraw money from the teller, or buy more boxes.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Snaek »

All items need to weigh at least 1pound for mechanical reasons I can't get into. We did it before and discovered those issues. This isn't something that will be changing. There's likely a few lingering no weight items floating around out there.

Tailoring worn items by race is something we want to as well but it's not as high of a priority right now. It's definitely been noted when mentioned before. We won't be changing everyone's carry limits or weight in the mean time. Creating twice the work to address something that is slated for later is not the answer.

Let's keep this to the original topic of bank boxes if there is anything else to add there.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by SquallScribe »

If all items must weigh a minimum of 1 pound, then staff really should look into reducing the disparity between the low end and high end for carry limits. I think it would be a complementing step in the right direction to future fixes if the low end were upped with the high end scaled back. It's an unnecessary and imbalancing mechanical disparity between races like Sylph (with a max carry of around 80) and races like Gavial (with a max carry of around 1000). It would alleviate a great deal of trouble for smaller races and reduce the overwhelming capacity larger races have to carry items, given the requirement that all things weigh at least 1 pound.

I like the multiple box types idea, but how would the game decide what can be placed in either box? I think that's getting a little too complex when the only fix that is needed is a single bank box that allows PCs to personally sort and organize their items into their own containers, and the ability of those containers to be placed in the bank without spitting everything out of them back into your inventory. Buying a house is not the answer to that issue, though it will no doubt be a solution for a number of characters until the system can be fixed.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Shadowbane »

I think it's less the game knowing, and the player designating where they want stuff deposited. Depositing currency always puts it in one place, but if you want your steel dirk in the second box, you need to type DEPOSIT DIRK BOX2 and it will place it in your second bank box. Otherwise, if you just deposit the item, it defaults to the first box. Maybe you can have the option of naming a box, so say we name the second box GEAR for all your armor and weapons. DEPOSIT DIRK BOX2 becomes DEPOSIT DIRK BOXGEAR. Sort of like putting your dirk in your knife sheath and not your sword or back sheath.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by SquallScribe »

Ah, ok. I misunderstood the suggestion then. I thought by having boxes for "Weapons," "Accessories," etc. that the box would determine what type of item could be placed in them. Like how scroll cases used to work (or possibly still do) to only allow parchments to be placed in them.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Bank Box = Locked box?

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Well, that'd require the game to recognise listing multiple options in a room with a bank teller, which as Visyn pointed out earlier is already impossible because you can't filter your depository holdings. It'd likely require a completely new command, so I'd have to agree that it's getting a bit too complex.

Also, I've got to imagine that weight capacity is undeniably tied to the topic of bank boxes. The reason people want to store organised sets - beyond those of us who are inclined in such ways, regardless - is to help alleviate the irksome limit of weight capacity (and weight of races, because I'm pretty sure most of the elves and humans are tired of rolling up as 6'0-6'9 and 112 pounds) which hinders almost everyone that isn't a beast race (I can only think of two humanoid characters in game that are probably okay carry wise). It's not really a topic which can be separated from one another, because again the irritation with the current depository system is directly linked to the aggravation caused by not being able to properly store sets, many which are necessary to ensure a character has enough carry to pick up random items or hunt with any level of moderate efficiency.

If zero pounds cannot be used - for whichever reason which cannot be explained - and staff is not going to adjust the weight issues of rollup, then it would be both helpful and beneficial to the quality of play which players experience if a flat rate was set across the board. Giving small capacity characters more carry is not going to unbalance the game from a hunting or coin earning perspective.
Post Reply