Is it ok to post spell / prayer lists here, or should we do it on an off site board?
.... just curious on what levels give what, and i think beginning players would
like to know at least the basics?
thx,
X
Spell / Prayer lists
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
We've been told in the past that we can post those things here so there are not multiple boards floating around out there.
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
Spoiler alerts would be helpful for those looking to preserve any charm in the natural progressions we have set up.
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
I am all for spoiler alerts and I understand there are people who may enjoy not knowing what's coming next but that is an OOC preference to game mechanics. What is the IC justification for keeping spells and prayers a secret?
In a place where there are presumably thousands of inhabitants there is no way my priest would not know which prayers he is due to acquire. Even if it was not common knowledge to the general population I think it would be safe to assume there are high ranking priests among the population that I would speak with. Due to mechanical limitation I am obviously not able to have these conversations, we can only pretend that I have been speaking with other priests and sharing information.
In a place where there are presumably thousands of inhabitants there is no way my priest would not know which prayers he is due to acquire. Even if it was not common knowledge to the general population I think it would be safe to assume there are high ranking priests among the population that I would speak with. Due to mechanical limitation I am obviously not able to have these conversations, we can only pretend that I have been speaking with other priests and sharing information.
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
It's an OOC preference either way, really. Especially when it involves mechanics, which by their definition are OOC configurations that establish play style and access to certain abilities, progression, damage, etc.
It's fine that it's your preference to want to know everything beforehand and some other people's to be surprised, but I will say this: strategy guides don't come with their respective video, board or computer games. Walk-throughs and cheat codes are not something the developers give out with their games; they want players to discover things on their own and experience the game organically. That's your IC justification - learning as you go. Especially in a medieval fantasy world that won't even define laws for its population IC after IC events lead to the request for them. Maybe you can start an IC guild to collect, gain and disseminate that knowledge you want rather than ask for it OOCly. It would be cool to see players set up guilds.
I also wanted to add that your character CAN go and communicate with other priests to learn their knowledge and be taught the information your PC wants - but just like in the real world (so this relates to IC justification) you can't know or be taught what hasn't been discovered yet. You're the intrepid explorer, discovering new prayers and bringing your knowledge to the world, provided you want to share it.
It's fine that it's your preference to want to know everything beforehand and some other people's to be surprised, but I will say this: strategy guides don't come with their respective video, board or computer games. Walk-throughs and cheat codes are not something the developers give out with their games; they want players to discover things on their own and experience the game organically. That's your IC justification - learning as you go. Especially in a medieval fantasy world that won't even define laws for its population IC after IC events lead to the request for them. Maybe you can start an IC guild to collect, gain and disseminate that knowledge you want rather than ask for it OOCly. It would be cool to see players set up guilds.
I also wanted to add that your character CAN go and communicate with other priests to learn their knowledge and be taught the information your PC wants - but just like in the real world (so this relates to IC justification) you can't know or be taught what hasn't been discovered yet. You're the intrepid explorer, discovering new prayers and bringing your knowledge to the world, provided you want to share it.
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
Thank you for your reply. I do not agree with you and I'm not even completely sure that your response addresses what I am talking about but thank you all the same.
I want to point out that I CANNOT communicate with other priests. There are dozens and dozens of priests wandering the city streets and presumably dozens more but I can only communicate with a small fraction of them. We are limited to our interactions with PC's but there are hundreds and maybe thousands of NPC's in Pearl. It would be inconceivable and a bit silly to think someone like Doxx or Bocon are the most skilled or knowledgeable priests in a thriving and bustling city.
No one is asking for a walk through or cheat codes and it is not OOC or far-fetched to think prayers and spells would be common knowledge, especially to those in that profession. I am presumably an influential priest of Pyrous and former high priest and you expect me to just roll with it that I don't know what prayers i'll be getting? That's ridiculous.
I am not advocating against spoiler tags or keeping it a secret for others who do like to be surprised but I do think the information should be available. If we had a linear system where there was just simply prayers and spells then I don't think it would be as big of an issue but our system breaks prayers and spells into individual skills. I think that is where the root of the problem of not knowing comes from. (For the record I do like our system better)
I want to point out that I CANNOT communicate with other priests. There are dozens and dozens of priests wandering the city streets and presumably dozens more but I can only communicate with a small fraction of them. We are limited to our interactions with PC's but there are hundreds and maybe thousands of NPC's in Pearl. It would be inconceivable and a bit silly to think someone like Doxx or Bocon are the most skilled or knowledgeable priests in a thriving and bustling city.
No one is asking for a walk through or cheat codes and it is not OOC or far-fetched to think prayers and spells would be common knowledge, especially to those in that profession. I am presumably an influential priest of Pyrous and former high priest and you expect me to just roll with it that I don't know what prayers i'll be getting? That's ridiculous.
I am not advocating against spoiler tags or keeping it a secret for others who do like to be surprised but I do think the information should be available. If we had a linear system where there was just simply prayers and spells then I don't think it would be as big of an issue but our system breaks prayers and spells into individual skills. I think that is where the root of the problem of not knowing comes from. (For the record I do like our system better)
-
Nikolas Suyessod
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
You CAN communicate with NPCs. You'll have to hope staff has time to interact with you through them, but there's nothing preventing you from finding NPCs and speaking with them on your character. You could even send in assists or mails documenting what you've done and hope for some type of result or ongoing exchange.Swamp Ape wrote:
I want to point out that I CANNOT communicate with other priests. There are dozens and dozens of priests wandering the city streets and presumably dozens more but I can only communicate with a small fraction of them. We are limited to our interactions with PC's but there are hundreds and maybe thousands of NPC's in Pearl. It would be inconceivable and a bit silly to think someone like Doxx or Bocon are the most skilled or knowledgeable priests in a thriving and bustling city.
It is OOC, though. Because people in this case are working under the OOC understanding of mechanics to know there is a finite number of spells, prayers or abilities available to them and the limitations therein. Would our characters believe in such a restriction? Or in a world of magic and the impossible (though I suppose to them it's entirely possible) would they believe instead of infinite combinations, techniques, advances and knowledge? Considering there are plans (or were) for variations of in this case priest prayers based on alignment/religion (in terms of description text and effects) WOULD each individual know exactly what to expect or should they anticipate the knowledge they learn eventually to be something entirely different?Swamp Ape wrote:it is not OOC or far-fetched to think prayers and spells would be common knowledge, especially to those in that profession. I am presumably an influential priest of Pyrous and former high priest and you expect me to just roll with it that I don't know what prayers i'll be getting? That's ridiculous.
Perhaps information should be available, but rather in the form of vague descriptions left in books and tomes. Details offered in passages about the effects of prayers/spells and the descriptions, but not fully and not the level gained. Regardless of how people feel of it the fact is prayers, spells, and abilities of all kinds are mechanics and mechanics are inherently out of character because it's the base structure of a game which makes it and our characters operate. Levels exist for us as players to have a standard knowledge of the progression of our characters. Would our characters know anything of 'levels' - no matter how it's phrased - or would they simply understand the more they study something the more advanced they become in the knowledge of the ability they're studying and researching?Swamp Ape wrote:I am not advocating against spoiler tags or keeping it a secret for others who do like to be surprised but I do think the information should be available. If we had a linear system where there was just simply prayers and spells then I don't think it would be as big of an issue but our system breaks prayers and spells into individual skills. I think that is where the root of the problem of not knowing comes from. (For the record I do like our system better)
It's one thing for players to speak of levels and know the exact point when they will get something in terms of an arbitrary number or spell name. It's another matter entirely when we're trying to justify using that and speaking of it in IC settings.
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
You've given me some thoughtful insight to consider. But come on, I could speak with 100 priests NPC's and never get a response. I've spoken with the fisherman that teaches fishing so I know it happens but the probability that I would have any meaningful discussion about prayers or spells with an NPC is so low it's laughable.
However, i'll agree that you make a valid argument in regards to levels being OOC knowledge to start with but it still not not convince me that a priest or mage would not know what's coming. No one wants to spends hours working a spell or prayer only to get nothing from it and i'm not asking for levels and I'm fine with spoiler tags but i think it's reasonable to want to know if I'm leveling the correct thing.
However, i'll agree that you make a valid argument in regards to levels being OOC knowledge to start with but it still not not convince me that a priest or mage would not know what's coming. No one wants to spends hours working a spell or prayer only to get nothing from it and i'm not asking for levels and I'm fine with spoiler tags but i think it's reasonable to want to know if I'm leveling the correct thing.
Last edited by Swamp Ape on Tue Nov 04, 2014 4:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Spell / Prayer lists
As far as levels go, i try and Rp this but am not sure it is
going so well.... i say "I've studied the 16th scroll of Aerthane, on healing" etc...
or say that i'm a 16th level Pa'U ... if there were titles for our abilities it might
be easier... lvl10-20 neophyte, 20-30 apprentice , etc... mebbe we could agree to
some kind of naming convention in game... not sure it's needed tho.
as for spell levels unlocking new stuff, this is what will keep me playing this game...
If ii learned that we don't get any new spells till lvl 50, i would prolly stop pt-ing
and just sit back and rp. learning that i get a new spell at lvl 20 will have me out there
hunting etc, so i can get to that level! It's the new spells or abilities that motivate people
to stay in game, and spend hours there.
I don't see a "spoiler" button for posting, so not sure how to go about that here.
It might be fun if , say for priests, the temple leader made the scribe write out
a scroll on what spells came from practicing what , and gave that to any new
priests.
personally, i respect each person's choice on if they want to know or not,
it's just that ... i want to know, and not having the info about prayer levels
means a greater change of me getting bored and not playing as much
is there a Spoiler tag we can use on these boards?
going so well.... i say "I've studied the 16th scroll of Aerthane, on healing" etc...
or say that i'm a 16th level Pa'U ... if there were titles for our abilities it might
be easier... lvl10-20 neophyte, 20-30 apprentice , etc... mebbe we could agree to
some kind of naming convention in game... not sure it's needed tho.
as for spell levels unlocking new stuff, this is what will keep me playing this game...
If ii learned that we don't get any new spells till lvl 50, i would prolly stop pt-ing
and just sit back and rp. learning that i get a new spell at lvl 20 will have me out there
hunting etc, so i can get to that level! It's the new spells or abilities that motivate people
to stay in game, and spend hours there.
I don't see a "spoiler" button for posting, so not sure how to go about that here.
It might be fun if , say for priests, the temple leader made the scribe write out
a scroll on what spells came from practicing what , and gave that to any new
priests.
personally, i respect each person's choice on if they want to know or not,
it's just that ... i want to know, and not having the info about prayer levels
means a greater change of me getting bored and not playing as much
is there a Spoiler tag we can use on these boards?

Re: Spell / Prayer lists
I dunno about a spoiler tag. I was just assuming we'd add the word "spoiler" to the subject line.