Parry

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Parry

Post by Creon »

I've played for a while and one of the most frustrating things is so many of the creatures out there do not do a check against parry. I don't know if this is a task that can happen but I think it's too limiting right now for Parry not to work on creatures that use natural abilities. If something claws at you it is definitely viable to be able to parry that attack. I think it was less of a RP decision and more of a mechanical decision but I think it was a mistake and the idea should be revisited.

V/R
Draven's player
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Shadowbane »

Believe me, I've beaten that horse until it became a greasy smear. Classes who are parry only are very crippled when it comes to hunting and combat. Use a shield, if you can, or learn to love statues until we get some love. Or until we're told we'll always be the redheaded stepchild of SI combat classes.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Parry

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

I've yet to see assassins (as the single class which has only parry) explain why they should get the same defence capabilities as shield block which would make them nearly defensively equal to warriors and barbarians (for the record I don't think barbarians should have both shield block and parry, but barbarians as a whole need revisited and reworked). Assassins have been promised a host of future implementations that will make them the premiere offensive melee class. They have the same progression as warriors, they're given two defence checks with parry and off-hand parry - an opportunity not afforded to scouts, templars (unless there's plans to give templars dual wield) or thieves in melee or any caster -, have backstab and shadow strike (which no one disagrees requires a much needed damage boost - and I'm not going to explain for a fourth or fifth time how those two secondary abilities work when the inevitable response of too hard to level is used), will receive poisons, will receive dual wield and who knows what else the future will hold (a lot of secondary, complementary abilities discussed in previous meetings between staff and players).

The combination of parry and off-hand parry gives assassins a 15-20% defence rate higher against melee weapons than most of the other classes and only 10-15% lower than warriors and barbarians. They had dodge taken away from them the same reason thieves had parry removed - for balance purposes. Yes, dodge works in ways that parry does not. Yet there is no off-hand dodge. The two classes with dodge will have less offensive power than assassins (as it should be). There is no sound mechanical reason to give parry the full power of shield block because all it does is increase the pros while taking away a con. There must be balance much like how templars were not given healing or vigor prayers for balance purposes.

The solution is not to give parry back the ability to block natural attacks.

The solution is to increase the number of hunting grounds and bring about a varied mix, the fixing of melee damage range and implementation of spell evolution (which should go in at the same time), the proper adjustment of backstab and shadowstrike and for the addition of several promised abilities when they're ready.

Giving parry back the same capabilities as shield block does nothing but offer short term relief which assuages some people without an eye on long-term sustainability of mechanical balance and the longevity of the game. One is a quick-fix; the other makes the game much better overall.

As for being at the bottom of combat classes, any one who thinks that is quite free to go roll a barbarian and play them for any length of time. I'd suggest it in fact.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Wren »

I think more than anything, on the subject of balance, I'm worried about Warriors also getting Dual Wield because the majority of races playing that class are the beast races, which means the hardest hitting characters are going to have a chance for a second attack. Throw in them having Dual Parry at the same time, thus no con for switching to Dual Wield instead of using a sword and Shield Block, and that's a bit worrisome.

I don't know if all classes will be able to utilize poisons on their weapons or not, but I'm hoping if not that'll be the damage boost smaller-race Assassins need to equal things out a bit.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Parry

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Wren wrote:I think more than anything, on the subject of balance, I'm worried about Warriors also getting Dual Wield because the majority of races playing that class are the beast races, which means the hardest hitting characters are going to have a chance for a second attack. Throw in them having Dual Parry at the same time, thus no con for switching to Dual Wield instead of using a sword and Shield Block, and that's a bit worrisome.

I don't know if all classes will be able to utilize poisons on their weapons or not, but I'm hoping if not that'll be the damage boost smaller-race Assassins need to equal things out a bit.
There is a con with warriors switching from a one-handed to dual wield and thus dual parry - a loss of 10-15% of defence and also the natural and range blocking of shield block. There's few situations where a warrior is likely going to use a two-hander or dual wield if they're being smart about it from a strategic standpoint and that's basically casters. Then there's different strategies in that situation between average strength races and beast races (and beast races should be harder hitting and the class or they shouldn't be penalized for being good.. at the thing they're supposed to be good at - much like one day certain races will have high casting mods) which help balance out those cases.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Shadowbane »

Assumptions are based on skills that aren't available to PCs, and while the melee system itself blows. Currently, assassins suck as far as combat goes and in regards to what we can hunt effectively. If I want to hunt without having to rely on someone else (in my case, someone outside my temple), I'm stuck with statues.

I can afk to go make dinner -- for at least an hour -- while my character hunts them solo with triggers and daggers, no mending breaks between fights, and come back to her health hanging out at around half. I would much rather go hunt vampires, but guess what? I can't hunt them at any sort of efficiency, because I can't defend against them. I do far better with statues, but it's so boring it kills me.

Assassins are hunters of sentient beings. In SI, sentient beings use more than just melee attacks. They use melee, ranged, natural, AND magic attacks, and we can only defend against ONE of those. That makes assassins, who specialize in hunting and killing people (be they human, elf, or one of the beast races), only capable of defending against a quarter of the attack types coming from the things they supposedly hunt and kill for a living. If I played a character that needed to put a hit out on someone, I wouldn't be hiring an assassin. I'd probably hire a warrior (they have the defense and utility that's most likely to help them succeed) or a mage (they have the utility and sustained damage that's most likely to help them succeed).

Know what I need as an assassin to be successful in a fight against most other PCs as it stands right this second? A healer or a mage, neither of which I would bring on a job.

I don't care if we never get something like shield, but I'd like for my parry to actually be useful if I hunt something besides a human, elf, dwarf, bolinau, or goblin that's anything but a warrior, barbarian, thief, or assassin. Or templar, but I haven't had the chance to fight one of those yet. As useful as it is (against a human warrior, for example), I am boned six ways from Sunday if I decide to go after someone like Visyn. We have zero utility, and that combined with the crap melee system and skills that don't exist for us is what makes the class not worth playing. There's a reason there's only two active assassins. My one and only saving grace is that my character's CC skill is nearly maxed, so I just trump people and targets on pure AR/DR rating. That's not how any fight should go.

We'll supposedly get some of these things promised, but we were also originally told we'd be able to track our targets and we all know what's happened with that. So until I see it in game, I'm not going to make assumptions about what I will or won't get. To do so would be almost asinine. There is still a chance that we don't get something, again, and then we'll be right back here.

As for trying a barbarian, I have. If I didn't like my main character so much, I'd probably be playing one of those instead, or go back to warrior. Only two things make me stick with this character, and it's the extremely selective number of people I involve myself with and my bullheaded determination to make a crappy melee class into something respectable (or get her to the point that when the rogue classes finally get their update, she'll have already put in the work required for her class skills to actually matter).

And on the subject of backstab being too hard to level. It's not a matter of it being hard, it is a matter of it being pants-on-head stupid when it comes to time vs reward. I average somewhere around 23 or so uses AN HOUR in backstab. Working through level 11 backstab, I have gone from level 29 to level 33 unarmed, and I still have 650 uses to go. I've been at it for hours at a time since 11/29.

If it's going to take me weeks upon weeks of literally nothing but training this damn skill to get it anywhere near useful, I better be making opening shots that take an enormous chunk out of someone's health and produces a bleeding effect. Otherwise, it is not worth it and I would have been better off making money with craft skills.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Bocon L »

I'll have to agree with Nik here, and I'll tell you why. Assassin's are getting updated, and while you have no idea what skills are going to come into the game, staff does. Your skill set would probably be too good with another defensive skill. I also agree that the problem is with inadequate hunting grounds and not the parry skill itself. Just have faith that there will be an updated place for you to hunt, that draws to your strengths.

Crafting still probably makes the most money per hour, or it's on par with normal hunting. This is for everyone, not only you. But again, that's only because we have no updated hunting areas at all. I'm sure there will be places that drop better coin in the future and it will leave crafting as an RP skill.

As for PvP, I am totally against any skill that doesn't give the opposing player a chance to react. I think buffing shadowstrike damage isn't the way to go. The fact that you can hit and hide without any retaliation, over and over again is just absurd. Finish with backstab and good game. I'm glad that it's hard to level, because I don't even want to see what it looks like at high levels, especially once melee damage is fixed. I agree that assassin's need to have a high, front loaded burst, but I think they need to pay the price of failing to dispatch a target quickly. They should never be able to win a 1 on 1 with someone like a warrior with equal skill levels in a straight up fight.

In conclusion, dual parry is fine. The hunting grounds are not and you need a skill update. Just don't get too hyped about it, because I thought we'd be getting a bunch of useful new spells and fixes to utility and it didn't happen. Just wait until the update. If you don't like it and think the class still sucks, re-roll, quit, or stick it out til they are fixed.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Shadowbane »

Just don't get too hyped about it, because I thought we'd be getting a bunch of useful new spells and fixes to utility and it didn't happen.
That's exactly my point. Speculation on things that don't exist isn't exactly helpful, especially when things have been changed before implementation in the past.

And it's great that staff knows what's planned, but us plebians don't. They have said certain things will be a certain way before only to have them changed last minute, so you'll have to excuse me for being a little skeptical.

If our update actually gives us things that make our class a true glass cannon, I'm perfectly fine with that. I can do glass cannons, and I can do them well. However, at this moment, we're all the glass and none of the cannon.

I am perfectly fine with putting in the time to make my character's class something other characters are concerned about. It's the only reason I'm currently up to my ears in dead squirrels, because that's the most effective thing I can train these skills on at the moment. Other classes have the means to counter assassins, however, and given how useful our parries are against ranged/natural/magic attacks, I think attacking from the shadows is reasonable. Some classes have counters against them, make use of them. We can't track our marks, after all.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Parry

Post by Xiija »

WARNING: mini derailment ahead
Crafting still probably makes the most money per hour, or it's on par with normal hunting.
Just wondering if anyone wants to share info on this?
i hear it all the time in the forums, but never get any info on trade skills

When i first started, it tried foraging, and the message was " nothing to forage around here"
so....i quit trying for a while ... then, somehow i found a place to forage, and i got the message " your foraging yields nothing"
or somesuch .... i didn't realize you get uses from these, and that much of skilling up is
unsuccessful attempts ...so i quit foraging. Now i have triggers, and just sit and auto forage
an area... but still don't know if you can "strip" an area out?... or can you forage indefinately in the same area?

If there was some guide on how to do crafting, ....one that showed how it can make as much money as
hunting, more folks might try it ?
anyhow, thanks for any info on this :)

***********end derailment *********************
I can afk to go make dinner -- for at least an hour -- while my character hunts
beware the evil mouse! ( and Gargoyles, and tiny floating bubbles...)

________________________________





as for Parry and Assassins,
i think a backstab with a poisoned blade from the shadows should do massive damage,
and Assassins should be high DPS, low defense.

Barbs should be the other high DPS class, along with mebbe Fire Mages?
Our Tanks should be... Earth-Mages, Warriors/Templars ?
Utility should be Scouts, Thieves, and water mages?
and air mages would be a mix of offense,defense, utility

Is there any list of what classes get what skills anywhere?
Tanks should get the parry,dual parry, shield etc, everyone else should only have one defense option?
there is no info on the site about water mages.... what do they specialize in?
Image
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Parry

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Shadowbane wrote:Assumptions are based on skills that aren't available to PCs, and while the melee system itself blows. Currently, assassins suck as far as combat goes and in regards to what we can hunt effectively. If I want to hunt without having to rely on someone else (in my case, someone outside my temple), I'm stuck with statues.

I can afk to go make dinner -- for at least an hour -- while my character hunts them solo with triggers and daggers, no mending breaks between fights, and come back to her health hanging out at around half. I would much rather go hunt vampires, but guess what? I can't hunt them at any sort of efficiency, because I can't defend against them. I do far better with statues, but it's so boring it kills me.
Assumptions on skills is all there is to go on along with a basic understanding of them. You are promised skills which are described to boost your offence in a way which will make you the premiere offensive class. You are using assumptions on what you will or will not get to argue in favour of having parry restored to its previous form, are you not? No, currently the hunting grounds are incomplete and aren't varied and that causes you limitations in what to hunt effectively. There is a distinct difference and I think it should be noticed and not turned around.

No, you can't hunt them with any sort of efficiency (though you can hunt them), that's entirely true. Yet your solution is to make it so the same capabilities as shield block is set with parry - regardless of the imbalance it offers. It's a mechanical advantage which would benefit you every where, not just hunting, and that also shouldn't be ignored in what you're asking. Instead of making it so assassins have another pro when considering what they're going to get in the future, the solution is again to create more hunting grounds which offer a unique variety of hunting styles, skills and abilities necessary. This ensures assassins have a high level hunting ground which is engaging to them and makes use of their form of defence without giving them more defence that makes them closer to other combat classes.

Shadowbane wrote:Assassins are hunters of sentient beings. In SI, sentient beings use more than just melee attacks. They use melee, ranged, natural, AND magic attacks, and we can only defend against ONE of those. That makes assassins, who specialize in hunting and killing people (be they human, elf, or one of the beast races), only capable of defending against a quarter of the attack types coming from the things they supposedly hunt and kill for a living. If I played a character that needed to put a hit out on someone, I wouldn't be hiring an assassin. I'd probably hire a warrior (they have the defense and utility that's most likely to help them succeed) or a mage (they have the utility and sustained damage that's most likely to help them succeed).

Know what I need as an assassin to be successful in a fight against most other PCs as it stands right this second? A healer or a mage, neither of which I would bring on a job.
Yes, but as you said you specialise in killing people. You don't specialise in defending against them. You should specialise in high burst damage to start and surprise attacks - which again is why I said I don't think really anyone (except maybe Bocon?) is against the idea that shadow strike and backstab need an increase in damage output. But you don't get to be the killing machine (even if it's in the future) and comparable to defensive classes as well. That isn't balanced and it isn't fair. You don't like how mages (and I suppose priests) are right now but mages only get one passive defence and their DR is atrocious - even when leveling melee skills. They are almost always going to be hit and once resist is fixed they will not always hit you for full damage.

You keep using things as they stand right this second. But that's a short-sighted approach which only requires more fixing farther down the line and which is why what is to come must be considered for long-term balance and mechanical health. No one can beat anybody in PVP right now unless it's organised like the AFC fights or games. Assassins are not alone in being unsuccessful against other PCs in IC combat right now - that's a game wide issue.
Shadowbane wrote:I don't care if we never get something like shield, but I'd like for my parry to actually be useful if I hunt something besides a human, elf, dwarf, bolinau, or goblin that's anything but a warrior, barbarian, thief, or assassin. Or templar, but I haven't had the chance to fight one of those yet. As useful as it is (against a human warrior, for example), I am boned six ways from Sunday if I decide to go after someone like Visyn. We have zero utility, and that combined with the crap melee system and skills that don't exist for us is what makes the class not worth playing. There's a reason there's only two active assassins. My one and only saving grace is that my character's CC skill is nearly maxed, so I just trump people and targets on pure AR/DR rating. That's not how any fight should go.
Yes, you're possibly 'boned' against Visyn.. but so are other people. Visyn will be in a difficult situation against other people. Just like any character in the game. Again, we all have foils. We're supposed to have foils. It's interactive and we're all going to beat or be beaten by someone else. You chose a human assassin and that is an average race overall and the truth is you're going to have to work harder than others to beat equally or slightly lower level high strength beast races or (one day) high modifier casters. Which is how it should be because smaller, average races get different benefits from higher damage races (though starting DR needs an overhaul).

The melee damage system is poor and still needs reworked, along with spell evolution, and you won't find any argument there. You don't have zero utility, though - you have backstab and shadowstrike; yes, they need to be reworked but they are utility for you along with hide and one day dual wield and poisons. You can't just ignore what's coming down the line because you want to have the same defence capabilities as shield blockers/dodgers right now. EVERY CLASS is playing a class that's incomplete right now. That's just a fact. Barbarians, mages, priests, assassins, thieves (though thieves are pretty well off considering), warriors and even templars. They're all incomplete and they all can be really, really boring to play. That isn't a unique problem limited to assassins only.
Shadowbane wrote:We'll supposedly get some of these things promised, but we were also originally told we'd be able to track our targets and we all know what's happened with that. So until I see it in game, I'm not going to make assumptions about what I will or won't get. To do so would be almost asinine. There is still a chance that we don't get something, again, and then we'll be right back here.
You might not, but that's all we have to work with and needs to be considered when discussing mechanical issues and balance. The default stock code description of assassins being on the webpage was an unfortunate occurrence for people who rolled, yes. But you are making assumptions on what you may not get because you're using them in arguments here as to why assassins should have parry reverted to being the same as shield block or something rather comparable. Just the same as I am assuming staff will come through on the abilities promised that aren't based on an error in a stock code help file description.


Shadowbane wrote:And on the subject of backstab being too hard to level. It's not a matter of it being hard, it is a matter of it being pants-on-head stupid when it comes to time vs reward. I average somewhere around 23 or so uses AN HOUR in backstab. Working through level 11 backstab, I have gone from level 29 to level 33 unarmed, and I still have 650 uses to go. I've been at it for hours at a time since 11/29.

If it's going to take me weeks upon weeks of literally nothing but training this damn skill to get it anywhere near useful, I better be making opening shots that take an enormous chunk out of someone's health and produces a bleeding effect. Otherwise, it is not worth it and I would have been better off making money with craft skills.
But level is not the end all be all in how backstab and shadowstrike works. This has been explained numerous times and I can't really do anything if that's not going to be acknowledged. The damage is atrocious, that I wouldn't argue at all. That's what's holding the skills back - not them being hard or 'stupid' to level because it doesn't work like that with them. Also, I think it's somewhat disingenuous to say you only get twenty-three uses or so an hour when from your statement you're using it an opener and then leveling UC. You're going to kill stuff at a slower pace with UC and the result is less opportunities to use backstab or shadowstrike as openers. That'd be like me saying I only get X amount of uses in fishing but I'm stopping to cook on every catch.

And I do think assassins should retain their ability to use shadowstrike with a damage buff (though not the same damage put out as backstab), but I've already said those two skills need a large damage adjustment. And all damage for all classes is pretty awful which is why melee damage range being fixed and spell evolution being implemented (and both going in at the same time, please) will be a great thing to see and ease frustration with a lot of classes.

Xiija's player,

All mages should be the same in terms of offence and defence. This isn't other games where mages of any type could have a number of religious made available to them. Here fire is restricted to Pyrous, water to Kaleith, air to Aerthane and earth to Tetherias. To make them the traditional archetypes would be in my opinion terribly unbalanced and catastrophic in the end because you'd have people choosing mechanical reasons to play certain mages but they're assigned to specific gods and that skews the religious roleplay heavily. You'd also see number issues in terms of some religions being stacked and others not. Shattered Isles is supposed to be heavily revolved around The Shattering and religious roleplay. Making them the default, traditional archetypes throws everything out of whack in this world. Special cantrip spells should differ, yes, but pushing offence to one and defence to another just will throw everything out of whack in the long-term.
Post Reply