Parry

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Parry

Post by Xiija »

All mages should be the same in terms of offence and defence. This isn't other games where mages of any type could have a number of religious made available to them. Here fire is restricted to Pyrous, water to Kaleith, air to Aerthane and earth to Tetherias. To make them the traditional archetypes would be in my opinion terribly unbalanced and catastrophic in the end because you'd have people choosing mechanical reasons to play certain mages but they're assigned to specific gods and that skews the religious roleplay heavily. You'd also see number issues in terms of some religions being stacked and others not. Shattered Isles is supposed to be heavily revolved around The Shattering and religious roleplay. Making them the default, traditional archetypes throws everything out of whack in this world. Special cantrip spells should differ, yes, but pushing offence to one and defence to another just will throw everything out of whack in the long-term.
erm...
If all mages are basically the same, then people would just be choosing a religion and we could get rid of the 4 elements.
sorry, mage specialization is the one thing that would make the game more interesting IMHO :P
Image
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Shadowbane »

The biggest choice players should make is the religion you follow, because the game is based on religious conflict. The only cool thing different elemental mage get is their flavor text.

I prefer that. Tired of seeing just Aerthanians and Pyresians. If there were advantages of one element over another, we'd be up to our eyeballs in firemages. (Not that we aren't already dealing with religious imbalance already).
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Parry

Post by SquallScribe »

Shadowbane wrote:The biggest choice players should make is the religion you follow, because the game is based on religious conflict. The only cool thing different elemental mage get is their flavor text.
Precisely. All mages are the same class. The only difference is flavor which is tied to religion - just like all templars/warriors/barbarians/scouts/assassins/priests have the same skillset no matter the religion they choose. It would be foolish to say that fire mages do more damage, water mages have more utility/healing, air mages are harder to hit and earth mages absorb more damage because you cannot roll an earth mage of Pyrous. It would skew rollup heavily to one particular mage type and leave some others lacking instead of allowing players to choose the most important choice on rollup outside of race - their religion (which is all based on elements in this game) - in favor of mechanical benefits which that sort of constrained system would confer.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Parry

Post by Creon »

The scope of this post was to change monsters with natural attacks to be able to be parried. The math wont change the same rounds and odds would be and place and shield block would still be better. It would only improve player experience as they would not be restricted to a few places to hunt.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Parry

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Creon wrote:The scope of this post was to change monsters with natural attacks to be able to be parried. The math wont change the same rounds and odds would be and place and shield block would still be better. It would only improve player experience as they would not be restricted to a few places to hunt.
The math does change because it increases the percentages of those with only parry in areas where before they had no defence. You can't change NPCs with natural attacks able to be parried without rewriting NPC natural attacks into a separate skill (which it might already be), recoding how it works and then likely recoding parry to recognise the difference between NPC natural attacks and PC natural attacks. Restriction to a few places to hunt is awful, it's true, which is again why the solution to this should be increase the number of hunting grounds available which incorporate a variety of checks and balances. Making it so parry people can block natural attacks in hunting would be a stopgap attempt to improve player experience without considering mechanical balance. Increasing the amount of areas all people can go to and thus giving players ample choices on where to hunt without disrupting the balance of the game improves player experience far more and keeps a mechanical health to the game.

The Watcher's Tower is open now which gives a place for those with parry to hunt high level stuff. A new option which I'm sure the playerbase appreciates. But down the line players and staff alike should be thinking of how many varied hunting grounds we could have which don't eliminate checks and balances but instead give different classes an area to excel: Hunting grounds where mages excel, hunting grounds where mages are resisted more than normal. Hunting grounds with magical attacks that can't be defended outside of a mage or priest giving a player an absorb shield or a resist defence spell. Hunting grounds where priests do great damage against the undead, hunting grounds where priests can't. Hunting grounds that operate best with someone with shield block and high DR. Hunting grounds where being afflicted by a poison would temporarily lower the AR/DR of the MOB. Hunting grounds where ethereals can exist without being abused by melee to level.

There's so many opportunities to showcase the pros and cons of each class and improve player experience in this way rather than simply make a class unbalanced by changing how one of their defence checks work.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Parry

Post by Creon »

I think you're taking what I'm saying out of context, I'm saying they would still block the same amount of times as they would a melee NPC mathematically not the difference from no defense now. It doesn't benefit the player base to exclude some of them from content by not letting the 'defend' of a natural attack the same % they would against a melee attack. The only reason a player should be excluded from a hunting mechanically is the level difference. It only takes away from fun to exclude players mechanically (and I mean combat related classes). More content to a game is a natural progression that should be given or the game becomes stagnant it shouldn't specifically compensate for mechanics short comings of a particular player base.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Parry

Post by Snaek »

This has been a great topic to read through. I am always impressed with the knowledge of the players when it comes to the mechanics of the game. There are no plans to open up parry to defend as well as shield block and I dont see that changing for all the reasons mentioned. It is a matter of balance. Balance is a delicate dance we play between realism and mechanics. If we did everything by a realistic approach, nothing would balance out.

That said, the answer to this problem is more diverse hunting. As stated above (and really should not have been mentioned outside the game) a new hunting area has opened with this in mind, as well as others in development. You're all right in that the game needs more areas that allow the different classes to fully utilize their skillet. To be clear though, no hunting is limited to just one class. You just excel in some places more than others. The places you don't can still be hunted with a friend or group. You may have to hunt below your primary skill level to hunt by yourself and that's really how it should be.

We're well aware of a need for more hunting that caters to the different classes. This isn't this first time it's been brought up. Two more areas of weapon wielding mobs are nearing completion now. Look for news of those in the IC world, and try to keep them there when they are newly discovered!
Post Reply