There's a lot of factors at play here. Maybe I can clear some up. These are in no particular order.
1. Shops reset their inventory when the game restarts. Resource shops sell a limited amount of goods on purpose. In the case of hawkers, the purpose is to give new players something to work with, but not so much that it discourages using gathering skills.
2. Cooking is no exception to trade skills in need of price adjustments. It's slated to be fixed along with the others in the upcoming trade update.
3. As the game evolves, we are moving toward an economy that works with the finished product more than the raw materials. Bundling played a role in this with its issues but it shed some light on better solutions that benefit the game. When we switched the resource shops around, we didn't intend for players to bundle/unbundle to get around selling some things. We never said not to either. Just didn't account for it. What we are going to do is make the names of all store bought materials unique. A pinch of salt instead of some salt. You can still bundle store bought materials and still craft with them, but you won't be able to sell raw materials anywhere. We think this will encourage a player driven market.
All this working together puts more importance on the finished product and the trading of resources between players. It also from a staff position eliminates a few long standing bugs from happening and gives us a more polished system.
cooking recipies
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: cooking recipies
I don't think discouraging selling raw materials is a good idea. Sometimes a middle man is preferred, because let's face it, it's probably best one character doesn't know they bought material courtesy of another character they don't like. I think some vendors should act as those middle men. For example, my character won't do transactions with specific people in a personal setting (and it's most likely a mutual thing), and until there's actually an ATC-endorsed 'supplier' who doesn't care who they supply so long as the merchant buying can pay, that's probably how it'll go.
There's a player driven market out there currently. As characters are most likely to do here, there's preferences for some on who they buy and sell to. Chances are, it'll always be that way. For those with fewer connections, they still have an option to sell what they gather to NPC vendors who buy it. If you take that away, there's a good chance that people training are just going to leave the stuff they find on the ground.
There's a player driven market out there currently. As characters are most likely to do here, there's preferences for some on who they buy and sell to. Chances are, it'll always be that way. For those with fewer connections, they still have an option to sell what they gather to NPC vendors who buy it. If you take that away, there's a good chance that people training are just going to leave the stuff they find on the ground.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: cooking recipies
Yeah, I just don't want to wait anymore. LOL. I realized changes were probably coming down the pipe. From my perspective some kind of stopgap wouldn't take too long to implement. For example, what about just raising the price of simple meat dishes, such as boiled meat, just at the jolly vendor? It'd give us one tiny outlet in the meantime. I guess I could just cook it now and store it though if this isn't possible.
Player markets for fur and meat are just impossible right now. No one will buy fur for taxidermy uses and it will likely take tailoring to make a player market come about, which it will right away I'm sure.
The player bone market exists, but it is really constrained due to lack of profit. I think things like ivory will change this.
I don't think PC grudges are that limiting sales interactions. They just aren't that common. Many characters just don't see a profit in crafts. The wood craft market basically consists of wood carvers giving out gifts to friends. The only market that seems thriving is smithing, so perhaps the profits are there. I'm not an expert on it.
I have no problem with there being no npc buying of materials, as long as there are PC outlets to profit. After all if a craft is profitable enough, I can do it myself when my buyers are not buying. I'm already a semi decent bone carver. NPCs buying for minimum prices might be a better solution though. That does give an outlet for someone that can't find a buyer for whatever reason, yet favors a player market.
Can't wait to use air magic to start a steam driven cloth mill.
Player markets for fur and meat are just impossible right now. No one will buy fur for taxidermy uses and it will likely take tailoring to make a player market come about, which it will right away I'm sure.
The player bone market exists, but it is really constrained due to lack of profit. I think things like ivory will change this.
I don't think PC grudges are that limiting sales interactions. They just aren't that common. Many characters just don't see a profit in crafts. The wood craft market basically consists of wood carvers giving out gifts to friends. The only market that seems thriving is smithing, so perhaps the profits are there. I'm not an expert on it.
I have no problem with there being no npc buying of materials, as long as there are PC outlets to profit. After all if a craft is profitable enough, I can do it myself when my buyers are not buying. I'm already a semi decent bone carver. NPCs buying for minimum prices might be a better solution though. That does give an outlet for someone that can't find a buyer for whatever reason, yet favors a player market.
Can't wait to use air magic to start a steam driven cloth mill.
Re: cooking recipies
I'm not sure players are interested in a "player driven market" ? ..... i posted an offer
to try a Farmers market type thyng for people to sell to each other and got
ZERO responses.
I think that npc merchants could work if their inventory is based on items sold to them tho.
Example:
A new merchant called "the Trapper" opens a store.
you hunt for an hour and end up with 50 fur, 50 meat, and 50 bone
You sell 50 bone to the Trapper for 3db each............. *You get 150 db*
( same as an item drop, you get 3db for selling a bone dagger)
A carver player checks the trapper and sees he has bone, selling for 6db each.
The carver player spams "Buy Some Bone" 50 times . ............ * the carver pays 300 db*
The carver player goes and carves 50 items with that bone, and then sells the carved bone for 9db........... * they make 450 db - a 150 db profit*
Both the original seller of bone, and the carver make the same, and the carver gets skill uses. and the economy goes on!
The bone that is dropped sells for the same as a bone dagger that is dropped, so, no imbalance anywhere?
::shrugs::
Currently , as Kaiah implies, one might use an intermediary to sell to.
( If i sell bone to Blink for 3db, he sells to Wren for 6db, etc)
but if Blink is a carver, he may choose to carve it himself, and end Wren's supply.
I'm not sure enuff players are gathering / selling to support the economy?
As for salt, I can't see putting meat (1db) and salt (5db) in a pot, and cooking 'boiled meat' that sells for 1db?
Salt should be 1db, and boiled meat should sell for 3db, meaning you get a whole 1-2db per skill use?

to try a Farmers market type thyng for people to sell to each other and got
ZERO responses.
I think that npc merchants could work if their inventory is based on items sold to them tho.
Example:
A new merchant called "the Trapper" opens a store.
you hunt for an hour and end up with 50 fur, 50 meat, and 50 bone
You sell 50 bone to the Trapper for 3db each............. *You get 150 db*
( same as an item drop, you get 3db for selling a bone dagger)
A carver player checks the trapper and sees he has bone, selling for 6db each.
The carver player spams "Buy Some Bone" 50 times . ............ * the carver pays 300 db*
The carver player goes and carves 50 items with that bone, and then sells the carved bone for 9db........... * they make 450 db - a 150 db profit*
Both the original seller of bone, and the carver make the same, and the carver gets skill uses. and the economy goes on!
The bone that is dropped sells for the same as a bone dagger that is dropped, so, no imbalance anywhere?
::shrugs::
Currently , as Kaiah implies, one might use an intermediary to sell to.
( If i sell bone to Blink for 3db, he sells to Wren for 6db, etc)
but if Blink is a carver, he may choose to carve it himself, and end Wren's supply.
I'm not sure enuff players are gathering / selling to support the economy?
As for salt, I can't see putting meat (1db) and salt (5db) in a pot, and cooking 'boiled meat' that sells for 1db?
Salt should be 1db, and boiled meat should sell for 3db, meaning you get a whole 1-2db per skill use?
Last edited by Xiija on Wed Jan 14, 2015 6:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Re: cooking recipies
I think you didn't get responses because people didn't feel a need to meet at a certain time to do it. Most buying and selling happens either through advertising posts or through people the person already knows. Pretty much all my sales are through people I already know. I rarely buy, but sometimes I'll buy bone, and I just bought some from a Gargoyle I just met that offered to sell it. Most of the smiths seem to collect their own materials, buy through posts or relationships, or a combination of those two.
Re: cooking recipies
True true,
it's sad tho, i'd seen everyone at peddles and hoped this could be
a kind of 'player run peddle' type of thing, like every saturday you know
that at 9 bells, there will be people in a certain area, with goods to sell.
I might have even tried it if I had gotten even one or two responses,
but as you say, most of these kind of sales are between friends.
it's sad tho, i'd seen everyone at peddles and hoped this could be
a kind of 'player run peddle' type of thing, like every saturday you know
that at 9 bells, there will be people in a certain area, with goods to sell.
I might have even tried it if I had gotten even one or two responses,
but as you say, most of these kind of sales are between friends.

Re: cooking recipies
I like the idea of off-book, player based peddles, it's ideally how i'd like one of my t00ns to generate an income. It's just too bad they don't work at the moment.
I'm hoping that the crafting update will change things to where even low level tradesmen can craft player desired items.
What if advanced crafting required smaller parts that lower levels could build? We could grind our way into mastery on hinges and wooden pegs that we could peddle by the box full to higher level builders that don't have time to grind out nails and whittle handles.
On a sorta side note
If there is going to be any alteration to the current NPC market, I'd like to see, for sake of RP, some way to include more restrictions and penalties applied for things like poaching or black-market sales. At the moment you can just stand in front of a guard or marshal and sell off hundreds of pounds of ore to another player that was mined in the King's backyard with no tax or penalty applied. I'm not sure how it would work but it would give people an opportunity to make money from either side of the law.
Imagine this theory/example: Having to buy a license to catch/sell fish, it gives you the freedom to fish openly with some restrictions on the types of fish caught but gives you a taxed, regulated market that is always available to sell to. In order to gain a license to fish other types of fish requires advancing skill levels. It'll offer people a safe, balanced way to make a steady, honest income. Now you decide to do some fishing without a license, you'd have to find a sneaky spot so you don't suffer a ranger fineing you or taking your tackle, but gain access to every type of fish in the sea, being that your poaching and not following ATC regulations. It'll give you that option to fence/peddle exotic fish at a higher profit but with more risk. Regular markets can turn you down if not report you as a poacher.
or something like that.
Maybe I'd even buy a store and sell legal fish as a front and host a monthly black-market peddle in the back, after hours status, for all those poison makers and cooks that want more exotic product. I'll call it Blackwater Market (tm).
I'm hoping that the crafting update will change things to where even low level tradesmen can craft player desired items.
What if advanced crafting required smaller parts that lower levels could build? We could grind our way into mastery on hinges and wooden pegs that we could peddle by the box full to higher level builders that don't have time to grind out nails and whittle handles.
On a sorta side note
If there is going to be any alteration to the current NPC market, I'd like to see, for sake of RP, some way to include more restrictions and penalties applied for things like poaching or black-market sales. At the moment you can just stand in front of a guard or marshal and sell off hundreds of pounds of ore to another player that was mined in the King's backyard with no tax or penalty applied. I'm not sure how it would work but it would give people an opportunity to make money from either side of the law.
Imagine this theory/example: Having to buy a license to catch/sell fish, it gives you the freedom to fish openly with some restrictions on the types of fish caught but gives you a taxed, regulated market that is always available to sell to. In order to gain a license to fish other types of fish requires advancing skill levels. It'll offer people a safe, balanced way to make a steady, honest income. Now you decide to do some fishing without a license, you'd have to find a sneaky spot so you don't suffer a ranger fineing you or taking your tackle, but gain access to every type of fish in the sea, being that your poaching and not following ATC regulations. It'll give you that option to fence/peddle exotic fish at a higher profit but with more risk. Regular markets can turn you down if not report you as a poacher.
or something like that.
Maybe I'd even buy a store and sell legal fish as a front and host a monthly black-market peddle in the back, after hours status, for all those poison makers and cooks that want more exotic product. I'll call it Blackwater Market (tm).
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: cooking recipies
Cool ideas!
(But I think you should call it Backwater Market (tm) you know... since you're selling fish in... the back ;p)
(But I think you should call it Backwater Market (tm) you know... since you're selling fish in... the back ;p)
Re: cooking recipies
Here's the issue with selling resources, at least with ore and wood. It's not worth the time to gather it for the sole purpose of selling it. People typically won't pay more than what they will make from whatever they craft. So if my scepter takes 2 ore and sells for 40 gold, I will buy ore for for like 10 gold per pound. It takes 60 seconds to pull up a maximum of 3 ore per try and 1 minimum, assuming you find ore on every single try without fail and the same room spawns ore every time the resource timer cycles. You can make more than 10 gold a min, in almost any hunting area in the game. I can make 1300 gold an hour in the crypt alone. So gathering ore or wood for the sole purpose of selling it would be completely pointless. This is the main issue with a farmers market IMO. It's been stated more than once, that there's no intention of having crafting make as much as you can while hunting. So there's really no incentive at all to be a pure gatherer, only for the sake of making money.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: cooking recipies
For the most part, though, it's relatively easy to gather materials and it's not anywhere near as risky, if it's risky at all, as it is to go hunting. That's why hunting and killing things that could very well kill you pays better, because of the increased risk. I think that's a fair system. It wouldn't be fair to benefit as much from easy, risk-free work as someone does from going out and hunting and risking character death at worst, or a steep repair bill at best.
Hopefully the upcoming crafting fix will straighten a lot of things out.
Hopefully the upcoming crafting fix will straighten a lot of things out.

Hierophant of Itzal