A bit on Role-play etiquitte

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Post Reply
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

A bit on Role-play etiquitte

Post by ditchhook »

Just wanted to take a moment to explain what "power emoting" is and why it's bad.

"Power Emoting" is when one player types an emote that imposes an action or behavior on another players, or compels the other player to passively accept what the power-emoter imposes upon them. This is poor role-play style because we are all assumed to be equally entitled to tell our character's stories and express our own character's reactions and behavior. In a role play enforced game like Shattered Isles, it is inappropriate to force actions onto other players through emoting, even if the emote code allows for it.

There is provision for us to impose our will on other characters without their permission, via the combat, or thief codes, for example.

Examples of power-emoting and how to avoid it:

Emote lifts Snaek up and slams him into the pavement. (That's power emoting.)

Here's a more appropriate way to emote out such a scene:

Emote reaches out to grab Sneak. (This gives Sneak the option of accepting the action, or resisting it.)

Sneak tries to step away from you.

emote tries to maneuver Sneak into a corner.

Sneak quickly tumbles onto the ground and rolls away from your grasp. (Now, Sneak is on the pavement.)

emote throws herself at the prone Sneak, trying to pin him down.

etc.

Another example:

emote hugs Sneak (however, Sneak is not as enamored with you as you are with him.)

A better approach:

emote reaches out to hug Sneak

and possible responses:

Sneak accept a hug from you.

or

Sneak gently pushes you back.

Of course, all rules are meant to be broken, and if the scene has built up to the point where it would seem clear to all parties that a hug is in order, then go ahead and "cut to the chase." But never use emotes as a shortcut to imposing your will (or your idea of how the scene should be going) onto other players without giving them a chance to provide their own input.

Even giving someone something when they are not expecting it is a form of power-gaming. It can be forgiven if it is innocuous, but otherwise one should wait for an indication of acceptance before the 'give' command is used. It's not only polite (helps people keep mental tabs on what's in their inventory at the moment), but "give" can also be abused: for example by 'giving' someone's character a stolen item while they are link-dead, or just distracted by combat or other role-play. In real life a thief type might "plant" something on another person without permission, but they cannot 'give' something to them without permission.

In a role-play intensive game we need to be wary not to interfere with (or disempower) other players without them having a say in the matter, even if sometimes the code inadvertently allows such. Now I'm all in favor of trickery, however. Give their character a knapsack with the stolen item inside. And if they accept it, you've played out the scene properly.

As a rule of thumb: if someone like your character could absolutely pull off something like you are attempting in real life, go ahead. But if you are exploiting code to pull off something your character couldn't otherwise accomplish, stop and think whether you are depriving other players of the full use and enjoyment of their character.
Bihi
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: A bit on Role-play etiquitte

Post by Shadowbane »

Is this really about giving someone an item or using the hug/cuddle/lean/touch/[insert contact emote here]? Or one of those emotes where people add on additional fluff to give it more substance so it's less bland?

While I agree with the first part of your post (forcing an action on someone, such as jerking them around by the collar), I'm not following along with the second. It seems a little nit-picky, for one, because of all the things in this game that there are legitimate gripes for (both on the game itself and other players) this is something that gets an etiquette post? Sure, sometimes I feel players in ANY game could use a few tips when it comes to roleplay, but we all started new once and this is something we constantly learn new things about. Everyone has a different style. This is one of those things where roleplayer A will never like how roleplayer B plays and always calls it wrong, not because it is wrong but because they don't like the style. Yes, metagaming and godmoding and 'power emoting' or power playing are bad forms and, assuming it isn't someone who's just super new to roleplay (in which case, they should be shown more acceptable methods of RP and not harshly criticized), they should never be accepted or made the norm. I fully, completely agree.

There are other things in Shattered Isles that deprive me of the full use and enjoyment of my character. Base emotes and being handed items isn't one of them.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: A bit on Role-play etiquitte

Post by ditchhook »

I'm the last person to insist on 'hard and fast' rules that must be applied on all occasions. I'm just saying please be a bit careful doing things that involuntarily affect other characters' status in the game. If a situation arises where it just might be confusing or imposing on the other player's plan for their character to give it something, just take an extra moment to signal and wait for a response before doing so.

And it is a good idea to make a habit of this, because on the occasion when you might want them to take something not in their best interest to take (a poison, a stolen item, etc.) you don't want to 'tip them off' by suddenly using a different procedure.

Unsolicited 'gives' can be annoying for a number of reasons. I might be distracted by some intense combat or roleplay, and not notice your 'give.' Then I might want to use an item that was in my inventory, but the item you gave me shares a keyword with the item I wanted to use, so I'm junking, or throwing, or somehow using the wrong item in my play. Or I might notice it in my inventory only much later, and wonder what happened to put that item there. Or it might unexpectedly put me too near my weight capacity: I move my character far away to start another task, only to find I can't carry the item back without abandoning something else. It's a big problem with coins, because the code automatically 'sums-up' the coins in my inventory. I would have remember my previous coin holdings, and subtract that from the total, to know how many coins you gave to me, if I wasn't watching carefully. Having a warning helps me with these tasks.
Bihi
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: A bit on Role-play etiquitte

Post by Snaek »

I don't think this has been an issue. Our players have been great about not forcing actions on others. They've also been accepting and patient with new players who come to the game with different role-playing styles. Still, this is a good opportunity to update the Code of Conduct with a better stance on what constitutes forced role-play.
Post Reply