player death

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: player death

Post by Austere »

Shadowbane wrote:...permanent character death needs to stay completely in the hands of that character's player.

No one has the right to dictate when someone else's character permanently dies, ever.
No one, but a beholder.

Muahahahaha!


Seriously though, be careful.
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: player death

Post by ditchhook »

Shadowbane wrote:
The reason we have coded skills to determine our combat success is because this is a game that's driven by conflict, and the average player cannot be trusted to play anything but a winner.
Dead characters are not winners. I don't understand how this is consistent with your earlier contention that:
Shadowbane wrote: If someone requires game mechanics to make their RP realistic or believable (treating death seriously, considering certain people likely threats, eating bad food, etc. etc.), then it's not the game that needs something, it's the player.
Bihi
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: player death

Post by Blink »

There's a good reasons there will never be perma death game. It would be a basic violation of the agreement the staff and players had about what this game is and why we should invest a bunch of time in it. There are perma death muds out there, and they generally start out that way in the beginning, rather than springing it on their player base after several years. It's a good way to lose a huge chunk of the player base all at once.

I think longer terms as ghosts, but never permanent, is the best of both worlds. Spells to interact with ghosts would be needed first, however, as it gets a bit boring as a ghost when you can't find someone to spy on. The ghost thing does a good job of putting you out of the action and I happen to like it. It's just not long enough yet.

By the way, the code is in this game because this is a mud. Without the code this would be a mush. Like perma death, it's one of those things you should know about when selecting a game to play. Some people like perma death muds and some like mushes. They may not play SI on learning it is neither of those things.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: player death

Post by Xiija »

First of all, i realize that more important stuff like skills and trades etc will take the coders till
2017 to finish, so changes like this won't be coming soon, and that this is an intellectual discussion.

That being said,
I'd like to see something like this...

When a player dies, ( usually in combat with Boss mobs or swarmed ) they get transported
to their temple, and are in "spirit" form. They have the option to fly anywhere in game as a spirit,
and could interact only with speech. This would allow a fallen player to go seek out someone to help them.

If they choose to resurrect themselves at their altar, they would experience "resurrection sickness",
(like spells that give a DR boost etc, this would give a deficit to AR/DR, strength etc, and would last a day,
and each following death that day would add to the sickness timer. ( 2 deaths in the same day = 2 days sickness)

If a player has donated coin to a deity, they could amass "favor" , and if they have enuff favor they could pray for
a resurrection that would bring them back with no sickness. Priests of the same religion could rez someone with
their Rez prayer ( priests would need favors to do this, but it would cost less than if you did it yourself, and a priest
of a different religion would cost more than one of your own). - the rezzed player would then "owe" the prieist the cost of a rez.

I think stat loss would be a good option as a penalty for death if we had a way to regain those stats, i.e. you lose
2 points CON by dying, but you can purchase a 2 point CON potion at a peddle or shop for an exorbitant amount.
( Or if you have enuff favors when you "auto rez" , the stat loss is bypassed - taking x amt of favor?)

With lots of people amassing great wealth in game, the coin used to buy favor could help redistribute this wealth,
and donating to a temple / god would bring more religion into the game, as well as the cost of stat potions.

Didn't we use something like this in Dragon's Gate? ( been so long, i can barely remember)

As a bonus, players who die could get scars, and have the option of wearing their scars proudly, (or in shame)
or having them removed for more coin.

**p.s. if even non priests reach a high devotional level ( tons of favors) they could get a bump to their "luck" stat
or some other bonus? .. this would encourage people to spend coin to donate.
I also wouldn't mind being able to use favors to "buy" a temporary stat raise - 10,000 favors = 1 hour STR boost?

:: 2 cents added :P ::

X.
Last edited by Xiija on Tue Jun 16, 2015 8:09 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Image
Voegelin
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 68
Joined: Tue May 27, 2014 7:35 pm

Re: player death

Post by Voegelin »

I'd agree that forced permadeath is a bad idea for this game. However, real penalties imposed upon the player's character when it dies are reasonable. In most of the games I've played, these penalties take a few forms: basically a timeout penalty and/or some sort of skill/stat/hit point penalty. A ghost stage makes for a good timeout penalty, so long as some provisions are made that allow for RP'ing in the ghost stage. Forcing the character to take a step back in skills or stats might be a bit harsh, but could be used for a character that dies repeatedly in a short period of time. I'd favor a strictly temporary reduction in the character's hit points after it returns--say, 50% for an hour or two of actual playing time. This would provide an element of guidance to players in RPing death events.

There seems to be an argument that we can just RP death without such guidance. There are mechanical problems with that, I think. For instance, how exactly does a player RP a character's weakness in combat after returning from the dead? Whether or not the character that immediately returns to combat winds up dying because it is temporarily more vulnerable than usual isn't something that can be RP'd without mechanical assistance. Obviously, the player can choose to have the character avoid combat for a while rather than attempt to RP vulnerability in combat, but this just places a different constraint upon the player's choices. I think some modest imposed, or mechanical, penalties, offer guidance while creating a useful common ground for all the players in RPing death events, while still placing the emphasis upon the player's imaginative response to the game circumstances.

--Aruskin
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: player death

Post by Xiija »

I like the 50% health idea ... it allows you to return to a group to get your split, or to
get your dropped bones/corpses etc while still making you vulnerable. It would be nice to
be able to see "Aruskin is deathly pale" on your description while the death penalty is in effect.
Image
Yiri
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 124
Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2013 1:06 pm

Re: player death

Post by Yiri »

I second pretty much all of Xiija's ideas so far. Great suggestions.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: player death

Post by Shadowbane »

ditchhook wrote:
Shadowbane wrote:
The reason we have coded skills to determine our combat success is because this is a game that's driven by conflict, and the average player cannot be trusted to play anything but a winner.
Dead characters are not winners. I don't understand how this is consistent with your earlier contention that:
Shadowbane wrote: If someone requires game mechanics to make their RP realistic or believable (treating death seriously, considering certain people likely threats, eating bad food, etc. etc.), then it's not the game that needs something, it's the player.
Not sure how you think I believe dead characters are winners. If you read my post instead of cherry picking it, then the rest of the message would have made your statement pretty pointless. I like having code to let me determine whether or not I win in a fight. It gives me and others a base to RP in a realistic manner when it comes to combat, depending on character nature.
Shadowbane wrote:The reason we have coded skills to determine our combat success is because this is a game that's driven by conflict, and the average player cannot be trusted to play anything but a winner. Have you ever hung around one of those roleplay forums with a big population? I have. I've been an admin for one. Reading most 'fights' in those threads was like watching a fight scene out of Dragon Ball Z. No one wanted to lose, no one wanted to take the hit, and it was twenty pages of "I hit you!" and "you missed but I got a hit!" or "I countered!" along with "I dodged your counter!" Someone has to lose in a conflict, that is what the coding and skills are there for. Whoever puts the work into the skills is typically the one that gets the prize. Thankfully, in SI, the one short on skills can still win by bringing his friends along for the ride.
If you're going to quote me, quote the whole piece.

Besides that, I can count on one hand the number of people I trust in a purely RP setting when it comes to winning and losing and conflict in general. Only one of them plays SI regularly. If someone needs more game mechanics outside skill and combat coding to be able to convince themselves to RP realistically, it sounds like a case of old-school PEBKAC.

I like and second the ideas Xiija's brought up. I'm in favor of temporary stat loss, needing deity favor to come back without suffering a penalty, looking 'deathly pale' if you're suffering from death sickness/penalty. Not sure I'm ok with a permanent stat loss, considering I've gained over 200 levels across multiple skills and don't need more than one hand to count my stat raises, but being unable to play as anything but a ghost for a certain amount of time or having lowered stat/health while suffering a death penalty seems fair. However, if there are temple shops implemented to allow you the means to purchase the stats you lost (and only the ones you lost) for a ridiculous amount of money, sure, I can go along with that. And if it only happens after you've died too many times in a certain period, even better.

When my character dies IC, she is affected. She is ill and weak and isn't doing a whole hell of a lot for a couple days afterwards. Dying isn't pleasant, nor is it met with 'whoops,' and her RP reflects that when it comes to her death and most others. I've seen some others do something similar, or at least show it seriously affected them. I like seeing that kind of creativity and wish there was more of that.
Forhekset
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 150
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 9:59 pm

Re: player death

Post by Forhekset »

Whatever is decided I'd like that skill penalty removed entirely.

Having died twice today for having weapons/armor that was from an older version of the game and bugged... the 1700 uses I gained from dying set me back 3-4 hours.

I don't have that kind of time to play, and waste.
Kaiya
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 66
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 5:48 pm
Location: Seattle, WA

Re: player death

Post by Kaiya »

Forhekset wrote:Whatever is decided I'd like that skill penalty removed entirely.

Having died twice today for having weapons/armor that was from an older version of the game and bugged... the 1700 uses I gained from dying set me back 3-4 hours.

I don't have that kind of time to play, and waste.
You use skill points when you die?! I died recently for the first time, but I didn't think to look at my uses and see if things decreased. Now I might freak out when I get home to check :/
Post Reply