Mind potion alert

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Mind potion alert

Post by Xiija »

so, for anyone thinking of getting a mind potion, it's 1200 or so for a ONE use
potion that lasts a minute. i don't think this will ever be used? I'd resort
to a tell if i had that much of an emergency.

I realize that this takes away from mages, but honestly, how many times have you asked a mage
to give you voices?.. if you can even find one?
I'd say , either make it 10 sips, or charge 100-200 for a single-sip bottle? i'd spend 100 to try and reach someone
if i needed them.

anyways, thoughts on this from the players?

X.
Last edited by Xiija on Sun Aug 02, 2015 4:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by ditchhook »

I would make it something that an advanced player character could make themselves and distribute on their own terms.
Bihi
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Snaek »

Location of items found in game shouldn't be discussed in the OOC section of the forums. If you want to debate their use that's fine, but refrain from revealing these things, especially WHEN THEY JUST COME OUT.

Also I'd like to remind you that when you use the TELL command, it clearly states it is for OOC use. This is not a substitute for IC communication. Abuse will result in the loss of the command.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Xiija »

mkay, edited the OP ,

- the tell command isn't needed , people would just use skype?
the main point was the potion is in game, but will most likely never be used?
it takes most people over an hour of hunting to afford that, and after trying it,
I barely had time to contact someone before the effect faded.

just curious if players would use one if they were cheaper, or lasted longer?

@ Bihi, i think there was some discussion about that at the last coffee with creators gathering?

ty
X.
Image
Garaven
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 8:13 am

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Garaven »

Personally, I don't see what the problem is. Sure, it can be frustrating to not be able to reply to someone who has contacted you. At least now there is an option to contact someone when a mage is not present or available. I am sure it is not intended for everyone to have conversations back and forth.

I like the fact that this game doesn't use CHANNELS for communication. I have played games like that and they are quite annoying and destroy immersion for me.

Make the potion cheap as you suggest and people will easily stockpile up on them and invalidate the unique abilities that the mages have for communication. As it is, that price is not much of a deterrent to carry several for emergencies for most players with some experience behind them. I am sure there are quite a few players with hundreds of thousands in the bank that this price will not be so much a deterrent.

You don't have to buy the potion, but I know Garaven most likely will keep a few on him. Perhaps give it a little time in game before assuming that no one will buy them and discouraging others from using them. I'd be more worried that everyone would have multiple potions, running around contacting each other like a makeshift channel.

I could care less if Garaven has a way to contact others. As it is, I think the Divine Path already takes a bit much away from the mages. But I will use what is at my disposal as long as it is available.
Kaiya
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 66
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 5:48 pm
Location: Seattle, WA

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Kaiya »

Garaven wrote: I'd be more worried that everyone would have multiple potions, running around contacting each other like a makeshift channel.
Why is that an issue, exactly? They're talking to each other IC. Through IC means. Do the creators of the game really hate telepathy THAT MUCH that they'd consider it an abuse if people used the potions as a means of chatting with friends in a different part of the game world?

I don't understand why that's a problem. How does it harm the game?
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Shadowbane »

I think if folks want to chat back and forth without having to find each other in the game world, it SHOULD come at a cost. I know when I played regularly, Kaiah and Wren only spoke if they were in the same room together. None of that voices stuff, or tells or channels. It's not hard to get a little over a thousand doubloons for a potion. You'll either pay in levels, or doubloons, or time looking for a mage to get you your telepathy.

For a while, the argument used was 'what if I need to find someone?' Leave a message on the forums, arrange places and times before hand to meet. It's not difficult. If your character doesn't know where to find another character because they weren't told or didn't bother to ask, and you don't want to go checking common spots, that's on the player(s). My character knows where to find her friends, and even where to find people she doesn't like.

Skype is also usable, if you absolutely positively need to get ahold of someone immediately and don't want to go looking. To be honest, I think the only reason I'd ever have to buy one of those is so my toon can tell someone else to get the hell out of her head and talk to her face to face like a normal person.

If it's a reply to an emergency situation, I'm not really sure how telepathy is going to help. The character in question should probably just tell them to go someplace specific because it's super important. If the reply is 'why' and not an immediate walk/run/teleport to the spot, then really, it must not be an emergency to them.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by ditchhook »

Kaiya wrote:
I don't understand why that's a problem. How does it harm the game?
I think there's no right or wrong answer to how available this potion should be in the game. We all have our own opinions-- and that's fine. However, when the staff set price/availability of this potion (and so many other things) players can get frustrated that their opinion is being rejected, and arbitrary rules are being imposed on them. When they feel that way, they start "cheating" (using the OOC tell option for IC communication).

It is just impossible for staff to make the right decision on the proper prices for the thousands of items just in this tiny game-- even if they had the time and energy to do so. Thousands and thousands of very smart and dedicated people tried to do something very similar in a much bigger "game." They called theirs "The Soviet Union."

We all know how that turned out.

When other players (not staff) are making these decisions, the resulting situation feels more holistic, and subject to change as a result of player interaction: "I won't buy it if it's too expensive, and the player/character selling it will lower the price if they do want to sell it." or "I'll buy that from someone else." or "I'm going to create a character to make that stuff." Not: "I have to complain to staff (or get on the boards and build a player constituency) to get this fixed."

There are some basic rules staff can follow to avoid this kind of situation.

1. Exploiting "group intelligence". Players will do what they think best to maximize their enjoyment of the game-- including leaving the game. If staff approach the management of the game with an attitude of "we know what's best for players despite themselves" they will inevitably fail. So, instead of perpetually trying to find the "right" price for a potion or any of a thousand other items in the game, it would behoove them to instead code up ways to ease inter-player and inter-character access so PLAYERS can decide on what prices are the "right" prices for them, based on their immediate assessment of maximizing their enjoyment of the game. For example: creating an auction house where a character can leave their surplus items to be sold to the highest bidder. Staff can use this auction house as well: put three of these telepathy potions in it each month, and let players decide on the price they want to pay. This is a much more holistic, much more player-focused means of operating our little economy: as opposed to a surprise closing of shops to buying player-created objects in game, like has been done recently. Players-- working together in this way-- will create more bone if other players want to advance their scrimshaw skills, for example. Players work together to maximize their enjoyment of the game. What we have now is staff trying to monitor our interest in Scrimshaw skill, then-- after delay and discussion-- making a game modification to cater to it (Like making fire-trolls a skinnable creature to provide more bone) only to find we fickle players have already moved on to other interests.

2. Stability: so folks can have a long term plan on how to advance their character. Currently staff seem to be jumping from fire to fire: stopping shops from buying or selling, etc. Using extreme remedies that only propagate repercussions into the community's interaction with the code that demand yet another extreme remedy. They are going to make lots of mistakes with this method, and players are going to get frustrated with them. Instead provide players with a stable, intuitively sensible base code AND STICK TO IT. Right now, killing a 100lbs+ deer provides one pound of meat, two pounds of bone, and two pounds of hide. That just doesn't make intuitive sense! Gophers dropping gems?! I can guess what happened: staff got caught up in an infinite loop of "making adjustments" that sent them off following more and more extreme tangents, none of which will ever break them out of that same infinite loop. Should it take thirty seconds for a hunter to find that deer? I would much rather have a code that simulates a real hunting experience: spend an hour tracking and hunting an "intelligent" deer (one that at least runs away and hides when attacked) and once I take down and skin that deer, get a reward commensurate with that: 15 pounds of bone, 60 pounds of meat, 15 pounds of hide. Start with some basic, realistic simulations for hunting, mining, foraging, digging, fishing, etc, and don't ever change them. Sure staff will not get that balance "perfect" but if foraging is too easy, the prices paid by other players for foraged goods will just go down until it finds a new balance on its own.
Bihi
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by Blink »

You might put in some kind of quest that lets you get a potion or an ingredient that gets you a potion. Substitute some kind of in game effort for cost. This wouldn't change much for experienced players, as they can easily afford the current potion. But it'd let those who can't afford the potion to get one another way.

There's been some inflation in store prices, which is likely part of the reason for the cost. None of us have really adjusted to it yet. It's quite possible treasure is going to go up. It already has for skinners, as we make more an hour now if we are good at skinning and hunting both.
User avatar
the_VOICE_of_Pearl
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 69
Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2014 4:03 pm

Re: Mind potion alert

Post by the_VOICE_of_Pearl »

One hour's worth of coin for sixty seconds of telepathy?
RISE UP AGAINST THE TYRANTS!

just kidding .

One has to wonder if this is the game's answer to a messaging system though?
If so, it seems to exclude low level players. It might be nice if one could use the in game EMAIL BOX
system, and when a message is sent the receiving player would get a notification of some kind.
A room message like, " A carrier pigeon drops off a note to Yiri." One would then know to check their email box?

Setting the price so high makes sense, as there are several players who might abuse the potion to send taunts
to others ( though this might lead to a little RP - that seems a little scant lately) . Since this game is in Alpha/Beta
still, the introduction of a new item/system needs to be given a chance to be tested, time will tell if it is valid?

The only other consideration would most likely be the inability to find anyone to RP with, and even though the world is
small, it still seems difficult to locate people at times. If the GM's scripted an NPC to appear at a certain place two or three
times a day, with an item players actively sought, there might be cause for people to meet in a central location for a bit?

....your 2 cents worth of feedback has been given!
The VOICE of Pearl
an independent underground publication
Post Reply