Accurate Descriptions

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Xiija »

I'm thinking the AR boost must differ for each race, as my steel kris boosts my AR 91, not 63.

Go ahead and add redwood to the bow for +174 (at least for me!)
yeowch! those are good numbers.

my numbers are listing the difference between base AR ( unarmed at my current lvl) and the AR when the weapon is equipped.
-not the final AR with the weapon equipped? this is difficult, because the difference is based on each persons unarmed lvl. or their current CC / ranged level. ( class AR/DR progression)
it would be easier if there was some way to tell what AR boost each weapon provides...like a weapon with NO AR boost to use as a control.

also, if your AR boost from a bow is +174 ( meaning you have 174 PLUS your current ranged AR, I AM GOING TO LEARN ARCHERY! lol
I'm not sure what the AR/DR progression is for scouts... i don't think race is tied into it yet tho? mebbe we could also get a list of AR/DR progressions for each class?
** i think mages are 3/3 , priests are 3/4 , thieves 4/6, assassins&warriors 6/5?, and scouts are 6/6? so if Kaiya has lvl 20 ranged, she would have a base AR/DR of 120/120 ranged?
** There is a separate AR/DR progression for Ranged and Close Combat? dunno if this is still true?

@Aruskin i love the way you RP situations in game, keep it up!
Image
ditchhook
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:26 am

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by ditchhook »

Voegelin wrote:There are a lot of oddities in any fantasy world. My suggestion when one encounters an oddity is to come up with some fun or interesting explanation for it that doesn't break with the overall fantasy world. --Aruskin
I certainly do that. That being said, my creative solution to explain something like this might be completely different than yours. If that aspect of the game/code becomes central to a story we wish to tell, the discrepancies become big issues.

A MUD-- especially an RPI MUD-- is about story-telling. We are here to cooperate in telling an epic story of Shattered Isles. We can't cooperate to tell those stories if we are not in agreement on fundamental facts. Bihi "knows" electrum is a silly metal to make a blade from, and ebony a bow from. So I tell the story of Geel's foolishness of paying so much for such a blade through Bihi. But if we can't agree-- or don't have the knowledge to even decide-- that electrum is a silly metal to make a bladed weapon from, then we can't tell those stories either way about Geel's decision. Every story we can't tell impoverishes the game.

I see this issue of ebony bows and electrum blades compelling us players to be spectators instead of contributors because we are denied a common understanding of things like materials from which we can build stories. The easiest way for staff to provide that common understanding is to depend on references we all have access to whenever possible: references like dictionaries and Wikipedia, and when they wish to deviate from those presumed references, letting us know they are doing so.

There's an easy solution to the example issues: Ebony and Electrum indeed are poor materials for their respective items, however, they both have some magical attributes. But that needs to be made clear, and it needs to be consistent. What I mean by that is when Bihi finds a stand of ebony in the forest, or vein of electrum in the mine, he can rely on that ebony or electrum to have magical properties (and the accompanying story-telling potential) as well.
Bihi
Kaiya
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 66
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 5:48 pm
Location: Seattle, WA

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Kaiya »

Xiija wrote: my numbers are listing the difference between base AR ( unarmed at my current lvl) and the AR when the weapon is equipped.
-not the final AR with the weapon equipped?
That is how I reached the numbers I posted as well. My AR unarmed is 9. With the steel kris, it's 100. Therefore, +91. With the redwood bow my AR rises to 184.

Though, the rest of your post was like reading gibberish to me. I removed all my weapons, and typed stat. My AR was 9. When I wielded the bow, it was 184. I don't know how the RC/CC levels affect these stats or how to even tell.
Voegelin
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 68
Joined: Tue May 27, 2014 7:35 pm

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Voegelin »

Regarding scouts, bows, and AR/DR progression:

AR progression for Aruskin (a scout) using a bow is 6 per level. DR progression is also 6 per level.

To figure out the AR boost from different bows, I used a simple wooden bow as my baseline. It currently yields an AR of 273. My cedar recurve bow yields an AR of 285, giving an AR boost of +12. Here are my figures for AR boost.

Simple wooden bow: +0
Cedar recurve bow: +12
Yew longbow: +15
Osage recurve bow: +15
Ebony flatbow: +20

I no longer have a bear-etched oak bow, but old figures suggest its AR boost is +12.

I have no way of telling IC if the differences in performance are tied to the materials used or the design, or both. Aruskin cannot make a bow, and there is no path known of that would allow him to learn to make a bow. His knowledge of bows is simply that of an experienced user, not that of a crafter of bows. Subtleties in the interplay between design and materials are beyond him, and I intend to stick to that limitation in my RP.

--Aruskin
User avatar
Xiija
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2014 6:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Xiija »

@kaiya
I don't know how the RC/CC levels affect these stats or how to even tell.
so, if your AR/DR progression for a scout is 6/6 that means you get 6 more AR and 6 more DR for every level you have
in a skill. if you have lvl 20 in ranged , and lvl 10 in CC .. you would have 6 x 20 = 120 AR/DR as a base ranged stat, and your
CC would be 6 x 10 = 60AR/60DR base CC.

so, take your 184 and subtract your base ranged AR/DR and that gives you the AR boost of your weapon. ( in this case, with lvl 20 ranged,
= 120 base, it would be a +64 boost?)

hope this helps :)

X.

EDIT : after going in game and checking, i have no idea how it all works :P
unarmed, with no shield armor or spells, my AR/DR was 18/126 for lvl 6 unarmed, and it should have been 18/24?

oh well :P
Image
Voegelin
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 68
Joined: Tue May 27, 2014 7:35 pm

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Voegelin »

Xiija, I think the AR/DR progression differs depending on the character's class and the combat skill related to whatever weapon is readied. I'm pretty sure Aruskin is not gaining 6 AR/DR for each level gained in CC.

--Aruskin
User avatar
Illegal Activity
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Dec 11, 2013 11:17 pm

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Illegal Activity »

Don't forget some articles of clothing can add Attack/Defense rating!
Rochiriel Azahar
Conclave Representative
Posts: 59
Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2014 8:53 am

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Rochiriel Azahar »

I found the best way to find out what material is better than another is through RP. Most of the knowledge my character has comes from watching past peddles and observing what draws a higher price. In past experiences I have found that the electrum weapons almost always go for crazy amounts of money followed by blacksteel and orichalcum.

Other than that I ask around. When there are custom armor orders Vogrok is always willing to answer questions that you ask about the metals. My character wanted to know why her orichalcum armor was so shiny and if it was as sturdy as it was nice looking. My thought is if you don't ask you won't get any answers.

I did notice that there is a difference in the type of weapon as well. Two weapons made from the same metal can have drastically different AR/DR bonuses if they are a different size or damage type. This is all stuff that can be figured out IC'ly through RP and paying attention to prices in shops and what other players are using.

There are a lot of things in the game that don't follow RL rules. Why can I find salt in a certain spot one minute and poof its not there a few minutes later? Look at healing potions that magically take you from the brink of death to perfect health in a mater of a minute. This game is based on fantasy and mystical things. Do you know any real life ogres? vampires?

You can't let OOC knowledge affect your characters choices and feelings on things. Things that your character knows should be learned in game when possible in my opinion.
Rochiriel Azahar
Conskill
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 14
Joined: Fri Sep 04, 2015 4:09 pm

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Conskill »

I disagree on a pretty basic level. I am certain I am supposed to let my OOC knowledge of Newtonian physics, Human anatomy, basic social norms, the English language, the general attributes of the Sun, and many many other things affect my IC choices. The question shouldn't at all be whether or not we bring assumptions about the universe into a fictional setting -- which is not only unavoidable but downright convenient to avoid a lot of repetitious writing about whether stones drop up or down -- but what we should do to avoid miscommunications where the fictional setting takes a step apart.

On an entirely unrelated note: hi folks.
Rochiriel Azahar
Conclave Representative
Posts: 59
Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2014 8:53 am

Re: Accurate Descriptions

Post by Rochiriel Azahar »

What I meant is when it comes to armor, weapons,potions. etc. Your OOC knowledge shouldn't trump your IC observations and information. Ex. A wet noodle bow goes for 600,000 doubloons and everyone is bidding on it. I wouldn't assume IC'ly that everybody lost their minds for wanting the wet noodle bow. I would ask IC'ly why this wet noodle bow was so great. My OOC knowledge tells me to eat if for dinner. I didn't mean throw all your knowledge about the basics of life out the window. I meant that if you are trying to learn about which materials are better IG your first place to look for answers should be IG.
Rochiriel Azahar
Locked