Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Maceman
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2016 2:01 am

Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Maceman »

As with all RPGs involving a skilling system, the player is required to do x action x amount of times until they level up.
Because of this system skill levels become highly unbalanced which causes an unrealistic level gap between players and constant, senseless farming.


My suggestion?
A more logical and roleplay-required advancement system.
One that promotes roleplay and removes unneeded and extensive "Grinding" that ruins roleplay.
Remove classes: Your actions, skills and roleplay define your character's "Class"


"If you wish to be good at a skill then you need to be educated by another via roleplay and training."


This gives true meaning to the academy and creates a system where players are taking apprentices and forming bonds, creating groups, businesses and clans.
Retiring your character? "Nonexistent" Permadeath due to story arc? Your apprentice can continue your legacy!
Realistic businesses and clans can be created this way, guild masters, a master in that specific skill can train others!


"But what about the problem where someone with enough time can master everything!?"
Simple, the amount of ranks you can have is limited to your intelligence points.
A normal human should have at least 10 intelligence points.
Anyone has the option to forget ranks via command.


"The Academy grants you one skill of your choice to be Educated in when you arrive."


Untrained: Has no training in this skill and minimal knowledge.
(Everyone starts here)

Trained: Has minimal training in this skill, but no formal education.
(Has become an apprentice of another Character and was trained)

Educated: Has been formally and officially trained in this skill.
(Has been formally and further trained by another Character)

Proficient: Has extensive training and education in this skill.
(Gained through unlocking traits by training others)

Mastered: Has officially mastered this skill and can educate others.
(Has unlocked all trainable traits in the skill)

Preeminent Skills: Rare traits within skills that are not gained alongside training.
(Can be gained through a great accomplishment or story related event/godly boon)

Mastered Rank and Preeminent Skills are primarily gained through taking apprentices and ranking them up.


Skills: Blacksmithing(Weapons, Armor and Smithing), Carpentry, Alchemy, Botany, Fighting, Marksmanship, Magic, Finesse(Rogue skills), Athletics(Anything movement), Prayer(Divine Magic).ect
Ranks: Level of the skill
Traits: Learnable actions within a rank


Things like Mining, Woodcutting, Farming and Foraging are too simple and common knowledge to be -Skills- but each skill has traits to improve these "Actions"




*How does this all work?

When you start out the Academy grants you Educated through a single skill of your choice.
To become Proficient you have to unlock a number of "traits" by training others. (Unlock does not mean you gain access to those traits, it means you will gain them upon ranking up)
To unlock traits you must apprentice someone until they rank up. (Each time they rank up you may choose one trait to unlock)
Each rank requires a certain amount of traits to be learned. (Usually based on %)
To train someone they must be in your party and they must be your apprentice, this allows you to give them access to certain traits of your choosing that you know.

*How do i learn a new Skill from scratch?

First, find someone that is at least Educated in the skill you're wanting to learn(Academy is a great place for this, looking on the forums for teachers is good too!)
Second, become their apprentice, while in their party and while also being their apprentice you have access to any trait they choose to give you.
Third, after using a number of traits for the first time you will rank up and gain each of those traits that you used permanently without needing to be in your master's party.

A Mastered Master can train anyone up to Proficient, but to become Mastered you must apprentice and train others.





What are everyone's thoughts on this system? Replacing the age old numbered skill and leveling system with something more stable(Easily balanced) and roleplay oriented?

This system is also one step forward to freeing people from "RPG Leveling" and into something more realistic and advanced that cant be cheesed out of!
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Vexing »

I like it to some degree, however, it should still be possible to figure things out on your own, it will just take forever (as the current system shows).
However, unless stats are static over the course of a characters lifetime (outside factors excluded) basing the number of skills you can learn on them seems counter intuitive.
Is only the natural value considered, or is the full end value used?
And what does 'how smart a person is' have to do with manual labor type skills?
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Rochiriel Azahar
Conclave Representative
Posts: 59
Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2014 8:53 am

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Rochiriel Azahar »

So basically you want to play a different game? Some characters are loner types and like to explore things on their own. They don't want to have to RP with a bunch of different people to be able to craft something. And what about creativity? Does that not play a role in crafting? It seems to me that if I practice at something enough I will eventually get better/more creative with my trade. I do like the idea of being able to gain levels through an educator if you want but I don't think that should be the only way. RP should be something you can do not something that is forced upon you.

Rochiriel's Player
Rochiriel Azahar
Shattered Mind
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 125
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2014 9:18 pm

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Shattered Mind »

I sat down to write a response to your suggestions only to realize it was going to be pages long.

Instead I am simply going give you my personal summed up response.

You are basically suggesting a wipe of the current game and creating a new one. The staff, and players, have put a lot of work (years) into Shattered Isles and are not likely going to want to throw all that away.

You have obviously put some thought into your suggestions however, I do not believe they fit within the framework that Shattered Isles is designed under and may not even be possible with the coding system used.

It is not easy for someone who has not been exposed to Shattered Isles, or the coding system it uses, for very long to understand even basic restrictions (what can and cannot be done).

My suggestion for you is to attend the next "Coffee with the Creators" event, when staff schedules it. You can also read through the logs of previous coffee with the creator events that are posted on the boards.

I like your enthusiasm and desire to encourage RP. Keep it up! and by all means, continue to submit suggestions. :)
User avatar
Maceman
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2016 2:01 am

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Maceman »

Vexing wrote:I like it to some degree, however, it should still be possible to figure things out on your own, it will just take forever (as the current system shows).
I put some thought into how to make this possible without some sort of grinding, the idea that first came to mind was the ability to buy "Books" to self train or to hire an NPC and buy Ranks.
Vexing wrote:However, unless stats are static over the course of a characters lifetime (outside factors excluded) basing the number of skills you can learn on them seems counter intuitive.
Im not quite sure what you mean by this, but the idea was to prevent a single person from being able to master in ALL skills.
Basic labor stuff thats pretty much something anyone can do without training (Mining, Farming, Foraging.ect) are integrated into the Skills as Traits

Of course skills needed to be integrated into each other and narrowed down for this system:
Blacksmithing Skill would cover
Mining, Forging bars, Smelting, Crafting Weapons, Crafting Armor.
Basically anything that has anything to do with blacksmithing.

However you would need to learn each "Action" as a trait, this actually allows one to specialize in a certain field if they dont want to master in the Skill in order to have access to an "Action" such as smelting bars or weapon crafting, they can choose those specific ones as traits for the first "Talented" Rank, so unless you're wanting to cover the entire Blacksmithing "Skill tree(?)" I think it could be called, then you would only need "Talented" first rank.

Vexing wrote:Is only the natural value considered, or is the full end value used?
Full value, im hoping that characters can become smarter over time to better benefit from this system.
Vexing wrote:And what does 'how smart a person is' have to do with manual labor type skills?
See quote Two on labor. Anyone could mine without training, but Blacksmithing gives access to "Traits" to Mine "Better/Smarter" basically for more resources or the like.



-----


Shattered Mind wrote:I sat down to write a response to your suggestions only to realize it was going to be pages long.

You are basically suggesting a wipe of the current game and creating a new one. The staff, and players, have put a lot of work (years) into Shattered Isles and are not likely going to want to throw all that away.

I like your enthusiasm and desire to encourage RP. Keep it up! and by all means, continue to submit suggestions. :)
Nyyyyuuuu! Save those pages! Im a writer, anything you have to say is extremely useful!

Also Yes! That was my greatest fear when writing this, i knew that it was HIGHLY unlikely to have any effect on the game however it came to mind and i started writing anyway, so i thought:
"Well, it's something! Never hurts to share ideas that may help the game grow! So there's always that chance!"

Thank You! I cant help but write down great ideas when they come to mind, i love designing mechanics and balancing things, there's more to come but this is all i have so far!
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Vexing »

I don't see why people object to someone eventually learning everything.
Isn't that the ideal of any permanent scholar?
Stopping it from happening in the first place is counter intuitive.
The issue is learning so much about so many things all at once.

Jacks-of-all-trades are notorious dabblers, never truly excelling in any one thing, but more than capable of most anything.
Specialists are just the opposite, focusing in on one thing/group to the exclusion of all else.
Most people fall somewhere in the middle.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
Kody_Oakborne
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 209
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Kody_Oakborne »

Fear not, It would literally take you a real-time lifetime to come even close to mastering every skill in this game. By my calculations, without factoring the time to gather materials, it will still take approximately 1.3 years of actual play time to max out ONE crafting skill. With that in mind, the creators of the game suggest that you not take a jack of all trades approach unless that's really what you want to commit to. Running each skill up to 11 is one thing, but trying to maximize multiple types of skills to the 50-100 range is unrealistic. Once you've had a taste of everything, with our current system, it is suggested that you pick a path to go down and follow it. Some do combat skills, others crafting. There are players in this game with very low combat skill that have been here for years, just because hunting isn't their "thing."

There are ways to roleplay things in this game without the actual mechanical "skill" to back it up, and as long as it's not playing God or "i win," most people are willing to roll with it. GM intervention will sometimes dictate if they will let it pass or not. I understand this game encourages copious amounts of grinding from a mechanical standpoint, but much of what you can do in this game doesn't require your "skills" to be high level, as long as you've established your roleplay and have the right audience (IE GMs) in attendance for whatever you're trying to make happen.

Just my little... blurb.
Last edited by Kody_Oakborne on Mon Feb 22, 2016 1:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Swamp Ape »

Shattered Mind wrote:I sat down to write a response to your suggestions only to realize it was going to be pages long.

Instead I am simply going give you my personal summed up response.

You are basically suggesting a wipe of the current game and creating a new one. The staff, and players, have put a lot of work (years) into Shattered Isles and are not likely going to want to throw all that away.

You have obviously put some thought into your suggestions however, I do not believe they fit within the framework that Shattered Isles is designed under and may not even be possible with the coding system used.

It is not easy for someone who has not been exposed to Shattered Isles, or the coding system it uses, for very long to understand even basic restrictions (what can and cannot be done).

My suggestion for you is to attend the next "Coffee with the Creators" event, when staff schedules it. You can also read through the logs of previous coffee with the creator events that are posted on the boards.

I like your enthusiasm and desire to encourage RP. Keep it up! and by all means, continue to submit suggestions. :)
+1 to this. I agree with what Shattered Mind is saying here and I think it is refreshing to see a new player offering suggestions and sharing their ideas. Sometimes it takes fresh set of eyes and an unbiased new mind to help shape our world.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Blink »

some people hate the grind, some people love it. I understand both views, since I go through periods of both. The problem is that some of us have put in a lot into the game already, so any kind of wipe would be pretty unpopular, or any method of getting experience just as fast as the grind. Hint, don't play a mage if you hate the grind.

I do like the educating idea. I've heard similar ideas before and I liked those as well. I'd suggest it give like ten percent or so of what you typically get in an hour, based on what type of skill it is. (You can generally get 400 attack spell uses in an hour, much less for say crafting, so you'd get 40 per hour educating an attack spell and less for crafting) I think this would encourage people to be in game rping with each other, because they'd be able to entertain each other and still partially take part in the grind. Yet the actual grinders would still maintain their advantage.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Skill system overhaul suggestion - Maceman

Post by Bocon L »

I keep coming back to this game because it's simplistic, has an auto-mapper, there's no outside OOC channels spamming my screen, and I can choose when and where I want to RP. As someone who takes 6 college classes per semester, I can still train my skills while I do my homework. Under your system, I am screwed.

The major flaw with a class-less system, is that someone will eventually figure out the most powerful skill combinations or the most profitable, and every other power gamer will copy that, leaving nothing but clones. I've seen it far too many times in every other class-less game I played. At least with a class system, you pick what you think would be fun and you can easily build RP out of that, taking nerfs and buffs as they happen. It's far easier to balance classes, than it is to balance every single combination of skills, in your system.

However, you can rest assured that no one in this games life span will ever master every skill. It's not possible and I think if you spent a bit more time in game and learning the system, you'd also come to that realization.

When the game first came out, crafting was but an afterthought and there was almost nothing being done with it. Regardless, people still took a lot of interest in crafting and the creators saw this and
now we now have a somewhat decent system, with an update/overhaul due this month (supposedly). And while I'd love to see crafting be a much larger part of the game, and have each craft actually be meaningful and offer some soft of mechanical advantage, I don't think that's ever going to happen.

TL;DR: Your system takes away the simplicity of the game and makes it far harder to balance.
Post Reply