Without poisons, thieves and assassins are as crippled as scouts? Oh.Shadowbane wrote:A good chunk of their combat effectiveness comes from not only making these poisons, but successfully applying them.Kody_Oakborne wrote:Scouts? Fletching? Initially taking 5pounds of wood per quiver, resulting in thousands upon thousands of trees, entire forests felled all by one scout, to get to level 10!...and insult to injury, the skill only adds flavor, no actual benefit.Shadowbane wrote:No one else has class skills that rely on crafting yet.
So as a scout... I have cover shot (which is still broken/unchanged by the update), and ranged combat... and that's it. womp womp.
Without poisons, thieves and assassins have as much variation in their combat skills as scouts do.
Pummel question
- Kody_Oakborne
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 209
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am
Re: Pummel question
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
Kody
- Kody_Oakborne
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 209
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am
Re: Pummel question
Actually, someone else said that...Bocon L wrote:Sure you did. You said "Oh you just backstabbed me for 80 damage? Watch me berserker rage and 3 shot your with my 2 hander!" I don't know how else you could take that.Vexing wrote:I never quantified how to be on top of the world, so don't shoot it down based off of your own bad example.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
Kody
Re: Pummel question
Oops, I take that back then, lol.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Pummel question
Without poison, they have (combat only, since we're not counting defenses or mobility) CC, backstab, and shadowstrike. They get a 6/5 progression on CC, and if I remember correctly, scouts have a 6/6 or something close to that with their bow. Can't recall what the ranged combat progression is for assassins, but it's no 6/5. Backstab and shadowstrike can't be focus trained, kinda like cover shot and pummel (and blindside), and they're still incomplete. Shadowstrike doesn't get reliable chains past 1 until well after level 20.Kody_Oakborne wrote:Without poisons, thieves and assassins are as crippled as scouts? Oh.
So really, assassins have CC and scouts have ranged.
They also hit like a noodle until the combat updates are in, and I recall ranged damage doing much better, but don't quote me cause I didn't level a scout very far. Visyn could answer that one better. Single digit is common, double digit is crazy special, and people can block or dodge attacks coming out of hiding (unless it was changed recently, cause Alexis wasn't half bad at blocking me coming out of hiding when we last tested this).
Thieves aren't so much a combat class, as assassins cover most of that on their side of rogue. Thieves have an entirely different skill set, but it doesn't mean they can't fight. It just means that's not typically their biggest focus. They have other talents that make them far more useful when it comes to things outside a fight.
So yeah. Poisons are a heck of a game changer. It actually made assassins kinda useful.

Hierophant of Itzal
-
Shattered Mind
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 125
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2014 9:18 pm
Re: Pummel question
I agree with Kaiah's last post. She has a good grasp on the situation.
I am not currently aware of any poisons that can knock anyone out for 60 seconds, or 10 seconds, or that prevent running away/fleeing. Which class(es) are considered OP tends to change as the game gets updates so I don't see any point in debating assassins being OP for poisons that, to the best of my knowledge, do not even exist. However, I will be sure to enjoy the time assassins are OP, if/when that ever happens.
I am not currently aware of any poisons that can knock anyone out for 60 seconds, or 10 seconds, or that prevent running away/fleeing. Which class(es) are considered OP tends to change as the game gets updates so I don't see any point in debating assassins being OP for poisons that, to the best of my knowledge, do not even exist. However, I will be sure to enjoy the time assassins are OP, if/when that ever happens.
Re: Pummel question
Let me clarify on the pummel thing.
1) You cannot go into a hunting/mining area and simply run around pummeling mobs.
2) You can run down the road or through the city (will give you a criminal record) pummeling NPC's/Mobs along the way.
The difference is the frequency you come across things to pummel. Most players tend to go back to the academy to train their harder to level skills. Find something easier to kill to practice pummel on. Go smash an orc in the face or even those evil white rabbits in Tallwood!
Happy smashing and dashing yall!
Saphira
1) You cannot go into a hunting/mining area and simply run around pummeling mobs.
2) You can run down the road or through the city (will give you a criminal record) pummeling NPC's/Mobs along the way.
The difference is the frequency you come across things to pummel. Most players tend to go back to the academy to train their harder to level skills. Find something easier to kill to practice pummel on. Go smash an orc in the face or even those evil white rabbits in Tallwood!
Happy smashing and dashing yall!
Saphira
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Pummel question
Both look like cases of resetting the combat timer, no matter how fast or slow you go or where you do it. You're still leaving combat to find a new target, which is still faster than simply killing the target you first hit.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Pummel question
I have to question the legitimacy of any rule whose sole purpose is to slow down skill gain.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Pummel question
I have to question the legitimacy of anyone whose sole purpose is to aggravate staff and other players!Vexing wrote:I have to question the legitimacy of any rule whose sole purpose is to slow down skill gain.
Besides allowing you to run down the road and pummel people is very nice concession that we are willing to make given how hard pummeling is to level. But....we can take that away if you'd like...After all we are here but to please individuals that play the game for a week or two and determine what is and isn't legitimate.
Saphira
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Pummel question
My only beef is that the CoC seems to be stuck to with about as much dedication as the lore we were provided with. Before, you had to do it the hard way by finishing the fight. Now it's ok to spam it if the frequency is low enough? Are we gonna start going lax on other sections of the CoC or stop enforcing them, like parts of the game lore?
While I don't agree with a lot of Vexing's points, he does bring up one here I can sympathize with. When I was first ripped up over how I trained BS and SS (and then ripped up again when I adjusted the timing and targets), I had to wonder why staff gave my class a set of skills, called them the "bread and butter" of that class, and then dared to tell me I couldn't train it like every other skill I had. Why give someone a skill they can't actively focus train? Why not just give me a command that pulls directly from my CC and hiding skill levels?
It's a little late in the game to be changing the CoC we all agreed on, especially if SI is supposed to go officially live this year. I get that people want the game to grow and gain players, but (and I'm speaking from experience here) slacking on your own rules isn't going to get numbers or maintain what quality there is. It will cause things to flounder. Find rules that people are willing to enforce, because backtracking like this when everything goes live isn't going to do the game any favors.
While I don't agree with a lot of Vexing's points, he does bring up one here I can sympathize with. When I was first ripped up over how I trained BS and SS (and then ripped up again when I adjusted the timing and targets), I had to wonder why staff gave my class a set of skills, called them the "bread and butter" of that class, and then dared to tell me I couldn't train it like every other skill I had. Why give someone a skill they can't actively focus train? Why not just give me a command that pulls directly from my CC and hiding skill levels?
It's a little late in the game to be changing the CoC we all agreed on, especially if SI is supposed to go officially live this year. I get that people want the game to grow and gain players, but (and I'm speaking from experience here) slacking on your own rules isn't going to get numbers or maintain what quality there is. It will cause things to flounder. Find rules that people are willing to enforce, because backtracking like this when everything goes live isn't going to do the game any favors.

Hierophant of Itzal