Is it just me or does this seem like the messaging is rather boring?
Not entirely accurate in skill title either, since we end up full on butchering those things as we are able.
Any chance that the messaging can be improved, and perhaps add a check at more the one stage, considering?
Stage one, gut it and let it bleed out, remove offal.
Stage two, skin it out.
Stage three, butcher the meat and harvest organs of worth.
Stage four. gathering trophies such as teeth, claws and other bones, and maybe some sinew.
Now, the skill should only get tested at a stage where there is something for the player to acquire.
But it should also get tested at EVERY stage where there is something to acquire.
Arguably, there should be something someone would want from any corpse as well.
Also, can the stuff be spawned directly into the player inventory?
I know it seems trivial to complain about having to enter another command afterwards...
But it takes such a long time for the process to complete, it would be nice if all trades included their own cleanup.
Also, if the task gets interrupted, why is that it?
Presumably i could pick up where i left off, or start over.
Can the body not be consumed until the very end, when all the other items get made?
Butchering aka Skinning
Butchering aka Skinning
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
I like your idea of adding more detail into the process of skinning a kill. It's something we'll take a closer look at when the time comes. The reason the loot doesn't spawn directly into your inventory is to be consistent with other trade skills, and not everyone wants every resource they skin so we leave it up to the player to pick and choose upon completion. The body is consumed as soon as you start for a number of reasons. If you get distracted you can assume you ruined the pelt and everything else of value. It's one of those times where realism has to yield to mechanics.
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
Lines of code can be reordered though, so id doesn't -have- to yield...
Can you expound on the reasons why the body is immediately consumed?
Can you expound on the reasons why the body is immediately consumed?
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
Fishing spawns directly into your inventory... and I hope it stays that way.Snaek wrote:The reason the loot doesn't spawn directly into your inventory is to be consistent with other trade skills...
Just saying: it's not a consistency issue.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
Is this you Sweeney?
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
No comment.
Cooking takes it a step further and spawns the item into a container in your inventory.
Cooking takes it a step further and spawns the item into a container in your inventory.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
How about letting us skin with axes?
Or even swords... there is a bit of blurring on when the length of your blade goes from a longknife to a shortsword, and really, its more or less the same implement in scale.
Especially when you bring up the racial size discrepancies on top of relative blade length.
Its all about how well you know how to skin in the end.
I could even see a blunt weapon being more useful to skin some things, such as insects.
Crush the carapace to get at all the gooey ichor covered bits within.
...but then the pommel or flat of most every blade is a blunt weapon.
(Like Harry Potter in potions class, crushing the bean.)
Or even swords... there is a bit of blurring on when the length of your blade goes from a longknife to a shortsword, and really, its more or less the same implement in scale.
Especially when you bring up the racial size discrepancies on top of relative blade length.
Its all about how well you know how to skin in the end.
I could even see a blunt weapon being more useful to skin some things, such as insects.
Crush the carapace to get at all the gooey ichor covered bits within.
...but then the pommel or flat of most every blade is a blunt weapon.
(Like Harry Potter in potions class, crushing the bean.)
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
That's a good question. I wonder why we use knives?
Well, let's see... I know phone books aren't much of a thing anymore, but have you ever tried to link the two together? All you have to do is set each page together, one after the other, until both books have put their pages in order. Once this is done, try pulling them apart. You might discover that while it was easy to slip the pages together in the first place, it's quite another to try and pull them apart once the bond has been made.
Now I know this is a bit of a leap, but most things you can skin have connections as well. That's why you can't just pull skin off with your bare hands - everything is linked together by various sinew and what not. Keep in mind that the point of skinning is to separate the skin from the body without A) ruining the skin and B) ruining the stuff below it. So it then becomes a question, what is the right tool to accomplish these goals?
Axes traditionally have been used in some cases to skin, but they're not ideal for the process. First of all, it's extremely taxing to try to hold the blade in such a way to create the necessary force to cut the connections between skin, muscle and bone, because you need the sharp end of the axe and axes by design have heavy heads to better work with the handle of the axe in a swing. Because of this, they are likely to ruin the pelt and cut you in the process as you try to force the blade under the flesh, which is likely to tear due to lack of precision.
Clubs being used to break open shells or insects also have this issue of destruction of the chittin you are trying to collect. Keep in mind that most shells and exoskeletons are like bone - they work only when they are a singular entity and, once broken, they're no longer useful for what they are designed for - ie, being hard enough to protect the fragile innards. In the same way, you'd not be able to make anything useful out of them, so this fails Goal A. Goal B might also be ruined, as if you've ever seen a bug on a windshield, you know that the blunt force sends what meat is in the insect flying all over. No one likes to eat muddy bug meat. Yuck.
So what about swords? They're long and sharp and have many of the properties of a knife! Well, the problem in the case of a sword is again precision, but it's also a matter of physics. The further you are from the cutting edge, the weaker the lever action becomes, thereby increasing the force necessary to cut the sinew and other cords in the first place. Why are swords able to cleave flesh then, you ask? Well, it's because, like the axe, they are designed to work with a swing - momentum of the blade helps to apply more pressure on the sharpened edge. Trying to cut like a knife with a sword is extremely awkward and is likely to ruin the pelt, the meat, and might end up stabbing you in the knee. And as we all know, knee injuries mean you can't adventure anymore.
The knife, therefore, has the best design to skin. It is small enough and held close enough to the blade to be both precise and powerful, and since you are able to get closer to the victim, you can use your free hand to pull back flesh a layer at a time.
This lesson of pseudo-science has been brought to you by the Dead Horse Association. Dead Horse: Please stop beating us and just skin us already. With a knife.
Well, let's see... I know phone books aren't much of a thing anymore, but have you ever tried to link the two together? All you have to do is set each page together, one after the other, until both books have put their pages in order. Once this is done, try pulling them apart. You might discover that while it was easy to slip the pages together in the first place, it's quite another to try and pull them apart once the bond has been made.
Now I know this is a bit of a leap, but most things you can skin have connections as well. That's why you can't just pull skin off with your bare hands - everything is linked together by various sinew and what not. Keep in mind that the point of skinning is to separate the skin from the body without A) ruining the skin and B) ruining the stuff below it. So it then becomes a question, what is the right tool to accomplish these goals?
Axes traditionally have been used in some cases to skin, but they're not ideal for the process. First of all, it's extremely taxing to try to hold the blade in such a way to create the necessary force to cut the connections between skin, muscle and bone, because you need the sharp end of the axe and axes by design have heavy heads to better work with the handle of the axe in a swing. Because of this, they are likely to ruin the pelt and cut you in the process as you try to force the blade under the flesh, which is likely to tear due to lack of precision.
Clubs being used to break open shells or insects also have this issue of destruction of the chittin you are trying to collect. Keep in mind that most shells and exoskeletons are like bone - they work only when they are a singular entity and, once broken, they're no longer useful for what they are designed for - ie, being hard enough to protect the fragile innards. In the same way, you'd not be able to make anything useful out of them, so this fails Goal A. Goal B might also be ruined, as if you've ever seen a bug on a windshield, you know that the blunt force sends what meat is in the insect flying all over. No one likes to eat muddy bug meat. Yuck.
So what about swords? They're long and sharp and have many of the properties of a knife! Well, the problem in the case of a sword is again precision, but it's also a matter of physics. The further you are from the cutting edge, the weaker the lever action becomes, thereby increasing the force necessary to cut the sinew and other cords in the first place. Why are swords able to cleave flesh then, you ask? Well, it's because, like the axe, they are designed to work with a swing - momentum of the blade helps to apply more pressure on the sharpened edge. Trying to cut like a knife with a sword is extremely awkward and is likely to ruin the pelt, the meat, and might end up stabbing you in the knee. And as we all know, knee injuries mean you can't adventure anymore.
The knife, therefore, has the best design to skin. It is small enough and held close enough to the blade to be both precise and powerful, and since you are able to get closer to the victim, you can use your free hand to pull back flesh a layer at a time.
This lesson of pseudo-science has been brought to you by the Dead Horse Association. Dead Horse: Please stop beating us and just skin us already. With a knife.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
- Illegal Activity
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Wed Dec 11, 2013 11:17 pm
Re: Butchering aka Skinning
I would argue that the first knives and axes in civilizations distant past were more or less the same tool.
A shard of retouched flint.
Sure, the axe was a bit thicker, to handle the forces required to chop, but it is the same implement.
We are splitting hairs by assuming a task can be done with only one or the other.
I agree that using an exceptionally long cutting edge would make the task difficult.
But that does not automatically rule out all axes.
Battle axes sure, but a hatchet or tomahawk should be more than capable.
Some modern axes are sold with the skinning notch built in.
And you still haven't addressed how the size differences between the races.
What would be a longsword for a small race might only be a butter knife in the hands of a big race.
P.S. If you boil the body and then give it an ice bath, you can very much skin something with your bare hands, alive even. That was a form of torture in the dark ages. Ahhh... the alchemy wonders of cooking.
A shard of retouched flint.
Sure, the axe was a bit thicker, to handle the forces required to chop, but it is the same implement.
We are splitting hairs by assuming a task can be done with only one or the other.
I agree that using an exceptionally long cutting edge would make the task difficult.
But that does not automatically rule out all axes.
Battle axes sure, but a hatchet or tomahawk should be more than capable.
Some modern axes are sold with the skinning notch built in.
And you still haven't addressed how the size differences between the races.
What would be a longsword for a small race might only be a butter knife in the hands of a big race.
P.S. If you boil the body and then give it an ice bath, you can very much skin something with your bare hands, alive even. That was a form of torture in the dark ages. Ahhh... the alchemy wonders of cooking.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.