Disclaimer: THIS POST IS LONG
Questions:
1. When engaged in combat, does the monsters resistance/damage taken go off of the current spell level of the spell being cast?
2. Is the horrific failure rate on low level spells supposed to be that bad? If so, when does it get better?
3. Does failure rate go up, depending on the difficulty of what you are casting on?
Comparisons VS Melee/Non-Caster:
I feel that the game has an extremely strong bias toward melee classes right now. Looking at skill sets and mechanics, it's pretty hard not to notice. I also understand that Mages are not finished, not that it matters much. I'll explain.
There is 1 basic skill that rules your AR/DR as a melee class. Close Combat. This skill, when raised, will open up new and exciting abilities. However, you will still get uses, AR and DR, from close combat when normally killing whatever. You also get weapons and armor to boost your AR/DR progression. So the better your gear, the better your character. The boosts of these items are pretty significant. So no matter what new skill you get, you are not being majorly penalized for using it, since most of your rolls are vs your close combat and AR. You can miss a swing and there might even be a monster that dodges and parries once in a blue moon.
I'm not sure if there are level restrictions on gear right now, but someone can give a level 1 the best sword and armor they can buy and they can go and hunt stuff that they sure as hell shouldn't be. This might not be rampant now, but it sure will be in the future.
As a Mage, I get to start at level 1 every single time I get a new spell, and let me tell you, my spells branch off like a 500 year old family tree.....This means I get to fail my cast about 60% or more of the time, no matter if I have 300 other combined levels in magic spells. Not only do I fail my casts, I also get to deal with monster natural resistances and resistance saving throws.
This is basically the equivalent of you getting your AR reset every time you equip a new weapon or gain a new ability. It's pure misery.
This applies to all of my other "Utility" spells as well. While I obviously have not unlocked a ton of the later spells, all the utility spells I have right now are basically worthless, minus my FTG spell.
I highly doubt that the utility abilities that melee are unlocking right now, are even close to being as bad as what I'm seeing. There are absolutely 0 reasons for me to go back to my old spells, the ones that unlocked the newer spells. They are now just clutter taking up my spell list.
Armor raising my DR means almost nothing. No Mage is going to sit and level close combat to get horrible DR returns, instead of casting magic. Mage shields are giving .5DR per level and do not absorb any damage.
I have nothing to use to boost my main form of attack.
::EDIT:: Faran brings up a point that I totally forgot about(thanks). Thanks to no movement in combat, Mages are forced to sit there and just take hit, after hit, after hit, while melee get to dodge and parry/shield and have high DR to make the MOB miss. This, coupled with not being able to wear any decent armor, is so crippling, that I can't even begin the fathom how badly I'm going to get destroyed in later levels.
Feedback on other issues:
1. Spell trees are far too big and I don't know why they branch off into 10 different categories. If this stays the way it is, I'll be leveling at least quadruple the number of skills that non-casters have to level. Which means faaaaaaaar more time invested, for less pay out.....
2. Spells fail way too much compared to how often a melee of the same level misses. This is probably due to me casting my new level 5 DD, even though I have 30+ levels in other DD's.
3. Armor is absorbing far too much damage. The 200 DB bronze armor was absorbing roughly 50% of my damage or 14-15 points of it. Not sure if it goes off % or a static number. But going from 24 damage to 12 damage for just 200 seems really, really, off to me.
Possible solutions:
1. Condense all spells into only a few schools and fix the way new, higher level spells, act vs mobs and players.
2. Make spells evolve once they reach the new branch. There's no reason why I should have 30 lesser versions of my DD.
3. If you think the spell trees re-starting us at level 1 every time we get something new is OK, then give us a weapon to wield that lowers our spell failure rates.
4. Fix armor damage absorption and make materials that armor and weapons are made from, require a certain level of proficiency to use. Cause it's going to get abused.
5. At some point, most people are going to have an encounter with human PvP. Either from a player, or an NPC in a scenario. With no tact or anything else, I don't even see how a caster can even survive a non-caster class at this point in time. I honestly have no solutions to this, other than the person who is losing is going to have to room dodge in order to not die.
::In response to EDIT::6. If no form of combat movement is going to be coded for combat, Mages are going to need a ton of crowd control spells in order to mitigate similar damage that other non-casting classes have. If you think this will negatively effect PvP, then make the spells PvE only.
Thanks for reading. Any suggestions are welcomed.
Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Solutions
Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Solutions
Last edited by Ghrex on Fri Sep 27, 2013 1:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
I've noticed a good bit of this myself on my caster. Altogether I have roughly 30 levels in offensive spells and starting over at 1 every time is simultaneously taxing and wasteful, considering there is zero reason to use the previous damage spell after getting the new one. Why level up Water Blast or Water Globe when Ice Daggers do far more damage?
My fatigue spell seems to be the strangest so far. It is easily my highest level spell (because mages didn't benefit from a no-stamina bug while leveling up only ONE skill as opposed to how ever many "skills" they will be required to level in the current spell tree breakout) but it fails more than any other spell I have, including lower level or just-learned damage spells.
Right now, I'm not sure of the payoff for mages. In combat, we are terribly squishy and if we ever were to get into PvP, would be so easily overwhelmed that it would be laughable to try. Without the benefit of units of distance to move to get away from close combat, we are sitting ducks.
I also agree that it seems off balance for mages to level each new spell as a new skill whereas melee classes have only one or two skills they have to level. I also don't see the reason to keep previous versions of spells (i.e., all the variant damage spells). I like the idea of them evolving as they unlock rather than starting over again at level 1.
Our AR/DR is atrocious as compared to melee or even hybrid classes. Again, this refers back to the squishiness and lack of ranged movement in a single room.
As for the armor, I'm almost required to have the heaviest/strongest armor I can find so I can hunt with a proficiency still laughably behind melee classes, but tolerable.
As it stands, it seems like there is very little payoff for all of the extra work and hindrances mages have as compared to melee.
My fatigue spell seems to be the strangest so far. It is easily my highest level spell (because mages didn't benefit from a no-stamina bug while leveling up only ONE skill as opposed to how ever many "skills" they will be required to level in the current spell tree breakout) but it fails more than any other spell I have, including lower level or just-learned damage spells.
Right now, I'm not sure of the payoff for mages. In combat, we are terribly squishy and if we ever were to get into PvP, would be so easily overwhelmed that it would be laughable to try. Without the benefit of units of distance to move to get away from close combat, we are sitting ducks.
I also agree that it seems off balance for mages to level each new spell as a new skill whereas melee classes have only one or two skills they have to level. I also don't see the reason to keep previous versions of spells (i.e., all the variant damage spells). I like the idea of them evolving as they unlock rather than starting over again at level 1.
Our AR/DR is atrocious as compared to melee or even hybrid classes. Again, this refers back to the squishiness and lack of ranged movement in a single room.
As for the armor, I'm almost required to have the heaviest/strongest armor I can find so I can hunt with a proficiency still laughably behind melee classes, but tolerable.
As it stands, it seems like there is very little payoff for all of the extra work and hindrances mages have as compared to melee.
Transcribed this day by Faran Fairuz-Taqqi
One Who Speaks With Many Voices, Khalsat of Kaleith
Emissary of the Kalesian Isle
Faran of the Gale
Step into the water and you will not drown; Fall into the fire and you will not burn
One Who Speaks With Many Voices, Khalsat of Kaleith
Emissary of the Kalesian Isle
Faran of the Gale
Step into the water and you will not drown; Fall into the fire and you will not burn
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
I don't play a caster (I've honestly never been good at them) but maybe there could be a caster only weapon? Maybe a staff, or some kind of orb or focus. Equipping it lets them benefit from their AR/DR like those melee with their weapons.
I personally think it's silly they basically start from 1 again every time they get an evolved form of an old spell, if I'm understanding this all correctly. Unless they become omgwtfhalp overpowered at later levels, it doesn't seem very even from what I'm reading. I'll have to start a caster just to see what's up, I think.
I personally think it's silly they basically start from 1 again every time they get an evolved form of an old spell, if I'm understanding this all correctly. Unless they become omgwtfhalp overpowered at later levels, it doesn't seem very even from what I'm reading. I'll have to start a caster just to see what's up, I think.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Having been in PvP with a (water) mage, I can tell you that you are indeed NOT that squishy. With a shield spell up, I was hardly harming the mage, all the while, he was walloping me with 14-17 dmg per spell through my armor, which is the highest quality available at the merchant shop in the academy (that i could wear as a thief). Sure, I hit him almost every swing, but I definitely got handled! I was swinging the highest quality one-handed sword I could find in the academy. My 100 hps just couldnt hang with that sort of onslaught. (yes i let him kill me instead of running off, you're welcome!)
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Your a goblin. And if you only have 100 hps. wont take much to kill you. Not to mention your strength is probably one of the lowest in the game, so your damage output was just as bad as your hps.
I myself rerolled quite a few diff races for a mage thinking the stats is why I was failing my spells so much. Got very frustrating. With no tact dancing and no real defense, I spent more time trying to revig myself then I actually did hunting. Was no different for a mage to a priest.
I am curious to how a pvp fight would pan out with two semi equal race/class combos going at it. Maybe we are all just jumping the gun here.
I do agree with the frustration with so many resist and fails.
I myself rerolled quite a few diff races for a mage thinking the stats is why I was failing my spells so much. Got very frustrating. With no tact dancing and no real defense, I spent more time trying to revig myself then I actually did hunting. Was no different for a mage to a priest.
I am curious to how a pvp fight would pan out with two semi equal race/class combos going at it. Maybe we are all just jumping the gun here.
I do agree with the frustration with so many resist and fails.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
I also havent unlocked backstab or shadowstrike yet either. Those skills will hopefully make ME a little less squishy. I can deal with low hps; my DR is so high that I really dont get hit that often in melee combat, but magic just destroyed me.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Natari wrote:I also havent unlocked backstab or shadowstrike yet either. Those skills will hopefully make ME a little less squishy. I can deal with low hps; my DR is so high that I really dont get hit that often in melee combat, but magic just destroyed me.
Thieves are BY FAR the best looking and finished class in the game right now. A thief with level 1 pickpocket was able to attempt over 20 times to pick me without me noticing. I believe I finally saw on the 22nd attempt, this was after he gave me back all my coins multiple times(Thanks no perception stat). He was getting caught by the golems constantly and I saw him fail on golems constantly too.....
Shadowstrike looks overly powerful and I'm sure that with enough hiding, it's going to be. Especially with no perception stats or any way in hell to bring out someone who is hidden. Oh, and once poison is in, it will be absurdly broken I'm sure.
PvP based on gear from the starter area really can't be looked at in any serious manner. Let's fast forward to say level 50, where you have a dagger that does triple the damage you do now, and armor that's going to absorb 80% of a mages damage (Which, if armor absorption progression stays how it is now, will certainly look like that) with backstab and shadowstrike/poison. Not even a fair contest. The Mage will still be rocking his new damage spell at level 1 and you will be at level 50. I won't even start with things like Sap and being able to rob items off of people while disguised.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
I need to get into some PVP and see where I stack up!
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
There's some good feedback here, some real concern, and a lot of assumptions. I'll need some time to address it all, but I wanted to be quite clear that this is not Dragon's Gate, or any other game you've previously played. A decade of work has not gone into SI to fine tune it to the levels you are expecting. Something like a tact system where you can advance and retreat within the room is a great suggestion, one every game likely would have. It is not something you put in over night. It impacts a large portion of the game to write something like that.
Spells are evolving daily based on the positive feedback we've been receiving via the BUG and IDEA command. As for a spell being useless once you unlock the next one, that is not entirely accurate. Your shield spell for example, while being self only, increases the amount of DR it returns as you go up in level. It does not block damage, no, but at higher levels combined with good armor and some combat levels, you can be fairly difficult to hit. There's also the use of a held shield. Since your DR is lower in most cases, you're getting more chances to block than those higher level melee classes. Your wall spell can be cast on others, but you likely wouldn't use it on yourself. It's good for hunting with others. These two alone would be spells you continue to use as you unlock new things.
Attack spells are being adjusted to work the same. Obviously we don't want you to have a spell only to unlock the next one, so we're converting them all to increase their return as you go up in level. You can currently however continue forward with one spell to unlock others. You do not have to switch each time. This is to give you a chance to build up a better success rate with newer spells while still having your older, more reliable one to use and unlock things from. It is correct that our newer, more difficult spells start off with a lower success rate than your previous spell. They also have a higher increase per level as a result.
I think it's still a bit early to be so definitive about where each class stands. I don't think I've seen any mage unlock a haste or slow spell, or any of the storms. No one has had the chance to experience the ability to teleport not by remembered location, but directly to any place in the world by name or by person/npc. More spells will be added, both attack and support, and we'll fix the existing ones together with your help. All I ask is that you keep in mind that this is Shattered Isles, and not everything you may have experienced in the past is implemented here, and some of it may not ever be. Embrace the chance to create something new.
Spells are evolving daily based on the positive feedback we've been receiving via the BUG and IDEA command. As for a spell being useless once you unlock the next one, that is not entirely accurate. Your shield spell for example, while being self only, increases the amount of DR it returns as you go up in level. It does not block damage, no, but at higher levels combined with good armor and some combat levels, you can be fairly difficult to hit. There's also the use of a held shield. Since your DR is lower in most cases, you're getting more chances to block than those higher level melee classes. Your wall spell can be cast on others, but you likely wouldn't use it on yourself. It's good for hunting with others. These two alone would be spells you continue to use as you unlock new things.
Attack spells are being adjusted to work the same. Obviously we don't want you to have a spell only to unlock the next one, so we're converting them all to increase their return as you go up in level. You can currently however continue forward with one spell to unlock others. You do not have to switch each time. This is to give you a chance to build up a better success rate with newer spells while still having your older, more reliable one to use and unlock things from. It is correct that our newer, more difficult spells start off with a lower success rate than your previous spell. They also have a higher increase per level as a result.
I think it's still a bit early to be so definitive about where each class stands. I don't think I've seen any mage unlock a haste or slow spell, or any of the storms. No one has had the chance to experience the ability to teleport not by remembered location, but directly to any place in the world by name or by person/npc. More spells will be added, both attack and support, and we'll fix the existing ones together with your help. All I ask is that you keep in mind that this is Shattered Isles, and not everything you may have experienced in the past is implemented here, and some of it may not ever be. Embrace the chance to create something new.
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Snaek --
I didn't mean to jump the gun or overly criticize/compare SI to any other game I have played. These are just initial observations from admittedly short-term experience with levels in the caster class.
I am fully prepared, as I think many of us are, to embrace something new and evolved from our previous forays into the fantasy MUD realm. I myself am heavier on RP than skill crunching, but I recognize the fear that time input might not equal a foreseeable and stable output with casters as of yet. As you say, spells are evolving and there are going to be nuances that we as players do not know about that might be in store for us later which will drastically shift our view on the playability of a specific class in PvP and PvE.
That being said, with the inclusion of the understanding that it is still too early to be definitive about where each class stands, the true redundancy in spell unlocking and leveling (starting over at level 1 in each higher tier spell) stands with damage spells thus far. The usability of most utility spells will of course prove a higher return over time since they are not replicated to the extent that damage spells are at this lower level stage. Obviously I recognize the utility of my self-only shield spell in its level 10 incarnation as I do its future utility at level 50 or higher, provided that same spell does not unlock the same "stronger" version of itself as a self-only shield spell later in game which I then must level from 1 to 50 again. Again, the biggest problem lies with one shot damage spells that unlock a stronger version which (even at level 1) provides an adequate damage boost to render its level 10 predecessor obsolete.
I am, however, excited to unlock spells and discover more of my utility spells, as I think they will help put casters (mages in particular) in perspective with other classes. I also enjoy the idea of my handheld shield and a weapon. There's something decidedly sexy about a battle mage .... something about a lady on the street and a freak in the bed I assume.
As for tact dancing, it is of course difficult to code, but creates an added level of depth and strategy involved in PvP that cannot be said of its toe-to-toe button mashing combat compatriot. It also makes range a true idea in the game, giving dimension to the already flattened landscape of text. If it's not possible to code or too time consuming then so be it. It has been, and likely will continue to be, a popular suggestion from the player base until the alternative is realized and embraced.
I didn't mean to jump the gun or overly criticize/compare SI to any other game I have played. These are just initial observations from admittedly short-term experience with levels in the caster class.
I am fully prepared, as I think many of us are, to embrace something new and evolved from our previous forays into the fantasy MUD realm. I myself am heavier on RP than skill crunching, but I recognize the fear that time input might not equal a foreseeable and stable output with casters as of yet. As you say, spells are evolving and there are going to be nuances that we as players do not know about that might be in store for us later which will drastically shift our view on the playability of a specific class in PvP and PvE.
That being said, with the inclusion of the understanding that it is still too early to be definitive about where each class stands, the true redundancy in spell unlocking and leveling (starting over at level 1 in each higher tier spell) stands with damage spells thus far. The usability of most utility spells will of course prove a higher return over time since they are not replicated to the extent that damage spells are at this lower level stage. Obviously I recognize the utility of my self-only shield spell in its level 10 incarnation as I do its future utility at level 50 or higher, provided that same spell does not unlock the same "stronger" version of itself as a self-only shield spell later in game which I then must level from 1 to 50 again. Again, the biggest problem lies with one shot damage spells that unlock a stronger version which (even at level 1) provides an adequate damage boost to render its level 10 predecessor obsolete.
I am, however, excited to unlock spells and discover more of my utility spells, as I think they will help put casters (mages in particular) in perspective with other classes. I also enjoy the idea of my handheld shield and a weapon. There's something decidedly sexy about a battle mage .... something about a lady on the street and a freak in the bed I assume.
As for tact dancing, it is of course difficult to code, but creates an added level of depth and strategy involved in PvP that cannot be said of its toe-to-toe button mashing combat compatriot. It also makes range a true idea in the game, giving dimension to the already flattened landscape of text. If it's not possible to code or too time consuming then so be it. It has been, and likely will continue to be, a popular suggestion from the player base until the alternative is realized and embraced.
Transcribed this day by Faran Fairuz-Taqqi
One Who Speaks With Many Voices, Khalsat of Kaleith
Emissary of the Kalesian Isle
Faran of the Gale
Step into the water and you will not drown; Fall into the fire and you will not burn
One Who Speaks With Many Voices, Khalsat of Kaleith
Emissary of the Kalesian Isle
Faran of the Gale
Step into the water and you will not drown; Fall into the fire and you will not burn