This example sounds more like an IC profession change, which is supposed to be rare.Shattered Mind wrote: I could, if I chose to, create an old human (elderly), who may have been a farmer all his life (my rp) and decided to learn to become a tracker/scout. There is no way this human should start with knowledge relating to the skills for his new profession.
We don't commence into this game with some wistful intention for maybe what profession we might have someday in the future.
No, we are that profession already.
We might be the crappiest example of that profession you ever met, relatively speaking.
But even a crappy baker is going to outperform a ninja, in baking.
All I am asking for is a semblance of competence.
I would take it a step further and let you be competent at foraging, and any other plant/animal husbandry related skills.
Because it makes sense for an old old old old man to remember how to do the stuff he has done all his life.
Not to necessarily be good at it, just competent.
But I daresay that background based skills would never be considered here, no matter how logical it would be.
For the same reason that I bet those who do make an IC profession change lose all prior skills, even if learned the hard way.
Mainly for fear of unbalancing something by any one character actually becoming a jack of all trades and monopolizing the economy.
I say let it happen.
If they do it right they will be RPing with everyone anyway.
And it will be mimicking a real world dynamic.... what is the harm?
Besides, given the current grind, no one should have the time to realistically pull it off, even with a handful of extra out of profession competencies at commencement.
I will certainly argue the point if you don't have a solid argument of your own.Shattered Mind wrote: It's useless asking for anyone other than staff to chime in. You're going to disagree with anyone who doesn't share your point of view.
But don't tell me I am wrong, and then go off on another topic that is only tangentially pertinent.
Stay on topic and explain why.
If we are discussing OOC things, don't give IC rationale.
And only staff can say what changes to code will or won't be made.
You don't have the authority to make that claim.
At best you could say that player submissions of this magnitude are rarely if ever adopted.
But that is not staying on topic, that is discussing the merit of continuing the topic in this direction.
How rude!