My character is still very new so I can't really say much about the spell progressions yet, but if I can add my two doubloons to some of the other topics that have been brought up here...
First, I rather dislike the ideas of a hard level-limit to equipment in a roleplaying based game. What strange force is it that prevents the fresh recruit from picking up a fine sword and swinging it around? Perhaps some limits on how effective it is...maybe the new recruit doesn't know how to use the fine sword to its full potential, but at least let them try.
Second, as for the whole warrior vs wizard thing, I suppose that depends on what wizards are supposed to be and how they are viewed in this world. I would imagine that if you put a archtypical fantasy scholar-wizard who spends time study book and scrolls into a one-on-one fight with a warrior, then the warrior should easily win the fight. Fighting is after all the main point of warrior training. On the other hand, if wizards are supposed to be powerful forces on the battlefield...some kind of wizard-warriors, then it makes sense to make sure they can hold their own. Although that might lead to the issue that if someone can become a warrior and learn to fight or become a wizard and learn to fight plus all the other things wizards can do....well, who would ever bother being a warrior?
I suppose that all comes down to the focus of the game again. If it is going to be more pvp combat focused, then it makes sense that all of the classes are more or less balanced for pvp combat. While if it is more roleplaying focused it makes more sense that each class gets some useful and interesting niche in the world.
Anyways, enough rambling for now. I look forward to seeing where things go. It is pretty exciting to be here at the start of a new mud. Oh..teleport spells? *drools*
Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Solutions
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
**Edited Cuz I posted in the wrong thread, somehow**
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
I'm glad some of my feedback has been addressed here and I hope that I will see something in the near future for the other 80% of my post that wasn't addressed.Snaek wrote:There's some good feedback here, some real concern, and a lot of assumptions. I'll need some time to address it all, but I wanted to be quite clear that this is not Dragon's Gate, or any other game you've previously played. A decade of work has not gone into SI to fine tune it to the levels you are expecting. Something like a tact system where you can advance and retreat within the room is a great suggestion, one every game likely would have. It is not something you put in over night. It impacts a large portion of the game to write something like that.
Spells are evolving daily based on the positive feedback we've been receiving via the BUG and IDEA command. As for a spell being useless once you unlock the next one, that is not entirely accurate. Your shield spell for example, while being self only, increases the amount of DR it returns as you go up in level. It does not block damage, no, but at higher levels combined with good armor and some combat levels, you can be fairly difficult to hit. There's also the use of a held shield. Since your DR is lower in most cases, you're getting more chances to block than those higher level melee classes. Your wall spell can be cast on others, but you likely wouldn't use it on yourself. It's good for hunting with others. These two alone would be spells you continue to use as you unlock new things.
Attack spells are being adjusted to work the same. Obviously we don't want you to have a spell only to unlock the next one, so we're converting them all to increase their return as you go up in level. You can currently however continue forward with one spell to unlock others. You do not have to switch each time. This is to give you a chance to build up a better success rate with newer spells while still having your older, more reliable one to use and unlock things from. It is correct that our newer, more difficult spells start off with a lower success rate than your previous spell. They also have a higher increase per level as a result.
I think it's still a bit early to be so definitive about where each class stands. I don't think I've seen any mage unlock a haste or slow spell, or any of the storms. No one has had the chance to experience the ability to teleport not by remembered location, but directly to any place in the world by name or by person/npc. More spells will be added, both attack and support, and we'll fix the existing ones together with your help. All I ask is that you keep in mind that this is Shattered Isles, and not everything you may have experienced in the past is implemented here, and some of it may not ever be. Embrace the chance to create something new.
I certainly do not think of this game as any other game I played beforehand. I only used references to other games in order to create a visual aid to better explain what I'm trying to convey.
I have also participated in over 15 other beta tests and can usually spot common errors and bugs in mechanics that a lot of different games have shared.
Pardon some of my assumptions; I felt I needed to make them, based on lack of communication on any of the above subjects. Leading me to believe that there was nothing in the works regarding most of the things I posted about. I thought that since your new combat system was already in and the game went into beta, that we would have already seen or heard about a UD system if there was one being planned. Or that the core of the game was pretty much done.
Haste, Slow, Teleport, and Storms still don't address the huge disparities between non-casters and casters that I pointed out in my first post. I don't even want to know what level I'll have to level those to, in order to get a reliable cast from them either. Don't get me wrong, I like that we get useful utility spells later on and perhaps I should have separated some comments into exact examples. Because I already knew that the later utility spells would be better. It was more directed to the DD spells and probably storm spells.
I literally come into Alpha and Beta games with little to no expectations and look at them from a view with 0 biases from other games. But that also comes with my abrasive feedback and having no issues with pointing out flaws and bugs. Because if I don't do it, I doubt we would see anything brought up anytime soon.
Also, I attempted to have multiple chats 1 on 1 to avoid forums, but was told to post here. So I did.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Do the individual spells have level caps, or does each spell have to be raised to 100 to be fully effective?
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
And wait, can you hold a weapon while casting? If I level my close combat will that be my DR while fighting even if I'm spellcasting?
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Yes, you can. But that's not exactly the point here. Why should you be FORCED to level close combat in order to survive? Non-Casters don't have to level magic in order to live or be competitive. If that's the case, then all the mages should just be re-classified as warmage or battlemage. Not what I signed up for.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Straight damage verses utility, Bro. Mages do damage, fly, haste, slow, shield, buff, debuff, and I'm not certain if there are DoTs in this game but sometimes they have those, too!
I stand there and swing a sword at you. Hopefully a good one. That I had to buy. By killing stuff that was trying to kill me back. Chances are you'll reach max damage WAY before I will. Unless iron is the best stuff in the game. Which I'm willing to bet, isn't.
Anyway, yeah, I agree to some extent on the spells, each starting at level 1 or whatever. It seems odd. Still waiting on an answer about level 100 spells though.
If each spell only needed 20 levels to max, I'd be okay with it. Or if there were a way that the race mods could implement maximum level. So maybe the best casters would max a spell at 20 levels and the next guy 22-24, and the next guy 24-26 or something like that.
I stand there and swing a sword at you. Hopefully a good one. That I had to buy. By killing stuff that was trying to kill me back. Chances are you'll reach max damage WAY before I will. Unless iron is the best stuff in the game. Which I'm willing to bet, isn't.
Anyway, yeah, I agree to some extent on the spells, each starting at level 1 or whatever. It seems odd. Still waiting on an answer about level 100 spells though.
If each spell only needed 20 levels to max, I'd be okay with it. Or if there were a way that the race mods could implement maximum level. So maybe the best casters would max a spell at 20 levels and the next guy 22-24, and the next guy 24-26 or something like that.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Why should learning magic automatically make someone more effective in hand to hand combat? Being a battlemage sounds exactly what you are trying to sign up for. If mages didn't have to learn close combat to be effective front line fighters, if just studying magic was all that was required for that, then wouldn't they all be warmages?Ghrex wrote:Yes, you can. But that's not exactly the point here. Why should you be FORCED to level close combat in order to survive? Non-Casters don't have to level magic in order to live or be competitive. If that's the case, then all the mages should just be re-classified as warmage or battlemage. Not what I signed up for.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Trisket wrote:Why should learning magic automatically make someone more effective in hand to hand combat? Being a battlemage sounds exactly what you are trying to sign up for. If mages didn't have to learn close combat to be effective front line fighters, if just studying magic was all that was required for that, then wouldn't they all be warmages?Ghrex wrote:Yes, you can. But that's not exactly the point here. Why should you be FORCED to level close combat in order to survive? Non-Casters don't have to level magic in order to live or be competitive. If that's the case, then all the mages should just be re-classified as warmage or battlemage. Not what I signed up for.
Never stated I wanted to be a front line fighter. The game is forcing us to be one in it's current state. I want the ability to tactically outwit my opponent, not see who can throw out the most damage the fastest. Because right now, as thing s stand, whoever can take the most damage, while being able to deal the most will always win any PvE or PvP battle. There is nothing more to it. I 100% agree that mages should not stand a chance in a 1 on 1 facetank brawl. But that's the only option I have been given at this time.
Re: Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Soluti
Utility means nothing when you have no way to escape a 1 on 1 fight or even a group fight. You can focus a mage whenever you want, since everyone just stands right next to one another.Forhekset wrote:Straight damage verses utility, Bro. Mages do damage, fly, haste, slow, shield, buff, debuff, and I'm not certain if there are DoTs in this game but sometimes they have those, too!
I stand there and swing a sword at you. Hopefully a good one. That I had to buy. By killing stuff that was trying to kill me back. Chances are you'll reach max damage WAY before I will. Unless iron is the best stuff in the game. Which I'm willing to bet, isn't.
Anyway, yeah, I agree to some extent on the spells, each starting at level 1 or whatever. It seems odd. Still waiting on an answer about level 100 spells though.
If each spell only needed 20 levels to max, I'd be okay with it. Or if there were a way that the race mods could implement maximum level. So maybe the best casters would max a spell at 20 levels and the next guy 22-24, and the next guy 24-26 or something like that.
I guarantee you, that you will miss a mage far less than he fails his spells, or you resist them.
In regards to the level 100 question. I don't know for certain, but at level 15, my FTG spell still fails almost as bad as it did at level 1. So I'm going to guess that you won't get a 100% non failure rate until level 100.