Please keep in mind... they are only first impressions. As I learn more, often these impressions are proven wrong or I understand how it should be. These are just my raw thoughts:
* The pace of the mud is nice. In the academy, it almost feels like a forest retreat.
* There should be a default colorset, which should not be almost entirely white. My first impression of the game was very bland. Also, colors really need added to equipment. I understand materials need to be colorless, but EQ should have some flare.
* I was expecting base CoffeeMud crafting system. However, when I found that I could not view the skill tree, I knew things would be different.
* Not being able to view the skill tree is frustrating. How long do I have to forage before I get a new skill? When does my next new skill come? My only chance is to attempt to reach level X and hope I get something new.
* So now I'm carrying around 150 lbs of foraged goods. So.... what do I do with these? I can't cook them all!
* Why is salt so precious of a commodity? Can't I boil beans without salt?
* I really want a mapper. I have the .jpg maps and it's pretty easy to navigate. However, being able to see where I am on the map would be so very useful. However, the forums indicate that the best mapers are buggy because we can't get the room ids (vnums). That, to me, seems like a glaring hole in the code. GMCP, ATCP, or MSDP... any of these protocols is so, so, so needed.
-- OK, I found the mapper, but shouldn't this be in a github repository somewhere? And without MSDP, we'll see how good this one is...
-- (Actually, not too bad. Needs some polish, but not bad at all...)
* Spinning up a new character is a very slow effort. However, I sense that this is just a game that has slow progression. Still, to get wood chopping, I have to have foraging at level 5. Thats...1000 uses / 3 = 300 forages. That's very very slow.
* So, I start cooking something, my fire goes out, and my ingredients disappear? Hmmm... odd.
* Abundance of gold is very low at the start of the game. Gathering 192 credits for a hatchet took nearly an RL day's work.
* The fact that I can walk out of a room in the middle of a fight... Kind of surprising.
* My last mud was RP-rich. I miss being able to emote quotation marks such as:
emote nods thoughtfully and says, "That is an interesting idea you are proposing," while puffing his pipe.
* I miss being able to add my name into the middle of an emote, such as:
emote Chuckling slightly, $n says, "Well, let's not get carried away."
emote ^g$n nods, "^wWhile powerful, some things are worth providing.^g"
* Academy island is huge... Either it's too big or the rest of the world is massive. However, if salt is only found on academy island, then I'm guessing it's too large. Some of these areas should probably be moved to mainland... but then again, I've never left the island.
* I finally used the "Commands" command. Umm... wow. There are so few commands here. Yet, such a rich environment. Most muds have more socials than this one has commands. *eyebrow* *hmm*
So, take them as you will. They are my raw thoughts as I had them.