We all saw this coming, right? lol.
So in last weeks games, we were lucky enough to see some different poisons in action. There seemed to be some pretty interesting poisons that did all sorts of things, from slow, to making you pass out cold, to locking your character in place until you died. The first two seem in line with what the rest of the playerbase already have (slow and pummel/blindside), which are both very powerful and great skills. The last one however, is a bit over-the-top. Once hit, your character loses all ability do anything but talk. You can't move, drink, attack, anything. I'm not certain to exactly how long it lasted, or if it was continuously refreshed on hit, but it seemed to last about 45 to 60 seconds, or at least that's how long it took to die from minimal attack damage. This poison also pulses.
After this poison was used to literally kill everyone in the arena without the possiblity of harm or retaliation (Partly due to shadowstrike), a few things were said to justify something like this being in the game.
1. The poison itself, costs about an hours or so worth of hunting profits, so it's kind of expensive I guess, so it being powerful is supposedly justified.
I personally believe that an hours worth of hunting shouldn't give you the ability to kill anyone in the game, anytime you want, without having to worry about strategy or reprocussions. As there's absolutely no counters to this in a 1v1 situation or most situations, it's just silly. I'm a strong advocate for characters always having an option. Taking away someone's ability to do anything or make a choice with their own character is not fun and does not help the game in any way at all.
2. Priests needed to be countered.
While I agree that priests are strong right now, due to being the ONLY updated class, you still have multiple of options on how to handle them. Yellow pots will wipe level 100 plague off in 1 go, for the cost of almost nothing. No priest is gonna kill you with holy strike, especially after the nerf. Pummel and slow work extremely well against them and are usually the contributing factors to killing us in a PvP environment. If anything, you can always opt to push a directional button to disengage and live to fight another day. Paralysis poison does not afford a player any of those luxuries.
3. Healing is OP.
Healing is seemingly OP right now in PvP, due to magic and melee not being updated. The melee damage bug is the main factor in it being so hard to kill someone who can heal. 2 mages can kill 1 healer thanks to slow.
In a PvE environment, people are still dying on hunts that have a healer present. End game mobs hit really hard and facing more than 1 or 2 at a time, typically ends in a death, due to healing not being enough to keep someone alive. If a priest is healing, he's not doing damage.
4. No one is using this poison in PvE.
False. This poison has been and still is, used to completely trivialize PvE content. Just because some people haven't seen it used, doesn't mean it's not happening. Many people have seen it used on many hunts.
If this poison was created to counter a priest, I have another suggestion that doesn't completely break the game. Make it cut healing buy a certain %, or, since it's a pulsing poison, only give it a % chance to stun on every pulse, based off of the users CC level. Both of these puts a very heavy burden on the priest, but at least gives the player an option to choose what to do. Cure poison doesn't mean a whole lot when you can't even cast it.....
Thanks for reading.
Poison feedback
Re: Poison feedback
What I'm taking from this, is that of your points, you feel that the poison one is the most pressing one at this time.
To be more specific, the use of said poison in 1 on 1 PvP combat, and how it could potentially allow a significantly lower level character with a marginal chance of victory, something much more tangible than they should be given. I would like to see more numbers on this, but I understand hesitation by player-base and staff to give away information they feel should be IC only.
An issue with these statements without a more significant portion of the data, is that it discourages players from playing the OOC games for fear of not having a good time. ICly, it will limit people's willingness to become confrontational and avoidance to PvP for fear of excessive class imbalance.
The combat fix should adjust for the healing issue, I agree, and am content to wait it out until the September release, where more adjustments can be made if necessary.
I don't mean to disparage or pull at threads (no pun intended) Bocon, I am grateful for your input and viewpoint from OOC games as I do not participate in them. I do ask however, that if people have something to add information-wise, it would certainly help towards further balancing prior to the upcoming launch.
I am sure that staff are logging and noting as much as they can, but sometimes player input can provide a different angle of insight towards game development.
-Kschilan's player
To be more specific, the use of said poison in 1 on 1 PvP combat, and how it could potentially allow a significantly lower level character with a marginal chance of victory, something much more tangible than they should be given. I would like to see more numbers on this, but I understand hesitation by player-base and staff to give away information they feel should be IC only.
An issue with these statements without a more significant portion of the data, is that it discourages players from playing the OOC games for fear of not having a good time. ICly, it will limit people's willingness to become confrontational and avoidance to PvP for fear of excessive class imbalance.
The combat fix should adjust for the healing issue, I agree, and am content to wait it out until the September release, where more adjustments can be made if necessary.
I don't mean to disparage or pull at threads (no pun intended) Bocon, I am grateful for your input and viewpoint from OOC games as I do not participate in them. I do ask however, that if people have something to add information-wise, it would certainly help towards further balancing prior to the upcoming launch.
I am sure that staff are logging and noting as much as they can, but sometimes player input can provide a different angle of insight towards game development.
-Kschilan's player
Re: Poison feedback
I didn't bring up the fact that a far, far, less skilled thief/assassin can kill someone (typically a mage or priest) from 100% to 0% HP, who's skill levels are far superior to their own, because I didn't want to give out any ideas to people who would abuse it. But yes, it can easily be used like that for the high price of hunting for an hour and the getting apply poison skill up a few levels.
I'm not sure what numbers you want to see? You get hit with the weapon with the poison on it, then you can't act, then you die. There's not much more to say or test. Though I can imagine that a weapon can be poisoned and then given to someone else to use though, making it so anyone with a decent weapon skill can do this too.
I'm not sure what numbers you want to see? You get hit with the weapon with the poison on it, then you can't act, then you die. There's not much more to say or test. Though I can imagine that a weapon can be poisoned and then given to someone else to use though, making it so anyone with a decent weapon skill can do this too.
Re: Poison feedback
My 2 doubloons-
That specific poison should be the ultimate of the class that is most likely to use it.
If it can be made, it should be very hi level. Purchasing it should be a serious financial matter.
perhaps two or three versions of this poison from weak to strong throughout the skill progression if it is brewable?
Until we do see the effects of the planned combat update, it is difficult to speculate on such things
as resistance being able to lessen its effects, etc.
As far as the OOC games, perhaps a bit of restriction on use until we do see more combat updates might
help from discouraging participation.
That specific poison should be the ultimate of the class that is most likely to use it.
If it can be made, it should be very hi level. Purchasing it should be a serious financial matter.
perhaps two or three versions of this poison from weak to strong throughout the skill progression if it is brewable?
Until we do see the effects of the planned combat update, it is difficult to speculate on such things
as resistance being able to lessen its effects, etc.
As far as the OOC games, perhaps a bit of restriction on use until we do see more combat updates might
help from discouraging participation.
-
Kreve Moltenhoof
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 43
- Joined: Mon Dec 16, 2013 9:26 pm
Re: Poison feedback
i hunted with a player that used the gargoyle poison that makes you unable to attack/move etc. It made hunting pretty easy once the poison was applied. I Posted about this before. As the game is this poison is OP in any situation. I dont post much about balance issues because im hoping the combat update will fix alot of the problems we see.
Re: Poison feedback
The one thing in Bocon’s post that I agree with is the main point that Gargoyle Sludge in the current poison environment is overpowered. I think most people who have any experience with it would come to that conclusion. Now before we just go and declare this poison way to OP for SI, lets l take a look abit closer at the current poison system and what I think are bugs (These are all coming from limited experience and testing which resulted in a wide variety of results, someone correct me if you have different information). First, poison once applied to a blade, remains intact for roughly 3 minutes, during that time each time you successfully hit a target or multiple targets, the poisons either “reset” or stack. It was my understanding that poison was to be a “one time shot”, hit someone and it was gone and you had to reapply to hit a different target. Second, different poisons stack on a blade, if you are hit with poison A and then poison B is applied to the blade within poison A 3 minute window, you get re-hit with poison A and hit with Poison B. So what you were seeing was a magnified effect.
So if these are bugs and they were fixed, is there still any place in SI for Gargoyle Sludge? Should there be a poison that paralyzes you? If so what should the duration be? 15sec, 30 secs. 45 secs? Guess it depends how how high a level poison it is. Personally, I don’t see anything wrong with it’s effects, if it’s a one time shot that lasted for say 30 seconds and was perhaps the end poison in the skill. We do have to remember: Anyone can use poison
A few other suggestions for the skill. Alcohol should not have the same level of effects when used as a poison on a blade as it does when consumed. Perhaps it could reduce offensive and defensive ratings a few points but to have it potentially make you pass out is too much.
If poisons are bugged and it should only last for “one shot” then the length of time it remains on a blade should be increase to say 10 minutes. This would allow more people to use them in different situations without allowing any character to just “stockpile” poisoned blades.
That’s about all I have to say on poisons, it was fun to watch the reactions in the OOC games from players who generally rule the roost, when they had no counter to poisons. Now you know the frustration of melee players when two-three melee players beating on a healer and we can’t kill them. Oh and yes Healing is OP in the current environment (perhaps someone could offer up suggestions on how we can change that until the “melee bug” changes come into effect). The example given on how end game mob fights generally end in death even when there is a healer is hardly support that healing is not OP. Or that 2 mages using slow can kill 1 priest, 2 mages with equivalent skills SHOULD kill one priest, as should just about 2 characters of any class. Hell, one offensive class character with equivalent skills and tatics should kill the priest 50% of the time.
All in all most of this crap is trivial, one day your OP the next your nerfed, everybody will get a turn, just be ready to suck it up when your number is called.
So if these are bugs and they were fixed, is there still any place in SI for Gargoyle Sludge? Should there be a poison that paralyzes you? If so what should the duration be? 15sec, 30 secs. 45 secs? Guess it depends how how high a level poison it is. Personally, I don’t see anything wrong with it’s effects, if it’s a one time shot that lasted for say 30 seconds and was perhaps the end poison in the skill. We do have to remember: Anyone can use poison
A few other suggestions for the skill. Alcohol should not have the same level of effects when used as a poison on a blade as it does when consumed. Perhaps it could reduce offensive and defensive ratings a few points but to have it potentially make you pass out is too much.
If poisons are bugged and it should only last for “one shot” then the length of time it remains on a blade should be increase to say 10 minutes. This would allow more people to use them in different situations without allowing any character to just “stockpile” poisoned blades.
That’s about all I have to say on poisons, it was fun to watch the reactions in the OOC games from players who generally rule the roost, when they had no counter to poisons. Now you know the frustration of melee players when two-three melee players beating on a healer and we can’t kill them. Oh and yes Healing is OP in the current environment (perhaps someone could offer up suggestions on how we can change that until the “melee bug” changes come into effect). The example given on how end game mob fights generally end in death even when there is a healer is hardly support that healing is not OP. Or that 2 mages using slow can kill 1 priest, 2 mages with equivalent skills SHOULD kill one priest, as should just about 2 characters of any class. Hell, one offensive class character with equivalent skills and tatics should kill the priest 50% of the time.
All in all most of this crap is trivial, one day your OP the next your nerfed, everybody will get a turn, just be ready to suck it up when your number is called.
- Kody_Oakborne
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 209
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am
Re: Poison feedback
What?Requiem wrote: We do have to remember: Anyone can use poison
False.
Anyone can use poison IF you hand your weapon to a trusted poisoner, who poisons your weapon, and returns it to you.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
Kody
Re: Poison feedback
A lot of those sound like bugs to me. At least the being able to apply multiple poisons to one blade and having poisons stack. Priests just got nerfed so that different priests can't stack plague on a target, so I'd assume that poisons would fall into the same category. I think there is still room for it, as I gave suggestions on how to fix it to not be so game-breaking. It should also be far higher level, even in the state I suggested. If the poison pulses, having it stun for say, 12 seconds (3 rounds of combat) at a % that's tied to either your CC skill or your poison application skill, should still make it really, really good. I agree on making it last longer, so you can prep a few blades before a kill. At least there's some strategy and thought involved in that.
The issue in the area isn't healing itself, it's that there's too many priests and not enough everyone else. I personally stopped playing in the OOC games a while back, because when it was just me and xiija, we'd get ganged on and die in the first 15 seconds of every game. So you can't blame it on healing, as it's been proven that it's easy enough to stop a priest from healing using slow and blindside/pummel. When you have more healers than you have damage dealers (especially melee right now), that's what you are seeing.
Why does Bocon last so long now against melee? 2 reasons: 1. Because his shield block is probably higher than 3/4 of games melee's CC skills and 2. Melee damage has been broken forever and will be supposedly addressed/fixed at the end of the month. I agree, two melee or mages of EQUAL SKILL should kill a healer. If we went by that, I'd barely die, since there's only 1 mage and maybe 2 or 3 melee with skills on my level. Until then, people far benieth my skill level can 100-0 me with poison.
Healing is already getting a pretty huge nerf when the combat update goes in as well, as it will supposedly no longer cure bleeders and we'll have to use another spell just to do that. So rejoyce.
Since the game is 99% PvE, I think that my statement still stands perfectly fine. Healing doesn't trivialize PvE, these poisons do. And I believe that once this update does go in, melee are going to be incredibly good in both PvE and PvP.
The issue in the area isn't healing itself, it's that there's too many priests and not enough everyone else. I personally stopped playing in the OOC games a while back, because when it was just me and xiija, we'd get ganged on and die in the first 15 seconds of every game. So you can't blame it on healing, as it's been proven that it's easy enough to stop a priest from healing using slow and blindside/pummel. When you have more healers than you have damage dealers (especially melee right now), that's what you are seeing.
Why does Bocon last so long now against melee? 2 reasons: 1. Because his shield block is probably higher than 3/4 of games melee's CC skills and 2. Melee damage has been broken forever and will be supposedly addressed/fixed at the end of the month. I agree, two melee or mages of EQUAL SKILL should kill a healer. If we went by that, I'd barely die, since there's only 1 mage and maybe 2 or 3 melee with skills on my level. Until then, people far benieth my skill level can 100-0 me with poison.
Healing is already getting a pretty huge nerf when the combat update goes in as well, as it will supposedly no longer cure bleeders and we'll have to use another spell just to do that. So rejoyce.
Since the game is 99% PvE, I think that my statement still stands perfectly fine. Healing doesn't trivialize PvE, these poisons do. And I believe that once this update does go in, melee are going to be incredibly good in both PvE and PvP.
Re: Poison feedback
Poison is not only effective when it is still wet.
I think giving the user a much bigger window in which the poison effect remains is a good thing.
Really I would almost take it another route, and instead of being time based, make it use based.
One application will last for say 5 connects before the toxic residue has been rubbed off the blade.
Only the first hit gets the best poison strength, drop it by 20% each hit.
Multiple toxins on a blade should allow for stacked effects, although none of them may be at peak performance due to unknown chemical reactions when the poisons are mixed.
Heck, you might end up chemically deforming the weapon into rubbish. (not likely)
PvP and PvE should ideally play out the same.
Most Es are just simulating a P anyway.
Is healing an issue with NPC priests when you try to desecrate the other temples?
I think giving the user a much bigger window in which the poison effect remains is a good thing.
Really I would almost take it another route, and instead of being time based, make it use based.
One application will last for say 5 connects before the toxic residue has been rubbed off the blade.
Only the first hit gets the best poison strength, drop it by 20% each hit.
Multiple toxins on a blade should allow for stacked effects, although none of them may be at peak performance due to unknown chemical reactions when the poisons are mixed.
Heck, you might end up chemically deforming the weapon into rubbish. (not likely)
PvP and PvE should ideally play out the same.
Most Es are just simulating a P anyway.
Is healing an issue with NPC priests when you try to desecrate the other temples?
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Poison feedback
Kody_Oakborne wrote:What?Requiem wrote: We do have to remember: Anyone can use poison
False.
Anyone can use poison IF you hand your weapon to a trusted poisoner, who poisons your weapon, and returns it to you.
You lost me in your logic....... You claim the statement is false and then provide an IF THEN statement (in reverse order) that supports the original claim! I tried to think of where you were coming from and thought this might be an example: "Put Kody in a box (or a monocharacter game), with an orc, a blade, and a vial of poison, and in that situation then yes! not everyone can use poison" But in the current SI environment all you need is a tin training dagger, a few bottles of draught brew, and perhaps a few doubloons or a lb of seaweed to bribe or pay a poisoner and you too can use poison. I think anyone in game could manage those prerequisites and thus the statement Anyone can use poison.
I believe the only mechanical requirement to use a poison is the ability to swing a weapon. I think where you were going with this is that Not everyone can use poison with the same efficiency. That my friend would be a true statement.