Observations from my 1st week

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
Feir
Academy Student
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 12:39 am

Observations from my 1st week

Post by Feir »

Warning: Long post

The following are a number of observations I’ve made over the previous week since I’ve decided to try SI again to see how it has progressed. First, I’m extremely disappointed this is now being considered a beta, with the number of bugged mechanics and what I view as horribly designed or poorly balanced systems this feels much more like a mid-alpha. Not sure why the decision to change the game’s status was rushed so much but being sub-par for a game in beta it will likely deter at least a handful of potential long-term players. That being said I’m happy to see the amount of progress that has been made since I last took a look at SI well over a year ago and it’s great to see someone still trying to provide an environment for the RP fans.

As for the issues I’ve seen I would first recommend a post previously started by Ghrex, it goes in to further detail than I’d planned to on what I perceive to be a number of the flaws in the current magic/prayer system (excessive failures during casting and far too many spells to level long-term). I believe as he mentioned in one of his solutions instead of leveling each individual spell, condensing them in to their various schools and leveling the school of magic would likely be one of the easiest and best solutions available.

Next, the recent change to heals on non-players. It has been fairly standard in the past in most games that heals upon the undead would result in damage. I realize with the recent addition of holy strike that a damage prayer is now available but still believe personally that priest’s should be able to use heals as a form of direct damage when facing undead opponents, I don’t believe this would be too difficult as I imagine creatures already have some sort of flag/tag for marking them as undead for the turn undead skill. If for whatever reason this is not in line with what the staff had envisioned for priests then so be it, certainly not game breaking or end of the world, but I feel you may want to put further thought in to this decision.

Which brings me to gathering, something I’ve spent the majority of my return to SI doing to get a feel for the gathering and crafting system, while initially somewhat excited to see a fairly new and unique system it was quickly replaced by disgust which has grown the more I’ve used it. As it currently stands the entire system is so flawed it requires extensive reworking or should be scrapped entirely so players know not to waste their time. First, gathering a specific material seems to be a non-option, at level 4 wood cutting in a specific location I began finding beechwood, at 5 this progressed to cherrywood, at 6 and through most of 7, I’ve found absolutely nothing, similarly with mining I did not successfully find anything until reaching level 10. I’ve attempted to “chop beechwood or chop cherrywood” and it results in failure every time, in a location where I know for certain I was able to find it in the past. Second, is the unnecessary gathering skills, bundling should just be command available to all at start It makes little sense that it should need to be unlocked. Speculating is horrible and that it needs to be leveled and does so as slowly as many of the gathering skills only adds to the problem. Finally, the amount of time involved in attempting to level a gathering skill (which is significantly faster than leveling crafting and will discuss that shortly). At this point the only reasonable method of training is through mechanics abuse, and even doing this makes leveling a single gathering skill far slower than most spells or combat oriented skills.

On to crafting, I wish I had more to say about it but after some time of using gathered materials to start fires for glass blowing/cooking or carving stones the only craft attempt that has been successful aside from a few fires was making the boiled meat with the materials provided shortly after character creation. Again, it seems the only way to level crafting at all is via abuse of mechanics so that you aren’t wasting coin on material that could have just been sold. With most craft attempts appearing to require at least 1 minute, succeed or fail it seems likely people will be reaching near level 100 in spells or combat skills before a dedicated crafter can even hope to compete with NPC shops in the academy. Using some rough estimates and speculation I’m going to say it takes roughly 144000 uses to go from lvl 11 to 50 in a skill/spell. At 1 minute per attempt that’s 144000 minutes or 100 days of non-stop crafting (again only an estimate as I do not know the exact increase in skill requirements as you progress in level), in comparison to say close combat which would appear to require less than 1 week of non-stop swinging to make the same gain of 11-50. Obviously we can argue that close combat takes longer due to needing to find targets and health/stam regen, but the extended time is even more pronounced in crafting where you sometimes require multiple gathering and craft skills to make a single attempt. Obviously I can’t say much as to the value of items once crafted but to really make crafts viable any recipe should yield a higher return selling to the shops than if you were to have directly sold the materials to the shop and foregone crafting entirely. Finally on crafting there is again a lot of redundancy in the skills, there appears to be at least 7 or 8 craft skills many of which seem to produce items of little to no use to the player base. While nice for RP purposes maybe, the time involved for making items of limited use is far too great.

Possible solutions to crafting/gathering:
Eliminate speculation, upon initial use of a gathering skill in an area have it produce a list of gatherable items using that skill similar to how crafting lists work. Example –
>chop
With your current wood cutting skill you’re able to discover the following materials in this area.

Material Level Potential # Gathered Probability of Success
Beechwood 2 1-3 65%
Cherrywood 3 1-3 50%

While not all that information is necessary it would be nice, alternatively instead of a detailed number on how many can be gathered it could grouped in to classes such as “A few (1-3)” “Many (4-6)” “A lot (7-9)”, similar could be done for success rate with nearly impossible being below 5%, difficulty being 6-20%, unlikely being 21-40%, average being 41-60%, moderate being 61-80%, good being 81-95%, and easy being 96-100% to maintain the roleplay aspect of it. After seeing this initial list the player would have to attempt to specifically gather the material they want, perhaps with some possibility of gathering something different available in the area based upon their skill level such as mining for a gem with a nearly impossible rating due to rarity and instead ending up with granite which would be far more common.

As for leveling I can think of 2 options: First, maintain current use progression but greatly reduce the RT involved. Second, maintain current RT (15 second fails, 1 minute successes) while applying some form of modifier for the probability of success. Critical success in gathering might also yield a high-quality material which in turn improves the likelihood of successfully crafting an item or an item of better quality than normal. Quality of the gathering tool being used may also provide some increased probability to successfully gather a material, this would prevent even high level gatherers from finding high end materials with a basic cheap tool from the academy, it may be necessary to acquire a tool from a crafter to have any hope of even succeeding.

Crafting success on recipes below lvl 10 should be 100%, because coin is semi-challenging to come across already at this early stage of character development it seems counter-productive to penalize a crafter financially for trying to improve their craft. Upon hitting 11 crafters could see an increasing probability of failure for crafting items of equal level, or do away with failure entirely in the crafting system. Similar to gathering crafting needs to see some significant increase in usage gain if the times involved are to remain the same.

The last thing that comes to mind is the redundancy in craft skills, with a much larger player base a larger number of craft skills becomes more viable, yet even in the days of dgates prime I don’t think it ever warranted the number of craft skills we see now. Some could likely be combined such as weaving and tailoring or wood carving and fletching, to have so many that require the use of others with the horrible amount of effort involved to improve any of them only serves to promote afk scripting to see any progress in these skills. Furthermore, some crafts such as wood carving (haven’t used yet) sound to be of limited use based upon the help file, with limited practical use these crafts are likely to remain untouched when there is going to be an actual demand for other crafts by the playerbase.

I apologize if any of this feedback seems overly harsh or critical of the systems currently in place. I realize the game is still in its infancy and understand the level of work required by staff to make a game that is good or successful, let alone both. If I didn’t see some promise in the game and what it could become I wouldn’t have bothered with feedback at all and just moved on.
Forhekset
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 150
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 9:59 pm

Re: Observations from my 1st week

Post by Forhekset »

Yeah. The gathering skills are friggin' brutal. My biggest problem is there isn't any information for a new player to choose which kind of crafter they want to be. I wanted to go into armor/weapon making but not sure which skills need to go where. And leveling all of them is out of the question.

Also, how were you able to get a fire started? I gave up after like 50 tries.
Feir
Academy Student
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 12:39 am

Re: Observations from my 1st week

Post by Feir »

Seemed to have about a 33% success rate on the initial pine provided, and the beechwood and cherrywood i'd chopped myself. What i found most tedious about it was after spending the minute to get it lit, you have roughly a minute of fire with level 2 in fire starting. Now i'm quite sure with more levels you probably see some minor increases in duration and can probably start lighting entire bundles, but until you reach that point you've barely got enough time to do whatever recipe that requires the fire to begin with.
Ghrex
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 35
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2012 3:27 pm

Re: Observations from my 1st week

Post by Ghrex »

I'd like to see these lower level skills have a very high success rate and get more difficult along the way, depending on the material you foraged or item you wanted to make. This would make crafting and gathering actually worth the IMMENSE amount of time and effort it takes to gather and make stuff.
Seren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 25
Joined: Sat Feb 18, 2012 12:53 pm

Re: Observations from my 1st week

Post by Seren »

If you're having trouble starting a fire, try using the burning fires around the game. I think there are three.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Observations from my 1st week

Post by Snaek »

Feir wrote: The following are a number of observations I’ve made over the previous week since I’ve decided to try SI again to see how it has progressed. First, I’m extremely disappointed this is now being considered a beta, with the number of bugged mechanics and what I view as horribly designed or poorly balanced systems this feels much more like a mid-alpha. Not sure why the decision to change the game’s status was rushed so much but being sub-par for a game in beta it will likely deter at least a handful of potential long-term players.
I instantly regretted calling in Beta the moment I did so. To me it's just another stage in the game, but to some it's a more official meaning that I shouldn't have used lightly. However, we started alpha 1.5 years ago. We started with this idea 5 years ago. We're all in this part time. I'm not saying that in our defense. That much time invested in something drives you to want to put it out there for others to enjoy. We're still very much testing things as we go, but we decided when we made the call to open that we cared more about the role play side of the game than we do about making a perfect combat system. That's not to say we can't have both in time or won't continue to work on improving our mechanics. It's just where our priorities lie. It's a juggling act, but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to see what keeps players coming back and what drives them away.
Feir wrote:As for the issues I’ve seen I would first recommend a post previously started by Ghrex, it goes in to further detail than I’d planned to on what I perceive to be a number of the flaws in the current magic/prayer system (excessive failures during casting and far too many spells to level long-term). I believe as he mentioned in one of his solutions instead of leveling each individual spell, condensing them in to their various schools and leveling the school of magic would likely be one of the easiest and best solutions available.
We're not interested in a domain skill like spellcasting was in dragon's gate, or any smaller versions of it. Magic branches in several directions for a reason. If you want to know all spells it's going to take time. If you choose to specialize, you'll reach higher results faster. We're already making changes based on the feedback we've been receiving. Specifically to the success rates and increasing returns as you advance spells. I realize we need to get some lists out there for you so you can better see where each branch leads. It's on the list.
Feir wrote:Which brings me to gathering, something I’ve spent the majority of my return to SI doing to get a feel for the gathering and crafting system, while initially somewhat excited to see a fairly new and unique system it was quickly replaced by disgust which has grown the more I’ve used it. As it currently stands the entire system is so flawed it requires extensive reworking or should be scrapped entirely so players know not to waste their time. First, gathering a specific material seems to be a non-option, at level 4 wood cutting in a specific location I began finding beechwood, at 5 this progressed to cherrywood, at 6 and through most of 7, I’ve found absolutely nothing, similarly with mining I did not successfully find anything until reaching level 10. I’ve attempted to “chop beechwood or chop cherrywood” and it results in failure every time, in a location where I know for certain I was able to find it in the past. Second, is the unnecessary gathering skills, bundling should just be command available to all at start It makes little sense that it should need to be unlocked. Speculating is horrible and that it needs to be leveled and does so as slowly as many of the gathering skills only adds to the problem. Finally, the amount of time involved in attempting to level a gathering skill (which is significantly faster than leveling crafting and will discuss that shortly). At this point the only reasonable method of training is through mechanics abuse, and even doing this makes leveling a single gathering skill far slower than most spells or combat oriented skills.
I'll take a look at success rates. Trade skills did not get a final walk through before opening. Gathering specific resource has never been the plan and never will be. I'm not sure I need to explain why here. let's just say if cherries were the highest valued resource in the game, there would be a term for looking for them specifically with foraging. We do plan to advance skills with each tick of a successful attempt to make up for the need to abuse mechanics to advance yourself. We wouldn't want to encourage that and look down upon doing so obviously. Especially when noted in advance.
Feir wrote:On to crafting, I wish I had more to say about it but after some time of using gathered materials to start fires for glass blowing/cooking or carving stones the only craft attempt that has been successful aside from a few fires was making the boiled meat with the materials provided shortly after character creation. Again, it seems the only way to level crafting at all is via abuse of mechanics so that you aren’t wasting coin on material that could have just been sold. With most craft attempts appearing to require at least 1 minute, succeed or fail it seems likely people will be reaching near level 100 in spells or combat skills before a dedicated crafter can even hope to compete with NPC shops in the academy. Using some rough estimates and speculation I’m going to say it takes roughly 144000 uses to go from lvl 11 to 50 in a skill/spell. At 1 minute per attempt that’s 144000 minutes or 100 days of non-stop crafting (again only an estimate as I do not know the exact increase in skill requirements as you progress in level), in comparison to say close combat which would appear to require less than 1 week of non-stop swinging to make the same gain of 11-50. Obviously we can argue that close combat takes longer due to needing to find targets and health/stam regen, but the extended time is even more pronounced in crafting where you sometimes require multiple gathering and craft skills to make a single attempt. Obviously I can’t say much as to the value of items once crafted but to really make crafts viable any recipe should yield a higher return selling to the shops than if you were to have directly sold the materials to the shop and foregone crafting entirely. Finally on crafting there is again a lot of redundancy in the skills, there appears to be at least 7 or 8 craft skills many of which seem to produce items of little to no use to the player base. While nice for RP purposes maybe, the time involved for making items of limited use is far too great.
I'll look into success rates. You make some good points that need to be addressed. Again a list of how the tree branches is sorely needed. On the list, prioritized. As for the redundancy in skills, it was even worse in Alpha. We condensed a few, took out some others completely. Still we approach crafting the same way we do magic. You are not suppose to be a jack of all trades, and if you are it's going to take a long time. You can choose to specialize.

If it helps at all, generally your gathering skill is what unlocks the crafting skills, and they are from a related skill. Foraging starts it all. From there you learn digging. From digging you gain mining (these two are being considered to be combined), and mining unlocks blacksmithing, which unlocks the different types of armor crafting. Side note here armor crafting is not implemented yet. If you've played skyrim, armor will be crafted by material in a similar fashion.
Feir wrote:Possible solutions to crafting/gathering:
Eliminate speculation, upon initial use of a gathering skill in an area have it produce a list of gatherable items using that skill similar to how crafting lists work. Example –
>chop
With your current wood cutting skill you’re able to discover the following materials in this area.

Material Level Potential # Gathered Probability of Success
Beechwood 2 1-3 65%
Cherrywood 3 1-3 50%

While not all that information is necessary it would be nice, alternatively instead of a detailed number on how many can be gathered it could grouped in to classes such as “A few (1-3)” “Many (4-6)” “A lot (7-9)”, similar could be done for success rate with nearly impossible being below 5%, difficulty being 6-20%, unlikely being 21-40%, average being 41-60%, moderate being 61-80%, good being 81-95%, and easy being 96-100% to maintain the roleplay aspect of it. After seeing this initial list the player would have to attempt to specifically gather the material they want, perhaps with some possibility of gathering something different available in the area based upon their skill level such as mining for a gem with a nearly impossible rating due to rarity and instead ending up with granite which would be far more common.
That's good and all, but we're naught but humble pirates.
Feir wrote:I apologize if any of this feedback seems overly harsh or critical of the systems currently in place. I realize the game is still in its infancy and understand the level of work required by staff to make a game that is good or successful, let alone both. If I didn’t see some promise in the game and what it could become I wouldn’t have bothered with feedback at all and just moved on.
First read through it felt a little harsh, but I realize you wouldn't spend this kind of time and thought on something you didn't want to see succeed. Your feedback is appreciated and I hope you'll keep checking in to see how things are developing. There's some fun events you could be taking part in while you're waiting on mechanics to meet expectations.
Post Reply