New Armour Values and Changes

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by SquallScribe »

Swamp,

On a hunt with a level 10, possibly level 12 priest, where we were testing armor damage against vampires (including a control of unarmored) the damage was out-healed. This is coupled with the DR of the weapon user and shield block readied, but the priest was able to heal the damage inflicted against one, possibly two vampires while the combatant was unarmored.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Swamp Ape wrote:
SquallScribe wrote: A level 10 priest in healing can out-heal vampire damage even when someone is wearing 'new' value armor - or even no armor at all.
I would like to challenge this statement as being untrue. There is no way a level a 10 priest in healing will out-heal vampire damage. Especially with no armor. This is a very bold and irresponsible statement to make without some kind of proof to back it up. Show me an unarmored level 10 priest out-healing a vampire. I am significantly higher level than level 10 and I'm not even sure if I can do that effectively. I have not tested it so I am not sure if can or not.
The statement isn't untrue, it isn't bold nor is it remotely close to irresponsible. I'll gladly post the logs for you tomorrow, Swamp's person. It isn't hard at all for a low-level priest to out-heal the damage done to an unarmoured warrior, caster or truthfully anyone with moderate shield block or dodge. Which if you'd notice was the example given - the use of 'someone' - above since this situation actually happened in-game and was what was referenced. But you haven't tested, so please do in the future or be entirely aware of the facts given before calling someone's statement irresponsible, bold and untrue.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

As an aside, unless a silent priest adjustment has gone in then priest healing works similar to mage spell damage. There isn't much difference between the levels after a certain point, no matter how wide the gap. That's the entire purpose of implementing spell evolution.
User avatar
Shadowbane
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 397
Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Shadowbane »

But you haven't tested, so please do in the future or be entirely aware of the facts given before calling someone's statement irresponsible, bold and untrue.
I don't think this is necessary. As Swamp plays a priest, I'd be inclined to pay attention to his opinion, just as I'd pay attention to a mage player's opinion and those of melee or thieves in regards to their respective classes. As they main the class, they probably have a decent understanding of it. It's probably safe to assume that for the average priest in the average group in an uncontrolled environment, all of 10 levels will make it more than difficult in regards to keeping a group up under constant vampire assault. Playing healer isn't JUST about heals, you have buffs and rejuvenation to keep up on as well. Mages don't HAVE to help with vigor. Everyone plays their class differently, too. As far as I know, Swamp's character utilizes bite in his physical attacks instead of weapons for RP purposes.

I also don't think a short series of controlled tests is a good thing to base any argument off of. It's a nice start, but not everyone is fighting only one or two vampires. A test group that's too narrow will get very narrow results, and narrow test results are not something I'd want to see used when it comes to game mechanics. I'd want as many aspects of something looked at as possible, to find the best solution that doesn't put one play style up high while essentially crapping on another.
Image
Hierophant of Itzal
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Shadowbane wrote:
But you haven't tested, so please do in the future or be entirely aware of the facts given before calling someone's statement irresponsible, bold and untrue.
I don't think this is necessary. As Swamp plays a priest, I'd be inclined to pay attention to his opinion, just as I'd pay attention to a mage player's opinion and those of melee or thieves in regards to their respective classes. As they main the class, they probably have a decent understanding of it. It's probably safe to assume that for the average priest in the average group in an uncontrolled environment, all of 10 levels will make it more than difficult in regards to keeping a group up under constant vampire assault. Playing healer isn't JUST about heals, you have buffs and rejuvenation to keep up on as well. Mages don't HAVE to help with vigor. Everyone plays their class differently, too. As far as I know, Swamp's character utilizes bite in his physical attacks instead of weapons for RP purposes.

I also don't think a short series of controlled tests is a good thing to base any argument off of. It's a nice start, but not everyone is fighting only one or two vampires. A test group that's too narrow will get very narrow results, and narrow test results are not something I'd want to see used when it comes to game mechanics. I'd want as many aspects of something looked at as possible, to find the best solution that doesn't put one play style up high while essentially crapping on another.
Swamp Ape wrote:I am significantly higher level than level 10 and I'm not even sure if I can do that effectively.I have not tested it so I am not sure if can or not.
That's fine that Swamp's character utilises bite for his character, but his character isn't the lone priest nor is that particular playstyle indicative of the ability of priests overall. No one's calling for priests to be nerfed in this thread or adjusted, so I'm not particularly sure the rush to say another player is being irresponsible, bold and untrue. It's more a testament to the incredibly loose damage range (and the low high-end of spells, a subject both Blink and Faran's players have brought up before), and reaffirms how it needs to be tightened up. But that isn't the point of this thread, because again no one is advocating or wanting to see priests nerfed - because their healing isn't the problem. This thread was to bring to light how the changes in armour are so drastic and hopefully not as intended.

You're right, a short series of controlled tests isn't a good thing to base any argument off of. It's a good thing this hunt lasted for two hours and I've previous five straight hours of sitting with a priest testing through various classes and how much that priest could heal, from melee to casters from level 10 to level 90, single or multiple targets. Unarmoured or old armoured, and it wouldn't change much if any with 'new' armour since another priest out-healed damage done to an unarmoured character still. The only control in this hunt is that the two people testing armour differences knew the armour was off, because dying isn't real big on my things to do in-game. If you'd like to add a bit of a humourous and actually relevant spin to it, I'm almost entirely positive the priest didn't even realise I had my armour off since there was so much scroll. They kept on casting shields, rejuv and healing another player. But again, this isn't about nerfing priests but if we're going to say people are being irresponsible in statements and untruthful, well, I'll correct that when it simply isn't the case.

I love numbers, I don't like skewing numbers, I like numbers to be balanced and most of all I really love fair play for all in a balanced system with drawbacks for each class, complementary abilities and areas where each class can also excel. It's why I started this thread, because I don't think there's any fair play - whether intended or not - in a system which has effectively made all armour past a certain low tiers protect for 18-20%, as Faran's player posted, regardless of material. Because if it was working as intended as explained in an answered assist, with simply a switch around with a few point difference expected then for arcsilver as the example we'd be seeing 2.5/3 point difference overall. Which again is noticeable, but easily adapted to. With these changes there's an increase of around seven and a half points and a drop in percentage protected overall of 30%.

Since there's been no further posts from staff, I'm hopeful this is something that's being looked into and in the future more transparency will be offered.

But please don't act like this was some five, ten or even twenty minute test, don't act like like results were cherry picked. Please don't act like anyone here is trying to get priests nerfed when they weren't even the point of this thread (the only thing mentioned is how this armour change will make it increasingly difficult for solo hunters in mid-range hunting grounds to actually be able to hunt with any sort of positive net gain or success, and I'm not a solo hunter). And if someone is going to say another perosn's statement is untrue, bold and irresponsible and then end their own post by saying they haven't tested the argument they're making (which was not even relevant to the original point), then please don't be surprised when it causes a little agitation and a response pointing out that the other parties have in fact tested it for some length of time, specifically and with intent.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Bocon L »

So you're telling me that a person with good DR and defensive skills is easily kept alive? If I could post the ORLY owl here, I would do that. That proves absolutely nothing. You could just as easily sit and mend wounds with proper levels, while a level 10 mage killed it.

I cannot solo anything past a lesser vampire with my skill levels as a priest. Even then, if I'm only using holy strike, I still have to retreat to heal most of the time. I cannot heal AND do damage AND vigor myself AND try to turn and expect to live. Our heal heals for 20 points of damage on average and lesser vampires hit me anywhere from 0 to 30+ through armor. If I'm lucky, I can solo one without the need to retreat. If I'm unlucky, I have to run within a few hits. Did I mention it takes 15 or more holy strikes to even kill one? Let's also bring up that priest spell failure rates are far higher than a mage at the equivalent level. I'm not really going to get into the failure rates, pure randomness of success and the amount of uncontrollable things that occur, when you do get a turn off.

Every other class in the game is able to hunt other mobs, while we are stuck with the crypt or vampires. After many, many, many runs in both areas solo, I made more on average per 2 hours of hunting in the crypt, than I did in vampires. As a mage or melee, you can easily hunt other MOBS that pay similarly and don't hit nearly as hard. So I don't understand why you would pick the hardest MOB in the game for anyone to solo, to test on and base your assumptions around.

The comment made about priests being better off than mages with the armor change was unbelievably ignorant and had no real thought put behind it. Priests get the worst DR progression and have the lowest damage output in the game, other than a very lucky turn proc. It would take you far less time to kill something and heal, than it would for me to do the exact same thing. There's so many false, made up "Facts" in this thread, it makes me think that someone is running for office.

I'm sorry you guys are hurt and don't agree with the changes, but belittling people for having a difference of opinion is really childish. There's a lot of self entitlement going on in here too, which I am having a hard time understanding.
Could it have been patched in a more informative way? Sure. But we are players in somebody else's game and are subject to the changes those people deem to make. Does it suck that the armor advertised at the peddles isn't up to standards? Yep. But I'd like to have faith that things like that would be fixed through a simple PM, notifying them that it might have been a mistake. They might possibly adjust MOB damage to compensate as well, we just don't know and will have to wait to find out.

The biggest downfall I see from this, however, is that people are going to instantly explode in PvP if it's anything other than a 1 on 1.

Thanks for reading.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Swamp Ape »

Allow me to clarify. I have not tested it in a sense that I have not stood there while a Vampire beat on me to see if I could out-heal it's damage output. I can hunt there but I am moving, attacking, running, healing etc.

I still call bullshit that a level 10 healer can out-heal Vampire damage ESPECIALLY unarmored and if you're going to back up your "proof" and use a character with moderate defenses to prove your statement then quite frankly this debate is flawed. I called it irresponsible because it gives non-priest players a false perception of what a priest is capable of.

I did not intend to derail this so lets bring it back around to my original point that is more in line with the OP's topic. I challenged the irresponsible statement that a level 10 healer could out-heal vampire damage while wearing the new armor and/or unarmored. I did not challenge that a level 10 healer could keep a moderately skilled player alive in vampires.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Swamp Ape »

I'm sitting here at my computer and I still have the feeling that I need to be clear on what my point was. I think some of these responses have diluted it into something that it was not and some of the responses have additional variables added to make the counter-argument appear to be more valid. These variables were not included in the original debate and should be dismissed. Defensive rating and defensive skill levels being two examples of variables that I was not talking about but were later added to the formula.

I do not believe a level 10 Priest heal can out-heal the damage output of a Vampire on an unarmored PC. I made the statement that I did not think I could do that even at my level with my Priest but I was unsure since I have not tested it by standing there unarmored. I based my observation on my experience by spending actual hunting hours in the vampires.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Bocon L wrote:The comment made about priests being better off than mages with the armor change was unbelievably ignorant and had no real thought put behind it.
Okay, so I'm going to get to the rest of the responses later because I'm too tired to fully engage right now.

It's one thing when there's misinformation passed off in-game as roleplay. It's another thing entirely when a comment OOC is conjured out of thin air or either entirely so purposely misconstrued that remarking on it in such a way adds nothing to the conversation at all.

No one said priests were better off than mages with the armour changes. No one at all. Since that comment does not exist, it cannot be 'unbelievably ignorant and had no real thought put behind it'. The only comments about mages in this thread are these (outside of Shadowbane mentioning mage players and my own talking about prayers/spells having minimal gain after a certain level):
SquallScribe wrote:In regards to playstyles and mechanical balancing: There are a number of race/class combinations that do not have two defenses, or a defense set that procs against more than one type of damage. Assassins are one, so are mages. In the case of mages, they will almost always be hit by a melee character that is attacking them - even if they spend the ungodly amount of time required to slightly improve their DR with unarmed combat. Armor does not detract from the talents of a priest, nor make them useless in PVE or PVP, even with the 'old' armor values.
This was a comment after priests were randomly thrown into this conversation. It was an explanation that multiple classes - not only priests - only have one defence or similar defence procs (assassins with parry/dual parry), and that a priest is always welcomed, wanted and in many cases needed, and wont be replaced by high end armour or wound mending*. "In the case of mages" was then a comparison to the aforementioned assassins, since mages will almost always be hit by melee attacking them where that is not the case for assassins. It also applies to priest who, for the record, have a slightly better AR/DR progression than mages - unless it's been changed.

The above quoted comment was a response to your own post which acted like priests were made useless or had their worth devalued under the 'old' armour system. Her response was informing you that it was not the case, that even high end 'old' armour priests were very much considered a valuable piece of a hunting party. It wasn't a response saying mages were better off than priests, it's a response to your point trying to argue that old armour made you fear priests would be, in your own words:
Bocon L wrote:Playing a preist, it's nice to know that I'm not going to be replaced by high armor values combined with wound mending.
Because you weren't going to anyway under the 'old' armour system. That's what that part of her response was addressing. There isn't anything at all about priests being better off than mages in this system.

*Wound mending once upon a time was actually better than priest's healing overall. That was corrected several months ago. Because it wasn't fair, wound mending shouldn't outheal priests, there was a two second delay added to it in combat so people couldn't sit and outheal a MOB or multiple MOBs on them - which they were able to do until it was fixed.
Requiem
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 53
Joined: Thu Sep 19, 2013 2:18 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Requiem »

Well I thought the original post was well written, brought up valid concerns, and was informative. I for one had no idea that there were changes currently occurring to armor protection values. I'm not sure how the post was interpreted as a direct or indirect call to nerf priests. The main point I walked away with was that the new armor protection values for store bought armor was too similar to peddle armor that costs exponentially more. I'm glad the OP brought it up, now its up to staff to determine if thats the way they want it or not.
Locked