Hello, boys and girls!
Yes, it's me, the super fabulous Pahzrael!
You may remember me from such wonderful past experiences as the great armor breaking of 2014 and the various assists I may have helped many of you with in the past.
First, of all, I would like to thank everyone for their input and feedback on the newer areas. I have been watching many of you from the shadows, popcorn in hand, so I have a very good idea how hard a time, and how fun a time a lot of you have been having with the newer areas.
I am very anal, as it were, about testing things. Sometimes though, unexpected variables and last minute changes affect things, so the feedback goes a long way in getting things to where we want them. Please keep it up. The more information we gather the better for everyone!
That being said, we are pretty happy with the difficulty level of the warthogs. Yes, it is extremely tough by design, but this is due to their extremely rare drop. Its actual value by shop or by person is still a work in process, and we are likely to see it worth the while for groups to hunt in the near future. For now, the risk involved is related to the desire for the ivory, or the enjoyment of the hunt.
As for the troglodytes vs. vampires, I will look into it a little closer. The damage should be similar, and the payout should be tighter than the vampires. Also, if the weaponry is too heavy, and you prefer to hunt longer without stopping, there is an area where those heavy items can be easily disposed of within the tower.
Thanks again for the feedback, everyone!
I would have said more, but I fear I may have said too much already!
Enjoy!
Pahzrael, the Armor Breaker
Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)
-
Nikolas Suyessod
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am
Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)
The north and south holds are five rooms each, so there are eleven rooms (thirteen if we count rooms directly outside the doors) if we include the secret passage. You cannot spam the rooms in the same area with limitless abandon and expect for something to spawn. It's why going back and forth in the same two or three rooms in, say, vampires doesn't work out with any consistency or efficiency. You have to keep moving to different spots. The rest of the tower works the same - it's in a straight wrap-around line and not the open space of lower vampires or the quadrants of statues.Shadowbane wrote:The tower is pretty much broken up into three areas; the north hold, the south hold, and the corridor section between the two (not counting the hall above that leads to bats and the roof). One could say the north and south holds are one area, thanks to that nifty little passage they have, though avoiding the passage is a lot like avoiding a door (as in it can be done). So it's actually not hard to avoid other people if hunting parties are mutually mindful of each other.
Yes, I'm quite aware that avoiding passages, just like doors, can be done. Here's the thing. If you want to make these comments because my character ran by yours three times in about ten minutes yesterday, that's cool. I don't think it's coincidental you're making these comments. As anyone who has ever hunted in the same area as my character knows, I'm very much for looking in what direction you're going and trying to avoid people. Blink might tell you he's experienced the COUNTING. I think it's the polite thing to do not only from an IC perspective but also, and mostly, from an OOC one. Spawning can be rough. You should try to avoid spamming other rooms with people in them. So my character would try to talk to people about it because I think, as players, we all want to have a good time hunting. Most characters didn't seem to agree with the look before you move each time move and it's whatever, I eventually worked with it and we treated each other the same.
It wasn't that way for all characters. I'm not going to stop, be polite and look in each direction anymore for someone with the philosophy of it 'it's okay when I do it, but not okay when they do it to me because I'm hunting by myself and there's two of them so they can handle it.' It doesn't work like that. If you'd like it to be extended both ways, that's great. Let's do that. I have no problem doing that at all. I'm compulsive enough and on some days I'm even a rather nice person that looking every way before I move in hunting isn't a problem at all. In fact, I think we should all do it. But if you're going to try to shame me for yesterday in these not-so-subtle comments directly after it happens, I'm going to address it.
The statues do move, yes, though at a frequency much less than the others, that's a fair point. But my reason for bringing this up is it's quite easy to see in comparison to other hunting grounds as to what can possibly spawn in that room. When you look into another room at statues, you know there's X chance you'll spawn X statue based on X number of statues being physically in the room.Shadowbane wrote:The reason I compare the spawn pattern to statues is because more movement means more spawning. Yes, the statues spawn from actual room items (there are one or two super sneaky ones in there though) but the statues also move around the area once animated. The longer you're there, the more active they are, and the more challenging it is to appropriately leveled characters. The challenge increases with another party there, because movement makes them spawn faster than if you just stand there and wait. Eventually, a group will congregate in a different room and that is when another party passing through multiple times will raise the risk levels of the ones already there.
You seem to have a mage around enough, hopefully you'll be able to hunt with one soon. As for damage, that's interesting. I can hunt them fine with a steel dirk, and in fact did with another non-mage the other day (who had a lot of difficulty hitting them, which was to be expected and was perfectly fine) for about ninety minutes. Well, I switched between the dirk and the blacksteel. It helps to replenish vigor and there's always bottles, as well, whether you buy them in a shop or use the ones that drop occasionally whilst hunting. As for damage to the creatures themselves as well, the troglodyte armour seems to be set lower than the vampires simply based on the type of damage which gets through, such as a higher tier of damage/messages.Shadowbane wrote:In regards to damage, I don't have a mage or priest follow me around and provide constant defense or stamina with a spell.
I've not seen a troglodyte hit over 18 that I can recall, where vampires will hit over twenty. Vampires also hit much more frequently unless something has changed. No, your experiences aren't the same as everyone else's due to your class and that's understandable. But as someone who has shield block available for vampires and then took off the shield and tested with a single parry alone at troglodytes, I can tell you it's significantly easier to hunt troglodytes (unless vampires have been adjusted recently). Which is problematic based on the pay.Shadowbane wrote:On average, I take similar amounts of damage between trogs and vampires in a given amount of time under similar circumstances. I'm ahead with trogs because my defenses allow me to hunt there with an appropriate amount of challenge, even with having to make a run to sell in less than 45 minutes. My experiences are clearly not anyone else's, because my class is very different from the others. If I wanted a warrior's experience, I would have made another gargoyle or gone with a vukasin or gavial and played a warrior again.
You're right, there is a difference between being challenged and being restrictive. There's also a difference in something being a challenge and something just being tedious or not engaging (please see the paragraph which follows). Combat lacks dynamic for the most part. That's just a fact, a known one and it's something we have to deal with and hopefully is worked around in the future. The warthog isn't challenging in this way - it doesn't have any dynamic. It just takes a long time to kill and hits for the same as a vampire sometimes. That's fine. I like killing them, I really do. The image in my head is funny when fighting it for whatever reason. I like the new area, I think it's welcomed by most.Shadowbane wrote:As for my stance, it obviously wasn't completely understood and it needs to be explained more clearly. I have always been in favor of challenging areas, but there is a difference between being challenged and being restricted. 'Characters in general' applies to those who have the means to hunt in areas others can't (and that's actually most classes). They've had hunting options where others didn't because of restrictions. Eventually, those others severely out leveled the only places they could hunt and also had it easy. I want challenges, but I don't want to be excluded from a hunting area because of my mechanics, which is what we dealt with for a while. So my opinion is the same. I'm glad for the tougher areas not just for parry-only users but for those with shield and consistent damage. If you want something easy and lucrative, stick with what works. Not everyone finds it rewarding to just succeed in managing themselves in tougher areas . Some just want the money, and that is perfectly fine. But let's face it, people are usually either quick to bore with no challenge or they get conditioned to something easy and balk when they encounter something hard (note that hard is different from 'not supposed to work'). I'm glad we're closer to an even blend that accommodates everyone a bit easier.
This doesn't mean Blink's criticism and review of it wasn't fair or wasn't accurate. It's a balance issue. Staff presumably wants people of appropriate level to hunt in these areas. However, people like to be efficient and people don't like wasting their time. Bone has been lamented over in regards to being difficult to gather enough as it is compared to the other crafting materials. Hard beasts, even ones that take a long time to kill, are great - if the time spent invested returns an appropriate result. Otherwise it's a novelty and novelty wears off and people stop visiting.
The same is true for melee - except for perhaps large races, which is fine. Even with an electrum one-hander I still got messages of no damage. Such a high armoured creature with the damage variables for melee or the low, yet consistent, damage of mages can be discouraging - no matter how much you're used to it. Damage will hopefully be fixed in the future, but for now it is what it is.Blink wrote:There is no race combination of mage that will do anything but minor wounds to warthogs, no matter how high level.
If it's meant to be a MOB which requires a group to kill with any consistency or quickness, that's cool. I'd hope the payout would properly reflect that kind of requirement, though. Perhaps if the idea is that ivory is rare and the creature is quite hard to kill whilst requiring a group, it'd be better for it to be a rare MOB spawn with a significant drop to make it seem more appropriately like a challenge and engaging encounter.
I also think that's likely, yes, but I do think the constructive criticism given to them now considering the circumstances is appropriate and fair. MOBs are easier to adjust for balance in both the short and long term than it is to adjust player skills, classes or races. Those decisions generally have to be made with the long term only in mind.Blink wrote:I think what is more likely is that this area was implemented with the long game in mind and after the damage changes mages will be able to hunt warthogs reasonably well, especially skilled ones like myself.
Assassins are not a unique snowflake which is the only class which is lacking. All classes are lacking. All classes are incomplete. Many people have trudged through the game, and many people don't like each other (though we should all try to show up to support events of others). Everyone has received 'promises' or pretty words suggesting something is coming in the relatively near future. It's come up unfulfilled for them all. There's no one that's been left untouched. Every person here that's been playing for a significant period of time has 'sucked it up' and worked with incomplete skills. It's just how it works here for now. It isn't a badge of honour that only one class is wearing. We've all gone through it together.Shadowbane wrote:I get wanting to stay interested in a game, but you're right. I don't have a lot of sympathy for most other classes. I've trudged through a game I don't find fun as much as I should because of the very small number of players I actually have fun with, and because I keep getting promises of "soon" for my class. I've sucked it up and worked through incomplete skills and mechanics, mostly solo, for something that isn't even guaranteed.
I agree with this idea. Which is why maybe making the warthog - or some other creature - a rare spawn which is difficult to kill with a significant payout would be the way to go. It wouldn't be unlike finding rare spawns of wood, food, ore or gemstones. I think that's a good idea and would make sense.Shadowbane wrote:I don't think higher end materials should be easy to get solo, personally, and I think ivory should fall into that category. They're high end for a reason. The second they're easy to get (and flood the market) is the second they lose value. To be worth more than bone, it should require a group, or careful tactics and a ridiculous amount of potions.
Thank you. From my experience it isn't, and I even made sure to fight with only one defence active for an appropriate comparison.Pahzrael wrote:As for the troglodytes vs. vampires, I will look into it a little closer. The damage should be similar, and the payout should be tighter than the vampires. Also, if the weaponry is too heavy, and you prefer to hunt longer without stopping, there is an area where those heavy items can be easily disposed of within the tower.
It's good, also, that there's openness to looking into bumping ivory around. I'm sure bone carves will appreciate it.
Re: Heart of Stirling Forest Feedback (SPOILERS)
The current value of ivory isn't that big of a problem, since we've been told it's part of the very next update. You can just store it, and I'm sure it'll be given a good price.
It is a good goal to get people group hunting, and I group hunt often. It is disappointing to me though, since my character is heavily specialized in skinning and I was looking forward to the ivory. I didn't have any exact number in mind on what it'd be worth, just that I'd finally able to earn a decent hunting living on skinning. I can and will hunt with groups for ivory, but not everyone wants to hunt such things. And really the big issue is I play all sorts of times, often at times when there isn't people around, assuming I can find them.
So, if this is how it must be with ivory, I'd like some kind of carved material in value between troll bone and ivory, or a source of ivory that is obtainable to a solo person somehow. Yes, there is chitin, but we don't know it's real value yet as it can't be worked, and just sells for 5.
Another thing. Elves are actually meant to have a magic damage modifier, similar to how large races have a weapon modifier. Unfortunately for me, it's been made clear this change is way down the list, past the updates current on the list. So yes, I'll likely be able to hunt ivory solo at some point, but it'll just kinda suck for me if i have to wait a year or more.
Thanks for listening Pahzrael. I'm trying to be constructive and not complain too much, but skinning is the big thing I do in recent times, so it's very important to me.
It is a good goal to get people group hunting, and I group hunt often. It is disappointing to me though, since my character is heavily specialized in skinning and I was looking forward to the ivory. I didn't have any exact number in mind on what it'd be worth, just that I'd finally able to earn a decent hunting living on skinning. I can and will hunt with groups for ivory, but not everyone wants to hunt such things. And really the big issue is I play all sorts of times, often at times when there isn't people around, assuming I can find them.
So, if this is how it must be with ivory, I'd like some kind of carved material in value between troll bone and ivory, or a source of ivory that is obtainable to a solo person somehow. Yes, there is chitin, but we don't know it's real value yet as it can't be worked, and just sells for 5.
Another thing. Elves are actually meant to have a magic damage modifier, similar to how large races have a weapon modifier. Unfortunately for me, it's been made clear this change is way down the list, past the updates current on the list. So yes, I'll likely be able to hunt ivory solo at some point, but it'll just kinda suck for me if i have to wait a year or more.
Thanks for listening Pahzrael. I'm trying to be constructive and not complain too much, but skinning is the big thing I do in recent times, so it's very important to me.