Page 2 of 2
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:12 pm
by
To the editor:
Aruskin has written a missive to your publication which included the words.
"Bihi could, of course, respond that while this may not be a matter of concern to the people of Pearl, it should be a matter of concern to them, and further that the Conclave, as prominent subjects of the King and citizens of Pearl, ought to take the lead in making this a matter of concern for the people. Should Bihi adopt this course, he might consider refraining from directly insulting the Conclave, either individually or collectively."
I can assure you, editor, that I did consider refraining from directly insulting the Conclave. As an editor of a distinguished newspaper, I'm sure you would agree that when people feel insulted by the truth, it is they that need to reconsider their views and actions, not the truth-teller. This is a body that expressed far more concern about the volume of clock bells than the lynching and caging without trial of people accused of no crime beyond their race. "Honorable" just wasn't the first word to come to my mind under such circumstances. I hope my mind is never so twisted.
As to one of the many missives sent to you by Emissary Blink, he contends: "Pearl does have Goblin citizens, believe it or not. If you have evidence that any of these Goblins are citizens, please bring it forward."
First, we are not citizens (We do not live in a democracy). We are subjects-- of the King. As subjects, the King supplies us with various privileges and benefits. One of the most significant benefits he provides is access to the Academy. I personally have seen goblins roaming the Academy, taking advantage of it many services. I have seen no announcements that goblins must make special application, or that they are to be treated any differently than any other Academy student. Yiri himself for a long time roamed the Academy grounds, sold his surplus at the academy shops, first learned his martial skills among the golem trainers. Therefore, I bring forward it forward to Emissary Blink that the King does indeed consider goblins among his subjects.
Sincerely,
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 1:18 pm
by
Bihi, my friend,
Whether you do or do not chose to insult the Conclave is, of course, your business. I simply advised you to refrain from insulting people you'd rather were on your side than against it. Beyond that, I've no interest in this dispute, other than an academic interest in the rhetorical elements.
--Aruskin
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 1:35 pm
by
to the editor
I do not know why Mr. Aruskin uses your pages to send personal messages to me. I can say this in clarification: it is not my intent to cater to, or appease, Conclave. My intent is to bring their incompetence to the attention of the King.
Sincerely,
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 3:30 pm
by
There are a few points I would like to clarify about the following statement sent in by Citizen Bihi.
I was there, as were most of the other Emissaries, when--two public meetings ago-- a member of the Conclave asked the Knight Marshal in attendance what was being done to capture Yiri. The Knight Marshal's own response was that they were rounding up goblins in Three Bridges for retribution. If Emissary Rochiriel's memory doesn't serve to remind her of the Knight Marshals taking direct responsibility for the injustices, any of the other Emissaries present could have reminded her. If they themselves were not aware of the injustices being inflicted on the goblins of Three Bridges-- The corpse then hanging from the scaffold in the center square of Three Bridges, or the caged goblins being guarded by uniformed marshals-- the only reason could be dereliction of duty. Emissary Rochiriel's rather desperate attempt in her letter to you to avoid her personal-- and professional-- responsibilities, is so transparent it only reinforces the contention that her prejudices-- as well as the prejudices of the other Emissaries-- are severely interfering with their responsibilities. Does she claim confusion on whether the lynching and caging are legal acts of the Marshals? Where are the arrest warrants then? When was the Capital Trial conducted? Why was the execution not publicly announced. Emissary's Rochiriel's bigotry blinds her. As a mere cartographer; it is unreasonable to demand I bring sight to the intentionally blind.
The first point I would like to make is that at no point did any Knight Marshal admit to rounding up goblins in Three Bridges for retribution. Those are your words or interpretation of the words that were said. Knight Marshal Cascius stated only that goblins were being rounded up, some were killed in the process, none were the outlaw Yiri they sought. Why some were killed in the process we are unclear on. Perhaps they resisted being questioned about Yiri. Perhaps they attacked the Knight Marshals. Perhaps they were wanted for their own prior crimes. We don't know for sure. My point is that you are twisting the words that were said that evening by Knight Marshal Cascius. Perhaps if you hadn't fallen asleep on numerous occasions you might remember his words a little more clear.
My second point is Conclave is responsible for the citizens of Pearl and the City Pearl only. We are there to make sure the voice of the citizens of Pearl are heard on issues pertaining to them and the city. We do not make laws nor is it our responsibility to make sure they are being followed. The Knight Marshals office is responsible for the entire Isle as it falls under King Sauntere's rule with the exception of temple lands. They report directly to the King. It is not conclaves job to make sure that each Knight Marshal is performing his or her duty in accordance to the law set forth by King Sauntere.
My third point is to point out that you seem to not understand the very definition of a Monarchy. There are no arrest warrants. If the Knight Marshals wish to speak with you for whatever reason then you must comply. A Capital Trial is not a right that has been granted to anybody. King Sauntere himself may graciously allow for such a trial to take place but there is no guarantee for such. Not every execution is publicly announced unless King Sauntere wishes it to be so.
Each student that decides, after graduation from the academy, to venture over to Pearl is granted offered citizenship in the great City of Pearl. As a citizen you must abide by the law of the land or risk losing such a privilege as Yiri has. The amount of time spent within the city or the academy really has no impact on your ability to become a citizen. You may spend your entire life doing good deeds and training relentlessly the skills that help you in your chosen profession and still not be a citizen. Likewise if you choose to break the law of the land your citizenship may be stripped from you by the Knight Marshals or King Sauntere himself should he choose to be involved in such matters.
You may throw around your insults however you like. Your opinion of how I do my job within conclave means little to me. I answer to those of my temple, the Knight Marshals office and King Sauntere.
Sincerely,
Emissary Rochiriel Azahar
Faithful servant of Our Glorious Mother Tetherias
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 5:18 pm
by
To the editor:
I would ask your readers to consider carefully the missive sent to you by Emissary Rochiriel. She claims I'm twisting words. I have found through experience that no one can twist words like a committed racist. Let's study Emissary Rochiriel's claims for a moment. In her own words: " Knight Marshal Cascius stated only that goblins were being rounded up, some were killed in the process, none were the outlaw Yiri they sought. Why some were killed in the process we are unclear on." This begs the question: why were goblins being rounded up? Goblins in another town far from Pearl, a town another Conclave member claims isn't even in the Kinght's jurisdiction? This would be a question obvious to an honorable person, but one a committed racist would be blind to. She implies some goblins resisted arrest, and were reluctantly killed. But how does that explain the construction of a scaffold and a corpse hanging from it? How reluctant can a lynching be?! Again Emissary Rochiriel is willfully blind to these facts; willfully, despicably blind. She is the one twisting words, hoping to blind your readers as well.
On her second point, she ends a rambling paragraph with this: "It is not conclaves job to make sure that each Knight Marshal is performing his or her duty in accordance to the law set forth by King Sauntere." I can only respond AGAIN with the King's own charge to Conclave: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment." She is willfully blind to the misconduct of the Knights Marshal as described above, which allows her to be willfully blind to the King's own charge to her. This blindness I contend, again, is despicable.
In her third point, she contends " Not every execution is publicly announced unless King Sauntere wishes it to be so." But is that not EXACTLY what I have been charging? That the Knights Marshal lynched people WITHOUT His Majesty's knowledge and consent? First she implies the lynchings and cagings to be unfortunate incidents, next she claims them to be lawful executions, executions the king is aware of and simply declines to share his reasoning with the public. Which is it?! If we are unsure which it is, why is the Emissary so reluctant to bring this potential injustice up with the King? The Emissary doesn't just twist words, she has constructed a rhetorical labyrinth of contradictory and evasive "logic." Is this not a favored-- if despicable-- tactic of all bigots?
Finally she contends "Each student that decides, after graduation from the academy, to venture over to Pearl is granted offered citizenship in the great City of Pearl." Again. We are not citizens of any democracy, we are subjects of a KING. Subjection is not restricted by geography. The Academy is the property of the King. If he allows goblins to make use of his academy, it is because he considers them his subjects. AGAIN: this issue of subjection is simple to resolve: ASK THE KING! FOLLOW THE KING'S WRITTEN DIRECTIVE TO CONCLAVE. One fact here is undisputed: that Emissary Rochiriel is grasping for every opportunity to avoid seeking the guidance of the King. That one undisputed fact slams through her twisting rhetorical labyrinth of deception like a tidal wave through a child's sand castle.
Sincerely,
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 7:11 pm
by
First, we are not citizens (We do not live in a democracy). We are subjects-- of the King. As subjects, the King supplies us with various privileges and benefits. One of the most significant benefits he provides is access to the Academy. I personally have seen goblins roaming the Academy, taking advantage of it many services. I have seen no announcements that goblins must make special application, or that they are to be treated any differently than any other Academy student. Yiri himself for a long time roamed the Academy grounds, sold his surplus at the academy shops, first learned his martial skills among the golem trainers. Therefore, I bring forward it forward to Emissary Blink that the King does indeed consider goblins among his subjects.
I'm quite aware that there have been Goblin citizens, and yes we are considered both subjects of the King and citizens of the great city of Pearl. This is why I brought it up. However, you are making an enormous leap of logic in assuming that every person on the entire Isle of New Archai is a citizen of Pearl. I don't think you'd assume every person in the Rum village is a citizen here or has ever been to the Academy, yet you seem to assume it of an entire other village. The truth is we just don't know.
At the next Conclave meeting I will asking for clarification on citizenship and be attempting to determine if any of Three Bridges are citizens. Unlike you, I assume they are not.
This thread has doubly convinced me of the value of filtering requests made to his Majesty. Based on the content of these posts, I believe if you were granted an audience with the King, you'd end up calling him a racist after he did not give in to all your demands. Nonetheless, despite your demeanor, I am doing my duty to the citizens. (And only the citizens)
Blink Walkabout
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 7:50 pm
by
to the editor
Again, Emissary Blink-- using your periodical to address me directly-- wants to put words in my mouth and refute those words instead of quoting me directly. This deceptive rhetorical tactic-- known as a 'straw man' argument (because the deceiver sets up a 'straw man' to attack because he feels unable to attack his or her opponents own words). When did I claim any resident of Three Bridges must be a subject of the King?
What I do claim is-- whether or not they are subjects-- the Knights Marshal lynching and caging is an injustice. It is not JUST to lynch and imprison random others for the crimes of Yiri. If they are subjects, the Knights Marshal have stepped beyond The King's Law in lynching and caging them without trial. If they are not subjects, the Knights Marshal have not only acted unjustly, they have overstepped their authority by committing acts of war without a formal declaration of such. To make war without the King's permission is an obvious injustice, because it puts all the King's subjects at unnecessary risk. In either circumstance, I believe your more honorable and thoughtful readers would agree: the King's edit to the Conclave should be obeyed (how many times must I repeat it?!): "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment."
Yet they refused to act when asked to do so. Refused to follow the King's edict to them when reminded of it.
Even after these many, long exchanges, I can find no other words to describe Conclave's inaction on this matter other than "despicable racism." They have already refuted such excuses as "laziness" and "ignorance" with their varied and detailed defenses of their inaction.
Now, I must retire from this debate for a short time, as I was recently murdered, and need to recuperate. Fortunately, despite (or because of?) my persistent critiques of-- and eventual resignation from-- the Aerthane Temple community, The Goddess of Air has chosen to bring me back to Achari to continue my work. I do not intend to let her down.
Sincerely,
Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 8:57 pm
by
Very well, I withdraw my offer then, since even you don't believe these are citizens.
Yes, run along now. Your little game has failed and there is nothing left to play at.
Blink Walkabout