Alright. It seems the responses have stopped so I want to post my response.
First and foremost, POISONS ARE NOT BROKEN. You have an issue with two poisons. Those two poisons being Gargoyle Sludge and Alcohol.
My understanding is NOT that poisons were a one shot/one attack but rather that most poisons are a single use. Meaning that you may only apply/attempt to apply a poison to your blade, or drink it, once before it can no longer be applied/drunk again. I sometimes go through seven or eight poisons while attempting to poison a weapon which is why I agree with the current timed use rather than the one strike per poison some folks believed how poisons are supposed to work. Yes, I'll get better at this skill but I don't think, like most skills, it will ever be close to 100% success rate.
During the OOC Games for April those who played experienced or witnessed the effects of Gargoyle Sludge and Alcohol. I confirmed with the poison user at the games that these were the only two poisons in possession and used for those games.
Being "slowed" is not one of the effects of those two poisons. Slow is a mage spell.
Gargoyle Sludge does not do any damage and does not knock you out. If you passed out during the games it was from Alcohol and you were drunk. If you had checked your health status you would have seen that "You are affected by: Drunk". I confirmed this a couple days after the games via testing with the poisoner.
I agree that Alcohol needs to be toned down. Not only from the standpoint of being applied to a blade for use in PvP but also because I do not like purchasing alcohol in game, taking one sip and being so drunk I get slurred speech, stumble around, and pass out. I think it limits group RP during any social gathering, such as sitting in the Burning Bandit for a drink night etc.
Now there is something to be said for the smaller races getting drunk faster than the larger races, body mass and all that however, not sure if alcohol is coded to be able to work like that. Maybe some races just have very little tolerance to alcohol. :

:
Bocon's suggestion that Gargoyle Sludge be changed to affect priest healing is interesting however, that would make it a whole new poison and would only then be effective against healers. Staff, please take note of Bocon's great idea for a poison that affects the healing functions, if there isn't one already on the list.
Just to be clear, the alcohol is not a poison mixed by assassins. It is purchased from any of the establishments that sell alcohol from around the lands of SI.
The game is getting ready for a major combat update. I think any major tweaks to any poison can wait until we see what the new combat system looks like.
As a player I appreciate everyone's feedback as well. I have never played a "dark" character before and have to admit I am enjoying myself immensely.
Lueghee's player - Loving his moment in the OP sunshine