To clarify my position, I'm in it more for the elimination of what I perceive as an irritation (constantly adding the two commands to nearly every kill) rather than the inherit combat maluses (which are an issue, but not the main one in my opinion).
I am concerned that the suggestion is getting over analyzed, but in any event I would personally be fine with skinning came with a temporary combat malus to replace the current situation.
Skinnking Knives
Re: Skinnking Knives
I understand what you wanted, and the addition of the two commands is the only downside to a skill that's already too good IMO. The time saved for not having to actually equip and take off a skinning tool, would be a massive buff to the skill and not just solving a minor inconvenience. Triggers can already just do this for you anyways, as most skinnable animals are not KOS.
Re: Skinnking Knives
I agree with Bocon, tho. I like how convenient skinning is, since I could train both my trade and combat that way. But I think I'm not in the position to talk much about the problem that one would be vulnerable while skinning since we'll be holding a knife... since Ventusia's preferred weapon IS a dagger or knife, she could easily skin a body using the same weapon she uses for combat... whenever she decides to train her combat skill instead of the spells.
Re: Skinnking Knives
Skinning is a very involved process and really, the use of the knife in the process is surprisingly minimal.
Most of it is brute force as you peel the carcass, with come connective tissue and portions of skin cut through.
Now field dressing and butchering it gets a lot more use, and that has been rolled into the same skill.
Most of it is brute force as you peel the carcass, with come connective tissue and portions of skin cut through.
Now field dressing and butchering it gets a lot more use, and that has been rolled into the same skill.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Skinnking Knives
You can scrimshaw an item with absolutely no tool needed, kinda weird?
Everyone uses a mud client to connect, and they all have triggers, and the game has an alias command.
Personally, i'd like to see the delay for equipping items go away? There is already an added delay for picking up
stuff in combat, mebbe just remove the equip delays and add them only when in combat?
Then you could make an alias/trigger to remove your weapon, skin, and then wear your weapon. ( most people do?)
I like having to have a short blade worn to skin, but can see the point of having to constantly un-ready / ready something
being a P.I.T.A. ( also having to remove a weapon to heal ) . I'd like to see tools for crafts be needed ( i.e. carving tool etc)
In the end, the game is trying for realism, and if they aren't changing the ferry times, they won't change these things
X.
Everyone uses a mud client to connect, and they all have triggers, and the game has an alias command.
Personally, i'd like to see the delay for equipping items go away? There is already an added delay for picking up
stuff in combat, mebbe just remove the equip delays and add them only when in combat?
Then you could make an alias/trigger to remove your weapon, skin, and then wear your weapon. ( most people do?)
I like having to have a short blade worn to skin, but can see the point of having to constantly un-ready / ready something
being a P.I.T.A. ( also having to remove a weapon to heal ) . I'd like to see tools for crafts be needed ( i.e. carving tool etc)
In the end, the game is trying for realism, and if they aren't changing the ferry times, they won't change these things
X.

- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Skinnking Knives
I use triggers during hunting if I need to skin something. The only time it really becomes an issue is when I'm in an area that has aggressive mobs that attack me the second they walk into the room, which ends up interfering with said triggers.
Thankfully, there are places people can work skinning without having to worry much about aggressive mobs. Lizards in the orc caves are always a pain, just because the orcs seem to move around so much. I've lost a lot of lizard scales because of those jerks.
Thankfully, there are places people can work skinning without having to worry much about aggressive mobs. Lizards in the orc caves are always a pain, just because the orcs seem to move around so much. I've lost a lot of lizard scales because of those jerks.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: Skinnking Knives
Yeah, if this suggestion isn't possible, it'd be great to give scouts some special ability to do it quicker or switch between bow and knife quickly or something. It's very easy for mages to skin right now. We don't really use our weapons other than for defense, so just holding a knife all the time is no problem. It's pretty strange that mages have a skinning advantage over scouts. Skinning should be in a scouts area of expertise, but the bow thing gets in the way.
Re: Skinnking Knives
I feel like it would depend on the bent of argument you'd like to take, but at the heart, it's all about mechanics/play vs realism. Realistically, you would need to swap (mechanical advantage to mage, whom you could make require a free hand for arcane gestures, if that were desirable), but for the sake of playability, it's easier to allow skinning knives (and other gathering implements) to be used from inventory. Ultimately, it needs, I think, to be an admin decision as to whether it's forgivable to have that for ease of play, or if it compromises too much the integrity of the game.