Page 2 of 4
Re: Abusing a skill
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2016 6:30 pm
by
Pickpocket immunity = get in combat with something or hide
Re: Abusing a skill
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2016 7:35 pm
by
Kreve Moltenhoof wrote:So i havent played in a while due to just taken a break and within 10 mins of me being back i have someone abusing pickpocket on me. Why is it not frowned upon that someone can follow you around picking your pockets clean knowing mechanically that they can not get caught. Mechanically i can level pummel by pummeling a target, leave the room, reenter, and pummel again but im not suppose to level it this way even though the skill allows me to do it this way. Another example that would probably ruin someones enjoyment of the game like pickpocket is doing for me is, repeatedly killing someone over and over again, sure you can do it but its just something that people shouldnt do and you might get a slap on the wrist or worse. So why is pickpocket not treated the same way in its current state.
I didn't really want this to bleed into an OOC discussion, but I also don't want misinformation, especially about thieves, to spread. So, a few things:
1) Nobody abused anything. I pilfered you successfully exactly 3 times. My first pilfer I unexpectedly swiped about 1300-1400. Then, after you were taunting me while I was hiding, I got 2 more successful pilfers for something like 5 and 8 doubloons each. I was not harassing you.
2) You challenged me to come out and face you while I was hiding. It seemed like it made you mad that I didn't reveal myself, but try considering it from my perspective. I am a tiny Goblin who had just stolen from a pissed off giant goat man with a huge scary weapon. In no way am I going to leap from the shadows, twirl my mustache, and say, "Nyehaha! It was ME all along!" and then fight you in one-on-one combat. Yiri would expect to die in that situation. If you aren't actually upset about this, then no big deal. But saying, "knowing they cannot be caught" made me think it got under your skin.
3) I had HOPED that this IC action would bring about an IC response. Like maybe Kreve getting pissed off and starting some crap with Kaiah/Itzalites, upsetting the semi-truce between our temples (this is actually what I was hoping for). I'm kind of disappointed that one of the first responses to an IC interaction is to complain about it on the OOC forums.
I like Kreve as a character, and I have always thought the player behind the character was cool too. It's good for the game to have dedicated people like you playing, and I sincerely hope our interaction didn't drive you off from the game or give you cause to treat me differently IC. I just hope that we can keep these issues IC, because in no way was I trying to give you OOC grief or abuse anything.
Re: Abusing a skill
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2016 9:34 pm
by
Hey no hard feelings buddy, it was a little upsetting when I quit for a little and it was the first thing that happens. I should have named the title, Abusing a skill? since i was unsure if it would even be considered abuse or not since there is no way of me revealing you, since the skill is kind of broken/not complete. Thanks for the shout out btw i dont really interact much with Kreve and kind of tend to myself lol.
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 3:03 pm
by
We have a Searching skill almost ready to go. It's based on the upcoming character levels so we've been holding it back to avoid having it work every single time. It is a skill, not a command, so that skilled thieves still have a chance of not being detected. We'll then carry this over to the mage detection spells.
Of course as someone previously mentioned, you can put your coin in a container while hunting. You don't want to leave it there as it can get lost on rare occasions, but it's a perfectly valid defense that has always existed.
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 6:01 pm
by
Huzzah, search~
Can't tell you how often I got stuck searching for that gap on the way to Treehaven... /nostalgia
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 6:24 pm
by
Why not have an observation skill as well?
To make you more likely to notice subterfuge, whether used against you or not.
Although due to the passive nature of the reps you are likely to receive, you may need to slow down skillgain artificially.
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 6:34 pm
by
Two main reasons I can think of: first is that we don't need to add a passive skill as that could be a pain to level, and it would make far more sense to tie it to level of observer vs. level of stealther. And two, we don't really need it at all. It's hard enough to go completely undetected from what I can tell, and the more abilities or passives we give that hamper stealth and stealth classes lessens the value and fun of those classes. We do need an active way to counter it once it can affect us (player agency is most important in all cases), but that will be the purpose of search and spells that reveal stealthy classes.
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 6:46 pm
by
The reason it is hard to be so sneaky is because it was a one way street at the time.
I would assume that with a player defense to the skill, the success ratio was slatted for review in the near future.
I could see search being an active method of repping the observation skill... but if the passive reps are only 1/10th as effective, wouldn't it balance out?
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2016 9:55 pm
by
There is already a success/fail rate with hiding, sneaking, pickpocketing etc.
There is also a success/fail rate with observing being pickpocketed. A thief's chance of being detected by the victim is most likely tied to the thief's skill level.
If I recall correctly, staff has discussed during at least one of the Coffee with Creators and/or Religious Q&A's no skill is going to have a 100% success rate.
Personally, I don't see a need for a passive "Observation" skill.
"Search" can be used for so much more than just detecting hidden people and I think it will be a very good addition to the commands we can use.
I am looking forward to the update(s) and how they should significantly improve the game.
Re: Abusing a skill?
Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2016 7:37 pm
by
There will be cooking failures then?