[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • New Combat System vs Healing - Page 2
Page 2 of 7

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 7:26 pm
by
I feel underleveled.

That said, I still agree with Snaek that we're in a good place for combat at the moment. We just need to grow it and make it more interesting, which is sure to happen as time continues on.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 9:34 pm
by
Xijia's race/class is meta because of her stating stam pool is one of the highest as I recall, and flying it offers a substantial bonus in utility. Plus Boc already revealed that Xijia outheals him in terms of output. I have a feeling its because there is either a race modifier to spell/prayer effectiveness OR WIS is not the modifier or the only modifier that affects rolls. For example the wis modifier helps deterine success of the prayer but INT modifier deterines the actual output. I know that they have 2 seperate rolls so it is entirely possible. I am just speculating here by the way and am not certain that is the case. It would however explain her higher output.

I have only had 1 stat raise from skill leveling the entire life of my character. The RNG has been adjusted since I first started, however it doesnt scale or give any type of rollover protection as far as I know.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 9:55 pm
by
It takes substantial amounts of time and the staff is extremely limited. Plus they are not paid for there work. It has taken years to get to this point with melee combat formulas working. Priest and mages were overpowered everyone agreed I think perhaps some players are in a bit of shock that they are no longer overwhelmingly powerful. Which is good for that player and the playerbase. It isnt fun at all to feel at a extreme disadvantage in virtually every situation thats how it felt to be melee. Now I feel like I could actually kill a player if I was inclined. It is healthy for the game in my personal opinion.

Snaek called my character out specifically. He neglected to mention that outside my skill set I am extremely well geared I have arcsilver armor and top end material in every slot that offers a bonus. Not to mention I most likely have the highest damage two hander for a PC in the game right now. It offers me a substantial increase in combat effectiveness without it I would be slowed substantially in my killing prowess.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 10:15 pm
by
I'm curious if they changed anything else with the NCS.. like weapons?
I think it was said once that a weapons AR bonus was based on the metal, so a steel
dagger would be the same as a steel sword? Does weapon size ever get factored in?
Do 2 handers do more damage than 1 handers and daggers etc?

I remember rolling a beast race before, and the STR stat allowed me to kill much faster
then my Syl, but i rolled a garg recently, and it seems not so "beasty" now? I wonder how much
difference the stats make , now that player lvl pwns everything...

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 10:55 pm
by
I can only speak for NCS experience, but low-end weapons seem rather unimpressive early on. To the point where I had to let CC briefly climb above my scout's ranged because I couldn't afford to keep him in supply of arrows at the rate arrows were killing things, and couldn't access fletching to make my own because my RC hadn't climbed high enough.

Honestly, it was only the recent double-xp holiday that let me advance far enough, fast enough, to make the character financially self-sustaining. And even then I'm still faced with the choice of taking literal hours to fletch enough arrows for a level when my mage can magic up ranged attacks at will and vigor himself back up at will afterward.

This may change when I get access to better weapons, but the process of leveling up a non-priest/mage feels comparatively frustrating.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 11:05 pm
by
Creon wrote:Xijia's race/class is meta because of her stating stam pool is one of the highest as I recall, and flying it offers a substantial bonus in utility. Plus Boc already revealed that Xijia outheals him in terms of output. I have a feeling its because there is either a race modifier to spell/prayer effectiveness OR WIS is not the modifier or the only modifier that affects rolls. For example the wis modifier helps deterine success of the prayer but INT modifier deterines the actual output. I know that they have 2 seperate rolls so it is entirely possible. I am just speculating here by the way and am not certain that is the case. It would however explain her higher output.

I have only had 1 stat raise from skill leveling the entire life of my character. The RNG has been adjusted since I first started, however it doesnt scale or give any type of rollover protection as far as I know.
Xiija might outheal Bocon because she has basically max INT/WIS after her copious stat raises... Also, currently the only utility of flying is being able to travel 3 rooms at a time by flying 2 rooms up to "high in the sky" and 2 rooms down after you've arrived in your general area. You cannot "reach" players to bless/FA them while flying, you cannot be defending while flying, and even a squirrel can hit you while flying currently. Not sure sylph priest is the meta. But maybe I'm just defensive since I'm the same race/class and it wasn't at all due to a "min/max" outlook but more for the joy of playing something different. I'm fairly certain there are better races for a priest! From my research on the forums, elves start with more wisdom, and humans start with more stamina.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 11:26 pm
by
I am seeing very little difference in terms of variation of dmg between iron and arcsilver weapon 1h. 2h weapons certainly offer more dmg output but i havent tested lower quality material 2h weapons. I believe that dmg done to NPCs is scaled off total hp instead of a complicated dmg roll. It narrows preformance between races and players gear is less impactful on preformance. This is to place more emphasis on player investment in terms of skill and religious lvl instead of gear.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 11:27 pm
by
Xiija wrote:just to share for comparison...
Prayer Name Uses Remaining Level
Cure Disease..... 2949.......... 24
Remove Poison..... 2659.......... 23
Detect Disease..... 2964.......... 24
Disease Ward..... 2470.......... 20
Divine Path..... 4121.......... 31
Holy Shield..... 4019.......... 30
Inflict Plague..... 3904.......... 41
Mending Aura..... 571.......... 19
Rejuvenation..... 7374.......... 54
Revoke..... 1869.......... 32
Healing Touch..... 5394.......... 45
Holy Strike..... 4545.......... 43

Skill Name Uses Remaining Level
Turn Undead ..... 5432.......... 41
Unarmed Combat ..... 1484.......... 13
Close Combat ..... 2589.......... 30
Divine Blessing ..... 1217.......... 11
Hiding..... 2442.......... 20
Ranged Combat ..... 1473.......... 12
Searching..... 2408.......... 20
Shield Block ..... 1369.......... 46

TradeSkill Name Uses Remaining Level
Bone Carving ..... 538.......... 7
Clay Pottery..... 197.......... 2
Fishing..... 1405.......... 12
Glassblowing ..... 464.......... 6
Mining..... 680.......... 11
Skinning..... 268.......... 8
Speculating ..... 843.......... 12
Stone Sculpting ..... 582.......... 6
Wood Carving ..... 526.......... 7
Wood Chopping ..... 492.......... 9
Cooking ..... 586.......... 6
Foraging ..... 65.......... 20
*Not shown about 30 levels in removed skills like firebuilding and climbing

As for player level, It took me 27 trainings to go from lvl 48 to 49.... and 50 trainings to go from 49 to 50 .
(I'm not sure if all skills are weighted the same in advancing player level?)

I've also had 12 stat raise since we started, bringing my INT & WIS up around max.
With the higher levels in healing, i've seen the heal amount hits usually around 16-22 now, with alot
fewer misses, tho ... has anyone noticed... I seem to miss more during heavy combat, usually when
someone is in danger of dying (lol).

I think Bocon has a valid point about lvl 100 healing, but remember.. most NPC's are only around lvl 40-50 so far?
So Bocon has trained his skill beyond the current mechanics of the game... If the top mob levels stay this way,
i can see the point in not PTing above lvl 50, but if the mob levels go higher I'm sure a lvl 100 priest will become
what they are supposed to be :)

Edit: P.S. Staff says that having the max set at 100 instead of 50-60 lets people have more chances for a stat raise,
but I'd rather train 5 skills to 20, than a single one to 100 ? I'm guessing it's also to keep people from quitting after they max out?

Yeah, see, you have a bunch more mid-low ranged skills than I do. It used to be hard to justify working a lot of those skills, but I guess now it's absolutely needed in order to compete, which I can see being an issue for people who have RP conflicts with leveling different skills, yet still want to remain competitive.

That's some good info on what it takes to level your player level though, thanks!

12 stat raises is insane. I've had 5 I believe, lol. I think those misses are just more noticable, because it actually really counts to heal in those situations. You heal for as much as I do btw. I still see a lot of non-max numbers in my healing, even at level 100. it's kind of like shield block, where there's probably a cap on the varience of successes. Even at level 93, I seems to block just as well as I did when I was a far lower level. I also believe it doesn't work off of player level vs whatever you are fighting, as level 1 critters still get through my shield regardless.

So if I'm healing for the same amount, whith close to the same frequency as you are, then there's really no point in leveling it past what you have now, unless you just want them for stat raises. So level 100 means nothing, even when high level mobs are put into the game. I don't know if healing numbers will be tweaked as high level, harder hitting mobs go into the game, but I guess we'll see.

I didn't know that staff had said that. I should have stopped at 50 if that was the case and worked on something else then....Yeah, 5 skills at level 20 puts you at the exact same player level as someone with 1 level 100 skill, which I find ridiculous myself. Nothing in the player level system is weighted, all skills and levels are valued the same. This was stated in the last CwC.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 11:33 pm
by
Conskill wrote:I can only speak for NCS experience, but low-end weapons seem rather unimpressive early on. To the point where I had to let CC briefly climb above my scout's ranged because I couldn't afford to keep him in supply of arrows at the rate arrows were killing things, and couldn't access fletching to make my own because my RC hadn't climbed high enough.

Honestly, it was only the recent double-xp holiday that let me advance far enough, fast enough, to make the character financially self-sustaining. And even then I'm still faced with the choice of taking literal hours to fletch enough arrows for a level when my mage can magic up ranged attacks at will and vigor himself back up at will afterward.

This may change when I get access to better weapons, but the process of leveling up a non-priest/mage feels comparatively frustrating.

I feel you 100%. I've made a bunch of different non-mage/priest characters and it's been really frustrating without vigor. I have a feeling that better weapons really impove your sustainability, unless you're trying to just practice, then you'll want the lowest damage weapon possible.

Re: New Combat System vs Healing

Posted: Thu Mar 09, 2017 11:35 pm
by
Creon wrote:I am seeing very little difference in terms of variation of dmg between iron and arcsilver weapon 1h. 2h weapons certainly offer more dmg output but i havent tested lower quality material 2h weapons. I believe that dmg done to NPCs is scaled off total hp instead of a complicated dmg roll. It narrows preformance between races and players gear is less impactful on preformance. This is to place more emphasis on player investment in terms of skill and religious lvl instead of gear.
I'd really like to know if CC levels also increase the tightness of damage rolls and the chance of getting crits, or if your overall player level is more in charge of that.