[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Spell Suggestions - Page 2
Page 2 of 2

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 1:03 pm
by
I'm new to SI, but so far things are sounding quite interesting with these suggestions. Especially the little cantrips and the high level spells. Course perhaps that's a bit biased, considering I love mage characters and am playing around with a Fire-Mage and an Earth-Mage till Diviners and Dragons come about. (In which case I will most likely devote my time towards that class and that race and suggestions thereof for each of them respectively.)

I will agree that the medium and heavy armors should probably be off limits to them as a trade off for the damage they can do. But that already seems to be part of the agenda to be changed.

Now as for something unique to this world as far as mage armor goes? That's an interesting prospect and one that's going to take a bit of brainstorming. But then again, what new and unique idea doesn't? XD

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 1:17 pm
by
Regardless of the mechanics behind it, the ideal situation roleplay wise I believe would be for mages not to have to wear armor at all. It always seems jarring for certain classes such as assassins, thieves, and mages to have to wear heavy plate male, or be punished heavily by mechanics by not doing so. There isn't a roleplayer dedicated enough to do that, if they hunt monsters at all on a regular basis. I'm sure Avardi in particular would hate wearing heavy metal armor.

Long term what I'd like to see is the mage equivalent of armor being some kind of enchanted bonded item, rather than just mage versions of warrior type armors. So like protection amulets, rings, runes, sigils, etc. Combined with spells of course and taking account for the mages having those.

Oh, edited to add. I hope if Dragonscale is the top rated mage armor, that there is another equal alternative. Assuming mages and elves are going to be Dragon allies someday, that kind of creates a roleplay conflict with wearing the best armor in the game.

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 3:21 pm
by
Hey mates,

There's some things to consider when talkin' over mages and melee.

1. This isn't another game, and there's (at the time, who says what the future will bring?) no range/tact system for mages to dance around and away from melee. Caster DR gain is less than melee, you'll almost always hit them even if they've leveled CC. Only way for 'em to have any defence is their shield - they only get the one defence ability, where all others get two. There's no 'skill' to protect against castin', it's true, but there's a chance of resistin'.

2. It'll take mages to reach mid-level before they'll start maximising spells consistently, and even then it wont each time. They've got a chance to fumble in any cast, and they've gotta do it with every single one. Whilst we can consider their utility spells similar to the special/unique abilities of melee, so in turn maybe think of them as complementary, they've still gotta do it with each and every damage spell, where melee only 'have' to work CC as their main attack.

3. I'd say it's the opposite - mages'll be kept with their current maximum damage, where there'll always be new tiers of materials opened up or introduced for weapon settings, and there's the three kinds you can use - short, one-handed, and two-handed.

4. As Snaek said, 'DEFEND' is a skill available to a few - think of it as a complementary ability similar to how assassins and thieves get backstab, shadowstrike, disguise, etc. It fumbles a terrible bit at lower levels, even a bit at half-way to the level cap, and like SilverShade mentioned, it'll only take one target.

5. Mate, I dunno if there's gonna be a huge influx of mages for games or any other purposes. If you look at the numbers in game, there's about three consistent mages compared to eight or nine melee.

6. Blink, that sounds like a good lot of fun, this idea of mage armour maybe bein' tied into enchanted/bonded items for stylistic purposes. I'd definitely support lookin' and pokin' to see if that's possible in the future, thanks for the thoughts, chap.

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 7:19 pm
by
wait..real quick...

are wall spells just DR boosts that can be cast on other PCs, or do they absorb damage too?

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 8:07 pm
by
Just dr boosts, and lesser ones to shield at that.

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 9:55 pm
by
Blink wrote:Regardless of the mechanics behind it, the ideal situation roleplay wise I believe would be for mages not to have to wear armor at all. It always seems jarring for certain classes such as assassins, thieves, and mages to have to wear heavy plate male, or be punished heavily by mechanics by not doing so. There isn't a roleplayer dedicated enough to do that, if they hunt monsters at all on a regular basis. I'm sure Avardi in particular would hate wearing heavy metal armor.

Long term what I'd like to see is the mage equivalent of armor being some kind of enchanted bonded item, rather than just mage versions of warrior type armors. So like protection amulets, rings, runes, sigils, etc. Combined with spells of course and taking account for the mages having those.

Oh, edited to add. I hope if Dragonscale is the top rated mage armor, that there is another equal alternative. Assuming mages and elves are going to be Dragon allies someday, that kind of creates a roleplay conflict with wearing the best armor in the game.
I was thinking along those lines myself earlier. Enchanted jewelry that acts as armor by emitting a form of barrier around the mage. While not as strong as traditional armor, it would act as a form of protection. In a roleplay sense, the barrier would slow down (Or down right stop attacks if the barrier was strong enough and the attack weak enough.) attacks/projectiles to cause them to do less damage rather than absorbing the damage by hardness of material.

In mechanics sense, it would behave exactly like the current armor value system as far as judging how the attack damages, except it would be based off jewelry only useable by the mage/caster types (They would be limited to this obviously and only able to equip clothing). Roleplay wise once again, it could perhaps be explainable as they have to use their own will to maintain the barriers from the jewelry and also attack/cast on top of it. And their devotion to their art gives them the ability to do so, whereas other professions would stumble in such attempts of concentration. Except lets say, Arcanists, Diviners, Priests, and the sort if they are also going to be wearing no armor like mages. The reasoning behind the switch from other armors could perhaps be that they were just too cumbersome for the hand gestures and incantations that a mage required, which were already hard enough to master as it was, and thus such protection was born to free up their movement.

While it's not the most original idea, it's not completely copying the 'barriers absorb everything until they break' magic of mages in games past either. And it's also based around jewelry, rather than a spell cast, and it would mix in quite well with their castable shields. In the sense of roleplay, their castable shields would be a sort of a fortification over the barrier their jewelry permeates, strengthening it to further slow down and stop blows.

And much like Blink, I have to raise a brow at the Dragonscale. If it's added as top end armor, then one would hope there's also an alternative. Because that could cause quite the conflict between dragon and humanoid characters! I'm, of course, not saying remove it altogether. But without an alternative you may find that, from an IC perspective, there will be characters that will refuse to use/wear this high level armor in favor of not angering or not making uncomfortable friends, allies, or a race in general.

This was all rather hastily typed, so hopefully it makes sense! If not, then I can come back and better explain the thought later on!

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 11:18 pm
by
As to dragon armor, I don't think it's a problem to have to choose between getting the armor and having dragons as allies. There's already a history of dragon hunting in the game, which means this choice will have real consequences for your character IC, and plays into the world history as well. Hard choices like this shouldn't be shied away from, but welcomed, I think. That way, mages can either focus on hunting dragons, or helping them.

Sure, you don't get the BA armor. But you get a living bad ass as a friend. So I'd think it'd even out.

As for the armor discussion, while I agree that it feels odd for me to walk around in armor as a priest, but Anslem is right in that, as the system stands now, there's no other way to make my character survive in solo hunting. I barely make it as it is with the armor, and that's because I hunt undead things - the only thing that makes Holy Strike useful.

I do like the idea of class-specific enchanted items. Like robes or tunics for a priest, robes/capes for mages, rings, holy symbols, etc.

Maybe give mages dodge instead of shield? As for priests, I guess you could keep shield block, unless you give them not defensive skills, but up their holy shield to pick up the slack.

Re: Spell Suggestions

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2013 11:38 pm
by
Aumnren wrote:As to dragon armor, I don't think it's a problem to have to choose between getting the armor and having dragons as allies. There's already a history of dragon hunting in the game, which means this choice will have real consequences for your character IC, and plays into the world history as well. Hard choices like this shouldn't be shied away from, but welcomed, I think. That way, mages can either focus on hunting dragons, or helping them.

Sure, you don't get the BA armor. But you get a living bad ass as a friend. So I'd think it'd even out.
Yea, that's rather what I meant to say. Just forgot to add it! From what I've read and noticed of the world, that seemed to be the case. So it's good to know for sure! There will no doubt be those who will befriend dragons and others that will shun them, and to each their own reasons for it.

Given that, playing a dragon IC wise in this world will be quite interesting given the history of it and things such as this. It adds a depth to it that that I can agree shouldn't be removed. On both sides of things.

Though an alternative so those that forgo the dragonscale armor aren't completely gimped for skipping out on it, would be a nice addition as well I'd still say.

And I apologize if I've kind of jumped in and derailed the subject in your thread Blink! Didn't mean to do so! Just throwing out my own thoughts/suggestions of things that are creeping up.

I may be new, but I'm often not afraid to jump right into things. XD