Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
KschilanT
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 4:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by KschilanT »

Hi everyone!

While I understand the logical progression of giving Assassins a means to follow their target, my humble opinion is that it would in fact make assassins a "one-man (or woman) army", and not require one to perhaps engage the rest of the population in otherwise meaningful roleplay situations.

For example:
An assassin need to find someone to kill them as asked/paid to do/wants to do of his own free will. Why not find a scout and pay him to track someone down, and then possibly additional payment for their silence?

Since it would provide people means to track down and kill whomever they wished/whenever they wished, this would make assassins something that's not really in line with the spirit of the game, and could change the balance (and attitude) of the playerbase. My suggestion is, at this time, allow the staff to finish intended updates to classes who need their fixes, see how the balances play out in PvE combat first, then balance PvP combat second. A request for a more PvP related roleplaying ability would be at a distant third.

See you in game!

-Kschilan's player
Kschilan Tehekchen
Apprentice to Merchant Elmere Manske
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Teef »

how about no. That would mean finding a scout... if anyone plays one. hoping they don't mind tracking someone down and watching you kill someone... and then hope they don't run off and blab about it. not only that the scout would be the only one identifiable by the victim and would be hunted for retribution. so which scout will agree to that?
Save that let's RP it out stuff for Carebear Isles.

Why don't we just turn PvP off and delete the ASSASSIN class. Because then there would be no conflict. no conflict-no drama, no drama- no quality RP
Last edited by Teef on Mon Jan 06, 2014 4:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Anselm »

Mates,

Everyone is free to "chime" in as they want, as long as they don't attack other players. We're always open to constructive criticism, but we're not very fond of unnecessary rudeness towards other players. There's no reason to create drama on the boards, we like that kept in game.

There's scouts in-game, just like there's some of almost every class, ya just gotta maybe find 'em.

We're a RP game, we encourage RP in all situations - combat included. There's no need at all for the mite touch of histrionics, no one's suggesting there not be PVP or conflict, or to delete more edgier themed classes. Kschilan's suggestions were good ones. There's plenty of people who run through areas other people are, and doesn't mean a scout is going to automatically be blamed for finding someone.

It's all good fun, so let's have some good fun. I can't say whether tracking is still in line for assassins (that's not my area), but I'd remind everyone they'll get trapping and poisoning. Balance is a tricky thing, and whilst we're not all going to agree on how things are tweaked to make it so, that's our ultimate goal. No single class is going to be invincible, mate. So if you're facerolling through hunting, pvp or anything else of the sorts, that's not going to stick.

Kschilan,

Mate, thanks for the suggestions/encouragements. I hope some people read on it and take up the ideas. Cheers!


Also, again, mates,

Constructive, contributing replies only. No need for derails.
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Austere »

In my opinion, to give assassins tracking would make their skillset meaningless. Assassins track by unconventional means, there is no fun in landing a job and completing it in 5 minutes on account of tracking taking you directly to your target. To be clear, I'd be surprised to see a scout working for an assassin.
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by SilverShade »

As people seem to be concerned about a lack of rp in an assassin's hunt, I can speak from experience that there is plenty of interaction between assassins, and even assassins and their targets. It's part of the enjoyment of playing the class. I also don't see scouts working for an assassin, nor do I see a good assassin taking the risk associated with letting some random Joe in on their highly questionable line of work.

Tracking could easily be just as frustrating as it is useful. Just because you know where someone's been doesn't mean they're there all the time, or even regularly. I'm sure there's a way to adjust how it tracks someone, how successful it is, or how accurate it is. Besides that, those that play assassins most likely enjoy the rp aspect of the class. Tracking people down without interacting with others and drawing it out is boring.

Surely there's a compromise. Instead of tracking by name, what about race? I could recognize a human footprint, but hell if I know if they belong to Elmere or Ydeliah. Unless one of them has boat feet, I'd have to make an educated guess.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Teef »

Yeah. Just because you can find your target in 5 mins doesn't mean you're gonna fight them then. They could be with someone or hunting. You'd just follow them and bide your time. Learning the areas they frequent and finding out when they would most likely be alone and unprepared. So you can set up an ambush so the odds of winning are in your favor since there is no ability to Mark targets. And with not being able to look through doors, gates, portals... Which I'm sure you could do when I started playing but now something has changed. You're stuck with walking in to see if someone is there and with sneak as crappy as it is... You may as well walk in and say hello. The best part is when you walk in and they walk in from an opposite room before you can hide. A tracking skill at a crossroads or even in an Inn would tell you which way they went or which door. So you don't have to run in and blow your cover.

I'd rather not have to write a script that speed-walks me through every room
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Teef »

And if I was more concerned about finding and killing people in 5 minutes I'd roll a mage and just port to them.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by SquallScribe »

And if I was more concerned about finding and killing people in 5 minutes I'd roll a mage and just port to them.
How risible this statement is.

Aside from the fact that it would be irresponsible as a player to constantly portal to another player and "kill people in five minutes" (which I assure you, as long as said person wasn't AFK scripting, would not happen), think again if you believe raising the amount of multiple spell levels required to even get to that point would be the cakewalk that is close combat training.

I think we could debate the unique components of classes for eternity, but the prominent consideration is balance. Not only does giving the tracking skill to Assassins remove its distinctiveness from Scouts (a class already lacking individuality), but further exaggerates the already numerous unique skills Assassins get as a class. As Anselm said, no one class is invincible. The point of this game is roleplay and interaction, and I assume the creators will do what they can to foster that environment, even mechanically.
I'd rather not have to write a script that speed-walks me through every room
If roleplay and interaction is your aim, as you have previously claimed, then speed-walking through rooms really isn't in your best interest.
And with not being able to look through doors, gates, portals... Which I'm sure you could do when I started playing but now something has changed.
I assure you this current bug is just as annoying for non-Assassins as it is for Assassins.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Teef »

I'll put some RP into the script
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Which way did he go Geortge? Which way did he go?

Post by Teef »

COVER_SHOT


Skill : Cover Shot
Command : COVER
Usage : COVER [TARGET NAME]
Example : cover orc
If the player is unseen (hidden especially) by the target, then a
sneaky ranged strike can be made. Following the shot, the player will
instantly try to recover their hidden position. The target will be
totally unaware of where the attack came from.
Post Reply