Constructive suggestions and ideas have been put forward before, as well as questions, but most haven't been responded to. Since I just woke up to go to work, I'll submit even more later in the day.
Edit: In fact, I'll have a nice big post over the whole class today or tomorrow, after I'm done with work.
Lock picking
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Lock picking
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Lock picking
I think it was pretty clear Anselm was referring to Morley, not the true defenders of Assassins.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Lock picking
It didn't seem that way to me, and if it was, then I apologize. I will still be writing a bunch of things up for the assassin class and, hopefully, we can bring it to a discussion with other players and staff. Whenever that can be set up.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
Re: Lock picking
I'm very interested in seeing an Assassin write-up and what everyone thinks of the class.
Not that I necessarily agree with how Morley said it, but now that he mentions it, do Assassins have any Assassin-only skills? I hadn't realized until now that all of my skills are shared with at least one other class. Of course it's possible I just haven't unlocked something or everything simply isn't fully implemented.
I'm looking forward to the discussion!
Not that I necessarily agree with how Morley said it, but now that he mentions it, do Assassins have any Assassin-only skills? I hadn't realized until now that all of my skills are shared with at least one other class. Of course it's possible I just haven't unlocked something or everything simply isn't fully implemented.
I'm looking forward to the discussion!
Re: Lock picking
No, as far as I know we don't, which is my core concern with the class. There really isn't anything about it to set us apart from the others presently.
Unique skills aside, we don't have any non-combat utility skills either. Fun things like a Thief's lockpicking and pilfering, Scout's tracking, Mage's portals and eventual fly spell, etc.
I thought poisons and traps (Is the latter still intended?) would be Assassin-only at the very least. Not sure why a Thief would have to make use of poisons if he's not combat-oriented and is geared more towards theft and escape.
As Seryth said though, it's all up in the air still, so a discussion might be just what we need to get the right idea of what Assassins are meant to be and how to get them there.
Unique skills aside, we don't have any non-combat utility skills either. Fun things like a Thief's lockpicking and pilfering, Scout's tracking, Mage's portals and eventual fly spell, etc.
I thought poisons and traps (Is the latter still intended?) would be Assassin-only at the very least. Not sure why a Thief would have to make use of poisons if he's not combat-oriented and is geared more towards theft and escape.
As Seryth said though, it's all up in the air still, so a discussion might be just what we need to get the right idea of what Assassins are meant to be and how to get them there.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Re: Lock picking
I'd expect poison to be assassin only, if not traps as well, though that might be shared with another class, say Scouts.
Assassins might simply be a patchwork of other class skills that are worked together for a different aim. Frankly, I think assassins are a bit too 'forward combat' oriented right now in that the name of the game is hit it with sword (maybe hit it with dagger first) - and I know I'm going to get flak for saying it, but hear me out. Poisons and traps, if and when implemented, will give assassins a multitude of utility skills players seem to be missing right now. The effects are nearly limitless. Lethargic poisons to put a slow effect. Stunning poisons. Perhaps poisons that crumbles will (aka dispells a magical effect on a player). Traps could hold, damage, allow you to track and follow a target from a blood trail - really, it'd be the 'spells' of the assassin class. Stack this with the same AR / DR as a warrior and two defenses and you there may need to be some balancing that'd have to happen.
Of course, without these poisons and traps, the two defenses and AR / DR is understandable, but when the real assassins skills come in, some of their offense may have to be reduced to compensate.
And even if scouts and assassins share traps, there can be certain traps available to assassins that scouts don't get - like a blood trail trap.
Assassins might simply be a patchwork of other class skills that are worked together for a different aim. Frankly, I think assassins are a bit too 'forward combat' oriented right now in that the name of the game is hit it with sword (maybe hit it with dagger first) - and I know I'm going to get flak for saying it, but hear me out. Poisons and traps, if and when implemented, will give assassins a multitude of utility skills players seem to be missing right now. The effects are nearly limitless. Lethargic poisons to put a slow effect. Stunning poisons. Perhaps poisons that crumbles will (aka dispells a magical effect on a player). Traps could hold, damage, allow you to track and follow a target from a blood trail - really, it'd be the 'spells' of the assassin class. Stack this with the same AR / DR as a warrior and two defenses and you there may need to be some balancing that'd have to happen.
Of course, without these poisons and traps, the two defenses and AR / DR is understandable, but when the real assassins skills come in, some of their offense may have to be reduced to compensate.
And even if scouts and assassins share traps, there can be certain traps available to assassins that scouts don't get - like a blood trail trap.
- SilverShade
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm
Re: Lock picking
I've actually spent my breaks today coming up with a bunch of the things mentioned in the last few posts, including various traps (even the blood trail trap) and how to set specific skills of ours -- and desired skills -- apart from other variations.
Assassins are supposed to be an offensive class. We just had our defensive abilities chopped and can now only defend against one type of attack, melee weapons. Instead of also butchering our offensive abilities, make it so that the assassin must use a blend of their skills to get the most out of the class on a combative level. Make it a challenge. The average assassin will rely on parries and AR/DR. The great assassins will learn how to use as many of their skills as possible, and will know when one tool is best saved for one situation.
Assassins are supposed to be an offensive class. We just had our defensive abilities chopped and can now only defend against one type of attack, melee weapons. Instead of also butchering our offensive abilities, make it so that the assassin must use a blend of their skills to get the most out of the class on a combative level. Make it a challenge. The average assassin will rely on parries and AR/DR. The great assassins will learn how to use as many of their skills as possible, and will know when one tool is best saved for one situation.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
~Xercien
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
I count a lot of "if"s in the above. Frankly our two defenses can be easily circumvented with naturals and missiles and magic. If the tournaments have shown anything, it's that defense matters more than offense. Draven could have probably bitten me to death with his level 10 bite. So a class geared for offense is actually weaker than one that can't be hit.
So much so I'm thinking Morley would be better off as a fighter.
Also the RNG is pretty effective at rendering levels and AR/DR useless too, since you were able to hit Nikolas.
So much so I'm thinking Morley would be better off as a fighter.
Also the RNG is pretty effective at rendering levels and AR/DR useless too, since you were able to hit Nikolas.
- Morley Darkfire
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat Nov 09, 2013 2:19 pm
Re: Lock picking
That was directed at Loriel's player
Re: Lock picking
So it appears. However, that's not exactly an ideal setup. Assassins don't currently excel in anything, there's nothing about the class to make it exciting or worthwhile to put effort into if you can roll a Thief for example and have Disguise, which is infinitely better than Masking, and still have access to SS/BS/Poisons/Sneak, or go Warrior and still get Dual Wield/Dual Parry and be able to swap to a shield for Shield Block to fight against natural users. Point being, there has to be something they have that others don't to make the class appealing besides the name, which is hard to live up to at this stage.Assassins might simply be a patchwork of other class skills that are worked together for a different aim.
I honestly don't know how an Assassin's damage compares to that of other classes, and maybe things will change once class stats are implemented and racials don't count for as much, but given that an Assassin in better armor with 10-15 more CC levels couldn't take down a Warrior and was getting hit pretty hard in return, the idea of our offense being reduced is kinda scary.Of course, without these poisons and traps, the two defenses and AR / DR is understandable, but when the real assassins skills come in, some of their offense may have to be reduced to compensate.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
Emissary of Temple Itzal.