High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
- SquallScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
I only want to say that I agree with Doxx. And I never thought I'd type the words "I agree with Doxx" so now I'm going to go drink heavily and pretend it's all a wine dream.
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
from the manual ...

just curious tho,
if you could change to another religion, I.E. Kaleith ( the most peaceful)
would you do it?... and how would you RP it?
I'm guessing this is a staff interaction thing .. has anyone else done it?
::ponders becoming the first ever Sylvan Itzalite... captured?..tortured?.. Made to convert & go insane? ::
hehe, this sounds like Kiriath! no boundaries on the roleplay eitherBeliefs and Characteristics - Aerthane the Goddess of Air represents all of those who live as a free spirit. Followers believe in a world without boundaries. Though this encompasses their carefree beliefs, they can turn violent the moment they are confined in any way. Often incorrectly viewed as impulsive, they do expend quite a bit of energy in the preparation and planning for which they fight.
just curious tho,
if you could change to another religion, I.E. Kaleith ( the most peaceful)
would you do it?... and how would you RP it?
I'm guessing this is a staff interaction thing .. has anyone else done it?
::ponders becoming the first ever Sylvan Itzalite... captured?..tortured?.. Made to convert & go insane? ::

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
"The enemy of my enemy is my friend"
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
I'll convert you.Xiija wrote:::ponders becoming the first ever Sylvan Itzalite... captured?..tortured?.. Made to convert & go insane? ::

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
Each player already has ooc directives from staff. For Kiriath, as an Avardi and a follower of Aerthane, her staff directives are:Kiriath wrote:. . .barring ic directives from Aerthane or ooc directives from staff, I will let Kir evolve, and hopefully help the world evolve. I prefer to avoid unpleasantries whenever possible.
Avardi race
Aerthane religion
So as long as your character is founded on the information given here (and I know it's not much, but it's enough to get a good idea), then you're not 'roleplaying wrong'. But really, there's no 'roleplaying wrong', there's just picking a bad race and religion combo (as outlined by staff) for the role someone want's to play.
For instance, from what I've observed, Kiriath seems more like a Verdani to me than an Avardi, only because she grew up in a castle (schloss) with defined roles (servants, aristocracy, pedigree etc), and that sounds a lot like the traits I read in the Verdani race page under the culture section. You're not playing wrong, it just seems out of place for the race/religion you choose.
I'm not the RP cop, and I didn't open this post to yell at people because they are 'doing it wrong.' I just noticed that some characters displayed core traits that were not aligning with those outlined in their race/religion pages. I wasn't sure if things had changed, or if players were't heeding the guidelines. So I really want this thread to be a discussion on people's understanding of the current races/religions and their conflicts in the game. And it's not that everyone has to stick 100% to the given structure. As Nikolas pointed out:
There's plenty of room for everyone's character. There's plenty of room to create a character and grow and evolve them into a different character from when they started. That's the fun and the magic of MUDs and roleplaying games. But we still have to choose which races and religions best suit the 'role' we want to play.Nikolas Suyessod wrote:No one asking people become caricatures. . .People change over the course of time, personalities evolve and grow, tensions between individuals fade or increase.
I think it's actually both, which is partially why I opened the thread. Mostly religion based, but also founded at times based on race. The most obvious example of this is the Verdani's belief that they are the pure elves, and that the other elves are lesser. This may not lead to huge debacles, but even on the race page it says that it has caused divides between them and the other elven races. I also assume that there will be racial tensions between those of the same faith, living on the same isle.Shadowbane wrote:The game is based off religious conflict, not racial conflict.
For instance, while the Nydine likely live peacefully with the Bolinau on Kaleith, the elves probably consider themselves more advanced because they can comprehend magic and build ships to sail the open seas, while the Bolinau's craft smaller ships to navigate the inner river systems, and, while delightfully curious, they don't have the mental capacity to fully grasp what magic really is. Add the dynamics between Kaleith Argali or Gavial into the mix and you have a pot of subtle or not so subtle racial tensions.
Not to mention what happens if your characters parents were raised a different religion that what your character is - then even add born on an isle of an opposing religion! Jyle, the pyresian human whose parents were composed of an Avardi and a human Astraevan, born on the isle of Kaleith in a city mainly populated by the stoic and honor-bound Argali.
Yes, I agree. And I also agree with your other statement that people are going to be nice by default, and that's ok. I will point us all to a point Nikolas made:Synche wrote:I think it's crazy to not what to create strife in every way possible as a game designer. Yes, that includes racial strife. I don't think this is ever a situation where you "have" to do anything. You can play an elf that likes dwarves, even if most elves hate dwarves, and go against the grain. . .What about the situation where two racial enemies overcome tension because they follow the same religion, or any combination of those interactions?
In order to have that rewarding experience, we have to start from a place where our characters generally don't like certain people (or are at least weary of them) because of history between them, racial divides, or religious differences. In order to have the rewarding roleplay, you have to have the tensions to overcome.Nikolas Suyessod wrote:There's amazing and rewarding roleplay to be found in months long journeys to overcome conflict and resolve issues that the game has set out as groundwork.
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
The lack of detailed religious guidelines is something that falls squarely on my shoulders. Some of you may not agree with the approach of asking the players to contribute to the world's history, but this is very much a community project and that's exactly how we intend to go forward. The alternative to debates like these is to close the game to the public and focus on these things with no players to give us feedback, and no new members of the community coming in. Or you can watch from the sidelines like some others while those who are interested in building a world together can continue to do so. You won't be alone and we appreciate those of you who do check in. Everyone has something they are waiting on before investing time. I get it.
Now, assuming we are all here to make this game a better place for ourselves and for future players, there's some things that need to be understood.
1. This is an evolving world. It cannot be labeled as Alpha, Beta, open/closed testing, live, or any other traditional gaming progress category. It's all those things and more. It's a book that is being written, both present day and its history and you get to live inside it. You shape its future. You discover its past.
2. The mechanics often influence the world as we make changes. We do everything possible to come up with IC reasoning for OOC things that simply aren't in place yet. We put a lot of effort into blending the expansion of the game with the evolution of the IC world.
3. Pearl and the Academy are melting pots. NAI is all we have right now. It's the center of the world and you are going to see things going on there that would not happen on the elemental isles. This is important to remember. You may not agree with it, but it's perfectly normal in a place such a Pearl. It's not your place to tell someone ICly or OOCly that it is wrong. It's every bit your place to react ICly to their friendships and unions in your traditional styles. No one wants to be told how they are suppose to act, especially in character. This will not make you friends. Shun them, wrinkle your nose at them, or ignore them. Do not presume to tell someone what they are doing wrong with their RP in an in character manner. This toes the line between OOC and IC. You do not know what all went into bringing them to that point.
Along these lines, targeting players because you disagree with their style of RP has become an issue that will not continue. There's a lot of thinly disguised digs at the RP of others in these posts and they are no less noticeable than the same poorly disguised IC insults we see targeting the same individuals. You've all been vague, but it all seems to center around Geel and Seren, and one sentence from our severely lacking religious guidelines. Most often is not absolute. It does not mean all of one hates all of another. Shared experiences can bring opposites together. If your character does not agree with this, they should express their dislike of it ICly. Not tell someone they are doing it wrong. If your intent is to help, there are better ways.
We are working diligently to give you more complete religious guidelines. We're fully aware that this is something that has come to a head and needs to be pushed up the ladder. This unfortunately means other projects get bumped down the list until it is addressed. We can no longer afford to table it for later though. We've seen too many lines blurred and too many OOC responses to decisions made IC. We don't plan to change anyone's RP. Much of what is being written is influenced by the players, blended with our own visions.
To bring it all full circle to the original post, the title of Prelate was something the Aerthanians came up with on their own through RP. Pyrous players organized an OOC meeting to come up with the title of their religious leader along with other notable contributions to the Pyrous guidelines being written. Archai's Renewal gave us our first real opportunity to expand Tetherias RP and a lot came from that. Much of Kaleith's culture has been influenced by observing players in character, along with interactions between Kalesian players and actors. Itzal and Astraeva have not seen the advancements of others, but they are largely made up of actors which has given us plenty of opportunities to establish their roles in Pearl and the world. The point is we have entrusted our players to assist us in this area and they have delivered. Now it is up to staff to piece all this together with our own ideals and present you with a finished project. I use the term finished lightly because as mentioned, this world is always evolving thanks to our awesome community.
There's a lot of good debate in this thread. Thanks for your desire to see a better RP community. All I ask is some patience and understanding while we address these issues as they come up.
Now, assuming we are all here to make this game a better place for ourselves and for future players, there's some things that need to be understood.
1. This is an evolving world. It cannot be labeled as Alpha, Beta, open/closed testing, live, or any other traditional gaming progress category. It's all those things and more. It's a book that is being written, both present day and its history and you get to live inside it. You shape its future. You discover its past.
2. The mechanics often influence the world as we make changes. We do everything possible to come up with IC reasoning for OOC things that simply aren't in place yet. We put a lot of effort into blending the expansion of the game with the evolution of the IC world.
3. Pearl and the Academy are melting pots. NAI is all we have right now. It's the center of the world and you are going to see things going on there that would not happen on the elemental isles. This is important to remember. You may not agree with it, but it's perfectly normal in a place such a Pearl. It's not your place to tell someone ICly or OOCly that it is wrong. It's every bit your place to react ICly to their friendships and unions in your traditional styles. No one wants to be told how they are suppose to act, especially in character. This will not make you friends. Shun them, wrinkle your nose at them, or ignore them. Do not presume to tell someone what they are doing wrong with their RP in an in character manner. This toes the line between OOC and IC. You do not know what all went into bringing them to that point.
Along these lines, targeting players because you disagree with their style of RP has become an issue that will not continue. There's a lot of thinly disguised digs at the RP of others in these posts and they are no less noticeable than the same poorly disguised IC insults we see targeting the same individuals. You've all been vague, but it all seems to center around Geel and Seren, and one sentence from our severely lacking religious guidelines. Most often is not absolute. It does not mean all of one hates all of another. Shared experiences can bring opposites together. If your character does not agree with this, they should express their dislike of it ICly. Not tell someone they are doing it wrong. If your intent is to help, there are better ways.
We are working diligently to give you more complete religious guidelines. We're fully aware that this is something that has come to a head and needs to be pushed up the ladder. This unfortunately means other projects get bumped down the list until it is addressed. We can no longer afford to table it for later though. We've seen too many lines blurred and too many OOC responses to decisions made IC. We don't plan to change anyone's RP. Much of what is being written is influenced by the players, blended with our own visions.
To bring it all full circle to the original post, the title of Prelate was something the Aerthanians came up with on their own through RP. Pyrous players organized an OOC meeting to come up with the title of their religious leader along with other notable contributions to the Pyrous guidelines being written. Archai's Renewal gave us our first real opportunity to expand Tetherias RP and a lot came from that. Much of Kaleith's culture has been influenced by observing players in character, along with interactions between Kalesian players and actors. Itzal and Astraeva have not seen the advancements of others, but they are largely made up of actors which has given us plenty of opportunities to establish their roles in Pearl and the world. The point is we have entrusted our players to assist us in this area and they have delivered. Now it is up to staff to piece all this together with our own ideals and present you with a finished project. I use the term finished lightly because as mentioned, this world is always evolving thanks to our awesome community.
There's a lot of good debate in this thread. Thanks for your desire to see a better RP community. All I ask is some patience and understanding while we address these issues as they come up.
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
Wonton wrote:I think it's actually both, which is partially why I opened the thread. Mostly religion based, but also founded at times based on race. The most obvious example of this is the Verdani's belief that they are the pure elves, and that the other elves are lesser. This may not lead to huge debacles, but even on the race page it says that it has caused divides between them and the other elven races. I also assume that there will be racial tensions between those of the same faith, living on the same isle.Shadowbane wrote:The game is based off religious conflict, not racial conflict.
That's the full quote. I did mention that for elves, it was probably both. The same can be said about any one individual. My own PC is a closet racist. There is indeed racial conflict, because there are very, very few worlds that don't possess it to some degree. In the case of SI, though, a majority of the conflict is based on religion. That was the point I was trying to make.Shadowbane wrote:The game is based off religious conflict, not racial conflict (though elves can only belong to one specific religion, based on species, so perhaps for them it's both).

Hierophant of Itzal
- Shadowbane
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 397
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
Oh, and for the record, I wasn't making a dig at anyone. As strange as some RP choices might be, I'm never going to tell someone that they're doing RP wrong. That's silly and dumb. I might say it's strange and certainly not the norm, but as it was stated earlier, Pearl and the Academy are melting pots. You're going to find some strange things there.

Hierophant of Itzal
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
Hi everyone,
As I have been reading through this thread I have to say that I was quite surprised by it. Because I see loads of conflict in the game. Have you all ever been to a Conclave meeting and watched the dynamics? Have you ever watched the dynamics at a peddle? I have found that within the game most of the conflict is personality driven not race or religion driven and it is my own personal opinion that is a good thing. Like has been pointed out by many of the people posting here, there are different sides to each religion so it by itself should not be driving RP in any way. I also feel the same about race. I belief it takes a combination of things to create conflict. And I think there is quite a bit of it. Just one guys opinion
As I have been reading through this thread I have to say that I was quite surprised by it. Because I see loads of conflict in the game. Have you all ever been to a Conclave meeting and watched the dynamics? Have you ever watched the dynamics at a peddle? I have found that within the game most of the conflict is personality driven not race or religion driven and it is my own personal opinion that is a good thing. Like has been pointed out by many of the people posting here, there are different sides to each religion so it by itself should not be driving RP in any way. I also feel the same about race. I belief it takes a combination of things to create conflict. And I think there is quite a bit of it. Just one guys opinion
Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!
Hah! What's wrong with that? I am always right, agreeing with me is the only logical thing to do. ::nods solemnly:: Would you mind sharing that wine?SquallScribe wrote:I only want to say that I agree with Doxx. And I never thought I'd type the words "I agree with Doxx" so now I'm going to go drink heavily and pretend it's all a wine dream.