Page 3 of 3
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Thu Sep 10, 2015 5:58 pm
by
Hi Conskill! It's awesome to see your name around again. Hope to run into you in game

Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Fri Sep 11, 2015 7:50 pm
by
@Roch -
the game is still in alpha/beta, which means if they decide to change combat or armor protection values etc
then your blacksteel or arcsilver which used to be Uber could go up/down in value/protection. Will this be reflected
IC-ly? ... who knows. it's hard to rp in a land that has supposedly been around hundreds of years, and NOT KNOW
the basics of material values, AR/DR etc. i have been playing for a while now, and thought blacksteel was the best, with
arcsilver coming in second, now i learn about electrum being the best? IC-ly a town full of people would know if wood is
better than iron or not... we would all know which materials are the best, and which are worst. even if we did not,
the staff could easily post a list either IC or OOC. that they refuse to do so means the game is not finished, they will be changing
things, and the electrum you bought may go up/down in value or protection etc?
it's difficult to attend a peddle when one has NO idea of the properties of the item in question?
( just lobbying for some info

... )
X.
p.s. hi Conskil

Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Fri Sep 11, 2015 11:46 pm
by
Rochiriel Azahar wrote: I meant that if you are trying to learn about which materials are better IG your first place to look for answers should be IG.
I'm not trying to learn about which materials are better. I already know ebony is a poor material for bows, and electrum is lousy material for any kind of blade. It isn't about an unknown to be discovered, it's about giving players some kind of warning when the staff decide to contradict common knowledge.
It's as if I'm being told "well, you should have asked around" when I buy a pair of boots in a game shop only to discover they can only be worn on my hands.
Before I retired, I had about 40 managers under me and a couple thousand people below them. I would never dismiss a manager for making mistakes-- I wouldn't have any if I did-- but one of the fastest ways for a manager under me to be dismissed would be for them to try to shift the blame to their subordinates after I pointed out their mistake to them.
Don't start blaming players for staff mistakes.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Sat Sep 12, 2015 6:36 pm
by
ditchhook wrote:I'm not trying to learn about which materials are better. I already know ebony is a poor material for bows, and electrum is lousy material for any kind of blade. It isn't about an unknown to be discovered, it's about giving players some kind of warning when the staff decide to contradict common knowledge.
I don't think knowing that ebony is bad wood for a bow and electrum being lousy material for a blade counts as "common knowledge". Googleable knowledge, yes. But not common. It's not like they're trying to say that the cows fly and boots are worn on your hands. They're taking less common items and making them into their own ideas. That is why it is best to find those things out IC rather than OOC.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Sat Sep 12, 2015 11:44 pm
by
Kaiya wrote:
I don't think knowing that ebony is bad wood for a bow and electrum being lousy material for a blade counts as "common knowledge". Googleable knowledge, yes. But not common. It's not like they're trying to say that the cows fly and boots are worn on your hands. They're taking less common items and making them into their own ideas. That is why it is best to find those things out IC rather than OOC.
It does count as common knowledge. By common, I mean generally shared/available knowledge. It is the generally accepted knowledge. Google-ing is not a difficult process, neither is dictionary.com. Let's promote increasing vocabularies and general knowledge here instead of "reinventing the wheel" of knowledge. Why penalize people with a larger vocabulary or knowledge of materials, engineering, medieval history, etc. etc.
There is nothing stopping staff from inventing "whisperwood" or "kanstanium" if they want to make things into their own ideas.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Sun Sep 13, 2015 12:47 am
by
I used to play the game for fun. Stuff like this, this isn't fun. It's a game, a fantasy one at that. Of all the weird things in SI, item material is a serious focus?
Too bad the game isn't complete and balanced enough for that to be a primary concern.
I also disagree with the point on "penalizing people with a larger vocabulary or knowledge" of one thing or another. When it comes to anything beyond a history book (which even then shouldn't be considered objectively accurate most days), people should learn to suspend their belief in reality. Besides that, anyone who genuinely doesn't care that a fantasy material shares a name with a real life material may have just been insulted with the suggestion they are less intelligent. Last time someone suggested others use Google to educate themselves and become cultured, they were insulting people's intelligence for not knowing what an obscure, foreign article of clothing was.
It's not staff mistake. They decided what materials were going to be high quality for this fantasy game's reality. This is a case of players allowing rl knowledge to affect their character's behavior. There is plenty I know about that my character did not act on, because my personal knowledge was not her reality. The same is true in reverse. Her understanding of reality did not translate to me.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Sun Sep 13, 2015 2:12 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:
It's not staff mistake. They decided what materials were going to be high quality for this fantasy game's reality.
It is a staff mistake. If they want to redefine the meaning of English words for the game, it's quite alright. But it is their responsibility to let us know they did that, not our responsibility to ask.
If staff can redefine any word at random, and it is player responsibility to ask, where does it end? Is balsa one of the lightest woods, or one of the heaviest? Players cannot interact with each other (role play) without a common understanding-- a language-- with common meanings. If I want to role play lifting a bundle of fifty pounds of balsa wood, should I play it out as a huge, or as a small bundle? Is parsley orange? Are apples poison? Is the bow the front of a ship, or the back? Are just nouns up for grabs or adjectives as well? Is Orange orange? How about verbs? Is running faster than walking? Is "is" IS? Do I need to send an assist request to staff to determine the attributes of every object my player encounters? Is Shattered Islands one big Bill Clinton deposition?
Shadowbane wrote:This is a case of players allowing rl knowledge to affect their character's behavior.
Of course it is! If we want to interact together at all, we are going to have to use a common language with common meanings. I strongly suggest we continue using our "rl" knowledge of English!
P.S. For those adverse to Google: balsa is a remarkably light wood, often used for kites and model airplanes.
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Sun Sep 13, 2015 10:42 pm
by
Ditchhook,
In SI:
the combination of Gold and Silver through smelting creates a beautiful metal called Electrum which is harder than steel.
Balsa wood makes an arrow that flies fast, far, and kills.
Ebony makes a great bow.
armor that fits a Sylph and the same type of armor that fits a Gargoyle, or any other race for that matter, all weigh the same despite the obvious fact that much less material would be needed for the armor worn by a Sylph. As a player I have a huge problem with this and I expressed my concerns to the staff. I expect, and hope, that it is on their radar to address.
Until staff comes out with an explanation that changes these facts please open your mind and accept it. That doesn't mean not asking questions or making suggestions, which from what I've seen the staff encourages. Just don't expect an immediate, or even a "soon", response from the staff. As you know, they have a huge list of things they are working on. It is not reasonable for anyone to expect the staff to shift gears and change their agenda to address player complaints involving current game mechanics.
Let's create more conflict and RP in game so we can continue to grow the player base. A better use of our energies in my opinion.
With respect,
Flynt's player
Re: Accurate Descriptions
Posted: Mon Sep 14, 2015 12:01 pm
by
Thank you all for your suggestions to make Shattered Isles a better place!
I will not address all the issues brought up but will say this:
S.I. is continuing to grow and expand. We are constantly working to improve the existing world, as well as make changes that will encourage newer players to join as well. I can assure you that your concerns are not being dismissed. I won't go into why traditionally poor materials are used for weapons, but just know that for now they are.
One of our struggles on staff, is the limited amount of resources we have to work with. We are at the point where we have to remove something to add something new. Are things like Niello, Electrum and Ebony realistically the best materials to work with as far as weapons/bows? NO. Would it be better to have something unique to SI? YES. However, at the moment, to change something like this is not as easy as flipping a switch. EVERYTHING using these materials or ever being made with these materials would have to be changed and re-cataloged. And to satisfy a real world vs. fantasy debate, you can understand why it is not a top priority at the moment.
While a person would NOT know the ar/dr of weapon materials, they should know at least what would be better than others. Some of the rarer materials would not neccesarily be known to people either. But regardless, and to hopefully end this debate, I will provide the current material quality list, from worst to best.
**Keep in mind this is subject to change at any time, and should not be expected to be accurate forever**
Non-Metal Armor
*Note, non-metal armor provides a DR boost. This list is in terms of damage absorbed only!
Metal Armor
*Note, only custom metal provides DR boot.
Weapons
*Note, weapons dropped by MOBs will NOT follow this progression, only store bought/peddle ones.
Bows
*Note, weapons dropped by MOBs will NOT follow this progression, only store bought/peddle ones.
Now you know. And right or wrong, real world vs. fantasy, these are currently how materials stack up in Shattered Isles.
Thank you.
Now go back to playing already and leave the poor dead horse alone!
***EDIT****
Since this information has not been used responsibly and things have changed and are still changing, I am officially removing the information.
With Love,
The great and merciless Pahzrael