Page 3 of 8
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2016 11:43 am
by
Snaek wrote:
Spirits are working as designed.
I no longer get sucked through the portal when I die. I'm stuck in the death room until I resurrect at the altar, is that a bug then?
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2016 1:40 pm
by
I've never purposely died in order to walk around as a spirit. Afterall, that's time I'm missing out on getting uses. If you choose not to use what you've seen while dead, then that's personal preference. But it's a supported mechanic that most people use to have fun with in the case of you dying.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2016 2:56 pm
by
And I will continue to extend that courtesy to players, even if they've essentially decided not to show the same courtesy to others. It's a cheese, and it's cheap.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 10:54 am
by
And I will continue to extend that courtesy to players, even if they've essentially decided not to show the same courtesy to others. It's a cheese, and it's cheap.
This is pretty ridiculous. Why is the mechanic there? So we can watch orcs? Or they're trusting us to completely avoid people? Maybe sit in an empty room? What's the rule? No contact with other people at all, to avoid spying? If the Creators really wanted this, the mechanic should be limited or non existent. Or they'd make our ghosts visible or give off a moan or something. The mechanic's existence tells me the Creators don't want me to be bored while I'm dead and I use it as such. There's no way to differentiate between malicious spying and harmless people watching.
This all ignores how hard actual spying is. I know from past experience. Unless there's something like an actual temple meeting going on, it's near impossible to figure out when to spy, because most people aren't secretly plotting world domination all the time. Even if they are holding conversations when you go, it's likely something worthless. Perfect invisbility doesn't change that. Not to mention you have a time limit with death, so you can't do a long term stalking, which is the real way to get info on a person.
I will continue to people watch, although hopefully I'm done with dying so much. If the Creators don't want me doing this, all they have to do is tell me to stop it. I'd never go into a temple even as a ghost, but that's a character decision. If I was playing say a nasty Pyresian, I'd happily go into other temples.
If the mechanic has been changed that's fine, too. I'm not sure as I haven't died in quite a while.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 10:58 am
by
Spirits are working as designed. They can't pass through closed doors, so be extra suspicious and paranoid when discussing secretive stuff. Eventually priests will be able to detect spirits, so that will help out some.
It appears Snaek expects people are using death to spy and has no problem with it.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 1:51 pm
by
You can't even go into temples if the gate OR the doors are closed, which they almost always are. I don't think anyone else really has an issue with the spirit system, so it's not a huge deal. There's plenty of restrictions in place already. Unlike being able to hide and stalk a target with 100% impunity if they aren't a mage.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 3:49 pm
by
And that's fine if Snaek has no problem with it. I imagine there is plenty staff is ok with that players are not. There are several people, however, who do have an issue with it. I'm just the only one speaking out about it. You're dead because you messed up. We should not be able to benefit from messing up, we should sit there in the time out we deserved to think about what we did wrong, and how to not do wrong again. It's not the timed lockout that other games like SI have, but there shouldn't be a way to benefit from it.
As someone who leveled hide, sneak, and stealth pretty high, I know the limits and restrictions on those skills. It is hard for anyone using sneak and hide to keep up with someone if they are moving. With stealth, it is a quick and constant fatigue drain every time you move, and it's not perfect. The more a person is forced to move, the harder it is to stay hidden. Those doors and gates DO hinder them, and let's remember that NPCs catch you without actually seeing you enter the room. They're constantly spamming their own LOOK command.
Just because you CAN, doesn't mean you SHOULD. That is the most basic explanation of ethics. This applies to everything from science to games. There's a lot we can do in this game that people choose not to, because they know they shouldn't. It is the same concept that should discourage people from being absolute pricks at peddles when new characters or players are struggling to upgrade their equipment; just because your (general) character is a self-proclaimed snert, does not mean he SHOULD be one all the time. It's a little sad that people don't understand something so simple.
At least new players looking through our forums will know what to expect, right? This kind of stuff makes us look GREAT. So go ahead, take advantage of a mechanic that no one can prevent. It's more foolproof than the game's stealthiest character.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 4:47 pm
by
The last 5 times I've died was due to horrible internet connections or game crashes, so I wouldn't say that's my fault or that I messed up. The entire spirit mechanic will be expanded on later as well. No one dies on purpose, just to walk around as a ghost, I think you're really taking it to the extreme here. You don't even sit in spirit form for very long either. I think it's great that there's something to do when you've died, and so do many others.
I'm not oblivious to the "restrictions" of stealth and sneaking. 130+ FTG takes a while to drain. I believe the success chance at level 60ish was 74% or so. But they are very small penalties to skills that have ZERO counters to anyone other than a mage, who also has to be actively casting the spell to find the hidden person. Obviously this has nothing to do with NPC's, not sure why that was even brought up.
Arguing ethics is ridiculous in this case. It's a working mechanic that's been in the game forever and hasn't been abused by chain dying or anything else that you've taken to the extreme. Just because you think it's not okay to do, doesn't mean others think the same way. And obviously the makers of the game don't feel that way either, so guess who's in the minority? If you want to think you're more ethical because you don't use an INTENDED game mechanic, than good for you, carry on and feel better about yourself.
In regards to peddles: The only weapons I've seen people bid high for are max, or close to max weapons. Anything under blacksteel (sometimes even blacksteel) goes for almost nothing, so I'm not sure where you're drawing your observasions from? Maybe you could provide an example of occurances where a weapon under max was bid on for the sole purpose of being snerty?
I think new players would look here and see 1 person who's upset over an intended mechanic, that's been confirmed working as intended by the CREATOR, against a bunch of others who don't have issues with it, lol.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 8:02 pm
by
I don't think running around as a spirit was intended for intelligence gathering. It seems more like a pity offering to give people who die something to do besides staring at a screen numbly while they wait to play again.
Mages have the only active means against stuff like this, but that doesn't leave everyone else hanging. Be creative. It's not that hard to mess up the plans of someone who intends to spy on you. The two biggest things people can do is not be predictable, and not be stationary. It's pretty simple.
The fact that people think it's ok to use death as a means to spy on people is, personally, equal parts disgusting and disappointing. Now that it IS apparently ok and kosher for people to spy on others while dead, how long is it going to take for someone to use it that way? The second people are told "hey, we're cool with it" is the second someone else considers that extreme. This comes from the creators of a game that don't enforce their own lore or CoC, so take that as you will. I have every bit of faith that this game's community will go to whatever extremes they feel are necessary to get an edge, up to and including bending the CoC as much as they can. It's what people do.
As for being one person who's upset over this against a bunch of others? You can laugh. I'm not the only one. I'm just the only one with a pair enough to speak out against it, or the means to do so.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2016 8:22 pm
by
It honestly doesn't matter if you think it was meant for that or not, because you didn't make the game....it's not up to you to decide what is for what.
Because you always know when someone is gonna spy on you, right? Telling someone to "be creative" is just like me telling you to "be creative" when it comes to spirits. You'll agrue all day that it's not the same and i'll argue that it's exactly the same. So I guess we can leave it at that.
You and everyone else ultimately have 2 choices: You can play the game and accept the mechanics, regardless of your own, personal feelings. Or you can not play the game. It's a really easy choice. If it bothers you that much that people "might" do something that's within the intentions and mechanics of the game, then I dunno what to tell you. Maybe don't worry about what other people are doing and worry about how you're playing.