[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Bad shield, BAD! - Page 3
Page 3 of 9

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:09 pm
by
Additionally I would think a Priest would avoid PvP for the most part... I mean they are healers after all

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:17 pm
by
You are free to limit yourself as you please. I see nothing wrong with using the tools and abilities you have available, however. Don't try to insist on something to be restricted if you aren't willing to accept similar treatment. I imagine those with a high mending skill probably have it for a very good reason. I'd hate to see even more work and time tossed into the trash.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:23 pm
by
Mending needs to remain a viable way for non healers to heal up while hunting. They also need to be able to run out of a room barely alive, and start healing right away. It's a situation I find myself in often.

It'd be nice if weapon and natural users got some kind of major damage bonus to someone wound mending in front of them. I don't think this is necessary for spellcasters. Someone wound mending in front of a skilled mage would probaly be killed. It's the wound mending and defenses combo anyway, and spells go around defenses.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:27 pm
by
Additionally I would think a Priest would avoid PvP for the most part... I mean they are healers after all
That's not really a valid argument, or all that relative to the topic at hand. Do I think Priests should be as PvP combat-capable as mages and melee classes? No, but I don't think they should be stripped of what they have and left unable to participate at all, either.
Mending needs to remain a viable way for non healers to heal up while hunting.
Yes, thank you.
I imagine those with a high mending skill probably have it for a very good reason.
My reason? WOLVES.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:36 pm
by
However priest seem extremely overpowered to me CC/Parry/Shield/Spell Shield/Healing spell/Vigor/DMG Spells/defend.
As Anselm had said, priests do not have parry, and are only equipped with a single passive defense: shield block.

As well, as Anselm said, our CC progression doesn't really give us any advantage over CC focused classes. Loriel will never out-fence any combat class. The most I can do with CC is attempt to soak up a passive defense of my opponent, increase my stamina, and make my character slightly harder to hit with the increased DR. Though, against at CC-based class, and even at lvl 100 CC, the difference won't mean much; CC for me is mainly just for the stamina.

The shield spell is pretty much a joke in PvP. At level 100, my DR would increase by about 70 or 80. Against CC classes, this increase wouldn't even slow them down, not even in conjunction with lvl 100 CC.

We don't have damage spells, we have one offensive spell that does nearly nothing to anything unless it's undead. In fact, that might be the most broken thing about priests right now. Strike does quite a lot of damage versus undead. I can 1v1 solo vampires and my skills aren't anywhere near what other PCs in the game must have to even try to attempt such a feat. At any rate, Holy strike really isn't a viable PvP damage spell. It's not really a viable PvE damage spell, unless I'm hunting undead.

Defend is actually one of my favorite skills. It turns priests in an effective heal tank, while also drawing the agro from another so the priest can heal them faster. But it's not a defensive skill, per say, in that it doesn't keep me from taking damage. I'm not sure how defend works in PvP though. In PvE, mobs don't retarget, but PCs can. It'd be cool if defend blocked a PC from targeting another PC for a certain amount of time based on the defend level.
They need a reduction in defense the fact they have a healing spell is a huge thing defensively.
Priests healing and vigor spells might need a bit of tweaking, it's true, and I won't argue at all that balancing what they can do offensively with the fact that they can heal will be challenging. The fact that I can 1v1 solo vampires right now probably shows that I am either able to heal much more than I should at my current level, I do too much damage to undead at my current level, or some manner of both. Healing, right now, is our second defense, where shield block is our first, the ability to heal (roughly) balanced currently by the fact that a priest's damage output is on par with a wet noodle (which is where it needs to be, frankly, since priests are not combat roles, but support). I don't know how many priest abilities are implemented at the moment, but I think I've exhausted them. We've got a heal, a rejuvenate, and a shield spell. And that's pretty much it. We've also got cure disease and cure poison, but diseases and poisons aren't implemented yet, so there's really not much point to them.
Think of it this way a max prayer and heal with max shield. You can block a little less than 50% unbuffed of my damage while you would be laying waste to me I have no defense against spells.
With max shield block, priests do have the ability to block quite a few incoming blows. But due to a low AR / DR progression, any hit you get past the shield is pretty much guaranteed to hit. And with a decently leveled CC (not even max), plus some peddle grade weapons (even just steel), you're going to hit pretty hard. We might be able to out heal you at lvl 100, but out heal you and out damage you? Using strike against a PvP opponent would be like grinding you away with sandpaper: annoying, but not entirely effective. Plus, at the current effectiveness of mend, you could probably just sit and out heal our strike damage.

Edited to add: However, besides the shield blocking all damage from a hit, the only other damage reduction in the game currently is armor. Holy shield doesn't reduce damage received, just raises DR. I think there are plans for absorption spells/prayers, so when these come in I expect some more balancing to occur.

All classes do have resistances to spells. Not sure where that level is at, but it's there. Spells as a whole, however, should cut through most of a melee's defenses. It makes up for the fact that melee can pretty much hit spellcasters without effort as well.

And I know what you might say, casters have a shield to block with; they do, but what they don't have is the ability to easily increase their damage output. They can't go out and by a 'blacksteel' spell at the next peddle and instantly have their damage output increased. It takes many many many grueling hours to stabilize a spell's damage and many more to increase it.
If you're saying it should be unusable in combat as per game mechanics though, then I most certainly do NOT.
I actually think this might be an easy way to balance the ability. Combat healing is a powerful skill, and having the option to do it needs to be balanced carefully. This is no different for priests than it is CC classes. Priests can't put out damage, which balances the fact they can heal in combat right now, but CC classes can put out damage, and thus their ability to heal needs to be checked in a way that it is not currently.

I am not adamantly against mending remaining as a means of combat healing, but the fact that a combat class can heal in combat while suffering no penalties, save for a slight DR reduction from sitting (what is it, around 2 or 3?), makes the ability a bit too powerful. Yes, mending fails a lot (something I noticed when I have used it on some of my other characters I tooled around with for a bit), but you can work it up to where it fails less and less - eventually to where it hardly fails at all, and voila, you've got a healing spell in your back pocket.

I want to say this again, I am not against the ability remaining in combat; it seems like the easiest way to balance the skill at the moment, but I know it might not be the best. Other ideas for in-combat healing could include an increase in DR reduction for sitting (which should probably be increased regardless, as well as the one for laying down), needing to have an empty hand available for mending (or be completely unarmed, like you must be to use grapple), an increase in the delay, or a combination of these in varying degrees.
On the one hand, it does make little sense from a realistic point of view to be able to do all those things and still mend yourself in the middle of a fight
Yes, looking at the logic of doing all of this at once, it seems a bit comical to think a character can effectively block incoming blows as well as spend the time to focus on mending their wounds. All while sitting down.
but on the other, we need what mending power we have, and I can tell you that it likes to fail quite often. As someone who enjoys her solo hunts and has had to make use of the skill countless times, I think I'd prefer it be left alone.
I don't want mending to be taken away, nor do I want it nerfed so that it becomes a useless tool for solo hunters. I also don't want to create a dependency on priests or templars for healing, because I don't think you should need one to hunt or play the game, but I do want to a create distinct separation of class abilities and be sure that effective combat healing stays in the domain of the classes that are built for it, who have reduced effectiveness in other areas to make up for their increased support. Classes that have the damage output should have their ability to heal checked accordingly as well.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 2:52 pm
by
It's my perspective I'm not pushing it on anyone. Mending is a viable way as it is if you can't take the damage walk away mend up and get back into it. Mending in the middle of combat while being swung at how is it even possible? I'm not saying that someone can or can't I just don't understand how it seems completely unrealistic I think someones level should effect success rate and amount healed I still think it shouldn't be able to be used while in combat it makes absolutely no sense. I don't think priest can't PvP I just would think they would avoid it would be more accurate. I absolutely would be willing to loose the ability to mend while in combat I didn't (and wouldn't) do it last night when I was doing PvP for a prize that I actually need. Priest mechanicly seemed pretty outstanding perhaps I was mistaken though.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 3:10 pm
by
If mending couldn't be used in combat, that would screw every melee class out of being able to focus on training a defensive ability. I would much rather see a greater decrease in DR when sitting and laying down.

I'm OCD enough to find myself struggling to keep my defensive and offensive abilities on par with each other. It's bad enough I can't focus train all of my class abilities. If more were added to the list (and I'm of the opinion that you should be able to exclusively train anything on your skill list, otherwise it's pointless to have it as an actual skill) then it would ruin my enjoyment of the game a little more.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 3:15 pm
by
If mending couldn't be used in combat, that would screw every melee class out of being able to focus on training a defensive ability. I would much rather see a greater decrease in DR when sitting and laying down
I very much disagree particularly since you can just move one room over heal up and move back and the mobs will almost certainly still be there. Even if a timer gets implemented the same principle will apply plus it will raise the value of group hunting which I think is ONLY a good thing.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 3:17 pm
by
Only reason I didn't mend is because I forgot about it. Those shields since the "fix" to them are way more effective than both my parries. I rolled a mage and had level 10 shield before I had level 10 flame strike. I can't level dodge or parry that easy in the 1st 10 levels.

Re: Bad shield, BAD!

Posted: Fri Feb 14, 2014 3:22 pm
by
Only reason I didn't mend is because I forgot about it. Those shields since the "fix" to them are way more effective than both my parries. I rolled a mage and had level 10 shield before I had level 10 flame strike. I can't level dodge or parry that easy in the 1st 10 levels.
You don't know what level of shield block I am ;-)