Sorry, long post is long.
Morley wrote:I count a lot of "if"s in the above.
Unfortunately, ifs are all we have right now. If traps and poisons are put in, then some of the defenses might have to go. If they're not, then the defenses will probably stay - although if they aren't I don't really know what the assassin class is except for a warrior with backstab.
Morley wrote:If the tournaments have shown anything, it's that defense matters more than offense
Those fights were were in a controlled environment with equally skilled opponents, where each attacker knew who their opponent was and when they would strike. As an assassin, using traps and poison, your defender wouldn't get this luxury.
Morley wrote:Draven could have probably bitten me to death with his level 10 bite.
This is because bite seems to be broken right now. It shouldn't be able to kill you at level 10 with, what I'm guessing, is your high level CC and therefore high AR/DR.
Morley wrote:So a class geared for offense is actually weaker than one that can't be hit.
This is probably because there isn't any effective way, besides magic, to cut through a defense. CC vs passive defense will take a while because the two are geared to oppose each other. Traps and poison, when implemented, should help assassins get past someone's thick defenses. To clarify my comment from my previous post, I think assassins should be offensive in nature, but offensive using guile, planning, and surprise rather than straight "kill it" combat.
Morley wrote:Also the RNG is pretty effective at rendering levels and AR/DR useless too, since you were able to hit Nikolas.
To me, it was more surprising how much damage I did to Nikolas. I was landing grazing hits, yes, but decent strikes as well. My CC is terribly low, and yet I was actually able to some decent damage to him per strike, which should actually prove how effective CC actually is as a skill in general. Would Loriel have ever been able to kill Nikolas in a duel? No, because priests' AR is 2 and my CC isn't very high, and even at level 100 I'd have 200, maybe 250 max. The RNG might be cruel, but it's not priest eviscerates warrior cruel.
Wren wrote:Assassins don't currently excel in anything, there's nothing about the class to make it exciting or worthwhile to put effort into if you can roll a Thief for example and have Disguise, which is infinitely better than Masking, and still have access to SS/BS/Poisons/Sneak, or go Warrior and still get Dual Wield/Dual Parry and be able to swap to a shield for Shield Block to fight against natural users.
That's why I maintain that poison should remain an assassin only skill. And they should have some traps that only they can make if another class were to get the skill. Thieves, because they have so much already, shouldn't be given poison.
Wren wrote:I honestly don't know how an Assassin's damage compares to that of other classes, and maybe things will change once class stats are implemented and racials don't count for as much, but given that an Assassin in better armor with 10-15 more CC levels couldn't take down a Warrior and was getting hit pretty hard in return, the idea of our offense being reduced is kinda scary.
Assassins get the same AR / DR as warriors, and two defenses as well. Your damage output should be exactly the same as any other CC class.
As well, as I suggested above, I don't think your offense should be reduced, just focused in the area of poisons and traps. I think assassins should be a very offensive class, but their offense should be different from a warrior's offense.
Also, what assassin vs. warrior fight are you referencing? Was this at the fight club?
Wren wrote:This is how the class should be. High initial burst abilities. Get it done quickly or get the hell out kinda deal.
This is what the class of assassin suggests. The cost for that incredible burst will probably come from an assassins defenses though, wether that's removing duel parry, lower DR, both, or something else entirely.
However, that isn't what it has to be. It could be a blend of less burst, and utility.
Morley wrote:Assassins reflect the darkest and most wicked side of the rogue. The dealing of death becomes a goal in itself, the epitome of evil. The assassin becomes so centered on this art that he begins to slow his pace, learning and contemplating each "mark" as the best method of killing them becomes clear. They also learn skills in keeping track of and tracking down their marks, as well as other means of making life for the targeted miserable, and short. The assassin can use any weapons, unlike the standard thief, though his armor is still restricted.
I don't even know how accurate the site information is any more to the staff's direction. A lot of things have changed since that site has been put up.