[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Tell me again how weak mages are. - Page 3
Page 3 of 6

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 10:10 pm
by
Blink is no ordinary mage with a sword though. He's quite good with close combat.
But yeah, low strength.

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 10:12 pm
by
Creon wrote:I think a lot of issues for mages could be worked out by Implementing a few of the following:

Slow change it to 1 sec delay level 1-49 2 sec delay 50-99 3 sec delay 100.

Heya mate,

I wanted to respond to a few of your points and suggestions, and maybe give a better understanding of what we want for casters and how casters fit into the world, at least a bit.

Right now slow doesn't really work on a second delay. It's a multiplication delay, really, because that's how the code it. Maybe we'd make it a static, flat number in the future. There's really no plans to make it change from level, because I'd point out that slow already has to be unlocked from a different spell at a higher level, and also has to be leveled individually.

One thing in the future to counteract slow, at least in part for some, will be haste. Unfortunately right now we can't keep haste in for balance purposes. We want haste in, really, we do. But in a game without staggered delay drops, it isn't fair to put in haste and allow people to get uses whilst hasted. This would allow for certain classes to level significantly faster than others.

An alternative to this would simply be to give every single class a haste, but obviously that's incredibly unbalanced and isn't a viable solution.
Creon wrote:Increase the RT of damaging spells by 1 second mathematically I think this could bring the average in significantly more although with there damage consistency they should have a lot more output.
Right now a t3 attack spell will do the same damage or slightly less as a one-handed steel weapon bought in Vogrok's shop. As I responded to Blink's post about mage damage, that's something we'll probably need to increase for mages because that's disheartening, I'd imagine, to be mid-level t3 attack spell and not really seeing a even slightly noticeable increase in damage.

What I want to point out, however, and really want to stress to every single person is that there's one significant difference in caster damage versus melee damage right now: the damage range bottom and top end. Weapons actually have a higher top-end than caster spells, but right now due to something we DO NOT want they also have a significantly lower bottom end. Gir works tirelessly at trying to figure out how to tighten the weapon damage range. It's something want fixed. We don't want a bulky, sturdy two-hander hitting someone say 20 through blacksteel, but then also randomly hitting them for two. That's not intended or wanted.

(yes, SOME of this is racial damage modifiers - yet, racial statistics and modifiers cannot be ignored when speaking about classes. There are drawbacks to choosing a larger race, and there's drawbacks to choosing a more humanoid race. We're slowly addressing those. It might be really unfortunate for a player that their humanoid character doesn't do as much damage as a larger, more bestial race but that's one of the decisions you make for roleplay. It's one of the decisions that should be acknowledged and understood when considering mechanical outcomes)

This must be kept in mind when talking about casters, because there seems to be a lot of critique on how casters function whilst not keeping in mind hey, weapons aren't functioning how we want them. We're not going to punish casters because of something that needs to be fixed. I'm sure some melee feel like recent changes were made to punish them because of how things are currently, but that isn't true. Each adjustment is made with long-term balance kept in mind.

With that being said, who knows how those fights turn out if the damage range is where we want it for weapons, if more than one of them has a higher quality weapon, and also widely important: if the resist system was working like we want, and as I said earlier, is something we'll definitely be looking into.
Creon wrote:Restrict armor to lighter less protecting versions.
We'll likely see armour restrictions in the future for a number of classes.

Creon wrote:Remove the use of shield skill and increase the effectiveness of the shield spell.
We're not going to remove shield skills from casters. It's their only passive defence. It's their only defence check. In the fight against Requiem, he attacked Faran (since this is the event in which we're all referring) sixteen times. He hit ten times, missed two times, and was blocked four times. In the fight against Draven, he attacked Faran fifteen times. He hit thirteen times, missed one time, and was blocked one time. In the fight against Morley, he attacked Faran eleven times. He hit eight times, he missed one time, and was blocked twice.

As I mentioned above, the resist system obviously isn't where we want it (and I don't think you'd find any caster that would argue against fixing it), and we'll definitely be looking into it and adjusting it. With keeping in mind we want to fix the resist system and we definitely, one-hundred percent want to tighten the melee weapon damage range: do people think it's fair to take a caster's only passive defence-check against melee away? Do they think it's fair when you consider, looking above, how often a caster was hit? Do they think a caster should inexplicably also have to level unarmed combat/close combat to be on an even playing field with melee? If so, I'd ask why?

This isn't even bringing into question or consideration the massive ramifications it'd have in PVE. Even if we increased the effectiveness of the current shield spells (which increase DR), they are negligible in comparison to the AR/DR scale.

Creon wrote:Lowering the length of the slow spell / giving a pulse stamina cost (as the spell goes on in intervals it takes 5 stam away or whatever staff deems appropriate)
This is definitely something we want to add. We want to have pulsing spells of all kinds have a ftg cost, we one-hundred percent agree. As to whether we'll decrease the length of the slow spell, I'm not sure. It's something to think about, though.
Creon wrote:this is slightly separate but healing prayers should possibly take a slight penalty if the player is being attacked. I don't know if the penalty is how effective it will be or if it will go off but the priest could literally outheal 2 players damage. Maybe this would change when the RNG of weapons gets tightened up but I thought it might be worth mentioning.
We'll likely need to check lower healing prayer returns, yes. I'm wary over doing so from last night's events because the one time Loriel was being attacked by players, one of the melee attackers was a mage. It's also, again, a controlled event. But his previous reports on returns for vampire hunting at his relative level is something we've been talking about, and it's a matter we'll look over and try to address/figure out.
Creon wrote:I don't necessarily think all these ideas should be implemented I would mix and match it would help bring balance to the class. I had the highest racial modifier and I couldn't get Faran less than 30% of her health with a two hander before she could get me down over 200HP. It's not bad that the mage can do that much damage it's that there is no real check against it.

Very Respectfully,
Draven's Player

You're right about health, in a way. You were 9.5% of your health, Faran was 32% of hers. But something to keep in mind is armour difference as well. If your character had the highest available armour material that many other characters have, let's say that shaves off an average of two damage taken each of Faran's eighteen attacks against Draven. That's thirty-six health points. If the resist system was working, that'll shave off a little more damage for the four resists. That could entirely change the outcome of the fight, or any fights. This isn't even bringing up a tightened damage range for melee weapons so they don't bottom out at two point attacks randomly.

One of the comments I saw frequently and something I got a sense of is this thread is how 'quickly' it seemed a caster won. But that's two-fold, and can't be ignored. Yes, a caster won in a quick amount of time compared to melee vs melee fights. However, if the melee had won these fights against a caster, they would have won in a significantly shorter amount of time they'd beat another melee. People can't bemoan how fast a caster won without acknowledging if they had lost, they'd lose in an incredibly fast time as well.

In another thread Loriel made, someone else commented that we should want to build up classes rather than tear others down, so let's apply that here. The biggest issue seems not to be that casters are mightily overpowered or even a bit overpowered, but rather there are two problems: physical weapon damage range and a resist system we thought was working but isn't. That's two issues we've acknowledged (the physical weapon damage range one a LONG time that frustrates us as staffers to no end) and we want to fix. Does it appear this is an issue with caster damage, defence and slow, or problems elsewhere that aren't in-line with how we want those items/abilities to work?





Cheers!
Anselm.

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2014 3:21 am
by
You guys are super awesome, and patient. Thanks, Dudes.


DOMINATE!

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2014 11:59 pm
by
Re-reading this
It's also, again, a controlled event.
Even in an "uncontrolled" event any melee will lose to a mage. Because all the "uncontrolled" event based attacks to catch them by surprise are by all definitions broken. Even then with 4 second attacks and no stealth skill you're not surprising anyone. You have one shot maybe two, if they panic, before they hit you with a slow then they have all the time in the world to cast shield, ready armor, and so forth before your next attack lands, assuming it's not stopped by a shield shaped like a glove so they never have to unready it. I called it months ago when I said I should have rolled a mage if I wanted to kill anyone in the game.
outright lying
link please

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 1:29 am
by
In the fight against Requiem, he attacked Faran (since this is the event in which we're all referring) sixteen times. He hit ten times, missed two times, and was blocked four times. In the fight against Draven, he attacked Faran fifteen times. He hit thirteen times, missed one time, and was blocked one time. In the fight against Morley, he attacked Faran eleven times. He hit eight times, he missed one time, and was blocked twice.
You forgot to mention that against Requiem she got off 1 slow 21 daggers plus 1 miscast dagger 23 in all, Requiem resisted once
16 attempts 10 hits 2 misses 4 blocks against 22 attempts 20 "hits"(not counting resists) 1 "miss" and 1 "resist

62% success rate against 95%... but counting resists as hits... this is still 95%
Now let's pretend she had no shield... what would that do?
87% vs 95%

Draven - she got off 1 slow 18 daggers with 1 miscast slow and 1 miscast dagger. 21 in all Draven resisted 4 times
15 attempts 13 hits 1 miss 1 block against 19 attempts 14 "hits" 1 "miss" and 4 "resists"

86% vs 73% this is really 94.7%

93% vs 94.7%


and then 1 slow 15 daggers, with 2 miscast daggers. so 19 in all with 5 resists
11 attempts 8 hits 1 miss 2 blocks against 17 attempts 10 "hits" 2 "miss" with 5 "resists"


72% vs 58% and this is really 88%

90% vs 88%

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 4:02 am
by
Teef wrote:
assuming it's not stopped by a shield shaped like a glove so they never have to unready it.
It would be much appreciated if you could at least get facts right when you attempt to belittle, demean or otherwise petulantly and pathetically point fingers at other people because you feel lacking in some manner.

Faran, my PC, does not walk around with her armor or her shield constantly readied -- much unlike the Morley character, which inexplicably, almost always seems to have his armor and/or weapon readied, even when in casual settings and situations like, oh, I don't know.... sitting in a tavern and chatting. So before you go throwing poorly formed mud-pies, kindly make sure they haven't been fat-fingered together from the own muck you yourself are covered in.

Since you enjoy logs so much, here is the ill-fated attempt on Faran by Seryth which I'm sure you remember:
You exhale a bit of frost at Seryth.

Kalevala notches an arrow.

Seryth thrusts a short ebony-handled steel dirk at you.
The attack is a minor cut (4).

Frozen shards of ice begin to crystallize before you. The shards converge into a single dagger, crashing into Seryth!

The ice dagger is a decent strike.
[Delay: 4.0 sec.]


Nikolas moves in front of you to defend against Seryth.


Seryth thrusts a short ebony-handled steel dirk at you.
The attack is a minor cut (4).

Seryth dodges Kalevala's attack!
Kalevala removes a simple birch bow.
Frozen shards of ice begin to crystallize before you. The shards converge into a single dagger, crashing into Seryth!

The ice dagger is a decent strike.
[Delay: 4.0 sec.]


Nikolas swings a thin cross-hilted midnight blacksteel sosun pattah at Seryth.
The attack is a grazing cut.


Seryth thrusts a short ebony-handled steel dirk at you.
The attack is a minor cut (5).


Kalevala wields a simple iron dagger.
Morley reveals himself from his hidden position.
Morley thrusts a short ebony-handled steel dirk at Nikolas.
The attack is a decent strike.
Seryth dodges Nikolas’s attack!


Seryth thrusts a short ebony-handled steel dirk at you.
The attack is a mild prick (2).
You hold a lapis rune-inscribed arcsilver claw-finger gauntlet.
[Delay: 3.0 sec.]
So you'll notice (I'm certain of it, as I made it easy to spot with pretty, red bold words), Seryth attacked four (4) times before I readied my "shield shaped like a glove so I never have to unready it." Clearly I walk around with it readied at all times. And clearly I had it "shaped like a glove" so I could make this possible -- a claim both so delusional and fantastical to conceive of when it is clearly not an issue (since you and a number of other PCs constantly walk around in armor/shields/weapons almost at all times) for people to do so. Or perhaps it is only an issue if I were to do it. But I don't, so you can take that complaint and place it firmly back into the feebly constructed "Teef didn't get his way today" arguments box and have a nice day.
Teef wrote: Even then with 4 second attacks and no stealth skill you're not surprising anyone. You have one shot maybe two, if they panic, before they hit you with a slow then they have all the time in the world to cast shield, ready armor, and so forth before your next attack lands
It's always enjoyable when misinformation runs rampant, fostered by petty grievance and a rudimentary grasp of personal responsibility.

Yes, a mage's slow helps them. That is what the spell is designed to do. It debuffs the person trying to kill the mage so they do not get hit quite as often as a 4 second swing allows, seeing as how their DR is significantly lower than melee classes (even if they were to train close combat, which should not be required for a primarily casting class). I fail to see why you believe you are entitled to win 1v1 in a controlled environment against an elf mage when you have chosen - for whatever purposes - an elven meleer. Elves are not designed to be strong melee PCs. They will, in fact, be poor at it, despite the AR/DR advantages of the class progression because their strength is abysmal. That is a choice you will have to live with. And since racial mods for casting are not yet implemented, you perhaps did not lose as bad as you could have in that instance as well.

Furthermore, the claim that mages have "all the time in the world to cast shield, ready armor, and so forth before your next attack lands" is wildly inaccurate and exaggerated. You have, at most, six seconds to wait if the slow had just fallen on you as you attacked, and are presumably attacking again. In addition, it takes time away from attacking you to ready a shield, wear armor and cast the laughably negligible DR spell we have - which I only cast during the AFC because I had the time to buff and thought 'what the heck'. If you recall, I did not cast it during the uncontrolled fight against Seryth and Morley on the ferry because there is no point. It would take eight seconds in total to ready armor or a shield and then cast the shield spell; it would take eleven seconds in total to ready armor, ready shield and cast the shield spell -- both of those combinations, for your reference, are more than the six seconds of your attack delay.

Draven very nearly beat Faran. He very likely would have if he had had a blacksteel weapon and blacksteel armor. He did not. He had steel. He still hit Faran at his highest for 19 points of damage through her blacksteel armor. Faran would have lost just as swiftly as she won had Draven had those things because his race is designed to be a big meaty smack-it and excels in melee classes. From my recollection, the Draven PC is around three months old. Faran will be six months old later this month. I have three months more of power training on my PC than he does (yes, my 8 - 12 hours in game are usually spent power training. Shocking. I know.) Since others put such high importance on the time and effort invested into their characters, it would be more than disheartening if Draven could so easily defeat the powerful mage that Faran is, given he has only had to actively work one skill (close combat) to be viable.
Teef wrote: I called it months ago when I said I should have rolled a mage if I wanted to kill anyone in the game.
Do it. Please. If only to transfer the incessant complaining constantly spewed about how awful your current class is to the new one. There are already a few who abandoned casters for melee whom had previously clamored for casting fixes, only to then turn around and do the same for whatever class they are now.

p.s. I won't hold my breath for the wit of the collective internet you will have to plagiarize to respond to this post in meme form.

p.p.s. As to the other claims in this thread, I defer to the much less exhausted and angry explaining Anselm did in an attempt to inject reason, logic and awareness back into out of character discussions about the mechanics of the game.

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 7:09 am
by
I have removed the previous post; however they came to the conclusion they did, they are incorrect. It is inappropriate to insinuate the players behind other characters, unless they themselves have made it known. It is not fair to others to make those claims and we will not tolerate it. Many of our players aren't from the same games you may have played before, and none of us should have to read it now anyway. Leave whatever baggage you have back there.

Also, while a poster's forum handle may be tied to a previous game and they may have shared their real name there, unless they have done so here, it should not be posted. I have modified the post prior to the deleted one to reflect this.

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 9:30 am
by
Since others put such high importance on the time and effort invested into their characters, it would be more than disheartening if Draven could so easily defeat the powerful mage that Faran is, given he has only had to actively work one skill (close combat) to be viable.
I don't think most non mages grasp how much time goes into non combat spells for a mage. It's an enormous time sink. And it's probaly going to get worse with more spells added in the new system. I for example power trained my wall spell for weeks, which did absolutely nothing for my character. (I could have gained 10 CC levels in that time, and that's at my current level CC rates of around 5000 uses and more) I was under the delusion it'd unlock fly. Part of me likes having lots of goals, but if I was a melee I'd likely already have dual wield with the time I've put into Blink's magic and Close Combat. I'm not sure why, but I tend to get 600 uses an hour for CC, but only like 400-450 for lightning bolt. And some of the spells are much worse due to high rates, and/or fatigue. Or having to dispel the spell each time.

But yes, if my goal was just to go around killing people I'd make a Gavial or Vukasin melee character. Especially since I'd be sure something like spell resists not working would be fixed. It'd be a poor long term character strategy to rely on broken things to make my character powerful.

But yes, mages ARE a bit broken, for the reasons Anselm has stated. We aren't going to get a very accurate reading or combat test without those issues fixed. It doesn't matter much time you've put into grinding, SI isn't designed for one person to be hugely powerful. Taking on two or three characters will often prove difficult, unless something is very broken, or levels in your primary attack are vastly different. (Assuming everything is fixed and working right, like mid level third tier attack spells)

Oh yeah, I want to say I'm also glad that there are a ton of Human and elf melee people in the game. It's good to have roleplay diversity. It can get pretty tiresome when every warrior is a Vukasin and every mage is an Elf. That's why I love the idea of the elemental elves as well, especially Avardi of course.

I don't believes elven mages are that much better, if any, than Human mages with the current mechanics. The bonus just isn't there. So it isn't accurate to say elven mages are especially dangerous. (Where as it would be accurate to say Gavial Warriors and Barbarians are dangerous, we've seen it) A Human mage trained up may well have caused the same controversy by beating a bunch of high level warriors at the games because spell resists aren't working. Maybe the coming OOC games will help hash some of these issues out.

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 11:25 am
by
I have three months more of power training on my PC than he does (yes, my 8 - 12 hours in game are usually spent power training. Shocking. I know.) Since others put such high importance on the time and effort invested into their characters, it would be more than disheartening if Draven could so easily defeat the powerful mage that Faran is, given he has only had to actively work one skill (close combat) to be viable.
I thought it was a good fight, I think I would have won if I had higher tier armor/weapon. So the thing that makes people upset is people with the highest Armor/Weapon combo couldn't beat you and it seemingly didn't matter what level CC they were, that seems problematic. (Anselm did say this is partially due to the resistance mechanic that is currently not working properly) I certainly wouldn't win if I just won if CC was the only thing I leveled in addition to parry, dual parry, and shield block. Warriors have other skills to work combat related as well as assassins. That being said I tip my hat to your powertraining Faran and I don't want to take anything away from your hard work.

Very Respectfully,
Draven's Player

Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.

Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 11:58 am
by
I thought it was a good fight, I think I would have won if I had higher tier armor/weapon. So the thing that makes people upset is people with the highest Armor/Weapon combo couldn't beat you and it seemingly didn't matter what level CC they were, that seems problematic. (Anselm did say this is partially due to the resistance mechanic that is currently not working properly) I certainly wouldn't win if I just won if CC was the only thing I leveled in addition to parry, dual parry, and shield block. Warriors have other skills to work combat related as well as assassins. That being said I tip my hat to your powertraining Faran and I don't want to take anything away from your hard work.
Forgive me if this is incorrect for dual parry, but all those skills you listed appear to be passive defenses. You don't actually "work" them. I don't know anybody that doesn't do something else when gaining in shield parry or parry, be it Close Combat or Wound Mending. I've gotten decent Shield Parry without ever putting a second into it, as it it advances as I hunt things and raise my spells or CC. And yes, it is accurate to say that in the current system it is quite easy to simply just raise Close Combat. Put a few months into it and you'll dominate most, if not all PVP (assuming the spell resistance thing is fixed), and make the most in hunting per hour. Because your passive defenses will rise as you hunt or whatever you do to raise CC. And if you are a Gavial or a Vuk you'll do it much better, plus carry tons more to boot.

Assassins wise, they'll be able to do similar once there are well paying monsters that Assassins can use parry on. Just because they have masking, doesn't mean anyone is forcing them to spend time leveling it. They can benefit from the same simple equation of massive gains from raising just the Close Combat skill.

As I mentioned, a mage might put weeks into just the wall spell alone, and get pretty much zero gain out of it mechanically. Then they'll do the same for portal, which will at least give them some moving around ability, but it won't help them in combat. (Might boost money a bit by allowing them to sell really fast) They'll do weeks for shield and gain only a tiny amount of DR for that work. And other spells. I imagine once fly is in I'll be training that as well. And in addition a hunting mage has to raise their main attack spell and either CC or unarmed combat.

A mage could go combat crazy and just level his attack spell. Even that won't work right now, since at some point the spell stops raising in damage, as I've reported. And if you are a solo hunter like me as a mage, you do need some CC or unarmed. I started going crazy on CC lately because I can see actual gains to my hunting ability, if small ones. Where as massive training in lightning was getting me no where.

There's many issues going on with the Faran versus Draven fight. The glaring ones are the issues Anselm brought up. There's also the fact that Faran's elf doesn't have the proper elven damage bonus and probaly won't for months. (It's on their fix list but sounds much down the road) But Draven does have his proper racial strength bonus. He probaly has a large HP advantage. But his equipment is inferior to Faran's. Then depending Faran's level in attack spells, there's that issue I brought up about damaging spells not raising after a certain level. This is a complex mix of issues and we may not truly know where a Gavial Warrior and an Elven mage stand until some things are fixed.